Ancient Thrace During the First Millennium BC

COLLOQUIA ANTIQUA 1
THE BLACK SEA, GREECE, ANATOLIA AND EUROPE IN THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC
Edited by
GOCHA R. TSETSKHLADZE
PEETERS LEUVEN PARIS WALPOLE, MA 2011
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction to the Series . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to the Volume . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . List of Abbreviations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . List of Illustrations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CHAPTER 1 Ancient Thrace during the First Millennium BC Nikola Theodossiev . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Getae: Selected Questions Alexandru Avram . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Black Sea: Between Asia and Europe (Herodotus Approach to his Scythian Account) J.G.F. Hind. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Scythians: Three Essays Gocha R. Tsetskhladze . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The American-Ukrainian Scythian Kurgan Project, 2004 2005: Preliminary Report N.T. de Grummond, S.V. Polin, L.A. Chernich, M. Gleba and M. Daragan Skeletal Analyses: A.D. Kozak Faunal Remains: O.P. Zhuravlev . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Persia in Europe John Boardman . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Etruscan Impact on Ancient Europe Larissa Bonfante . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
VII IX XI XIII
CHAPTER 2
61
CHAPTER 3
77
CHAPTER 4
95
CHAPTER 5
141
CHAPTER 6
195
CHAPTER 7
203
VI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 8
Hallstatt Europe: Some Aspects of Religion and Social Structure Biba Terzan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Elusive Arts: The Study of Continental Early Celtic Art since 1944 Ruth Megaw and Vincent Megaw . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An Archaic Alphabet on a Thasian Kylix M.A. Tiverios . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Iron Age in Central Anatolia Hermann Genz . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Role of Jewellery in Ancient Societies Iva Ondrejov. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Mushroom, the Magi and the Keen-Sighted Seers Claudia Sagona and Antonio Sagona . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
233
CHAPTER 9
265
CHAPTER 10
317
CHAPTER 11
331
CHAPTER 12
369
CHAPTER 13
387
List of Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
437 439
ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC*

Nikola THEODOSSIEV
Abstract The paper provides a general discussion of ancient Thrace in the 1st millennium BC. Thrace was located on the northern fringe of Greece, in the northern part of southeastern Europe, and was inhabited by a number of tribes known as Thracians. The territorial extent of Thrace is discussed and the chronology of this period is outlined. Greek and Roman historical sources on ancient Thrace are examined, as are the various tribes and the political history of the most powerful tribal kingdoms. Attention is paid to the social structure of the tribal communities and to Thracian religion. Economic contacts and trade are also discussed, particularly to illustrate the dynamic relations and long-distance contacts of the region throughout the eastern Mediterranean. The various cultural interactions and ethnic interrelations between Thracians and Greeks, Persians, Scythians, Macedonians, Illyrians, Celts and Romans are outlined, together with such topics as settlement patterns, the urbanisation process and sanctuaries. Thracian funerary practices are examined, especially the rich aristocratic burials and the numerous Late Classical and Hellenistic Thracian monumental tombs. So too are Thracian metalwork and its iconography, particularly the significant gold and silver treasures/hoards, and lastly Thracian coinage.
Ancient Thrace, located on the northern fringe of the Greek world, was among the most dynamic regions of the eastern Mediterranean and played an important role in ancient history and culture. Since the early 20th century, a number of scholars from different countries have studied the region, examining a variety of topics and publishing important work. I am pleased to offer an overview of ancient Thrace in a volume in honour of Prof. Jan Bouzek, a brilliant
* I would like to thank Gocha Tsetskhladze for his kind invitation to contribute to this volume dedicated to Jan Bouzek. I wish to extend my gratitude to the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the Council of American Overseas Research Centers, the American School of Classical Studies at Athens, the American Academy in Rome, the Institute for Advanced Studies in the Humanities at the University of Edinburgh, the Center for Advanced Study in the Visual Arts at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC, the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study in the Humanities and Social Sciences in Wassenaar, the Maison des Sciences de lHomme in Paris, and the Centre dtude des Peintures Murales Romaines in Soissons for their generous support and the various fellowships which have enabled me to work on my research projects.
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
scholar whose career is closely related to the region, where he has been personally involved for many years in both theoretical and field research, and on which he has written many works of the greatest importance.
TERRITORIAL SCOPE AND CHRONOLOGY1 Ancient Thrace was an extensive but variable historical and geographical region of south-eastern Europe (Fig 1). It covered the following modern countries (from north to south): Moldova, the south-western part of the Odessa Province of the Ukraine, the eastern and southern parts of Romania, Bulgaria, eastern Serbia, the eastern part of the Republic of Macedonia, parts of northern Greece and the European part of Turkey (Danov 1976; Mihailov 1972; A. Fol 1972; 1974; 1975b; 1997; A. Fol and Spiridonov 1983; R. Hoddinott, 1981; Oppermann 1984; Spiridonov 1991; Archibald 1998; D. Popov 1999). During the 1st millennium BC Thrace spread from the West Pontic coast (in the east) to the Morava river valley, the area between the middle river valleys of the Struma/Strymon and Vardar, and the lower Axios (Vardar) river valley (to the west); and from the Transylvanian Alps and the Moldavian Carpathians (in the north) and the Dniester river (in the north-east), to the Bosporus (in the southeast), the northern coast of the Sea of Marmara, including the Gallipoli peninsula, and the North Aegean coast, including the islands of Samothrace and Thasos, and the Chalkidiki peninsula (in the south). Historically, separate Thracian tribes were attested in central Greece, north-west Anatolia and some Aegean islands, but in antiquity these areas belonged to other historical and geographical regions. The frontiers of ancient Thrace were relative, variable and quite dynamic, and during the 1st millennium BC certain Thracian areas belonged to the Greek colonies, the Achaemenid empire, Macedonia and the Roman Republic. Moreover, ancient Thrace was not a homogeneous region inhabited by homogeneous ethnic groups, and the ancient Thracians never formed a unified nation or entirely centralised kingdom controlling their whole territory. In fact, Thracians is a cumulative and relative ethnonym that included a great number of various tribes, often sharing a common culture, religion and language, but
1 In this article I do not deal with the North Thracian territories inhabited by the Getae and the Daci, except for present-day north-eastern Bulgaria. See A. Avrams chapter in the present volume. Also, I do not deal with an area of south-western Thrace which became a constituent part of the Macedonian kingdom during the Classical and Hellenistic periods.
ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC
Fig. 1. Thracian sites and tribal territories of the Classical period (after Z.H. Archibald, Thracians and Scythians. CAH VI, 2nd ed. [Cambridge 1994], 446, map 14).
1. Alexandrovo; 2. Arzos; 3. Asenovgrad; 4. Bednyakovo; 5. Brezovo; 6. Boukyovtsi; 7. Branichevo; 8. Chirpan; 9. Daskal Atanassov; 10. Derveni; 11.Didimotikhion; 12. Dolno Sahrane; 13. Dulboki; 14. Duvanli; 15. Edirne; 16. Ezerovo; 17. Glozhene; 18. Gotse Delchev; 19. Gradnitsa; 20. Izgrev; 21. Kaloyanovo; 22. Kazanlak; 23.Kirklareli; 24. Kyolmen; 25. Koprinka; 26. Kozarevo; 27. Krivodol; 28. Letnitsa; 29. Lukovit; 30. Lovech; 31. Madara; 32. Mezek; 33. Mumdyilar; 34. Nevrokop; 35.Novo Mahala; 36. Novoselets; 37. Opulchenets; 38. Oryahovo; 39. Panagyurishte; 40. Pastousha; 41.Pazardyik; 42. Philippi; 43 Pomorie; 44. Pudriya; 45. Purovay; 46.Pustrovo; 47. Razlog; 48. Rozovets; 49. Seuthopolis; 50. Skalitsa; 51. Slavyanovo; 52. Smolyan; 53. Stara Zagora; 54. Staro Selo; 55. Stoyanovo; 56. Strelcha; 57. Svetlen; 58. Svilengrad; 59. Tarnevets; 60. Tatarevo; 61. Chernozem; 62. Teteven; 63. Toros; 64. Topolovgrad; 65. Topolovo; 66. Troian; 67. Turnovo; 68. Velingrad; 69. Beroea; 70. Vetren; 71. Voinitsine; 72. Vulchitrun; 73. Vurbitsa; 74. Yankovo; 75. Yourukler; 76. Zlokoutchene; 77. Kabyle.
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
sometimes being quite different, while mixed groups consisting of local people who lived besides the Greeks, Persians, Paeonians, Illyrians, Macedonians, Scythians, Celts and Romans inhabited particular areas of Thrace, which were turned into zones of interaction. The 1st millennium BC in Thrace is defined as the Iron Age, during which various major developments occurred: the gradual political consolidation of the Thracian tribes and the rise of tribal kingdoms, the most significant being the Odrysian kingdom; important historical events in Thrace, such as the lasting Greek colonisation on the North Aegean and West Pontic coasts; increased productive activity among the Thracian tribes, a developing economy and intensive trade; and distinctive changes in Thracian material culture, such as the adoption of iron metallurgy, the appearance of rich aristocratic burials, the production of new types of pottery, weaponry, jewellery, toreutics, etc. all the result of dynamic internal developments of the tribal communities, besides various multilateral contacts and interactions throughout the eastern Mediterranean, the North Pontic regions and Central Europe. The Thracian Iron Age divides into two: Early and Late. A number of important publications deal with the chronology and periods of the Early Iron Age (Chichikova 1974b; Hnsel 1976; Toncheva 1980a; Gergova 1986; 1987, 718; Taylor 1989b; Gotsev 1990, 1720; Bouzek 1997; Archibald 1998, 2634; Borislavov 1999, 512; Nikov 2000). The recent studies clearly demonstrate that the beginning of the Early Iron Age should be placed between 1050 BC and 950 BC; its end between 550BC and 450 BC, depending on the specific historical, economic and cultural features in the different areas of Thrace. The Early Iron Age is usually divided further into two phases the first from the late 11th or early 10th to the 9th century BC, and the second from the 8th to the late 6th or early 5th century BC, although some studies on specific areas of Thrace during the Early Iron Age provide more detailed chronology and precise division by phases and sub-phases. The Late Iron Age covered the period from the middle of the 6th or middle of the 5th century BC down to the late 1st century BC or into the first several decades of the 1st century AD, when the main part of ancient Thrace was annexed by the Roman empire (Domaradzki 1994b; 1998a; Archibald 1998; Theodossiev 2000c, 1113). The Late Iron Age in Thrace is usually divided into the Classical and Hellenistic periods, following the model of classical archaeology, but several detailed studies on the northern areas of Thrace clearly demonstrate that the Late Iron Age chronology and periodisation here was somewhat different, often related to the La Tne phases (Theodossiev 2000c, 1113; Stoyanov 2000; cf. Domaradzki 1994b; 1998a).
LITERARY AND EPIGRAPHIC SOURCES While the ancient Thracians were a non-literary people and no domestic historical sources are known, a number of Greek and Roman authors give information on the region and the local tribes. Ancient writings provide some possibility to study Thracian political history, culture, religion and society, but, on the other hand, they do not contain sufficient data to enable those studying Thrace to draw comprehensive conclusions and to reconstruct the whole situation. Moreover, ancient written sources sometimes contain uncertain, exaggerated or biased information as their Greek or Roman authors, foreigners, sought to understand and explain a barbarian reality in a peripheral region which most had never visited and whose language they did not speak, relying on second-hand and fragmentary information to compile their accounts. In fact, the ancient authors rarely discuss Thrace, mentioning it but incidentally, usually when the local tribes interfered in some event related to Greek or Roman history. During the 20th century and since, study of ancient written sources about Thrace advanced significantly. Many scholars have published important works, discussing a number of sources and studying various theoretical and methodological issues (Katsarov 1916; 1930; Casson 1926; Todorov 1933 Danov 1976; 1998; Mihailov 1972; A. Fol 1972; 1975b; 1997; A. Fol and Spiridonov 1983; Papazoglu 1978; Tacheva 1987; Loukopoulou 1989; Spiridonov 1991; Stronk 1995; Yordanov 1998; Yordanov and Velkov 1984; Archibald 1998; 2003; D. Popov 1999; Boteva-Boyanova 2000; Theodossiev 2000c; Boshnakov 2003; Delev 2004). Alongside these, several volumes have provided collections of translations of ancient written sources (Katsarov and Dechev 1949; Lewis 1958; Velkov et al. 1981; Gocheva 2002), although further work is necessary to collect all the information available in ancient writings. Some Thracian personal and tribal names have turned up in Mycenaean documents (Best 1989). However, the earliest literary evidence on Thrace was given in Homers epics, although this information does not seem to be sufficiently reliable from an historical point of view. Later, a number of ancient authors Herodotus, Euripides, Thucydides, Plato, Xenophon, Demosthenes, Aeschines, Polybius, Livy, Diodorus, Strabo, Conon and Pompeius Trogus, among many others provide reliable and relatively objective, although not complete accounts, usually receiving first-hand information from Greeks and Romans living in the region or having personal experience in Thrace like Thucydides and Xenophon. Many ancient writers living during the Imperial age also described various earlier events related to Thracian history and culture of the 1st millennium BC, for example Pomponius Mela,
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Pliny, Julius Florus, Plutarch, Arrian, Pausanias, Appian, Polyaenus, Ptolemy and Athenaeus. While literary works are often ambiguous, a number of Greek inscriptions provide reliable information on Thrace in the Classical and Hellenistic periods (IGBulg; Mihailov 1980; Fraser 1960; A. Fol 1972; 1975b; Tacheva 1987; Loukopoulou 1989; Manov 1998b; Dimitrova 2006). Some of them, like those found at Seuthopolis (D. Dimitrov and Chichikova 1978; Velkov 1991, 711; Manov 1998a), Pistiros (Velkov and Domaradzka 1994; Domaradzki 1995; Archibald 1998, 317; Boshnakov 1999), Sboryanovo (Chichikova 1990) and Mesambria (Galabov 1950), contain valuable information on Thracian history, religion and topography, and clearly demonstrate that Greek was the official language of the Thracian aristocracy, while a certain number of Greeks inhabited inland Thrace, living in emporia or among the local people. Following various political and ritual practices in the eastern Mediterranean, a significant number of Thracian silver vessels of the late 5th and 4th centuries BC were inscribed in Greek; these inscriptions are usually brief and contain the names of local aristocrats or some Odrysian kings, such as Cotys I, Kersebleptes, Seuthes III and others (Venedikov 1972; Mihailov 1987; Der thrakische Silberschatz 1988; A. Fol 1990; Vassileva 199293; Theodossiev 1997a, 174; Zournatzi 2000; Delemen 2004b, 6069; Kitov n.d). Although the Thracians never created literature of their own, in the course of various contacts and interactions they adopted the Greek alphabet quite extensively, and in certain cases the script was used in the funerary ritual for recording the names of the dead aristocrats as in the tombs at Smyadovo (Fig. 2) (Atanasov and Nedelchev 2002) and Alexandrovo (Fig. 3) (Kitov 2002; 2004a; Kitov and Theodossiev 2003, 3442), which date to the 4th or the early 3rd century BC. In addition, several inscriptions with Greek letters but in the Thracian language are known. Thus, the inscriptions on a gold ring from Ezerovo (Detschew 1976, 56682) and on a stone funerary slab from Kyolmen (Theodossiev 1997b), both of the 5th or the early 4th century BC, consist of relatively long texts, but all attempts at translation have been highly uncertain, and much more epigraphic material and bilingual data are needed before proper translation of anything written in the Thracian language can be made.
TRIBES AND POLITICAL HISTORY Several scholarly works have provided comprehensive analyses of the ethnonymic situation in ancient Thrace and locate the separate tribes known from the written sources (Danov 1976; A. Fol 1972; 1975b; 1997; A. Fol and
Fig. 2. Inscription on the facade of the tomb at Smyadovo, 4th century BC (after Atanasov et al. 2002).
Fig. 3. Graffito in the tholos burial chamber of the Alexandrovo tomb, second half of the 4th or early 3rd century BC (courtesy Georgi Kitov).
