Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
9Activity
P. 1
Review of Witzel's Autochthonous Aryans

Review of Witzel's Autochthonous Aryans

Ratings: (0)|Views: 261 |Likes:
On scruitiny, it is found that all the Michael Witzel's claim about Indian flora and fauna as represented in PIE vocabulary are bogus. It is not he did not know the works of Pokorny etc on the words kamala, aravinda etc. Clearly is is a case of deliberate distortions.
On scruitiny, it is found that all the Michael Witzel's claim about Indian flora and fauna as represented in PIE vocabulary are bogus. It is not he did not know the works of Pokorny etc on the words kamala, aravinda etc. Clearly is is a case of deliberate distortions.

More info:

Categories:Types, Research, History
Published by: Premendra Priyadarshi on Dec 14, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/15/2013

pdf

text

original

 
0
Co}`}odg; V~oy`m`~sjo, V',
Og`mqh~}hg} eos}`ihs d~ mhlonh~`}h mos}d~}odgs4 ; @ ~hqohr da V~da'
Eocj`hl Ro}{hl‟s
qohrs dg
@x}dcj}jdgdxs @~y`gs
,
Qhmoc @qhgxhs
, >60>, 0*>/; *`cchv}hm ad~vxnloc`}odg `s Lh}}h~s }d }jh Hmo}d~/' @~}oclh nhogb v~dmxchm ro}j vh~eossodg `s dg 0=Mhchenh~ >600'
 
Lh}}h~ }d }jh Hmo}d~,
]jh Qhmoc Qhgxhs
'
Og`mqh~}hg} eos}`ihs d~ mhlonh~`}h mos}d~}odgs4 ; @ ~hqohr da 
V~da' Eocj`hl Ro}{hl‟s
qohrs dg
@x}dcj}jdgdxs @~y`gs
 
ny V' V~oy`m`~sjov~oy`m`~sjo060Fjd}e`ol'cde
Eocj`hl Ro}{hl j`s a~`g}oc`lly e`og}`oghm }jh s}`gm }j`} gdgh da }jh rd~ms ad~ }jh }yvoc`lSdx}j @so`g vl`g}s *loih ld}xs d~
i`e`l`
, n`endd,
`sjq`}}j`
,
nolq`
,
 k`enx
/ d~ `goe`ls *loihlodg, }obh~, lhdv`~m, hlhvj`g} h}c/ j`qh ~hv~hshg}`}odg og }jh Ogmd%Hx~dvh`g qdc`nxl`~y hqhgro}j `l}h~hm eh`gogbs *Ro}{hl >660;13/' Jdrhqh~, hqhg ` c`sx`l vh~xs`l da `gy V~d}d%Ogmd%Hx~dvh`g moc}odg`~y v~dqhs }j`} o} os ` ndbxs cl`oe e`mh ro}jdx} `gy v~dvh~ s}xmy da }jhossxh' Rh c`g }`ih `g hz`evlh da }jh h}yedldby da 
i`e`l`
*ld}xs/ `s boqhg ny Vdid~gy*0?8?/;Si
i`e`l`
9 VOH
+iheh~d%, +ideh~d%, +iheh~d%,
*Vdid~gy;88:/9 D'J'B'
jheh~`
, V~d}d%Bh~e`goc
+j
`eo~Ņ
*jhllhnd~h aldrh~/, Bh~' mo`l'
jheh~g
ms' *jhllnd~h/, ^CS *^xsso`gCjx~cj Sl`qdgoc/
ąheh~ы
vdosdg, d~obog`lly jhllnd~h9 ^xss'
ąheh~`
a' *jhllhnd~h/9Lo}j'
iheh~`o 
*
Hxv`}d~oxe c`gg`nogxe
/9 B~hhi λ
μΰπδώ
i`e`~ds
*
Mhlvjogoxe
/9B~hhi
λ 
ὰ 
 μμΰπδε, λ 
ὰ 
 μμδπδε 
 