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Spiridonov 1983; Papazoglu 1978; Yordanov and Velkov 1984; Tacheva 1987; Spiridonov 1991; Stronk 1995; Archibald 1998; D. Popov 1999; Boteva-Boyanova 2000; Theodossiev 2000c; Boshnakov 2003). The exact number of the Thracian tribes will never become known for example, at the end of the 1st century BC Strabo (7. frg. 48) counted 22 tribes, while in the Imperial age, Pliny (Natural History 4. 11. 40) wrote that Thrace was separated into 50 strategiae (these might reflect some ethnic division, besides being administrative units) and Ptolemy (3. 11. 6) described 14 strategiae. Some modern scholars consider that the actual number of the different Thracian tribes throughout the entire 1st millennium BC was up to 80. One of the major problems in studying the ethnonymic reality in ancient Thrace is to propose an exact chronological stratigraphy of the different ethnonyms for the separate regions and to explain clearly the quite dynamic ethnonymic situation, as attested in Greek and Roman sources. It is not always easy to understand why in ancient literary works different tribal names appear and disappear in one and the same region, and why certain ethnonyms spread far beyond their initial geographical location. Sometimes, this might be simply a result of a deficiency of knowledge and error. In other cases, the dynamic situation might reflect tribal migration. However, in most cases the appearance of any Thracian tribe in the written sources was a result of its political advance and significant military power which were good reasons for ancient authors to take note and to record the tribe; while disappearance was due to military weakness when certain tribes fell under the political control of other more powerful communities. The appearance of the ethnonyms in Greek and Roman sources depends also on geographical location: thus, the tribes living near the North Aegean and West Pontic shores were noted much earlier by the ancient authors than the tribes located deep in the Thracian interior. Simultaneously, ancient writers usually had more complete knowledge of the eastern and southern areas of Thrace, where they described a number of tribes, than with the western and northern hinterland, where the ethnonyms attested in written sources are less numerous. It is clear also that the ethnonymic situation as attested in Greek and Roman sources does not depict the true reality; very often the names of powerful tribes, such as the Odrysians, spread across extensive areas of ancient Thrace and covered the names of the minor tribes who existed at the same time. While the Odrysians, the Getae and the Triballi were among the most powerful ethnic communities that established strong tribal unions and kingdoms, a number of other tribes played political roles and are mentioned or relatively well described in ancient sources; in alphabetical order, they are the Agrianes, Apsynthioi, Astai, Bessoi, Bisaltai, Bistones, Bottiaoi, Brenai, Dakoi, Danthaletai, Dersaioi, Dioi, Dolonkoi,
Edonoi, Kainoi, Karpoi, Kebrenoi, Kikones, Korpiloi, Krestonaioi, Krobyzoi, Laiaioi, Maidoi, Melanditai, Mygdones, Nipsaioi, Odomantoi, Paitoi, Saioi, Sapaioi, Satrai, Serdoi, Sithones, Sintoi, Skaioi, Terizoi, Thynoi, Tranipsai, Trausoi, Treres, Tilataioi, and others (cf. Detschew 1976). Of course, many other tribes are only mentioned briefly in ancient sources. In fact, the true ethnic reality in Thrace and the names of all minor tribes will never become clear. The political history of the Thracian tribes has been studied thoroughly by several scholars (Katsarov 1916; 1930; Casson 1926; Todorov 1933; Danov 1976; Mihailov 1972; A. Fol. 1972; 1975b; 1997; Papazoglu 1978; R. Hoddinott 1981; Oppermann 1984; Gattinoni 1992; Lund 1992; Yordanov 1998; Yordanov and Velkov 1984; Tacheva 1987; Loukopoulou 1989; Stronk 1995; Archibald 1998; D. Popov 1999; Boteva-Boyanova 2000; Theodossiev 2000c; Boshnakov 2003; Delev 2004). An interesting example of a joint ThracoAthenian state-community, as attested in written sources, is related to the political activity of the Athenian aristocrat, Miltiades the Elder, who established his rule in Thracian Chersonesos in ca. 560 BC, being tyrant of both the Athenian colonists and the Dolonkoi. Later, this Athenian ruler was succeeded by his relatives Stesagoras and Miltiades the Younger, who married Hegesipyle, the daughter of the Thracian king, Oloros. In the late 6th century BC, the Edonoi established one of the most significant early Thracian kingdoms in the lower Strymon valley. Some of the Edonian kings, like Getas and Pittakos, were attested in the records. At the same time, far to the north, in the extensive areas of north-eastern Thrace, the Getae formed a powerful tribal union, which was already known to Greek writers at the end of the 6th century BC. From the middle of the 4th century BC down to the end of the Hellenistic period, some of the Getic kings, such as Kotelas, Dromichaites, Zalmodegikos, Zoltes, Remax and Byrebistas, played important roles in the political events of north-eastern Thrace. Another powerful tribal union was established in the north-western Thracian lands by the Triballi, who had significant military power by the last quarter of the 5th century BC. Ancient sources inform us of two Triballian kings, Chales and Syrmos, who were, obviously, strong rulers of the second and third quarters of the 4th century BC. Undoubtedly, the most significant supra-tribal state in Thrace was the Odrysian kingdom. The Odrysians inhabited south-east Thrace and were historically attested in the late 6th century BC at the earliest. Their first king known to ancient authors was Teres, who reigned during the first half of the 5th centuryBC, to be succeeded by Sparadokos, Sitalces, Seuthes I, Medokos (known as Amadokos I as well) and Hebryzelmis. One of the most powerful Odrysian
10
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
kings was Cotys I (383359 BC); he imposed his political control upon extensive regions of ancient Thrace and maintained diplomatic relations with the local Triballian and Getic rulers to the north. After his murder, the Odrysian kingdom split into three parts, ruled respectively by Kersebleptes, by Amadokos II and Teres II, and by Berisades and Ketriporis. In 341 BC the Macedonian king, Philip II, conquered the Odrysian kingdom, and Alexander the Great took possesion of almost the entirety of Thracian territory soon afterwards. In the time of the Diadochi, Lysimachus continued Macedonian control over a significant part of the Thracian lands and declared himself king of Thrace but, at the same time, a powerful Odrysian king emerged, Seuthes III. From the beginning of the 3rd century BC onwards, the Odrysian kingdom declined and split further, and many different kings are attested in the written sources. After 42 BC, Reskouporis I established the Sapaian dynasty with its capital at Bizye; he was succeeded by Roimetalkas I, Reskouporis II, Cotys V, Roimetalkas II and Roimetalkas III, the last Thracian ruler. In AD 45, the Roman emperor Claudius annexed the Thracian kingdom.
SOCIAL STRUCTURE AND RELIGION A number of studies have dealt with the social structure of the Thracian tribes during the 1st millennium BC (Katsarov 1916; 1930; Danov 1976; A. Fol 1970; 1997; Tacheva 1987, 94108, 11529; Domaradzki 1988; Spiridonov 1991; Archibald 1998; 2003; Porozhanov 1998; D. Popov 1999; Theodossiev 2000c, 4853; Bouzek and Domaradzka 2003; Stefanovich 2003, 4163). The literary and epigraphic evidence, as well as certain archaeological data, enable us to conclude that the Thracian communities usually comprised two main social strata. The upper consisted of kings, tribal chieftains, the aristocracy and elite groups; they were the main owners of the lands and the production. The lower comprised semi-dependent peasants who were small landowners within the frames of the royal economy. These semi-dependent peasants were the main producers of goods and the main resource of the armed forces recruited in time of war. It seems that through the weakness of the royalty or some other circumstances, in certain regions and at certain times some Thracian communities gained independence from the tribal kingdoms and were ruled by their own leaders. The Thracian aristocracy consisted of various noble clans who had different levels of power and control during the 1st millennium BC. Local chieftains controlled the great number of separate Thracian tribes known from the sources. The tribal chieftains often came under some supreme political control
11
and economic dependence when a stronger ruler managed to incorporate the separate tribes into some form of tribal union or kingdom (in fact, the kingdoms were supra-tribal states). The best example of such a structure is provided by the Odrysian kingdom during the second half of the 5th and first half of the 4th century BC. The Odrysian state was ruled by a supreme king from the royal dynasty, usually with hereditary power. He was surrounded by an entourage, which included paradynasts (paradynastoi) local tribal chieftains or governors who controlled separate regions of the kingdom and tribal aristocrats called eupatridai and gennaioi (cf. Thucydides 2. 97. 3). Very close to the supreme king were his wives and kin, his band of military warriors, servants and others. Thracian religion has been examined by a great number of scholarly works, displaying different patterns of study and deploying various methodologies (Perdrizet 1910; Katsarov 1916; 1936; Danov 1976; Pittioni 1977; D. Popov 1981; 1989; 1995; Cole 1984; B. Hoddinott 1989; R. Hoddinott 1989; A. Fol 1986; 1990; 1997; Beschi 1990; Bogdanov 1991; Marazov 1992; 1994; Lozanova-Stancheva 1993; Rabadzhiev 1994; 2002; Vassileva 1994; 1998; Archibald 1999; Theodossiev 2000c, 5370; 2002; Srbu and Florea 2000a; 2000b; Dimitrova 2002; Brown 2002; Roller 2002; 2003; Gocheva 2003; Delemen 2004a; zbayoglu 2004; Ursu Naniu 2004). Their quite different interpretations of the written and archaeological evidence and the contradictory results of their studies clearly demonstrate the significant difficulties in examining the religion of any ancient non-literary ethnic community that inhabited the fringes of the Graeco-Roman world during the 1st millennium BC. A number of literary sources and toreutic works show that a female Great Goddess, known by different local names in different regions, was a central deity in the Thracian religion, as in Phrygia. The written records provide some names of Thracian goddesses: Bendis, Ganea, Kotys/Kotytto, Rheskyntis, Zerynthia and others. In addition, literary and epigraphic sources attest that in the different regions of Thrace a male deity was worshipped, known as Deloptes, Darzalas, Zerynthios, etc. A number of written sources testify that mythical Thracian kings and priests, such as Zalmoxis, Rhesos and Orpheus, were considered as anthropodaimones and deities, while toreutic works and funerary paintings clearly reveal the cult of the king-hero. Simultaneously, some ancient authors, like Herodotus (4. 33. 5; 5. 7. 1), gave Greek or Roman theonyms to the gods worshipped by the Thracians, which is usually interpreted as the literary device of translating the Thracian religious reality for their readers. However, several 4thearly 3rd-century BC inscriptions from the Thracian hinterland, such as those from Pistiros (Velkov and Domaradzka 1994; Domaradzki 1995; Archibald 1998, 317), Seuthopolis (Velkov 1991,
12
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
711; Manov 1998a) and Sboryanovo (Chichikova 1990), testify to the cults of Dionysos, Apollo, Artemis Phosphoros and the Samothracian Great Gods, which clearly reveals the Hellenisation of Thracian religion, at least in the circles of the Thracian aristocracy.
ECONOMIC CONTACTS AND TRADE During the 1st millennium BC, the Thracian tribes were involved in active trade with each other and with neighbouring regions, besides being engaged in longdistance contacts (Bozhkova 1987; 2000; Stoyanov 2000; Stoyanov et al. 2004, 1623; Theodossiev 2000c, 92100; Nehrizov and Mikov 2000; Archibald 2001a; 2001b; Bouzek and Domaradzka 2003). Undoubtedly, most important for the Thracians were economic relations with the Greek colonies on the North Aegean and the West Pontic shores, which maintained large-scale trade with Thracian coastal areas and with the interior (Danov 1976; Mihailov 1972; Boardman 1980; Isaac 1986; Bozhkova 1992; Domaradzki 1995; Tsetskhladze 1998a-b; 2003; Balabanov 2000, 9799; Oppermann 2004). During the Classical period, the Greeks established inland market-places and trade settlements (see Thucydides 1. 100. 2; Ps.-Scylax Periplus 67; Arrian Anabasis 1. 1. 6; etc.) such as Pistiros and the Belanian emporia of the Prasenoi, as attested in the inscription from Vetren (Velkov and Domaradzka 1994; Domaradzki 1995; Archibald 1998, 317; Boshnakov 1999; Tsetskhladze 2000). The usual exports from Thrace included slaves, livestock, honey, beeswax, grain, wine, timber, charcoals, tar, metals, etc., while imports into the Thracian hinterland consisted of Attic black- and red-figure pottery, silver and gold vessels, luxury bronze tableware, gold and silver jewellery, weapons, wine, olive oil and other goods (Danov 1976; Bozhkova 1987; Reho 1990; 1992; Archibald 1998, 17796; Theodossiev 2000c, 92100; Lazarov 2003). It is usually supposed that the initial barter/commodity exchange was gradually replaced by the introduction of money, although both forms of exchange were always used in trade between the Greeks and the Thracians. The great number of imported Classical and Hellenistic amphorae in Thrace provides clear information of regular economic contacts with significant Greek trade and production centres, such as Thasos, Rhodes, Sinope, Cnidus, Heracleia Pontica, Kos, Scythian Chersonesos, Corinth, Chios, Colophon, Acanthus, Amphipolis, Ainos and others (Lazarov 1978; D. Dimitrov et al. 1984; Bozhkova 1987; 1988; L. Getov 1995; Stoyanov et al. 2004, 1623). Supposedly, long-distance trade contacts were usually indirect, being maintained via the Greek colonies on the Thracian shores.
13
A number of coins, minted both in Greek poleis and in Anatolia, penetrated into Thrace from the 6th century BC onwards, clearly testifying to intensive trade (Thompson et al. 1973; Gerasimov 1975). In addition, the Greek colonies in Thrace issued their own coins for the needs of the local trade (Mushmov 1912; Svoronos 1919; Gaebler 1935; Gerasimov 1975; Youroukova 1979), Maroneia (Schnert-Geiss 1987) and Mesambria (Karayotov 1992) among many others. During the Early Hellenistic period, a significant quantity of gold, silver and bronze coins minted by the Macedonian kings circulated within the Thracian territories, most of which became part of the Macedonian kingdom for several decades or more (Mushmov 1912; Thompson et al. 1973; Youroukova 1979; K. Dimitrov 1997; Theodossiev 2000c, 92100; Draganov 200001). In the 2nd1st centuries BC, Late Hellenistic Greek coins were in continuous use in Thrace, for example Thasian tetradrachms were widespread, while a significant number of Roman Republican denarii clearly indicates that the Roman military conquest of the northern Balkans was preceded by economic and trade expansion (Thompson et al. 1973; Theodossiev 2000c, 92100; Paunov and Prokopov 2002; Prokopov 2006).
CULTURAL INTERACTIONS AND ETHNIC INTERRELATIONS During the 1st millennium BC, ancient Thrace was a place of various interrelations and dynamic interactions between the different ethnic groups that inhabited or settled the region. Certain areas of Thrace came to be occupied by ethnically different groups or by mixed populations. Although abundant historical and archaeological evidence is available and in receipt of continued examination, further analysis of it is needed to obtain an overview of the exchange of ideas and the level of multilateral interaction, and to understand more completely the complex web of ethnic and cultural contacts and relations that took place. One of the most important historical events with a significant impact upon the Thracian tribes was the Greek colonisation of the North Aegean and West Pontic shores (Danov 1947; 1976; Venedikov et al. 1963; Daux 1967; Markov 1977; 1980; Boardman 1980; 1994; Balabanov 1983; Cole 1984; KoukouliChrysanthaki 1985; 1992; Ognenova-Marinova 1985; Porozhanov 1985; Samsaris 1985; Isaac 1986; Loukopoulou 1989; Panayotova 1994; Pelekidis 1994; Triantaphyllos 1994; Lazaridis 1997; Lehmann 1998; Tsetskhladze 1998a; 2003; Archibald 1998; 2002; Manov 1998b; Tacheva 1999; Owen 2000; Tsatsopoulou-Kaloudi 2001; Bonias and Dadaki 2002; Graham 2002; Damyanov 2003; Dimitrova and Clinton 2003; Musielak 2003; Avram et al. 2004;
14
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Oppermann 2004; Dimitrova 2006). While various archaeological material indicates active pre-colonial contacts between the Greeks and the Thracians (Bouzek 1985; 1997; Gergova 1987; Nikov 1999; 2000), the earliest Greek colonies in Thrace, such as Mende, Acanthus, Potidaea, Thasos, Abdera, Maroneia, Samothrace, Sestos, Cardia, Selymbria, Byzantium, Apollonia and Istros, were established between the middle of the 8th and the end of the 7th century BC, and even more intensive colonisation lasted throughout the 6th and 5th centuries BC. Greek colonisation stimulated multifarious ethnic and cultural relations and interactions between the Greeks and the Thracians, and led to gradual Hellenisation of the Thracian aristocracy and certain tribes who inhabited the coastal areas. Simultaneously, Thracian culture also influenced Greek literature, iconography and cult (Danov 1976; Mihailov 1972; D. Popov 1981; A. Fol 1997; Beschi 1990; Archibald 1998; Tsiafakis 1998; 2002; Brown 2002). Actually, the whole process followed the typical model of interaction between centre and periphery throughout the ancient world (cf. Alcock 1993; Randsborg 1993; Babic 2004). The inscription from Vetren, as well as some literary sources, clearly testifies that in the Classical period the Greeks had already settled in the Thracian hinterland and established emporia such as Pistiros, while being politically engaged with the Thracian kings (Velkov and Domaradzka 1994; Domaradzki 1995; Domaradzka and Domardzki 1999; Archibald 1998, 317; Boshnakov 1999; Bouzek 2000ab; Tsetskhladze 2000). On the other hand, a number of Thracians, usually mercenaries or slaves, spread throughout ancient Greece and the entire Hellenistic world (Griffith 1935; Best 1969; Danov 1976; Mihailov 1972; A. Fol 1972; 1975b; 1997; Velkov and A. Fol 1977; Tacheva 1987; Archibald 1998). Other very important contacts between the ancient Thracians and the Macedonians, Paeonians and Illyrians occurred within the interaction zone in the western frontier areas of Thrace (Bouzek 1986; 1997; Bouzek and Ondrejov 1988; Gergova 1987; Vasic 1987ab; 1991; 2000; Greenwalt 1997; Theodossiev 1998a; 2000a; 2000c; Borza 1999; Babic 2004). At the same time, in the course of the Argead political expansion northward and eastward from the late 6th century BC onwards, a great part of Thrace was gradually annexed by the Macedonian kingdom, which in fact led to Hellenisation of the Thracian interior especially during the Late Classical and Early Hellenistic periods (Casson 1926; Badian 1980; Hatzopoulos 1980; Hatzopoulos and Loukopoulou 1992; 1996; Borza 1990; Adams 1997; Archibald 1998; Yordanov 1998; Domaradzki 1998a; Chambers 1999; K. Dimitrov 1999; Stoyanov 1999). From the 8th7th centuries BC onwards, intensive cultural and ethnic processes occurred in north-eastern Thrace where the local tribes interacted and mingled with the Scythians (A. Fol 1975a; Melyukova 1976; 1979; Toncheva 1980ab; Yordanov
15
1990; Yordanov and Velkov; Zazoff 1991; Agre 1994; Fialko 1995; Damyanov 1998; Andruh 2000). Another significant event for the political and cultural development of the local tribes was the Persian occupation of Aegean Thrace during the late 6th and the first decades of the 5th century BC (Venedikov 1969; Marazov 1977; Balcer 1988; Zahrnt 1997; Boardman 2000; Zournatzi 2000; Yordanov 2003). Later, the large-scale Gallic invasion in Thrace at the very end of the 280s and the early 270s BC, was followed by Celtic settlement in certain Thracian areas and the establishment of a Gallic kingdom with its capital Tylis that existed till 213 BC (Katsarov 1919; Danov 197576; Fischer 1983; Luschey 1983; Domaradzki 1984; Tacheva 1987; Szab 1991; Cunliffe 1997; Megaws et al. 2000; V.Megaw 2004; Theodossiev 2000c). The Celtic inrush and settlement had quite a strong impact upon Thracian culture, which adopted a number of La Tne elements, while mixed populations of Thracians, Celts, Illyrians and Scythians appeared in certain areas of Hellenistic Thrace. After the fall of Macedonia in 168 BC, the Roman state launched regular military campaigns against the Thracian tribes and annexed most of the Thracian territories, which were set up as Roman provinces in AD 15 and AD 45. These political events clearly mark the end of the Iron Age in Thrace and the beginning of a powerful process of Romanisation and the adoption of Roman civilisation (Tacheva 1987; Theodossiev 2000c).
SETTLEMENT PATTERN AND URBANISATION Many ancient literary and epigraphic sources provide information on various settlements and some towns in inland Thrace (A. Fol 1970, 16374). In addition, intensive archaeological investigation has brought to light abundant evidence that has enabled scholars to study and publish, descriptively and analytically, on a wide variety of topics covering the whole of Thracian territory or specific regions (Chichikova 1974ab; Spiridonov 1979; Changova 1981; Domaradzki 1982; 1990; 1992; 1998a; Gergova and Iliev 1982; Gergova 1986; 1990; 1995; Georgieva and Bachvarov 1985; Bobcheva 1985; Ivanov 1985; Balabanov 1986; Triantaphyllos 1988; 1994; Lehmann 1998, 16973; Gotsev 1990, 1315; 1992; 1997; Archibald 1998; 2000; 2002; Borislavov 1999, 1321; Stoyanov 2000; Theodossiev 2000c, 1419; Tonkova 2000; Delev et al. 2000; Bozhkova and Delev 2002; H. Popov 2002; Kitov and Agre 2002, 5380; Kissyov 2004). The settlement pattern in ancient Thrace was quite dynamic and consists of various types of habitation. Most widespread during the 1st millennium BC seems to be the slightly fortified and open settlement, located on the plains as
16
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
well as on hills or mountain slopes. Some of these may be specified as Thracian villages, well-described in ancient written sources (for example Xenophon Anabasis 7. 4). Most settlements were inhabited for one to two centuries, and quite a few display greater continuity (throughout the entire 1st millennium BC or even from the Late Bronze Age down to the Imperial period), although further stratigraphic investigations are needed in order to identify whether there is true cultural continuity on such sites or not. Sometimes the settlements were quite extensive, while the usual domestic architecture included dugouts and rectangular huts constructed with posts and lath-andplaster or, rarely, with dry stone masonry. One of the most representative open settlements was excavated at Pshenichevo: it dates to the Early Iron Age and covers about 6 ha. Very important as well is the settlement at Koprivlen, dated to the 7th6th centuries BC, which displays remarkable monumental domestic architecture of stone-built quadrilateral buildings. Also widespread were hillforts, usually built on barely accessible elevations most often in the mountains. The fortification walls were up to 34 m in thickness and were constructed of roughly cut and irregularly arranged dry free stone blocks, while sometimes up to four-course fortification walls were built to protect particular sites. Some of the hillforts were residential centres, known as tyrseis in the literary sources (see Xenophon Anabasis 7. 2. 21), inhabited by local tribal chieftains or kings, together with their kin, military bands and servants. Other hillforts with larger areas were presumably fortified settlements inhabited by various social groups. Additionally, as the literary sources attest, the larger hillforts were used as refuges for the population from the surrounding open settlements in case of military danger. The archaeological material clearly indicates that many mountain hillforts were related to the extraction of ore and to metallurgy; presumably they were production centres. In addition, mountain hillforts with strategic locations were undoubtedly used as strongholds to control important passes and roads or to defend tribal frontiers. Some hillforts, for instance Gradishteto at Leskovets, were inhabited right through from the 8th6th centuries BC to the Imperial period, although the dating of their fortification walls is still questionable. Actually, the fortification walls of most Thracian hillforts were constructed in the Late Iron Age and fewer fortresses in the Aegean regions of Thrace were built in the Early Iron Age before Greek colonisation: Kremasto at Ergani, Vrychos in Samothrace, and others. While most Thracian hillforts display quite primitive fortification walling, some inland fortresses like Krakra at Pernik and Kastro at Kalyva, dating from the middle of the 4th century BC were constructed entirely using Greek architectural techniques and style of masonry, and were presumably built by the Macedonian king, Philip II.
17
Among the earliest examples of Thracian towns on the North Aegean coast is Ismaros, which is located on the Agios Georgios hill at Maroneia and existed already in the 9th8th centuries BC (Triantaphyllos 1988; 1994). In ancient sources, Ismaros is described as a Kikonian polis (Homer Odyssey 9. 3942; Strabo 7. frg. 44). Later, because of multilateral contacts and interaction at the time when Aegean Thrace became part of the Achaemenid empire, and of interrelations with the Greek colonies on the North Aegean and West Pontic coasts and with Macedonia, a process of urbanisation began in certain regions of the Thracian hinterland, starting in the Archaic period and continuing through the Classical into the Early Hellenistic (Balabanov 1986; Tacheva 1987, 12947; Archibald 1998; H. Popov 2002; Stoyanova 2002b). Thus, the Greek historians mention the Edonian towns of Daton (Herodotus 9. 75) and Drabeskos (Thucydides 1. 100. 3; 4. 102. 2), while another town called Myrkinos was established by the Ionian Greeks at the time of the Persian king Darius (Herodotus 5. 11. 2; 5. 124. 2); later it was known as an Edonian polis (Thucydides 4. 107. 3). One of the most important sites is the Greek emporion Pistiros near Vetren, inhabited by a mixed population of Greeks and Thracians (Velkov and Domaradzka 1994; Domaradzki 1995; Bouzek et al. 1996; 2002; Bouzek 1999; Domaradzka and Domaradzki 1999; Boshnakov 1999; Tsetskhladze 2000; H. Popov 2002, 7792); another was Seuthopolis, the capital of the Odrysian king, Seuthes III, which was built entirely in accordance with Hellenistic architecture and comprised insulae including houses with pastas, prostas and peristylon. Seuthopolis existed from ca. 320 BC to ca. 260 BC (Dimitrov and Chichikova 1978; Dimitrov et al. 1984; Velkov 1991, 711; H. Popov 2002, 12234). Other significant Late Classical and Hellenistic towns in southern Thrace were Kabyle (Velkov 1982; 1991; Domaradzki 1991; H. Popov 2002, 11122) and Philippopolis (Koleva 2000; H. Popov 2000; 2002, 93111), but further archaeological investigation is necessary to obtain a clear picture of their overall architectural appearance. The Getic town at Vodnata Tsentrala in Sboryanovo displays another kind of urban model, which was typical of the northern regions of Thrace and differed from the Early Hellenistic towns in southern Thrace (Stoyanov 1999; 2000; Stoyanov et al. 2004; H. Popov 2002, 15665).
SANCTUARIES AND RITUAL PLACES Some ancient historical sources provide scarce information on Thracian sanctuaries. Undoubtedly, the most famous was the sanctuary of Dionysos, whose exact location is still unclear (Herodotus 8. 111; Suetonius Divus Augustus 94. 6;
18
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
cf. A. Fol 1990). Other ancient writings state that the Thracians worshipped their deities in various natural places: in sacred mountains, such as Ganos, Rheskyntion and Kogaionon; in cult caves, like the grottoes of Zerynthia, Rhesos and Salmoxis; and in sacred forests, such as the grove at Ismaros dedicated to Apollo (A. Fol 1990; D. Popov 1989; 1995; Theodossiev 2000c, 1924; 2002). Among several pertinent inscriptions, the most important is that from Seuthopolis (D. Dimitrov and Chichikova 1978; Velkov 1991, 711; Manov 1998a; Archibald 1999; Rabadzhiev 2002, 1054), which records that two temples of Dionysos and of the Samothracian Great Gods were situated within the city of Seuthes III, while an altar of Apollo and a phosphorion existed in Kabyle. Actually, the Seuthopolis inscription indicates well the Hellenisation of Thracian ritual and cult during the Early Hellenistic period, at least in towns inhabited by a mixed population. In addition, many decorated ritual escharai, presumably associated with the cult of Hestia, are found within the most houses and the palace in Seuthopolis (D. Dimitrov and Chichikova 1978; D. Dimitrov et al. 1984; Archibald 1999; Rabadzhiev 2002, 5354), while similar ritual hearths are known in other settlements from inland Thrace, such as Philippopolis, Pistiros and Kabyle. Intensive archaeological excavation over recent decades has yielded important evidence, revealing the great variety of Thracian sanctuaries and ritual places, many of them related to contemporary settlements or necropoleis. A number of recent scholarly studies have brought together the investigations and analysed the material (Venedikov and A. Fol 1976; A. Fol 1982; Triantaphyllos 1985; Domaradzki 1986; 1990; 1994a; Gotsev 1990, 1617; Georgieva 1991; V. Fol 1993, 3866; Tonkova 1997; 2003; Kissyov 1998ab; Archibald 1999; Borislavov 1999, 2530; Theodossiev 2000c, 1924). Most impressive are the rock sanctuaries, predominantly located in southeastern Thrace, frequently adjacent to rock-cut tombs or megalithic dolmens from the Early Iron Age. The sanctuaries consist of stairs, platforms, solar discs, altars, ritual basins, thrones, seats and other elements, cut into the rock massifs. A number of very similar rock sanctuaries are known in Anatolia, especially in Phrygia, and they clearly demonstrate the strong relationship in cult practices (Vassileva 1994; 1997; 1998; cf. Haspels 1971; De Francovich 1990). Many sanctuaries in other parts of Thrace are also situated on hills or mountain peaks; they consist of various combinations including enclosing stone walls, escharai, bothroi, votive deposits of metal objects, coins and pottery, remains of ritual feasts and animal sacrifices, etc. Many of the peak sanctuaries functioned without major interruption through the entire 1st millenniumBC and even from the Late Bronze Age to Roman Imperial times.
19
Some archaeological investigations may, in addition, illustrate what ancient literary sources have to say about sacred caves in Thrace. Unfortunately, the excavated material is so far too sparse for us to be able to specify the exact Thracian rituals performed inside the caves, but the cult drawings in the Magurata Cave, most probably coming from the Late Bronze or Early Iron Age, show personages that could represent a female goddess and a male deity. During the 1st millennium BC the most common type seems to have been the open-air pit sanctuaries and ritual places, usually located in the plains area. Some of the sites consist of hundreds of bothroi dug into the ground and were in continued use from the Late Bronze Age down to late antiquity. The bothroi vary significantly in size and shape, and contain pottery, coins and metal objects, embers, ritual hearths, animal sacrifices, the remains of ritual feasts, etc. In certain cases, as in the sanctuaries at Gledachevo and Staliiska Mahala, the remains of human sacrifices (human body-parts or whole skeletons) dating to the Late Iron Age are found inside the bothroi.
MORTUARY PRACTICES AND MONUMENTAL TOMBS The funerary rites of the Thracian tribes were not well described by ancient authors. Herodotus (5. 8. 1) wrote that deceased Thracian nobles were buried by cremation or inhumation in tumuli, after three days of prothesis during which numerous sacrifices were made and funeral feasts were arranged; different contests, including single combat, followed the completion of the tumuli. Later information by Xenophon (Hellenica 3. 2. 25) supplements Herodotus description: in 399 BC, after a battle in Bithynia, the Thracian Odrysians buried their dead fellows, drank a lot of wine and arranged horse racing in memory of deceased. Earlier, in the late 6th century BC, the mixed inhabitants of Thracian Chersonesos Dolonkoi and Athenian colonists followed the custom, making sacrifices and arranging horse races and other athletic games in memory of Miltiades the Elder (Herodotus 6. 38. 1). A number of other ancient sources related to the mythological figures of Zalmoxis, Rhesos and Orpheus provide additional information on the eschatological conceptions of the Thracian aristocracy and testify that some Thracian kings and priests were deified after death and were worshipped as immortal heroes and anthropodaimones who would return from the underworld (Theodossiev 2000b). Some of this mythological evidence contains quite reliable descriptions, such as Conon (45. 46), who wrote that the grave of Orpheus was a large tumulus encircled like a temenos, which was a heroon and later became a sanctuary, being respected by sacrifices and by other things used in worshipping the gods.
20
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
While ancient written sources are relatively scarce, the intensive archaeological excavations underway continue to reveal significant amounts of information on the great variety of the rites and practices of the Thracian tribes during the 1st millennium BC. Many general studies of Thracian funerary rituals have appeared, analysing both archaeological and written sources, as have other studies exploring in detail these practices in individual regions of Thrace or publishing particular burial sites (Mirchev 1962; 1965; Chichikova 1974b; Bobcheva 1975; Venedikov 1976bc; Toncheva 1980ab; Triantaphyllos 1980; Delev 1984; Gergova 1986; 1989; 1995; Petropoulou 198687; Domaradzki 1988; 1998ab; zdogan 1988; 1991; Gotsev 1990; 1994; 1998; Koukouli-Chrysanthaki 1992; Radev 1992; V. Fol 1993; Stoyanov 1992; 1997; Kissyov 1993; 1998a; Kitov 1993; 1994a; Kitov and Agre 2002; Gocheva 1994; Koicheva 1994; Panayotova 1994; Totevski 1994; Nehrizov 1996; 1999; Bouzek 1997; Kull 1997; Ylmaz 1997; Archibald 1998; Lehmann 1998, 16970; Borislavov 1999; Theodossiev 2000c; Kulov 2002; Stanchev 2002; Georgieva 2003; Georgieva et al. 1998). The burial rites of the Early Iron Age are well examined. Among the most remarkable funerary constructions are the megalithic dolmens widespread in south-eastern Thrace and Samothrace. They were usually covered with small tumuli and come in three types: single chamber, with antechamber and funeral chamber, with complex layout. Another type of megalithic funerary monument spread through south-eastern Thrace is the rock-cut tomb consisting of a single burial chamber of irregular shape; these display their closest similarities with the rock-cut tombs of Anatolia (Vassileva 1994; 1997; 1998; cf. Haspels 1971; De Francovich 1990). While megalithic funerary monuments were typical of the eastern Rhodope, the practices in the western part of the mountains were quite different: burial constructions were usually small tumuli with both cremation and inhumation burials and with various remains of ritual activities bothroi, hearths, animal or sometime human sacrifices, ritual gifts placed within the tumular embankments, remains of funerary feasts, etc. Many tumuli in the western Rhodope were used for multiple or secondary burials, while certain necropoleis display remarkable continuity and sometimes functioned throughout the entire 1st millennium BC. Information on Early Iron Age mortuary practices in south-western Thrace is sparse, but it is clear that both flat graves and small burial mounds were used, similar to neighbouring Paeonia (cf. Mitrevski 1997). North-eastern Thrace is a region where intensive archaeological investigation has provided a relatively complete picture of burial rites in the Early Iron Age. The usual constructions were small tumuli, like those at Sboryanovo, Ravna, Dobrina, Kragulevo, etc., with single, multiple or secondary inhumation and cremation burials and various kterismata. However, the
21
burial mounds at Belogradets, dating to the 8th6th centuries BC, are larger and have monumental stone-built funeral and ritual constructions, anthropomorphic funerary stelai, and a rich burial inventory. In addition, the tumuli at Belogradets indicate contacts with the Scythians, similar to the late 8th- or early 7th-century BC burial mound at Polsko Kosovo. The archaeological discoveries in north-western Thrace show that during the Early Iron Age the local tribes made extensive use of flat graves, following the traditions of the Late Bronze Age, and small tumuli, which appeared in the 8th7th centuries BC, and practised both cremation and inhumation. Some burial mounds, like those at Leskovets, Sofronievo, Altimir and Tarnava, display significant variety of funeral rites. In certain regions, the Rhodope mountains and north-western and northeastern Thrace, the Late Iron Age continued the traditions of the Early Iron Age in some way. However, a number of innovations are evident throughout Thracian territory. Both flat graves and tumuli were widespread during the period, displaying regional differences in the correlation of cremations to inhumations and some unusual practices (partial cremation, inhumation of individual parts of the human body, etc.). The tumuli of the Late Iron Age were bigger than the earlier ones, sometimes up to 25 m in height and more than 100 m in diameter. The constructions within the burial mounds were multifarious: grave pits, platforms, pyres, urns, cist graves, sarcophagi, stone-built chambers, and many others. Very often, the tumuli were used for multiple and secondary burials, and contain various combinations of different funerary constructions. A number of additional ritual activities and constructions were also typical of the tumuli, such as animal or, rarely, human sacrifices (equine and canine sacrifices were most common), non-burial stone constructions, ritual hearths, bothroi, the remains of funerary feasts, ritual deposits of metal or ceramic objects, etc. At the very end of the Early and the beginning of the Late Iron Age, rich aristocratic and royal burials appeared in Thrace, being typical for the period from the late 6th to the first half of the 3rd century BC. Thracian elite graves usually contain gold and silver vessels and jewellery, various weapons, imported Greek pottery and bronze tableware, besides a number of other funerary gifts. Among the earliest rich aristocratic necropoleis is the burial ground at Sindos (Bouzek and Ondrejov 1988; Theodossiev 1998a; 2000a), located in the interaction zone between Thrace and Macedonia and providing an impressive burial inventory, in particular spectacular golden funeral masks. The most remarkable Thracian royal cemetery from the late 6th to the early 4th century BC is the tumular necropolis at Duvanli; it yielded significant amount of gold and silver objects, luxurious Greek imports, and many other
22
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
finds (Filov 1934; Bouzek and Ondrejov 1988). Other rich elite burials of the last quarter of the 5th century BC are found at Dalboki (Vickers 2002, 5675) and in the Svetitsata tumulus at Shipka (Kitov 2004b); this last includes an impressive gold funeral mask (Fig. 4) as well as other precious grave-goods (Fig. 5). Another aristocratic burial of this time was excavated in tumulus No.1 at Chernozem (Kissyov 2005); it contains significant local and imported gravegoods, a gold pectoral (Fig. 6) and silver kylix (Fig. 7) being very spectacular. During the 4th and the early 3rd century BC, rich aristocratic tumular burials spread through the entire Thracian territory, yielding various grave constructions and burial inventories: gold and silver jewellery, vessels and appliqus of horse trappings, weaponry, red-figure Attic pottery, Greek bronze tableware, etc. Examples include the tumuli at Koprivets (Stanchev 1994; 2004),
Fig. 4. Golden funerary mask from the Svetitsata tumulus at Shipka, last quarter of the 5th century BC (after Kitov 2004b).