i`ee`~dg
*
 @cdgo}xe
aldrh~/9 Ogmo`g
Cj`e`~oi@
 *
c`e`~oi@
/ a~de
i`e`l%oi@
']jxs cdg}~`~y }d }jh
Ro}{hl‟s cl`oe, }jh rd~m
i`e`l`
og edmoaohm ad~es j`s nhhg xshm }dmhgd}h ` l`~bh gxenh~ da Hx~dvh`g aldrh~s, ogcomhg}`lly `ll nhogb nlxh d~ vx~vlh og cdldx~'Gd} dgly
i`e`l`
nx} d}jh~ S`gsi~o} rd~ms ad~ }jh ld}xs,
`~`qogm`
`gm
g`log`
}dd j`qh nhhgv~hsh~qhm og }jh Hx~dvh`g lhzocdg; S`gsi~o}
`~`qogm`
*ld}xs/, B~hhi
h~hqogmds
cjocivh`s, VOH
+h~hb
ʲ  
*j/d%
, D'J'B'
`~`rho{, `~ro{,
Bh~e`g g`eh
H~nsh
, E'O~'
d~n`ogm 
h}c *Vdid~gy;3389
S}`~ds}og;?6>/' ]jh Hx~dvh`g aldrh~ “loly― os vh~j`vs ` cdbg`}h rd~m da S`gsi~o}
g`log`
 
eh`gogb “ld}xs―'
 ]jos sjdxlm v~dev} vhdvlh og }jh aohlm }d ~h%hz`eogh }jh rjdlh ossxh da }jh ald~` `gm a`xg`da }jh Ogmd%Hx~dvh`g jdehl`gm' O j`qh hz`eoghm }jh ossxh, `gm ` mh}`olhm ~hvd~} roll nhv~hshg}hm og ax}x~h' Jdrhqh~, }jh heh~bogb lh`ms sjdr }j`} eds} da rj`} Ro}{hl r~d}h r`sgd}jogb ed~h }j`g ` jd`z' Ro}{hl cl`oes }j`} }jh `goe`ls da Ogmd%Hx~dvh`g qdc`nxl`~y
 d}}h~, nh`qh~, rdla, nh`~, lygz, hli, ~hm mhh~, j`~h,
 
jhmbhjdb, edxsh
`~h `ll a~de cdlmh~cloe`}h `gm j`qh gd} loqhm og Ogmo` *Ro}{hl >660;83, 8=, 88/' Xgad~}xg`}hly ad~ joe, `ll da }jhsh `~h ho}jh~ v~hshg} og }jh Sdx}j @so` d~ rh~h }jh~h og }jh v`s}' Rh c`g shh ro}j }jhahr hz`evlhs }jh jdlldr g`}x~h da jos cl`oes;
 
>
Nh`qh~
; Ro}{hl‟s
v~hs}obodxs cl`oe *>660;83,8=,88/
}j`} “nh`qh~―
r`s gd} g`}oqh da Ogmo`mx~ogb }jh Qhmoc `bh os v~dqhm r~dgb ny `~cj`hdldby' Nh`qh~ ndghs ro}j }jh hqomhgch da jxg}ogb j`qh nhhg adxgm a~de }jh `~cj`hdldboc`l ~he`ogs og Ogmo` *h'b' I`sjeo~ Q`llhyGhdlo}joc so}hs Nx~{`jde `gm Bxai~`l =666 NV }d 3>66 NV9 Eos~`;8629 Sogbj; 00=9 O@^ 0?1>/'Jdrhqh~, nh`qh~ nhc`eh hz}ogc} l`}h~ a~de Ogmo`, v~dn`nly mxh }d }jh }joci jxe`gsh}}lhehg}s `ldgb ~oqh~ n`gis' Ehg}odgs da nh`qh~ og }jh
^ob%Qhm`
`gm l`}h~ Qhmoc }hz}ssjdr }j`} }jhy `~h qh~y dlm }hz}s' Adlldrogb }jh hz}ogc}odg da }jh nh`qh~, }jh s`eh }h~e
n`nj~x
c`eh }d nh `vvlohm }d edgbddsh og Ogmo` `gm }d eoch og gd~}j O~`g *
non`~ 
Vh~so`gedxsh, S}hogb`ss;08=/'
Jhgch Ghgogbh~‟s cl`
oe *da} co}hm ny Ro}{hl/ }j`} edgbddsh r`s }jheh`gogb da Qhmoc
n`nj~x
os a`lsh'Og Hx~dvh rh aogm cdgaxsodg og }jh eh`gogb da cdbg`}hs da }jh rd~m
“nh`qh~―'
]jh `~~oqogbOgmd%Hx~dvh`gs `vvlohm }jos rd~m }d eh`g shqh~`l d}jh~ }jogbs,
loih “aon~h―, “n~xsj― h}c
 *Vdid~gy 0?8?; 031/' Og }jh gd~}j Hx~dvh`g l`gbx`bhs o}s cdbg`}hs da}hg eh`g `gy}jogbn~drg,
ogclxmogb hqhg “nh`~―'
Og L`}og }jh~h j`s nhhg ` she`g}oc cj`gbh `gm }jh
 aonh~ 
$
 aon~`
 