23
Fig. 5. Greek gold ring from the Svetitsata tumulus at Shipka showing a spear-carrying athlete, last quarter of the 5th century BC (after The Valley of the Thracian Rulers [Calendar, 2005]).
Fig. 6. Gold pectoral from tumulus No. 1 at Chernozem featuring a Gorgon and animal figures, last quarter of the 5th century BC (after Kissyov 2005).
24
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Fig. 7. Greek silver kylix from tumulus No. 1 at Chernozem showing Bellerophon and Chimaera, last quarter of the 5th century BC (after Kissyov 2005).
Golemani (Marazov 1998, 20506), Dolna Koznitsa (Marazov 1998, 10411; Staikova-Alexandrova 2004), Kralevo (Ginev 1983; 2000; Marazov 1998, 11821), and Mogilanskata Mogila in Vratsa (Theodossiev 2000c, 14547, no.248). In the same century and a half, rectangular tumular (corbel- or barrel-vaulted, etc.) and beehive tholos tombs spread across Thrace. More than 100 monuments are known so far (Filov 1937a; Bittel 1942; Mansel 1943; 1973; Mikov 1955; Tomlinson 1974; Venedikov 1974ab; 1976a; Onurkan 1988; Stoyanov 1990; Valeva 1993; 1999; Gergova 1996; Ylmaz 1996; Hatas 1997; 2002ab; Tsetskhladze 1998c; Chichikova 1999; Steingrber 1999; 2001; Rousseva 2000; 2002; Delemen 2001; Stoyanova 2002ab; Bouzek and Domaradzka 2003; Theodossiev 2004; forthcoming).2 The appearance of the Thracian monumental
2 For comparanda, see Kurtz and Boardman 1971; Miller 1972; 1993; 1994; Pandermalis 1972; Ceka 1975; 1985; Gossel 1980; Oleson 1982; Torelli 1985; Fedak 1990; Steingrber 2000.
25
tombs and their architectural features were definite results of the economic advance of the local aristocracy and multilateral contacts, relations and interactions, predominantly with Anatolia, Greece and Macedonia, but also with Illyria and Italy. Thus, many of the Thracian tombs were built entirely in the manner of Late Classical and Early Hellenistic architecture. A 4th-century BC rectangular tomb discovered at Smyadovo (Atanasov and Nedelchev 2002) displays the rare use of the Greek script in the Thracian funerary ritual: a two-line inscription GONIMASJHJ SEUQOU GUNJ (Gonimaseze the wife of Seuthes) is placed on the facade (Fig. 2) and clearly identifies the deceased. Another significant monument is the painted tholos tomb at Alexandrovo of the second half of the 4thearly 3rd century BC (Kitov 2002; 2004a; Kitov and Theodossiev 2003); while the impressive funerary paintings show heroic banqueting, hunting and combat scenes (Figs. 810), some with clear iconographic parallels throughout the eastern Mediterranean (cf. Borchhardt 1968; Sevin et al. 2001; Delemen 2004a), a small graffito (Fig. 2) in the beehive chamber depicts the deceased and gives his name
Fig. 8. Hunting horseman from the paintings in the tholos chamber of the Alexandrovo tomb, second half of the 4th or early 3rd century BC (after Kitov et al. 2003).
26
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Fig. 9. Hunt of a stag from the paintings in the tholos chamber of the Alexandrovo tomb, second half of the 4th or early 3rd century BC (after Kitov et al. 2003).
Fig. 10. Hunt of a boar from the paintings in the tholos chamber of the Alexandrovo tomb, second half of the 4th or early 3rd century BC (after Kitov et al. 2003).
27
KOHIMACJC XRJCTOC.3 The Early Hellenistic tholos tombs at Starosel (Figs. 1112) (Kitov 200102; 2003a; Kitov and Theodossiev 2003) and Mezek (Filov 1937ab) are among the most impressive burial constructions known in Thrace and display quite monumental funerary architecture. Another Early Hellenistic rectangular tomb with remarkable architecture and an intact elite burial is found in the Naip tumulus near Tekirdag (Delemen 2004b), while the Zhaba Mogila tumulus at Strelcha comprises two funerary monuments of 350300 BC: a tholos tomb (Fig. 13) and a rectangular corbel-vaulted tomb with impressive pediment (Fig. 14) showing two lions in relief (Kitov 1979). The barrel-vaulted tomb at Sveshtari (A. Fol et al. 1986; Chichikova 1989; 1992; Valeva 1997), coming from the second quarter of the 3rdcentury BC, and decorated with caryatids in relief and a drawing depicting scene of heroisation, is the most remarkable funerary monument in northern Thrace.
Fig. 11. Monumental staircase and facade of the tholos tomb at Starosel, Early Hellenistic period (after Kitov et al. 2003).
I would like to thank Prof. K. Clinton for his consultation.
28
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Fig. 12. Tholos burial chamber with Doric semi-columns and frieze of the tomb at Starosel, Early Hellenistic period (after Kitov et al. 2003).
Fig. 13. Antefix from the tholos tomb in Zhaba Mogila at Strelcha, 330300 BC (photograph: N. Theodossiev).
29
Fig. 14. Parts of a pediment showing two lions from the corbel-vaulted tomb in Zhaba Mogila at Strelcha, second half of the 4th century BC (photograph: N. Theodossiev).
A number of significant monuments were excavated in the Kazanlak region. Thus, the tholos tomb in the Shushmanets tumulus (Kitov 1996; 1997; 1999; 2003b) from the second half of the 4th century BC displays an unusual combination of Greek architectural orders (Figs. 1516), while the sarcophaguslike tomb of 330320 BC (Fig. 17) in the Ostrusha tumulus (Kitov 1994b; Kitov and Krasteva 199495; Kitov et al. 1997; Barbet et al. 1995; Valeva 2002) provides remarkable paintings (Figs. 1819) on the ceiling of the monolithic rectangular burial chamber, entirely in the spirit of Early Hellenistic art. The monumental tomb in the Golyamata Kosmatka tumulus (Kitov n.d.) that dates to ca. 300 BC has a unique layout consisting of a dromos, rectangular corbel-vaulted antechamber, second beehive tholos antechamber and monolithic rectangular burial chamber; two inscribed silver vessels from the burial chamber, part of a rich funeral inventory (Figs. 2022), indicate that the monument was related to the Odrysian king, Seuthes III (ca. 330300 BC),
30
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Fig. 15. The barrel-vaulted entryway supported by Ionic column of the tholos tomb in the Shushmanets tumulus at Shipka, second half of the 4th century BC (after Kitov 1997).
Fig. 16. The beehive burial chamber with Doric semi-columns and supported by non-fluted Doric column of the tomb in the Shushmanets tumulus at Shipka, second half of the 4th century BC (after post-card).
while a bronze head (Fig. 23) found in front of the tomb, broken from a lifesize statue, is a masterpiece of Early Hellenistic sculpture and is most probably a portrait of Seuthes himself. The tholos tomb in Kazanlak (Frova 1945; 1953; Verdiani 1945; Picard 194748; Mikov 1954; D. Dimitrov 1966; Zhivkova 1974; Ognenova-Marinova 1977; Blzquez 1994), from the very end of the 4th or the first decades of the 3rd century BC, contained remarkable funerary paintings showing an heroic banquet and combats, entirely in the spirit of Early Hellenistic art. The rectangular corbel-vaulted tomb at Maglizh (Getov 1988; Barbet and Valeva 2001), dated to the middle of the 3rd century BC, is among the latest examples of Thracian painted funerary monuments.
31
Fig. 17. The monumental tomb in the Ostrusha tumulus at Shipka, 330320 BC (after Kitov 1994b).
Fig. 18. Portrait of a woman on the ceiling of the sarcophagus-like burial chamber in the Ostrusha tumulus at Shipka, 330320 BC (courtesy Philip Sapirstein).
32
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Fig. 19. Scene showing two men on the ceiling of the sarcophagus-like burial chamber in the Ostrusha tumulus at Shipka, 330320 BC (after Valeva 2002).
Fig. 20. Gold appliqu of horse trappings featuring human face, from the tomb in the Golyamata Kosmatka tumulus at Shipka, ca. 300 BC (after The Valley of the Thracian Rulers).
33
Fig. 21. Gold appliqu of horse trappings showing stag head in the Thracian Animal Style, from the tomb in the Golyamata Kosmatka tumulus at Shipka, ca. 300 BC (after The Valley of the Thracian Rulers).
34
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Fig. 22. Bronze greave with the head of Athena, from the tomb in the Golyamata Kosmatka tumulus at Shipka, ca. 300 BC (after The Valley of the Thracian Rulers).
35
Fig. 23. Bronze head of a life-size statue most probably depicting Seuthes III, found in front of the tomb in the Golyamata Kosmatka tumulus at Shipka, ca. 300 BC (after Kitov n.d.).
36
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
TOREUTICS AND TREASURES The toreutics of ancient Thrace are among the most attractive of archaeological materials. They have received intense scrutiny from specialists world wide who have use different methods of examination and proposed various interpretations within the contexts and contacts of the eastern Mediterranean, the Near East and the Pontic region (Filov 1917; 1934; Amandry 1959; Byvanck-Quarles van Ufford 1966; 1989ab; 1990; Strong 1966; Venedikov 1969; Venedikov and Gerasimov 1976; Berciu 1974; Marghitan 1976; Melyukova 1976; 1979; Pittioni 1977; Marazov 1977; 1978; 1992; 2002; Minchev 1978; BarrSharrar 1982; 1986; Taylor 1982; 1987; 1989a; Alexandrescu 1983; 1984; Fischer 1983; Luschey 1983; Pfrommer 1983; 1987; 1990; 1993; Archibald 1985; 1989; 1998; Bergquist and Taylor 1987; Drig 1987; Abkai-Khavari 1988; Ewigleben 1989; B. Hoddinott 1989; Schneider 1989; 1990; Schneider and Zazoff 1994; Vickers 1989; 1991; Stoyanov 1991; 2003; Zazoff 1991; Zazoff et al. 1985; Kaul 1993; Shefton 1993; Boardman 1994; 2000; Rabadzhiev 1994, 89102; Fialko 1995; Kemenczei 1995; von Blow 1997; Kull 1997; Damyanov 1998; Ebbinghaus 1999; Tsetskhladze 1999a; Srbu and Florea 2000ab; Theodossiev 2000c; 2003; Zournatzi 2000; Kitov and Agre 2002, 181219, 26174; Ursu Naniu 2004). A number of treasures and burial hoards comprising silver and gold objects, both of local Thracian production and imported, form the legacy of the Thracian aristocracy and provide options to examine a variety of topics. The most spectacular works come from the Classical and Hellenistic periods. The shapes known in Thracian toreutics were usually borrowed from Achaemenid and Greek metalware and ceramics, and include phialai, calyxes, goblets, skyphoi, kantharoi, jugs, rhyta, etc. A very important focus of research is on the rich iconography of the local toreutics from the 4th century BC onwards, which clearly shows the creativity and influences that formed the indigenous art. Some images of the Great Goddess and her male companion the king-hero remain without parallels beyond Thrace, and seem to belong to local tradition, but many other representations find a number of iconographical comparanda throughout the eastern Mediterranean. The Thracian king was usually depicted as a hunter-rider (Fig.24), while the images of the Great Goddess show more diversity. Other Classical and Early Hellenistic representations in Thracian metalwork are indicative of even stronger foreign influence and originated in Greek, Anatolian and Scythian art. Special attention must be given to the images of Kybele, Artemis (potnia theron), Heracles and Bellerophon, who appeared in the Early Hellenistic period. The presence of these characters testifies to the
37
Fig. 24. Gold ring from Peichova Mogila at Starosel featuring a hunting scene, second half of the 4th century BC (after Kitov 200102).
Hellenisation of local craftsmen and of the local aristocracy, who were aware of Greek myths. The strong syncretism evident in the iconography, especially the Thracian elements, may suggest, however, that some local deities and heroes were represented in the form of Greek and Anatolian personages. Some Early Hellenistic figures in Thracian toreutics, like the Lamassu, obviously originated in Iranian art and indicate cross-cultural contacts. Presumably, most of these connections were a result of the Eastern campaigns of Alexander the Great, when some members of the Thracian aristocracy participated in the actions of the Macedonian army and returned home with new syncretic ideas. In fact, the cultural diversity and free exchange of ideas between different ethnic communities in the eastern Mediterranean, Near East and the Pontic region during the 1st millennium BC gave rise to various interactions that influenced the forms and features of Thracian metalwork, of course on the basis of local traditions. Simultaneously, Thracian toreutics also influenced the art of the Celts and the Scythians. This is why the metalwork appears to be
38
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
among the best evidence showing that Thrace was closely related to the rest of the ancient world and actively participated in syncretic cultural processes and multilateral interaction. Most of the Thracian treasures have been well illustrated in a number of exhibition catalogues (Gold der Thraker 1979; Het Goud der Thracirs 1984; Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987; Berti and La Porta 1997; Marazov 1998; Ancient Thrace 2000). Among the earliest finds, ones that deserve special attention are the gold cup from Belene, which shows schematic decoration and dates to the beginning of the Early Iron Age (Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 130, no. 162), and the 7th6th-century BC hoard from Kazichene, comprising a bronze cauldron, a ceramic vessel and a decorated gold cup, 1.050 kg in weight (Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 12930, nos. 159161). Another important find is the treasure from Barzitsa, of which a pair of gold earrings and one gold and three silver hoops (presumably spiral bracelets) survived, being dated to the period from the 11th to the 8th7thcenturies BC (Gergova 1982; Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 13941, nos. 185189). One of the most significant hoards is the Rogozen treasure, comprising 165 silver vessels: 108 phialai, 54 jugs and three cups (goblet, skyphos, kotyle), a total weight of some 19.900 kg (Der thrakische Silberschatz 1988; ByvanckQuarles van Ufford 1989b; 1990; Archibald 1998, 26569; Theodossiev 2000c, 135, no. 196). The hoard is quite heterogeneous and belonged to the Triballi aristocracy. Some vessels are decorated with mythological scenes and images and obviously were produced in northern Thracian workshops; others are of imported origin: Greek, Macedonian and, presumably, Achaemenid. A number of stippled or incised inscriptions show that some vessels were possessions of the Odrysian kings, Cotys I (383359 BC) and Kersebleptes (359341 BC), who presumably offered the precious objects as political gifts to the Triballi chieftains during negotiations. Two inscriptions mention Satokos, presumably the son of the Odrysian king, Sitalces, and another one gives the name of Didykaimos, not attested in the literary sources. The vessels from the Rogozen treasure were accumulated over a long period and date from the middle of the 5th to the beginning of the 3rd century BC. Another important find is the Borovo treasure, comprising a silver pitcherrhyton decorated with two friezes showing Dionysiac scenes but with a form originating in the Persian toreutics, three rhyta with Greek and Achaemenid shapes and decoration, and a two-handled bowl (Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 20507, nos. 338342; Archibald 1998, 26465; Stoyanov 1998; Theodossiev 1998b). The vessels are heterogeneous and some of them may originate from toreutic workshops in north-western Anatolia. Three inscriptions
39
in Greek were stippled on the pitcher-rhyton and two rhyta, indicating that the objects belonged to the Odrysian king, Cotys I, who presumably offered the silver vessels as diplomatic gifts to unknown Getic ruler. The most spectacular hoard from Thrace is the Panagyurishte treasure, comprising nine gold vessels with a total weight of 6.164 kg (Svoboda and Concev 1956; Concev 1959; Simon 1960; Venedikov 1961; Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 23741, nos. 420428; Archibald 1998, 27174; Kitov and Atanasov 2000; Stoyanov 2004). The amphora-rhyton is decorated with Greek mythological scene, presumably showing the Seven against Thebes, but its shape undoubtedly originates in Achaemenid metalware. The three anthropomorphic head-vases display the images of Athena, Aphrodite and Hera. The two rhyta ending in stag heads depict the Judgment of Paris (Alexander) and two Labours of Heracles (the Hind of Ceryneia and the Cretan Bull). The rhyton ending with a rams head shows Dionysos, Eriope and Maenads, while the rhyton with a male-goat protome depicts Hera, Artemis, Apollo and Nike. The last vessel is a phiale decorated with circles of African heads in relief. The Panagyurishte treasure dates to the last decades of the 4th century or the early 3rd century BC; most probably, it was produced in some prominent workshop in north-western Anatolia. Two other important treasures, those found at Letnitsa (Pittioni 1977; Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 197203, nos. 315333; Venedikov 1996) and Lukovit (Chichikova 1980; Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 22033, nos. 375410; Archibald 1998, 269), date to the second half of the 4thearly 3rd century BC and contain a wide variety of silver objects of Thracian origin: appliqus of horse trappings decorated in the Animal Style or showing Thracian mythological scenes and vessels (jugs and phialai). The hoards from Galiche (Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 26064, nos. 472483; Theodossiev 2000c, 11415, no. 70) and Yakimovo (Marazov 1979; Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987, 26871, nos. 494502; Theodossiev 2000c, 147 48, no. 250) come from the 2nd1st centuries BC and consist of silver objects typical of Late Hellenistic Thracian toreutics: bracelets, round appliqus, a kantharos and conical bowls, some of them showing the images of the kingrider and the Great Goddess.
COINAGE The Thracian coinage provides a great variety of types minted in silver and bronze, which form a reliable source for studying political history, economy, trade, iconography and religion. The earliest coins appeared at the end of the
40
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
6th century and in the first decades of the 5th century BC and were minted in silver by the tribal kingdoms of the Derrones, Bisaltai, Tyntenoi, Ichnai and Orreskioi in south-western Thrace, on the border with Macedonia and Paeonia. Of special interest in this period are the silver coins of Getas, king of the Thracian Edonoi, which read: GETAS JDONEON BASILEUS (in several variants), and are one of the earliest examples displaying the use of the title basileus in ancient coinage. Later, a number of Odrysian kings, both attested in historical or epigraphic sources but unknown in ancient written sources, besides some kings who ruled other tribal states, minted different bronze and silver coins from the middle of the 5th century BC down to the first decades of the 1st century AD. Among the most important coins from the Classical and Early Hellenistic periods are those of Sparadokos, Saratokos, Seuthes I, Medokos (known as Amadokos I as well), Hebryzelmis, Cotys I, Amadokos II, Teres II, Ketriporis, Kersebleptes, Seuthes III and Spartokos, some of them showing quite realistic portraits of the kings. A number of other rulers, such as Adaios, Cotys II, Mostis, Cotys III, Sadalas II, Reskouporis I, Roimetalkas I, Cotys V, Roimetalkas II and Roimetalkas III, minted various coins throughout the entire Hellenistic period until the last Thracian kingdom was annexed by Rome in AD 45. While the Early Hellenistic Macedonian kings, such as Lysimachus, reigned in Thrace and issued numerous gold, silver and bronze coins, during the 4th2nd centuries BC some inland towns (Kypsela and Kabyle) coined their own emissions; and there were also coins minted by Scythian (Kanitos, Haraspos, Sariakos) and Celtic (Kauaros) kings who dominated in certain regions of Hellenistic Thrace. During the 20th century, several scholars published important numismatic studies discussing some of the Thracian coins (Svoronos 1919; Gaebler 1935; Gerasimov 1975). Other publications provided comprehensive studies of the coinage of ancient Thrace, in particular of the Odrysian Kingdom (Mushmov 1912; 1925; Youroukova 1976; 1992; Topalov 1994; 1998; 2000; Peter 1997), or examined aspects such the earliest tribal emissions (Gerasimov 1937; Tacheva 1998), the relationship between the early Thracian and Macedonian coinage (Greenwalt 1997), and the coins minted in Seuthopolis (K. Dimitrov et al. 1984) and Kabyle (Draganov 1993). * * I hope that this article has provided a general picture of Thrace during the 1st millennium BC and has described recent developments in scholarly research. Further detailed studies, combining written sources and archaeological data, *
41
will certainly result in publications that may provide us with a comprehesive, holistic view of Thrace and with more options for examining the relations and interactions between the Thracians and the other peoples who lived in the eastern Mediterranean and south-eastern Europe in antiquity.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abkai-Khavari, M. 1988: Die achmenidischen Metallschalen. AMIran 21, 91137. Adams, W.L. 1997: Philip II and the Thracian Frontier. In Actes. 2e symposium international des tudes Thraciennes: Thrace ancienne (Komotini), 8189. Agre, D. 1994: The Cross-Like Appliqu from Veliko Tarnovo District. Helis 3.1, 21532. Agre, D. and Kitov, G. (eds.) 2004: Panagyurskoto sakrovishte i trakiiskata kultura (Sofia). Alcock, S.E. 1993: Surveying the Peripheries of the Hellenistic World. In Bilde et al. 1993, 16275. Alexandrescu, P. 1983: Le groupe des trsors thraces du Nord des Balkans (I). Dacia n.s. 27.12, 4566. . 1984: Le groupe des trsors thraces du Nord des Balkans (II). Dacia n.s. 28.12, 8597. Amandry, P. 1959: Toreutique achmnide. AntKunst 2, 3856. Ancient Thrace 2000: Ancient Thrace. Gold and Silver Treasures from Bulgaria 5000 BCAD 300 (Exhibition Catalogue) (Helsinki). Andruh, S.I. 2000: Smeshannye s frakiitsami skifyi (Apol. Rhod. IV. 320). VDI 3, 6373. Archibald, Z.H. 1985: The Gold Pectoral from Vergina and Its Connections. OJA 4.2, 16585. . 1989: Thracian Interpretations of Greek and Oriental Elements in Fourth-Century Metalwork. In Cook 1989, 1225. . 1998: The Odrysian Kingdom of Thrace: Orpheus Unmasked (Oxford/New York). . 1999: Thracian Cult From Practice to Belief. In Tsetskhladze 1999b, 42768. . 2000: Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace. In Brock, R. and Hodkinson, S. (eds.), Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece (Oxford), 21233. . 2001a: Economic Relationships. In Archibald, Z.H., Davies, J., Gabrielsen, V. and Oliver, G.J. (eds.), Hellenistic Economies (London/New York), 20103. . 2001b: Geographies and Place. Regional Economies. In Archibald, Z.H., Davies, J., Gabrielsen, V. and Oliver, G.J. (eds.), Hellenistic Economies (London/New York), 13336. . 2002: The Shape of the New Commonwealth: Aspects of the Pontic and Eastern Mediterranean Regions in the Hellenistic Age. In Tsetskhladze, G.R. and A.M.Snodgrass (eds.), Greek Settlements in the Eastern Mediterranean and the Black Sea (BAR International Series 1062) (Oxford), 4972.
42
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
. 2003: Texts and Contexts: The People of the Odrysian Kingdom. In Nikolova 2003, 51924. Atanasov, G. and Nedelchev, N. 2002: Gonimasedze zhenata na Sevt i neinata grobnitsa. In Pitye. Studia in honorem Prof. Ivani Marazov (Sofia), 55057. Avram, A., Hind, J. and Tsetskhladze, G.R. 2004: The Black Sea Area. In Hansen, M.H. and Nielsen, T.H. (eds.), An Inventory of Archaic and Classical Poleis: An Investigation Conducted by The Copenhagen Polis Centre for the Danish National Research Foundation (Oxford), 92473. Babic, S. 2004: Poglavarstvo i polis: Starije gvozdeno doba Centralnog Balkana i grcki svet (Belgrade). Badian, E. 1980: Philip II and Thrace. Pulpudeva 4, 5171. Balabanov, P. 1983: Trakiiskiyat hinterland na Apoloniya i Mesambriya VIII v. pr.n.e. (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). . 1986: Gradove v drevna Trakiya predi pohodite na Filip II. In Vtori natsionalen simpozium Poselishten zhivot v Trakiya (Jambol), 4159. . 2000: Mchanismes du commerce lpoque hellnistique dans les environs de Messambrie et dApollonie Pontique. In Domaradzki 2000, 8799. Balcer, J.M. 1988: Persia Occupied Thrace (Skudra). Historia 37.1, 121. Barbet, A., Kitov, G. and Valeva, J. 1995: Tombeau-mausole dOstroucha. Archologia 313, 6266. Barbet, A. and. Valeva, J. 2001: Le tombe de Maglij (Bulgarie). In Barbet, A. (ed.), La peinture funraire antique IVe sicle av. J.-C.IVe sicle ap. J.-C (Actes du VIIe Colloque de lAssociation internationale pour la peinture murale antique [AIPMA], 610 octobre 1998, Saint-Romain-en-Gal, Vienne) (Paris), 23338. Barr-Sharrar, B. 1982: Macedonian Metal Vases in Perspective: Some Observations on Context and Tradition. In Barr-Sharrar, B. and Borza, E.N. (eds.), Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic Times (Studies in the History of Art 10) (Washington, DC), 12339. . 1986: Eastern Influence on the Toreutic Art of Macedonia before the Conquest of Alexander the Great. In Ancient Macedonia IV (Papers Read at the Fourth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 2125 September 1983) (Thessaloniki), 7182. Berciu, D. 1974: Contribution ltude de lart thraco-gte (Bibliotheca historica Romaniae 13) (Bucharest). Bergquist, A. and Taylor, T. 1987: The Origin of the Gundestrup Cauldron. Antiquity 61.231, 1024. Berti, R. and La Porta, E. 1997: Glorie di Tracia. Loro pi antico I tesori I miti (Exhibition Catalogue) (Florence). Beschi, L. 1990: Bendis, the Great Goddess of the Thracians, in Athens. Orpheus 1, 2936. Best, J.G.P. 1969: Thracian Peltasts and their Influence on Greek Warfare (Studies of the Dutch Archaeological and Historical Society 1) (Groningen). . 1989: Thrakische Namen in mykenischer Schrift. In Best and De Vries 1989, 13542. Best, J.G.P. and De Vries, N.M.W (eds.) 1989: Thracians and Mycenaeans (Proceedings of the Fourth International Congress of Thracology, Rotterdam, 2426 September 1984) (Leiden/Sofia).
43
Bilde, P., Engberg-Pedersen, T., Hannestad, L., Zahle, J. and Randsborg, K. (eds.) 1993: Centre and Periphery in the Hellenistic World (Studies in Hellenistic Civilization 4) (Aarhus). Bittel, K. 1942: Kleinasiatische Studien (IstMitt 5) (Istanbul). Blzquez, J.M. 1994: Los rituales funerarios de la tumba tracia de Kazanlak y sus paralelos en Grecia, Etruria, Campania, Lacio, la Peninsula Ibrica y Chipre. In Charis Didaskalias. Studia in honorem Ludovici Aegidii. Homenaje a Luis Gil (Madrid), 62535. Boardman, J. 1980: The Greeks Overseas: Their Early Colonies and Trade, 3rd ed. (London). . 1994: The Diffusion of Classical Art in Antiquity (London). . 2000: Persia and the West: An Archaeological Investigation of the Genesis of Achaemenid Art (London). Bobcheva, L. 1975: Trakiiski nekropoli pri selata Kragulevo i Cherna, Tolbuhinski okrag. INMV 11(26), 11928. . 1985: Geti prez I hilyadoletie pr.n.e. na teritoriyata na dneshniya Tolbuhinski okrag (po arheologicheski danni). In Severoiztochna Bulgaria drevnost i savremie. Parvi natsionalen simpozium (Sofia), 3948. Bogdanov, B. 1991: Orfei i drevnata mitologiya na Balkanite (Sofia). Bonias, Z. and Dadaki, S. 2002: Thasos: Kavalas Antiquities (Kavala). Borchhardt, J. 1968: Epichorische, grko-persisch beeinflute Reliefs in Kilikien. IstMitt 18, 161211. Borislavov, B. 1999: Yuzhna Trakiya v kraya na bronzovata nachaloto na rannozhelyaznata epoha. Problemi na prehoda (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). Borza, E.N. 1990: In the Shadow of Olympus. The Emergence of Macedon (Princeton/ Oxford). . 1999: Before Alexander: Constructing Early Macedonia (Publications of the Association of Ancient Historians 6) (Claremont, CA). Boshnakov, K. 1999: Identification archologique et historique de lemporion de Pistiros en Thrace. BCH 123, 31929. . 2003: Die Thraker sdlich vom Balkan in den Geographika Strabos (Palingenesia 81) (Weisbaden). Boteva-Boyanova, D. 2000: Problemi na trakiiskata istoriya i kultura (Sofia). Bouzek, J. 1985: Les contacts entre la Grce et la Thrace objets en bronze et cramique, VIIIeVIe s. av. n. .. ThrPont 3, 2029. . 1986: Macedonia and Thrace in the Early Iron Age. In Ancient Macedonia IV (Papers Read at the Fourth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 2125 September 1983) (Thessaloniki), 12332. . 1997: Greece, Anatolia and Europe: Cultural Interrelations during the Early Iron Age (SIMA 122) (Jonsered). . 1999: Pistiros and the South: Land and River Connections. In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 18996. . 2000a: Greeks Overland. In Tsetskhladze, G.R., Prag, A.J.N.W. and Snodgrass, A.M. (eds.), Periplous. Papers on Classical Art and Archaeology Presented to SirJohn Boardman (London), 3340.
44
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
. 2000b: La pntration grecque en Thrace centrale avant et pendant les guerres mdiques. In Domaradzki 2000, 3945. Bouzek, J. and Domaradzka, L. 2003: The Emergence of the Odrysian Aristocracy, the Greek Trade in Central Thrace, and the Emergence of Monumental Tomb Constructions. In Nikolova 2003, 52527. Bouzek, J., Domaradzka, L. and Archibald, Z.H. (eds.). 2002: Pistiros II: Excavations and Studies (Prague). Bouzek, J., Domaradzki, M. and Archibald, Z.H. (eds.). 1996: Pistiros I: Excavations and Studies (Prague). Bouzek, J. and Ondrejov, I. 1988: SindosTrebenishteDuvanli. Interrelations between Thrace, Macedonia, and Greece in the 6th and 5th Centuries BC. MedArch 1, 8494. Bozhkova, A. 1987: Ikonomicheski vrazki na Trakiya s elinisticheskiya svyat (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). . 1988: Tasoskiyat vnos v Trakiya prez IVIII v.pr.n.e.. Vekove 17.3, 2533. . 1992: Targovski kontakti na getskite plemena prez vtorata polovina na I hil. pr.n.e.. Helis 1, 10919. . 2000: Structures conomiques en Thrace du sud-ouest aux VIeIIe sicle avant J.-C.. In Domaradzki 2000, 7986. Bozhkova, A. and Delev, P. (eds.). 2002: Koprivlen 1: Rescue Archaeological Investigations along the Gotse DelchevDrama Road, 19981999 (Sofia). Brown, D. 2002: On the Relationship of Bendis and Artemis. In A. Fol 2002, 79197. Blow, G. von 1997: Beziehungen zwischen der Tiermotivik in der thrakischen und der skythischen Kunst. In Roman 1997, 5969. Byvanck-Quarles van Ufford, L. 1966: Remarques sur les relations entre lIonie grecque, la Thrace et lItalie. BABesch 41, 3449. . 1989a: A propos de lorfevrrie thrace. BABesch 64, 20519. . 1989b: Stijl, vorm en decoratie van de vazen uit Rogozen. In De Thracische Koningsschat, de zilverschat van Rogozen, Bulgarije (Amsterdam), 2026. . 1990: A propos du trsor de Rogozen. BABesch 65, 5172. Casson, S. 1926: Macedonia, Thrace and Illyria: Their Relations to Greece from the Earliest Times down to the Time of Philip, Son of Amyntas (Oxford/London). Ceka, N. 1975: Ndrtimet sepulkrale t qyteteve ilire. Monumentet 9, 3545. . 1985: Qyteti ilir pran Selcs s Poshtme (Tirana). Chambers, J. 1999: Perdiccas, Sitalces, and Athens. In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 21724. Changova, I. 1981: Trakiiskoto selishte ot I hil. pr.n.e.. In Pernik 1 (Sofia), 52107. Cicikova [Chichikova], M. 1974a: Habitats et forteresses thraces du Ier millnaire av. n. re. Pulpudeva 1, 15-33. Chichikova, M. 1974b: Prouchvaniya na trakiiskata kultura prez starata zhelyazna epoha. Arheologiya 16.4, 1927. . 1980: Trakiiskoto sakrovishte ot Lukovit (Sofia). . 1989: Tombeau royal de Svestari et certains aspects du culte sepulcral thrace. In Best and De Vries 1989, 20517. . 1990: Novootkrit epigrafski pametnik za kulta na Fosforos v Severoiztochna Trakiya. TAB 4, 8292.