eh`gs “sda}― d~ “hz}~heo}y da `gy}jogb― *Q`lvo;08>
%3/'Vx~hly dg }jh l
ogbxos}oc b~dxgms }dd, }jh VOH rd~m ad~ “nh`qh~―
+njhnj~x
mdhs gd} s}`gm }dnh da gd~}jh~g d~obog' Og
+njhnj~x
, rh aogm }jh ~hmxvloc`}odg da }jh
s}he “
nj
―, rjocj
os gd}` ah`}x~h da }jh gd~}jh~g l`gbx`bhs `} `ll, nx} `g oevd~}`g} `~h`l ah`}x~h da }jh sdx}jh~g*@xs}~d%@so`}oc, @xs}~dghso`g, M~`qomo`g, Ogmd%@~y`g `gm @a~oc`g/ l`gbx`bhs *R@LS Ah`}x~h>2 ny C`~l ^xnog/'
Edspxo}dhs `gm Alohs;
]jhsh }rd svhcohs, ogj`no}`g}s da }jh r`~e jxeom cloe`}hs, `~h rhll~hv~hshg}hm og }jh sdx}jh~g Hx~dvh`g l`gbx`bhs `l}jdxbj `nshg} a~de }jh l`gbx`bhs da cdlmh~ gd~}jh~g Hx~dvh; S`gsi~o};
e`sj`i`
,
e@coi@
,
e`iS`
,
e`iSoi@
jdxsh aly9
e`sj`i`
,
e`sj`
edspxo}d9 B~hhi;
μψ
ῑ 
ΰ *
exo`
/ jdxsh aly9 L`}og;
exsc`
jdxsh aly9 @ln`go`g;
eo{h
bg`}9Vh~so`g;
e`ij
0
r`sv, nhh *S}hogb`ss; 00?0/9
e`xs`, eXs`
nhh *S}hogb`ss;03=8/9 VOH
+e`i 
 
d%
, d~
+edi 
 
%d%
 
“aly― *Vdid~gy;1??/'U
 
Lodg ;
Vdid~gy *0?8?; 8>6/ sjdrs }j`} }jh S`gsi~o}
ihsj`
*j`o~, e`gh/, a~de VOH
+i`os
, oscdbg`}h }d ]dcj`~o`g @
řoříi 
 
*lodg/, ]dcj`~o`g О
 ṣ
hc`ih
*lodg/ `gm L`}'
`hs`~oēs
*a~de rjocjL`}og
C`hs`~ 
`gm Bh~e`g
i`os`~ 
eh`gogb Hevh~d~/ j`qh nhhg mh~oqhm' Jhgch
ihsj`~o 
*Silodg, iogb/ os `g Ogmd%Hx~dvh`g rd~m'@gd}jh~ h`~ly OH rd~m ad~ lodg r`s +
sogbjds
*E`lld~y `gm @m`es; 0=>/' Jdrhqh~, o} j`ssx~qoqhm dgly `} }rd vl`chs; @~e'
ogk 
,
ogi 
*lhdv`~m/ `gm Si'
soej`
lodg' S}`~ds}og *m`}`n`sh/los}s
@~ehgo`g “
og
 Ǥ 
*lhdv`~m/ `gm V~d}d%]dcj`~o`g +
s
    