45
. 1992: The Thracian Tomb near Sveshtari. Helis 2, 14363. . 1999: Le systme dcoratif dans la peinture murale en Thrace. In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 33344. Cole, S.G. 1984: Theoi Megaloi: The Cult of the Great Gods at Samothrace (tudes preliminaries orientales dans lEmpire romain 96) (Leiden). Concev, D. 1959: Der Goldschatz von Panagjurischte (Deutsche Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin, Schriften der Sektion fr Altertumswissenschaft 16) (Berlin). Cook, B.F. (ed.) 1989: The Rogozen Treasure. Papers of the Anglo-Bulgarian Conference, 12 March 1987 (London). Cunliffe, B.W. 1997: The Ancient Celts (Oxford/New York). Damyanov, M. 1998: The Matrix from Garchinovo: Problems of Origin and Dating. ArchBulg 2.2, 2839. . 2003: On the Local Population around the Greek Colonies in the Black Sea Area (5th3rd Centuries BC). AWE 2.2, 25364. Danov, K.M. 1947: Zapadniyat bryag na Cherno more v drevnostta (Sofia). . 197576: The Celtic Invasion and Rule in Thrace in the Light of Some New Evidence. Studia Celtica 1011, 2939. . 1976: Altthrakien (Berlin/New York). . 1998: Trakiisko izvoroznanie (Veliko Turnovo). Daux, G. 1967: Guide de Thasos (Paris). De Francovich, G. 1990: Santuari e tombe rupestri dellantica Frigia e unindagine sulle tombe della Licia (Mediaevalia 3), 2 vols. (Rome). Delemen, I. 2001: Tumulus Excavations in Thrace. In Belli, O. (ed.), Istanbul Universitys Contributions to Archaeology in Turkey (1932-2000) (Istanbul), 204 05. . 2004a: A Grave Stele from Barbaros on the Propontis. Epigraphica Anatolica 37, 18995. . 2004b: Tekirdag Naip Tmls (Istanbul). Delev, P. 1984: Megalithic Thracian Tombs in Southeastern Bulgaria. Anatolica 11, 1745. . 2004: Lizimah (Sofia). Delev, P., Bozhkova, A., Valcheva, D. and Hadzhiangelov, V. 2000: Koprivlen: une agglomration thrace sur le Nestos Moyen. In Domaradzki 2000, 15160. Der thrakische Silberschatz 1988: Der thrakische Silberschatz aus Rogozen Bulgarien (Exhibition Catalogue) (Sofia). Detschew, [Dechev] D. 1976: Die thrakischen Sprachreste (sterreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften. Philosophisch-Historische Klasse. Schriften der Balkankommission, Linguistische Abteilung 14), 2nd ed. (Vienna). Dimitrov, D.P. 1966: Za datata na stenopisite ot trakiiskata grobnitsa pri Kazanlak. Arheologiya 8.2, 113. Dimitrov, D.P. and Cicikova [Chichikova], M. 1978: The Thracian City of Seuthopolis (BAR Supplementary Series 38) (Oxford). Dimitrov, D.P., Chichikova, M., Balkanska, A. and Ognenova-Marinova, L. 1984: Sevtopolis 1: Bit i kultura (Sofia). Dimitrov, K. 1997: The Treasury of Lysimachos. Philip and Alexander Coin Hoards in Early Hellenistic Thrace. CD-ROM (Sofia).
46
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
. 1999: Macedonian Royal Traditions in Early Hellenistic Thrace c. 340c. 270 BC. In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 37581. Dimitrov, K. and Penchev, V. 1984: Sevtopolis 2: Antichni i srednovekovni moneti (Sofia). Dimitrova, N.M. 2002: Inscriptions and Iconography in the Monuments of the Thracian Rider. Hesperia 71.2, 20929. . 2006: Theoroi and Initiates in Samothrace: the Epigraphical Evidence (Hesperia suppl. 37) (Princeton). Dimitrova, N.M. and Clinton, K. 2003: An Archaic Inscription from Samothrace. Hesperia 72.2, 23539. Domaradzka, L. and Domaradzki, M. 1999: Population Structure of Pistiros (5th 4th c. BC). In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 38392. Domaradzki, M. 1982: Trakiiskite ukrepitelni saorazheniya IVII v. pr.n.e.. In Parvi natsionalen simpozium Poselishten zhivot v Trakiya (Jambol), 4459. . 1984: Keltite na Balkanskiya poluostrov (Sofia). . 1986: Sanctuaires thraces du IIeIer millnaire av. n. .. Acta Archaeologica Carpathica 25, 89100. . 1988: Trakiiski bogati pogrebeniya. TAB 3, 7886. . 1990: Trakiiskata kultura prez kasnozhelyaznata epoha v Rodopite i gornite porechiya na Maritsa, Mesta i Struma. In Domaradzki, M. (ed.), Trakiiskata kultura v Rodopite i gornite porechiya na rekite Maritsa, Mesta i Struma (Smolyan), 2944. . 1991: Zapadna krepostna stena na grad Kabile. In Kabile, vol. 2 (Sofia), 5482. . 1992: Trakiiskata kultura prez kasnozhelyaznata epoha v Severoiztochna Trakiya. Selishten i etnicheski oblik. Helis 1, 97108. . 1994a: Les lieux de culte thraces (deuxime moiti du IIeIer mill.av. J.-C.). Helis 3.1, 69108. . 1994b: Trakiiskoto izkustvo prez kasnozhelyaznata epoha. PrI 27.4, 4648. . 1995: Emporion Pistiros, vol. 1 (Septemvri). . 1998a: Trakiiskata kultura v prehoda kam elinisticheskata epoha. In Emporion Pistiros, vol. 2 (Septemvri), 1176. . 1998b: Tsistovi pogrebeniya v Rodopite. Rhodopica 1, 2729. . (ed.) 2000: Pistiros et Thasos: Structures conomiques dans la Pninsule Balkanique aux VIIeIIe sicles avant J.-C. (Opole). Drig, J. 1987: Les trsors dorfvrerie thrace (RdA suppl. 3) (Rome). Draganov, D. 1993: Monetosecheneto na Kabile (Sofia). . 2000-01: Monetite na makedonskite tsare: nominali, tipove, tseni, 2 vols. (Jambol). Ebbinghaus, S. 1999: Between Greece and Persia: Rhyta in Thrace from the Late 5th to the Early 3rd Centuries B.C.. In Tsetskhladze 1999b, 385425. Ewigleben, C. 1989: An Atelier of Silversmiths in Western Thrace: the Jug Cat. No. 155 from Rogozen and its Connections to the Vessels with Figural Reliefs from Poroina, Strelca, Loukovit and Vratsa. In Cook 1989, 2632. Fedak, J. 1990: Monumental Tombs of the Hellenistic Age: A Study of Selected Tombs from the Pre-Classical to the Early Imperial Era (Phoenix suppl. 27) (Toronto/ London).
47
Fialko, E.E. 1995: Frakiyskaya uzda iz kurgana Oguz. RosA 29.1, 13347. Filow [Filov], B.D. 1917: Denkmler der thrakischen Kunst. RomMitt 32, 2173. . 1934: Die Grabhgelnekropole bei Duvanlij in Sdbulgarien (Sofia). Filov, B. 1937a: Kupolnite grobnitsi pri Mezek. IBAI 11, 1116. . 1937b: The Bee-hive Tombs of Mezek. Antiquity 11.43, 30005. Fischer, F. 1983: Thrakien als Vermittler iransicher Metallkunst an die frhen Kelten. In Boehmer, R.M. and Hauptmann, H. (eds.), Beitrge zur Altertumskunde Kleinasiens. Festschrift fr Kurt Bittel, 2 vols. (Mainz), 191202. Fol, A. 1970: Demografska i sotsialna struktura na drevna Trakiya: I hilyadoletie predi n.e. (Sofia). . 1972: Politicheska istoriya na trakite: kraya na vtoroto hilyadoletie do kraya na peti vek predi novata era (Sofia). . 1974: Aperu historico-gographique des tribus thraces. Pulpudeva 1, 914. . 1975a: Thraco-Scythica. In Fol, A. and Ognenova-Marinova, L. (eds.), Frakoskifskie kulturnye sviazi (Studia Thracica 1) (Sofia), 16065. . 1975b: Trakiya i Balkanite prez rannoelinisticheskata epokha (Sofia). . (ed.) 1982: Megalitite v Trakiya 2: Trakiya Pontica (Trakiiski Pametnitsi 3) (Sofia). . 1986: Trakiiskiyat orfizam (Sofia). . 1990: Politika i kultura v drevna Trakiya (Sofia). . 1997: Istoriya na bulgarskite zemi v drevnostta do kraya na III v.pr.Hr. (Sofia). (ed.) 2002: Thrace and the Aegean (Proceedings of the Eighth International Congress of Thracology) (Sofia). Fol, A. and Spiridonov, T. 1983: Istoricheska geografiya na trakiiskite plemena do III v. pr.n.e. (Sofia). Fol, A., Chichikova, M., Ivanov, T. and Teofilov, T. 1986: The Thracian Tomb near the Village of Sveshtari (Sofia). Fol, V. 1993: Skalata, konyat i oganyat: Ranna trakiiska obrednost (Sofia). Fraser, P.M. 1960: The Inscriptions on Stone (Samothrace 2, part 1) (London/New York). Frova, A. 1945: Le pitture de Kazanlak. Arti Figurative 1.3, 10522. . 1953: A Hellenistic Painting Found in Bulgaria. Antiquity 27.106, 9697. Gaebler, H. 1935: Die antiken Mnzen von Makedonia und Paionia (Die antiken Mnzen Nord-Griechenlands 3) (Berlin). Galabov, I. 1950: Edin novootkrit nadpis ot Nesebar. INMB 1, 722. Gattinoni, F.L. 1992: Lisimaco di Tracia. Un sovrano nella prospettiva del primo ellenismo (Edizioni universitarie Jaca 90) (Milan). Georgieva, R. 1991: Obredni yami v Trakiya (kraya na III hil.pr.n.e.). Arheologiya 33.1, 110. . 2003: Sepultures insolites de Thrace (fin de IIeIer mill. av. J.-C.). Thracia 15 (In honorem annorum LXX Alexandri Fol), 31322. Georgieva, R. and Bachvarov, I. 1985: Novi danni za poselishtniya zhivot prez I hil. pr.n.e. v Silistrenski okrag. In Lazarov, M. and Yordanov, K. (eds.), Severoiztochna Bulgaria drevnost i savremie. Parvi natsionalen simpozium (Sofia), 6576. Georgieva, R., Nehrizov, G. and Aljakova, P. 1998: La ncropole du Premier Age du Fer prs du village de Katriste, rgion de Kustendil. ArchBulg 2.3, 3150.
48
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Gerasimov, T.D. 1937: Nahodki ot dekadrahmi na trako-makedonskoto pleme deroni. IBAI 11, 24957. . 1975: Antichni i srednovekovni moneti v Bulgaria (Sofia). Gergova, D. 1982: Proizhod, harakter i datirovka na sakrovishteto ot s. Barzitsa (b.Sheremet), Varnenski okrag. Arheologiya 24.34, 617. . 1986: Postizheniya i problemi v prouchvaneto na rannozhelyaznata epoha v Trakiya. Arheologiya 28.3, 1126. . 1987: Frh- und ltereisenzeitliche Fibeln in Bulgarien (Prhistorische Bronzefunde 14.7) (Munich). . 1989: Thracian Burial Rites of the Late Bronze and Early Iron Age. In Best and De Vries 1989, 23140. . 1990: Trakiiskata kultura prez rannozhelyaznata epoha v Yugozapadna Bulgaria prouchvaniya i problemi. In Domaradzki, M. (ed.), Trakiiskata kultura v Rodopite i gornite porechiya na rekite Maritsa, Mesta i Struma (Smolyan), 1728. . 1995: Culture in the Late Bronze and Early Iron Age in Southwest Thrace (Upper Mesta and Middle Struma Valleys). Zbornik n.s. 1: Arheologija (Skopje), 3148. . 1996: Obredat na obezsmartyavaneto v drevna Trakiya (Sofia). Gergova, D. and Iliev, I. 1982: Kam vaprosa za poselishtnoto razvitie v raiona na Kabile i Yugoiztochna Trakiya prez III hil. pr.n.e.. In Parvi natsionalen simpozium Poselishten zhivot v Trakiya (Yambol), 1123. Getov, L. 1988: Maglizhkata grobnitsa (Sofia). . 1995: Amfori i amforni pechati ot Kabyle (IVII v.pr.n.e.) (Sofia). Ginev, G. 1983: Sakrovishteto ot Kralevo (Sofia). . 2000: Trakiiski mogili pri selo Kralevo, Targovishtko (Varna). Gocheva, Z. 1994: Pogrebalnite obichai na trakite i vyarata im v bezsmartieto. In Seuthopolis 1994, 2532. . (ed.) 2002: Izvori za istoriyata na Trakiya i trakite, vol. 2 (Sofia). Goceva [Gocheva], Z. 2003: Le culte de la Grande desse-mre en Thrace. Thracia 15 (In honorem annorum LXX Alexandri Fol), 16978. Gold der Thraker 1979: Gold der Thraker Archologische Schtze aus Bulgarien (Exhibition Catalogue) (Mainz). Gold of the Thracian Horsemen 1987: Gold of the Thracian Horsemen. Treasures from Bulgaria (Exhibition Catalogue) (Montreal). Gossel, B. 1980: Makedonische Kammergrber (Berlin). Gotsev, A. 1990: Kulturata prez rannozhelyaznata epoha v Yugoiztochna Bulgaria (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). . 1992: Prouchvaniya na selishtnata sistema prez rannozhelyaznata epoha v Severoiztochna Trakiya. Helis 1, 7081. . 1994: Contacts and Interactions across the Eastern Balkan Range during the Early Iron Age. Helis 3.1, 4368. . 1997: Characteristics of the Settlement System during the Early Iron Age in Ancient Thrace. In Damgaard Andersen, H., Horsnaes, H.W. and Houby-Nielsen, S. (eds.), Urbanization in the Mediterranean in the Ninth to Sixth Centuries BC (Acta Hyperborea 7) (Copenhagen), 40721. . 1998: New Data on the Dolmens in the Sakar Mountain Region. In Stefanovich, M., Todorova, H. and Hauptmann, H. (eds.), James Harvey Gaul. In Memoriam (In the Steps of James Harvey Gaul 1) (Sofia), 24754.
49
Graham, A.J. 2002: Thasos and the Bosporan Kingdom. AWE 1.1, 87101. Greenwalt, W. 1997: Thracian Influence on the Ideology of Argead Kingship. In Actes. 2e symposium international des tudes Thraciennes. Thrace ancienne (Komotini), 12134. Griffith, G.T. 1935: The Mercenaries of the Hellenistic World (Cambridge; reprinted Groningen 1968). Hnsel, B. 1976: Beitrge zur regionalen und chronologischen Gliederung der lteren Hallstattzeit an der unteren Donau (Beitrge zur ur- und frhgeschichtlichen Archologie des Mittelmeer-Kulturraumes 1617), 2 vols. (Bonn). Haspels, C.H.E. 1971: The Highlands of Phrygia: Sites and Monuments (Princeton). Hatas, J. 1997: Der gisch-anatolische Kontext der thrakischen sepulkralen Bauwerke (5.3. Jh.v.Chr.). In Roman 1997, 31020. . 2002a: Grobowce trackie tak zwanego macedonskiego typu na obszarze Bugarii oraz Turcji europejskiej w pznej epoce zelaza - uwagi wstpne. In Studia nad Kultur Antyczn, vol. 2 (Opole), 95115. . 2002b: Konstruktionsreiche Grabanlagen der thrakischen Aristokratie (5.3. Jh.v.Chr.). In A. Fol 2002, 48799. Hatzopoulos, M. 1980: La politique thrace des derniers Antigonides. Pulpudeva 4, 8087. Hatzopoulos, M. and Loukopoulou, L. 1992, 1996: Recherches sur les marches orientales des Tmnides (Meletemata 11), 2 vols. (Athens). Het Goud der Thracirs 1984: Het Goud der Thracirs. TrojeThraci (Exhibition Catalogue) (Rotterdam). Hoddinott, B. 1989: Thracian Goddesses and Priestesses in the Rogozen Treasure. In Cook 1989, 4449. Hoddinott, R.F. 1981: The Thracians (London/New York). . 1989: Rogozen and Thracian Religion: the Indo-European Factor. In Cook 1989, 5058. Isaac, B.H. 1986: The Greek Settlements in Thrace until the Macedonian Conquest (Studies of the Dutch Archaeological and Historical Society 10) (Leiden). Ivanov, D. 1985: Trakite v Rusenskiya krai prez I hilyadoletie predi novata era. In Severoiztochna Bulgaria drevnost i savremie. Parvi natsionalen simpozium (Sofia), 5764. Karayotov, I. 1992: Monetosecheneto na Mesambria (Burgas). Katsarov, G.I. 1916: Beitrge zur Kulturgeschichte der Thraker (Sarajevo). . 1919: Keltite v stara Trakiya i Makedoniya. Spisanie na Bulgarskata Akademiya na Naukite 18: Klon Istoriko-Filologichen i Filosofsko-Obshtestven 10, 4180. . 1930: Thrace. CAH VIII, 53460, 78183. . 1936: Thrake. Religion. RE 6A, 472551. Katsarov, G. and Dechev, D. (eds.). 1949: Izvori za starata istoriya i geografiya na Trakiya i Makedoniya, 2nd ed. (Sofia). Kaul, F. 1993: The Gundestrup Cauldron and the Periphery of the Hellenistic World. In Bilde et al. 1993, 3952. Kemenczei, T. 1995: Zu frheisenzeitlichen Goldfunden aus dem Karpatenbecken. In Hnsel, B. (ed.), Handel, Tausch und Verkehr im Bronze- und Frheisenzeitlichen Sdosteuropa (Sdosteuropa-Schriften 17: Prhistorische Archologie in Sdosteuropa 11) (Munich), 33148.
50
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Kissyov, K. 1993: Pogrebalnite praktiki v Rodopite (kraya na III hil.pr.n.e.) (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). . 1998a: The Thracian Culture in the Smolyan Region. Rhodopica 1, 2126. . 1998b: Arheologicheski svidetelstva, svarzani s trakiiskite kultovi mesta i praktiki v Srednite i Zapadnite Rodopi v perioda kraya na III hil.pr.Hr.. Rhodopica 1, 3138. . 2004: Trakiiskata kultura v regiona na Plovdiv i techenieto na r. Stryama prez vtorata polovina na I hil.pr.Hr. (Sofia). . 2005: Thrace and Greece in Ancient Times 1: Classical Age Tumuli in the Municipality of Kaloyanovo (Plovdiv). Kitov, G. 1979: Trakiiskite mogili krai Strelcha (Prouchvaniya NEK 1) (Sofia). . 1993: Trakiiskite mogili. Thracia 10, 3980. . 1994a: The Thracian Mounds. Bulletin of the Ancient Orient Museum (Tokyo) 15, 12147. . 1994b: Trakiiski grobnichno-kultov kompleks v mogilata Ostrusha krai Shipka. PrI 27.4, 1320. . 1996: The Thracian Valley of the Kings in the Region of Kazanluk. Balkan Studies 37.1, 534. . 1997: Tombes monumentales thraces. Archologia 338, 2835. . 1999: Royal Insignia, Tombs and Temples in the Valley of the Thracian Rulers. ArchBulg 3.1, 120. . 200102: Starosel centre cultuel thrace. Orpheus 1112, 560. . 2002: New Thracian Frescoes from Bulgaria. Minerva 13.3, 4245. . 2003a: A Thracian Cult Complex near Starosel. Chetinyova Mogila in Light of the Investigations in 2000. In Nikolova 2003, 50518. . 2003b: Dolinata na trakiiskite vladeteli (I). Arheologiya 44.1, 1328. . 2004a: Novi nablyudeniya v Aleksandrovskata grobnitsa. Arheologiya 45.12, 4251. . 2004b: Teres vaskrasna ot zlato v Dolinata na trakiiskite tsare. Odisei 10 (37), 1215. . n.d.: Grobnitsata na Sevt III (n.p.). Kitov, G. and Agre, D. 2002: Vavedenie v trakiiskata arheologiya (Sofia). Kitov, G. and Atanasov, A. 2000: Panagyurskoto sakrovishte (Sofia). Kitov, G., Barbet, A. and Valeva, J. 1997: Plafond peint du tombeau de Chipka dans le tumulus Ostrucha (Bulgarie). In Scagliarini Corlita, D. (ed.), I temi figurativi nella pittura parietale antica ( IV sec.a.C.IV sec.d.C.) (Atti del VI Convegno internazionale sulla pittura parietale antica) (Studi e Scavi 5) (Imola/Bologna), 22124. Kitov, G. and Krasteva, M. 199495: The Thracian Grave and Cult Complex in the Ostrousha Tumulus near Shipka. Talanta 2627, 728. Kitov, G. and Theodossiev, N. 2003: I colori dei Traci. Archeo 19.8(222), 3447. Koicheva, K. 1994: Nadgrobni mogili v Tsentralniya Balkan. In Seuthopolis 1994, 8997. Koleva, B. 2000: Prospections archologiques sur le Trimontium. In Domaradzki 2000, 10312. Koukouli-Chrysanthaki, C. 1985: Abdera and the Thracians. ThrPont 3, 8298. . 1992: Protoistorike Thasos. Ta nekrotapheia tou oikismou Kastri (Demosieumata tou archaiologikou deltiou 45), 4 vols. (Athens).
51
Kull, B. 1997: Tod und Apotheose. Zur Ikonographie in Grab und Kunst der jngeren Eisenzeit an der unteren Donau und ihrer Bedeutung fr die Interpretation von Prunkgrbern. Bericht der Rmisch-Germanischen Komission 78, 200466. Kulov, G. 2002: Prinos kam tipologiyata i hronologiyata na skalnite grobni saorazheniya v Iztochnite Rodopi. Rhodopica 12, 99122. Kurtz, D.C. and Boardman, J. 1971: Greek Burial Customs (London). Lazaridis, D. 1997: Amphipolis (Athens). Lazarov, M. 1978: Amforite i targoviyata po trakiiskiya bryag na Ponta (IVI v. pr.n.e.). (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). . 2003: Drevnogratskata risuvana keramika ot Bulgaria (Varna). Lehmann, K. 1998: Samothrace. A Guide to the Excavations and Museum, 6th ed. (Thessaloniki). Lewis, N. 1958: The Ancient Literary Sources (Samothrace 1) (London/New York). Loukopoulou, L. 1989: Contribution lhistoire de la Thrace propontique durant la periode archaique (Meletemata 9) (Athens). Lozanova-Stancheva, V. 1993: Mito-ritualniyat kompleks na trakiiskite kotitii (Sofia). Lund, H.S. 1992: Lysimachus. A Study in Early Hellenistic Kingship (London/New York). Luschey, H. 1983: Thrakien als ein Ort der Begegnung der Kelten mit der iranischen Metallkunst. In Boehmer, R.M. and Hauptmann, H. (eds.), Beitrge zur Altertumskunde Kleinasiens. Festschrift fr Kurt Bittel (Mainz), 31329. Manov, M. 1998a: Golemiyat nadpis ot Sevtopilis. Arheologiya 39.12, 815. . 1998b: Prosopografiya na trakite v tsirkumpontiiskiya areal (po epigrafski danni ot VI v. pr.n.e. do 45 g. ot n.e.) (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). Mansel, A.M. 1943: Die Kuppelgraeber von Kirklareli in Thrakien (TTKY 6.2) (Ankara). . 1973: Gebze yresinde Kutluca kubbeli mezari ve onun Trakya kubbeli mezarlari arasinda aldigi yer. Belleten 37.146, 14358. Marazov, I. 1977: Influences et originalit ou lIran et la Thrace. Thracia 4, 1531. . 1978: Ritonite v drevna Trakiya (Sofia). . 1979: Sakrovishteto ot Yakimovo (Sofia). . 1992: Mit, ritual i izkustvo u trakite (Sofia). . 1994: Mitologiya na trakite (Sofia). . (ed.) 1998: Ancient Gold: the Wealth of the Thracians. Treasures from the Republic of Bulgaria (New York). . 2002: Transition from Abstraction to Figuration in Thracian Art. Acta Musei Nationalis Pragae Ser. A Historia 56.14, 15760. Marghitan, L. 1976: Tezarre de argent dacice: Catalog (Bucharesti). Markov, K. 1977: Thassos and Its Peraia (7th3rd C. B.C.). Thracia 4, 3345. . 1980: Samothrace and Its Peraia (From the 7th to 3rd Century B.C.). Thracia 5, 14554. Megaw, [M.]R., Megaw, [J.]V.[S.], Theodossiev, N. and Torbov, N. 2000: The Decorated La Tne Sword Scabbard from Pavolche near Vratsa: Some Notes on the Evidence for Celtic Settlement in Northwestern Thrace. ArchBulg 4.3, 2543. Megaw, [J]V.[S.] 2004: In the Footsteps of Brennos? Further Archaeological Evidence for Celts in the Balkans. In Hnsel, B. and Studenkov, E. (eds.), Zwischen
52
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Karpaten und gis. Neolithikum und ltere Bronzezeit: Gedenkschrift fr Viera Nemejcov-Pavkov (Internationale Archologie, Studia honoraria 21) (Rahden), 93107. Melyukova, A.I. 1976: K voprosu o vzaimosvyazakh skifskogo i frakiiskogo iskusstva. In Skifo-sibirskii zverinnyi stil v iskusstve narodov Evrazii (Moscow), 10627. . 1979: Skifiya i frakiiskii mir (Moscow). Mihailov, G. 1972: Trakite (Sofia). . 1980: Les inscriptions comme source de lhistoire des Etats thraces. Pulpudeva 4, 2126. . 1987: Les inscriptions dans le trsor de Rogozen. Linguistique Balkanique 30.1, 519. Micoff [Mikov], V. 1954: Le tombeau antique prs de Kazanlak (Sofia). Mikov, V. 1955: Proizhodat na kupolnite grobnitsi v Trakiya. IAI 19 (Serta Kazaroviana 2), 1548. Miller, S.G. 1972: Hellenistic Macedonian Architecture: Its Style and Painted Ornamentation (Ann Arbor: University Microfilms). . 1993: The Tomb of Lyson and Kallikles: A Painted Macedonian Tomb (Mainz). . 1994: Hellenistic Burial Tumuli in Macedonia: Problems and Questions. In Seuthopolis 1994, 7780. Minchev, A. 1978: The Pitcher-Rhyta: A Special Feature of Thracian Rhyta. Pulpudeva 3, 17788. Mirchev, M. 1962: Rannotrakiiskiyat mogilen nekropol pri s. Ravna. IAI 25, 96162. . 1965: Trakiiskiyat mogilen nekropol pri s. Dobrina. INMV 1(16), 3370. Mitrevski, D. 1997: Protoistoriskite zaednitsi vo Makedonija (Skopje). Mushmov, N. 1912: Antichnite moneti na Balkanskiya poluostrov i monetite na bulgarskite tsare (Sofia). . 1925: Monetite na trakiiskite tsare. In Yubileen Godishnik na Narodnata Biblioteka v Plovdiv (Mlanges Boris Diakovitch) (Sofia), 195265. Musielak, M. 2003: Spoeczenstwo greckich miast zachodnich wybrzezy Morza Czarnego (Seria Historia 199) (Poznan). Nehrizov, G. 1996: Mogilnite nekropoli v Iztochnite Rodopi. In Seuthopolis 1994, vol. 2, 718. . 1999: Pogrebalni praktiki v Iztochnite Rodopi prez parvoto hilyadoletie pr.Hr.. Rhodopica 1, 2133. Nehrizov, G. and Mikov, R. 2000: Relations commerciales dans les Rhodopes de lEst, 5e1er sicles avant J.-C.. In Domaradzki 2000, 16180. Nikolova, L. (ed.) 2003: Early Symbolic Systems for Communication in Southeast Europe (BAR International Series 1139) (Oxford) Nikov, K. 1999: Aeolian Bucchero in Thrace?. ArchBulg 3.2, 3142. . 2000: Kulturni kontakti na Yuzhna Trakiya s Egeiskiya svyat prez rannata zhelyazna epoha po danni na keramikata (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). Ognenova-Marinova, L. 1977: Essai de mettre en rapport Athnion de Marone avec la peinture en Thrace vers la fin du IVe sicle avant notre re. Thracia 4, 17788. . 1985: Mesambria et le monde thrace entre le VIIe et le Ve s. av. n. .. ThrPont 3, 23844.
53
Oleson, J.P. 1982: The Sources of Innovation in Later Etruscan Tomb Design (ca. 350100 B.C.) (Archaeologica 27) (Rome). Onurkan, S. 1988: Dogu Trakya tmlsleri maden eserleri (TTKY 6.26) (Ankara). Oppermann, M. 1984: Thraker zwischen Karpatenbogen und gis (Leipzig/Jena/ Berlin). . 2004: Die westpontische Poleis und ihr indigenes Umfeld in vorrmischer Zeit (Schriften des Zentrums fr Archologie und Kulturgeschichte des Schwarzmeerraumes 2) (Langenweibach). Owen, S. 2000: New Light on Thracian Thasos: A Reinterpretation of the Cave of Pan. JHS 120, 13943. zbayoglu, E. 2004: Some Remarks on Dionysos Cult in the Light of Recent Excavations in Thrace. In Praktika 11th Diethnous Synedriou Klassikon Spoudon, vol.3 (Athens), 26976. zdogan, M. 1988: 1987 yili Edirne ve Balikesir illeri yzey aratirmasi. Aratirma Sonulari Toplantisi 6, 57190. . 1991: 1990 yili Trakya ve Marmara blgesi aratirmalari. Aratirma Sonulari Toplantisi 9, 40523. Panayotova, K. 1994: Nadgrobni mogili v raionite na gratskite kolonii po bulgarskoto Chernomorie. In Seuthopolis 1994, 8188. Pandermalis, D. 1972: O neos makedonikos taphos tes Verginas. Makedonika 12, 14782. Papazoglu, F. 1978: The Central Balkan Tribes in Pre-Roman Times: Triballi, Autariatae, Dardanians, Scordisci and Moesians (Amsterdam). Paunov, E.I. and Prokopov, I.S. 2002: An Inventory of Roman Republican Coin Hoards and Coins from Bulgaria (Glaux 15) (Milan). Pelekidis, C. 1994: The Greeks in Thrace. In Selemis, G. (ed.), Thrace (Athens), 98114. Perdrizet, P. 1910: Cultes et mythes du Pange (Annales de lEst 24.1) (Paris/Nancy). Peter, U. 1997: Die Mnzen der thrakischen Dynasten (5.3. Jh. v.Chr.). Hintergrnde ihrer Prgung (Griechisches Mnzwerk) (Berlin). Petropoulou, A. 198687: The Thracian Funerary Rites (Her. 5.8) and Similar Greek Practices. Talanta 1819, 2947. Pfrommer, M. 1983: ItalienMakedonienKleinasien. Interdependenzen sptklassischer und frhhellenistischer Toreutik. JdI 98, 23585. . 1987: Studien zu alexandrischen und grossgriechischen Toreutik frhhellenistischer Zeit (Archologische Forschungen 16) (Berlin). . 1990: Untersuchungen zur Chronologie frh- und hochhellenistischen Goldschmucks (IstForsch 37) (Tbingen). . 1993: Ein GrabDrei Kulturen. IstMitt 43, 33949. Picard, C. 194748: Le repas nuptial chez Hads: peintures hellnistiques dune tholos de Kazanlak (Bulgarie). RHRel 134, 11319. Pittioni, R. 1977: Bemerkungen zur religionshistorischen Interpretation des Verwahrfundes von Letniza, Bezirk Lovec, Bulgarien (sterreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-Historische Klasse, Sitzungsberichte 321) (Vienna). Popov, D.P. 1981: Trakiiskata boginya Bendida (Sofia). . 1989: Zalmoxis religiya i obshtestvo v drevna Trakiya (Sofia). . 1995: Bogat s mnogo imena (Sofia).
54
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
. 1999: Trakologiya (Sofia). Popov, H. 2000: Philippopolis Archologie und Geschichte. In Domaradzki 2000, 12332. . 2002: Urbanizatsiyata vav vatreshnite raioni na Trakiya i Iliriya prez VII vek predi Hrista (Sofia). Porozhanov, K. 1985: Les relations entre les colonies grecques et les tats thraces du littoral occidental de la Mer noire VIIeVe s. av. n. .. ThrPont 3, 15865. . 1998: Obshtestvo i darzhavnost u trakite, sredata na IInachaloto na I hil. Pr.Hr. (Studia Thracica 6) (Sofia). Prokopov, I. 2006: Die Silberprgung der Insel Thasos und die Tetradrachmen des Thasischen Typs vom 2.1. Jh. v. Chr. (Griechisches Mnzwerk) (Berlin). Rabadzhiev, K. 1994: Herakal varhu aplikatsiyata ot Panagyurishte. Godishnik na Sofiiskiya Universitet. Istoricheski Fakultet. Studia Archaeologica 1, 89102. . 2002: Elinski misterii v Trakiya. Opit za arheologicheski prochit (Sofia). Radev, R. 1992: Nyakoi nablyudeniya varhu nekropolite v Severoiztochna Bulgaria ot VI v.pr.n.e.. Helis 1, 12034. Randsborg, K. 1993: Greek Peripheries and Barbarian Centres: Economic Realities and Cultural Responses. In Bilde et al. 1993, 86123. Reho[-Bumbalova], M. 1990: La ceramica attica a figure nere e rosse nella Tracia bulgara (Archeologica 86) (Rome). . 1992: Athicheska chervenofigurna keramika v Natsionalniya Arheologicheski Muzei Sofia (Sofia). Roller, L. 2002: The Phrygian Mother Goddess and her Thracian Connections. In A.Fol 2002, 68394. . 2003: The Mother Goddess between Thrace and Phrygia. Thracia 15 (In honorem annorum LXX Alexandri Fol), 16167. Roman, P. (ed.) 1997: The Thracian World at the Crossroads of Civilisations (Proceedings of the Seventh International Congress of Thracology, May 2026, 1996, ConstantaMangaliaTulcea, Romania), vol. 1 (Bucharest). Rousseva, M. 2000: Thracian Cult Architecture in Bulgaria (Jambol). . 2002: Trakiiska grobnichna arhitektura v bulgarskite zemi prez VIII v.pr.n.e. (Yambol). Samsaris, D. 1985: Les colons grecs de Thasos et les thraces lpoque archaique. ThrPont 3, 6977. Schneider, L. 1989: Les signes du pouvoir: structure du langage iconique des thraces. RA 2, 22751. . 1990: Vom Bild zur Bilderwelt vom Betrachter zur Betrachtergemeinschaft: zur Bildkunst der Thraker. Visible Religion 7, 27994. Schneider, L. and Zazoff, P. 1994: Konstruktion und Rekonstruktion. Zur Lesung thrakischer und skythischer Bilder. JdI 109, 143216. Schnert-Geiss, E. 1987: Die Mnzprgung von Maroneia (Griechisches Mnzwerk) (Schriften zur Geschichte und Kultur der Antike 26) (Berlin). Seuthopolis 1994: First International Symposium Seuthopolis. Burial Tumuli in the South-East of Europe, 2 vols. (Veliko Turnovo). Sevin, N., Krpe, R., Tombul, M., Rose, C.B., Strahan, D., Kiesewetter, H. and Wallrodt, J. 2001: A New Painted Graeco-Persian Sarcophagus from an. Studia Troica 11, 383420.