ēříih
*lodg/, `gm v~dvdshs VOH +
soej`
 *lodg/' Jdrhqh~ Ro}{hl *0???;11/ }~ohs }d eoslh`m ny s`yogb }j`} }jh v~dvdshm ~dd} *jh los}s;+
shgbj`$sogbj`
7 +
sogk"j`
9 ++
s0hgbj`
/ os ` sxns}~`}h rd~m a~de gd~}j Chg}~`l @so` d~ H`s}Hx~dvh nd~~drhm og}d Ogmd%O~`go`g, `s oa }jhsh ~hbodgs j`m lodg og }jh v`s}'
0
Vh~so`g
e`ij
j`s ~h}`oghm e`gy da }jh she`g}oc ah`}x~hs da alo
hs `gm edspxo}dhs' O}s eh`gogbs “nhh― `gm“r`sv― j`qh ~h}`oghm }jh ah`}x~h “no}ogb― cj`~`c}h~os}oc da edspxo}dhs' Jdrhqh~ d}jh~ eh`gogbs loih “s}ociogb,`ggojol`}hm, ~hmxchm }d gd}jogb― `~h ah`}x~hs da ` jdxsh aly' ]jh l`s} }rd j`qh nhhg rhll hzv~hsshm og
Rollo`e
Nl`ih‟s vdhe “]jh Aly― *@e O gd} ` aly loih }jhh4/'
 
3
Lhdv`~m;
 
Og svo}h da Ro}{hl‟s cl`oe *0???;11/ }j`} S`gsi~o}
 v@~m`ix
os ` V`~`%Exgm`sxns}~`}h rd~m, vjoldldby sjdrs }j`} lhdv`~m r`s `g `goe`l da }jh Ogmd%Hx~dvh`gjdehl`gm'VOH *S}`~ds}og/
+v~m 
d~
+vh~m 
lhdv`~m; S`gsi~o}
 v^m`ix
, B~hhi
 v`~mds
, Dlm B~hhi
 ~
%s
,
 ~`
%s
,
 ~`o 
%s
,
V`~mhl 
, *V`g}jh~/, ]`koi%O~`go`g Sdbm
 
 r~νi 
, V`sj}d
 v~ 
    
Āb
, G' Vh~s'
 v`l`gb
*v`g}jh~/' *^hah~hgchs; RV OO =? a'9
S}`~ds}og‟s m`}`n`sh/' Lo}j'
 `~x`qğs
*adzy/ e`y nh ~hl`}hm, rjh~h og }jh `nshgch da lhdv`~m, }jh rd~m bd}`vvlohm }d }jh adz'
V`g}jh~;
L`}og
 v`g}jh~ 
, B~hhi
 v`g}jh~ 
, S`gsi~o}
 vxgM`~ooi`
 
}obh~, }jh yhlldrosj `goe`l
 *J`~vh~ Mdxbl`s/'
K`ci`l *H'/ ;
Si'
sj^b@l 
*
sj~ob`l 
/9 Vh~s'
sj`bj`l 
9 ]x~iosj
â`i`l 
9 Bh~e`g
scj`i`l 
9 Lo}j' 
9 L`}q'
 Š`iĀos
9 Nxlb`~o`g
cj`i`l 
*
тжлжй
/9 Vdlosj
s{`i`l 
9 Ix~e`gco Ix~m
cj`c`l 
'
Ldv@sj`
 
*Si' adz, k`ci`l/; Cdbg`}h rd~ms `~h rhll ~hv~hshg}hm og Hx~dvh`g l`gbx`bhs da}hgro}j `l}h~hm eh`gogb *}d rdla/;Si
ldv@sj`
*VOH +
x
   
   
 v%, lxv%, +sx
   
oli 
ʲ  
%
; adz, k`ci`l, rdla9 Vdid~gy; 002?/; Bh~e`goc
 
+rxla`{
,
Hgblosj “rdla―,
@q'
x~xvos
mdb,
~`dvos
adz$k`ci`l9 E'Vh~s'
~Ņ@s
, Vh~s'
~Ņn@j
 adz9 @~e'
`xēs
adz9 L`}'
qēs
adz, `lsd
lxvxs
rdla9 N~h}'
ldx`~g
adz9 Rhlsj
llyr`~g
 adz9 Vdlosj *
+lxhs
/
los
adz9 Bi'
ἆ 
 ι
φβη 
*
`ldvhis
/ `gm
ἆ 
 ιϏφ
὿
ώ
*
`ldvds
/ adz9 Lo}j'

*
+x
  
ē
/,
qooŠs
rolm c`}9 L}q'
l`vs`
adz' *shh Gd}hs, S}`~ds}og;3=06%3=00/'S}`~ds}og *M`}`n`sh/ ~hcdgs}~xc}s ` VOH ~dd}
+lxv%
eh`gogb nd}j rdla `gm adz' Jdrhqh~,`a}h~ c~o}oc`l hz`eog`}odg, rh c`g s`y }j`} }jh d~obog`l eh`gogb da }jh ~dd}%rd~m *+
lxv%
/exs} j`qh nhhg adz `gm k`ci`l, `gm o} mom gd} ogclxmh rdla og }jh nhboggogb'
Rdla;
Rdla os adxgm og Ogmo` }dm`y, `gm o}s sihlh}`l ~he`ogs j`qh nhhg adxgm a~de Ogmo`g`~cj`hdldboc`l ~he`ogs'S`gsi~o}
q^i`
 
*` “}h`~h~―, r
dla/9 @q'
Ǖ
j~i`%
, Bi'
 ι
ό 
λδώ
*
lxids
/, D'Och'
ylb~,
Lo}j'
qoi`s
,L}q'
qìlis
, D'V~xss'
rolios,
D'C'S'
qьiы
ms', @ln'
xli 
,
xlix
, Olly~' g`eh
Xlcxmoxs
,
Xlco~xs
,D'N~o}' g`eh
Xlc`bgxs
, D'O~' g`eh
Dlcàg
`ll eh`g rdla' D}jh~ cdbg`}hs `~h D'O~'
dlc
,bhg'
xolc
 
“e`m, rocihm, hqol―'
@lsd, Srhmosj
q`~bjdg`
,
q`~bogg`
,
q`~bnñg`
, “sjh
%
rdla―' S}`~ds}og *m`}`n`sh/
~hcdgs}~xc}s VOH
+r 
h
li%,
`gm `mms ]dcj`~o`g N
r`lirh
 
“rdla― }d }jh los}'
@g`}dlo`g *Lxq'/
r`lr`$o%
*lodg/ os ` cdbg`}h da }jhsh *E`lld~y `gm@m`es; 03:/'Ro}{hl cdevlh}hly obgd~hs }jh OH s}`}xs da sdeh sdx}jh~g Hx~dvh`g%Sdx}j @so`g`goe`ls e`gy da }jhe `~h cdlm%nlddmhm, `gm loqh dgly og }jh r`~eh~ `~h`s' ]jh Ogmd%Hx~dvh`g rd~ms ad~ }jhsh j`qh nhhg v~hsh~qhm og }jh sdx}jh~g ~dx}h l`gbx`bhs dgly,d~obog`}ogb a~de Ogmo` ~h`cjogb Sdx}j Hx~dvh'
C`gch~;
L`}og
c`gch~ 
, B~hhi
i`~iogds
, Jogmo
ihgi`~@
, S`gsi~o}
i`~i`]`
,
i`~i`
' Jdrhqh~, oggd~}jh~g Hx~dvh, rjh~h c~`ns `~h gd} adxgm, }jos rd~m r`s `vvlohm }d eh`g }jh svomh~s;

Activity (9)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
Uma Sathyakam liked this
yphapan liked this
Vikram Tejpal liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->