55
Shefton, B.B. 1993: The White Lotus, Rogozen and Colchis: The Fate of a Motif. In Chapman, J. and Dolukhanov, P. (eds.), Cultural Transformations and Interactions in Eastern Europe (Centre for the Archaeology of Central and Eastern Europe monograph 1) (Worldwide Archaeology Series 6) (Aldershot), 178 209. Simon, E. 1960: Der Goldschatz von Panagjuriste Eine Schpfung der Alexanderzeit. AntKunst 3, 329. Srbu, V. and Florea, G. 2000a: Les Gto-Daces: Iconographie et imaginaire (ClujNapoca). . 2000b: The Image of the Horseman in the Thracian Art (5th century BC1st Century AD). Starini 1, 2343. Spiridonov, T. 1979: Selishtnata sistema v drevna Trakiya prez I hil. pr.n.e.. Thracia Antiqua 5, 6792. . 1991: Trakiiskiyat etnos: Problemi na formiraneto i razvitieto (Sofia). Staikova-Alexandrova, L. 2004: Srebarni aplikatsii za konska sbruya ot mogilno pogrebenie pri selo Dolna Koznitsa, Kyustendilsko. In Agre and Kitov 2004, 17180. Stanchev, D. 1994: Mogilni grobnitsi ot Rusensko. In Seuthopolis 1994, 17378. . 2002: Rezultati ot arheologicheskite razkopki na mogilata Yalandzha Tepe do s. Polsko Kosovo, Rusensko. In Pitye. Studia in honorem Prof. Ivani Marazov (Sofia), 51931. . 2004: Trakiiski nakiti ot Istoricheski muzei Ruse. In Agre and Kitov 2004, 14962. Stefanovich, M. 2003: Paleobalkanskite etnosi i predizvikatelstvata na savremennostta (Sofia). Steingrber, S. 1999: Grabarchitektur und Grabmalerei in Thrakien und im vorrmischen Italien eine vergleichende Studie. PrI 32.4, 5368. . 2000: ArpiApulienMakedonien. Studien zum unteritalischen Grabwesen in hellenistischer Zeit (Mainz). . 2001: Gab es eine Koin in der Mediterranen Grabmalerei der frhhellenistischen Zeit?. In Barbet, A. (ed.), La peinture funraire antique IVe sicle av. J.-C. IVesicle ap. J.-C (Actes du VIIe Colloque de lAssociation internationale pour la peinture murale antique [AIPMA], 610 octobre 1998, Saint-Romain-en-Gal, Vienne) (Paris), 20106. Stoyanov, T.N. 1990: Grobnichnata arhitektura v Severoiztochna Trakiya v svetlinata na kontaktite s Mala Aziya (VIIII v.pr.n.e.). TAB 4, 12233. . 1991: Za interpretatsiyata na kanichka No. 155 ot Rogozenskoto sakrovishte. Arheologiya 33.4, 2134. . 1992: Pogrebalni obichai v Severoiztochna Trakiya prez rannozhelyaznata epoha v svetlinata na novite prouchvaniya. Helis 1, 8296. . 1997: Early Iron Age Tumular Necropolis. Sboryanovo 1 (Sofia). . 1998: Sakrovishteto ot Borovo v arheologicheski i istoricheski kontekst. In Parvi akademichni cheteniya v pamet na akademik Gavril Katsarov (Seminarium Thracicum 3) (Sofia), 6590. . 1999: New Light on the Relations between Thrace and Macedonia in the Early Hellenistic Times. In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 107589.
56
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
. 2000: Spatial Pattern and Economic Development of Northeastern Thrace 7th 2nd Centuries BC. In Domaradzki 2000, 5567. . 2003: Za proizhoda na fialite s antropomorfna plastichna dekoratsiya. In Sbornik v pamet na d-r Petar Gorbanov) (Studia Archaeologica suppl. 1) (Sofia), 87104. . 2004: Panagyurskoto sakrovishte izobrazitelna programa i prinadlezhnost. In Agre and Kitov 2004, 1130. Stoyanov, T.N., Mihailova, Z., Nikov, K., Nikolaeva, M. and Stoyanova, D. 2004: The Thracian City at Sboryanovo (Sofia). Stoyanova, D. 2002a: Gratskata vrata v Trakiya. In Pitye. Studia in honorem Prof. Ivani Marazov (Sofia), 53249. . 2002b: Monumentalna arhitektura v Trakiya VIII v.pr.Hr. Stroitelni materiali, tehniki, konstruktsii, orderi (Summary of Dissertation) (Sofia). Strong, D.E. 1966: Greek and Roman Gold and Silver Plate (London). Stronk, J.P. 1995: The Ten Thousand in Thrace. An Archaeological and Historical Commentary on Xenophons Anabasis, Books VI.iii-viVII (Amsterdam Classical Monographs 2) (Amsterdam). Svoboda, B. and Concev, D. (eds.). 1956: Neue Denkmler antiker Toreutik (Monumenta Archaeologica 4) (Prague). Svoronos, J.-N. 1919: Lhellnisme primitif de la Macdoine prouv par la numismatique et lor du Pange. (Journal International dArchologie Numismatique 19 [19181919]) (Paris/Athens). Szab, M. 1991: Thraco-Celtica. Orpheus 1, 12634. Tacheva, M. 1987: Istoriya na bulgarskite zemi v drevnostta. Vtora chast (Sofia). . 1998: GETAS EDONEON BASILEUS. In Peter, U. (ed.), Stephanos Nomismatikos. Edith Schnert-Geiss zum 65. Geburtstag (Griechisches Mnzwerk) (Berlin), 61326. . 1999: Le barbaricum balkanique et les colonies hellniques. In Ancient Macedonia VI (Papers Read at the Sixth International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 1996), 2 vols. (Thessaloniki), 112734. Taylor, T. 1982: The Iconography of Power in Getic Princely Burial. Pulpudeva 5, 4765. . 1987: Flying Stags: Icons and Power in Thracian Art. In Hodder, I. (ed.), The Archaeology of Contextual Meanings (Cambridge), 11741. . 1989a: An Agighol-type Beaker in the Rogozen Hoard. In Cook 1989, 91100. . 1989b: Iron and Iron Age in the Carpatho-Balkan Region: Aspects of Social and Technological Change, 1700400 BC. In Stig Srensen, M.L. and Thomas, R. (eds.), The BronzeIron Transition in Europe; Aspects of Continuity and Change in European Societies, c. 1200500 BC (BAR International Series 483.1) (Oxford), 6892. Theodossiev, N. 1997a: A New Early Thracian Inscription from Bulgaria. Kadmos 36.2, 174. . 1997b: On the Reading and Date of the Kjolmen Inscription. Indogermanische Forschungen 102, 21629. . 1998a: The Dead with Golden Faces: Dasaretian, Pelagonian, Mygdonian and Boeotian Funeral Masks. OJA 17.3, 34567. . 1998b: Two Silver Vessels with Dionysiac Scenes from Thrace. AntJ 78, 4362.
57
. 2000a: The Dead with Golden Faces. II. Other Evidence and Connections. OJA 19.2, 175209. . 2000b: Monumental Tombs and Hero Cults in Thrace during the 5th3rd Centuries B.C.. In Pirenne-Delforge, V. and Surez de la Torre, E. (eds.), Hros et hrones dans les mythes et les cultes grecs (Kernos suppl. 10) (Lige), 43547. . 2000c: North-Western Thrace from the Fifth to First Centuries BC (BAR International Series 859) (Oxford). . 2002d: Mountain Goddesses in Ancient Thrace: The Broader Context. Kernos 15, 32529. . 2003: Art Treasures in Northern Thrace from the 4th to Early 3rd Century B.C.E.. Center 23, 13739. . 2004: The Origin of the Thracian Beehive Tholos Tombs. In Praktika. XI Diethnous Synedriou Klassikon Spoudon, vol. 3 (Athens), 34867. . forthcoming: The Beehive Tombs in Thrace and Their Connection with Funerary Monuments in Thessaly, Macedonia and Other Parts of the Ancient World. Ancient Macedonia VII (Papers Read at the Seventh International Symposium, Thessaloniki, 2002) (Thessaloniki). Thompson, M., Mrkholm, O. and Kraay, C.M. 1973: An Inventory of Greek Coin Hoards (New York). Todorov, Y. 1933: Trakiiskite tsare. Godishnik na Sofiiskiya Universitet. IstorikoFilologicheski Fakultet 29.7, 180. Tomlinson, R.A. 1974: Thracian and Macedonian Tombs Compared. Thracia 3, 24750. Toncheva, G. 1980a: Chronologie du Hallstatt ancien dans la Bulgarie de Nord-Est (Studia Thracica 5) (Sofia). . 1980b: Ncropole tumulaire prs de village Belogradec du VIIe s. av. n. re. Thracia 5, 552. Tonkova, M. 1997: Un champ de fosses rituelles des VeIVe s. av. J.-C. pres de Gledacevo, Bulgarie de Sud. In Roman 1997, 592610. . 2000: Sur le systme des sites du Deuxime Age du Fer dans la rgion des Collines de Chirpan. In Domaradzki 2000, 13344. . 2003: Late Iron Age Pit-Sanctuaries in Thrace: The Contribution of the Studies at Gledachevo. Thracia 15 (In honorem annorum LXX Alexandri Fol), 479 504. Topalov, S. 1994: The Odrysian Kingdom from the Late 5th to the Mid-4th C. B.C. Contributions to the Study of Its Coinage and History (Sofia). . 1998: Plemena i vladeteli ot zemite na Odriskoto tsarstvo i granichnite mu yugozapadni teritorii ot kraya na VI do sredata na IV v. pr.n.e. Prinosi kam prouchvane monetosecheneto i istoriyata na drevna Trakiya (Sofia). . 2000: Information about the Unknown Types of Early Thracian Tribal and Rulers Coins Minted in the 6th4th C. B.C. Kept in Private Collections, and the Studies Made on Their Basis (Sofia). Torelli, M. 1985: Macedonia, Epiro e Magna Grecia: La pittura di et classica e protoellenistica. Atti Taranto 24 (1984), 37998. Totevski, T. 1994: Pogrebalni obichai na mestnoto trakiisko naselenie, obitavalo gornoto techenie na r. Osam prez perioda VIII v.pr.Chr.. In Seuthopolis 1994, 99104.
58
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
Triantaphyllos, D. 1980: Les monuments mgalitiques en Thrace Occidentale. Pulpudeva 4, 14563. . 1985: Les sanctuaires en plein air dans la rgion Cicones. ThrPont 3, 12841. . 1988: La Thrace genne avant la colonisation grecque. ThrPont 4, 283308. . 1994: Ancient Thrace. In Selemis, G. (ed.), Thrace (Athens), 3597. Tsatsopoulou-Kaloudi, P. 2001: MesembriaZone (Athens). Tsetskhladze, G.R. 1998a: Greek Colonisation of the Black Sea Area: Stages, Models, and Native Population. In Tsetskhladze, G.R. (ed.), The Greek Colonisation of the Black Sea Area: Historical Interpretation of Archaeology (Historia Einzelschrift 121) (Stuttgart), 968. . 1998b: Trade on the Black Sea in the Archaic and Classical Periods: Some Observations. In Parkins, H. and Smith, C. (eds.), Trade, Traders and the Ancient City (London/New York), 5274. 1998c: Who Built the Scythian and Thracian Royal and Elite Tombs?. OJA 17.1, 5592. . 1999a: Between West and East: Anatolian Roots of Local Cultures of the Pontus. In Tsetskhladze 1999b, 46996. . (ed.) 1999b: Ancient Greeks West and East (Mnemosyne suppl. 196) (Leiden/Boston/Cologne). . 2000: Pistiros in the System of Pontic Emporia. In Domaradzki 2000, 23346. . 2003: Greeks beyond the Bosporus. In Karageorghis, V. (ed.), The Greeks beyond the Aegean: from Marseilles to Bactria (Papers presented at an International Symposium held at the Onassis Cultural Center, New York, 12th October, 2002) (New York), 12966. Tsiafakis, D. 1998: E Thrake sten attike eikonographia tou 5ou aiona p.H. (Komotini). . 2002: Thracian Influence in Athenian Imagery of the 5th Century BC: The Case of Orpheus. In A. Fol 2002, 72738. Ursu Naniu, R. 2004: Limbajul mitic i religios al artei princiare getice (Chiinau). Valeva, J. 1993: Hellenistic Tombs in Thrace and Macedonia: Their Form and Decorations. In Moormann, E.M. (ed.), Functional and Spatial Analysis of Wall Painting (Proceedings of the Fifth International Congress on Ancient Wall Painting) (BABesch suppl. 3) (Leiden), 11926. . 1997: Mythology and History. The Painted Frieze of the Sveshtari Tomb with Caryatids. In Scagliarini Corlita, D. (ed.), I temi figurativi nella pittura parietale antica (IV sec.a.C.IV sec.d.C.) (Atti del VI Convegno internazionale sulla pittura parietale antica) (Studi e Scavi 5) (Imola/Bologna), 29598. . 1999: Les dcors thraces et le style zones (IVeIIIe sicle av. J.-C.). PrI 32.4, 6978. . 2002: Tombeau mausole du Tumulus Ostroucha prs de Chipka (Bulgarie). In Pontrandolfo, A. (ed.), La pittura parietale in Macedonia e Magna Grecia (Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi in ricordo di Mario Napoli, Salerno Paestum, 2123 novembre 1996) (Paestum [Salerno]), 5356. Vasic, R. 1987a: Moravsko-Timocka oblast. In Praistorija Jugoslavenskih zemalja 5: Zeljezno doba (Sarajevo), 65172. . 1987b: Trakokimerski, skitski i trako-getski utacaji u Jugoslovenskom Podunavlju. In Praistorija Jugoslavenskih zemalja. V. Zeljezno doba (Sarajevo), 55967. . 1991: Cultural Groups of the Early Iron Age in the West and Central Balkans and the Possibilities of Their Ethnical Identification. In Benac, A. (ed.), I iliro-tracki
59
simpozijum. Paleobalkanska plemena izmedju Jadranskog i Crnog mora od eneolita do helenistickog doba/Symposium illyro-thrace Tribus palobalkaniques entre la mer Adriatique et la mer Noire de lnolithique jusqu lpoque hellenistique 1989, Nis et Blagoevgrad (Sarajevo/Belgrade), 7382. . 2000: Thracian Fibulae in the West: Invasion or Cultural Exchange?. ArchBulg 4.1, 1320. Vassileva, M. 199293: The Inscribed Thracian and Phrygian Phialae in Comparative Context. Talanta 2425, 16166. . 1994: Thrace and Phrygia. Some Typological Parallels. In Europa Indo-Europea (Atti del VI Congresso Internazionale di Tracologia e VII Symposio di Studi Traci) (Rome), 22127. . 1997: Thrace and Phrygia. Some Problems of the Megalithic Culture. In Actes. 2e symposium international des tudes Thraciennes. Thrace ancienne (Komotini), 19398. . 1998: Thracian-Phrygian Cultural Zone. In Tuna, N., Akture, Z. and Lynch, M. (eds.), Thracians and Phrygians: Problems of Parallelism (Proceedings of an International Symposium on the Archaeology, History and Ancient Languages of Thrace and Phrygia) (Ankara), 1317. Velkov, V. 1982: Kabile. Mestopolozhenie, prouchvaniya, izvori. In Kabile, vol. 1 (Sofia), 717. . 1991: Nadpisi ot Kabile. In Kabile, vol. 2 (Sofia), 753. Velkov, V. and Domaradzka, L. 1994: Kotys I (383/2359 av. J.-C.) et lemporion Pistiros de Thrace. BCH 118, 115. Velkov, V. and Fol, A. 1977: Les Thraces en Egypte grco-romaine (Studia Thracica 4) (Sofia). Velkov, V., Gocheva, Z. and Tapkova-Zaimova, V. (eds.) 1981: Izvori za istoriyata na Trakiya i trakite, vol. 1 (Sofia). Venedikov, I. 1961: The Panagyurishte Gold Treasure (Sofia). . 1969: Predahemenidski Iran i Trakiya. IAI 31, 543. . 1972: Nadpisite varhu trakiiskite fiali. Arheologiya 14.2, 17. . 1974a: Larchitecture spulcrale en Thrace. Pulpudeva 1, 5662. . 1974b: Lorigine des tombeaux coupole. Thracia 3, 20305. . 1976a: Mogilnite grobnitsi v Trakiya. In Venedikov and A. Fol. 1976, 11523. . 1976b: Skalnite grobnitsi v Trakiya i mikenskite grobnitsi. In Venedikov and A.Fol. 1976, 11015. . 1976c: Trakiiskite dolmeni, dolmenite v Kavkaz i grobnitsite v Mala Aziya. In Venedikov and A. Fol. 1976, 7681. . 1996: Trakiiskoto sakrovishte ot Letnitsa (Sofia). Venedikov, I. and Fol, A. (eds.) 1976: Megalitite v Trakiya (Trakiiski Pametnitsi 1) (Sofia). Venedikov, I. and Gerasimov, T. 1976: Thrakische Kunst (Leipzig). Venedikov, I., Gerasimov, T., Dremsizova, T., Ivanov, T., Mladenova, Y. and Velkov, V. 1963: Apoloniya. Razkopkite v nekropola na Apoloniya prez 19471949 g. (Sofia). Verdiani, C. 1945: Original Hellenistic Paintings in a Thracian Tomb. AJA 49, 402 15. Vickers, M. 1989: Panagyurishte, Dalboki, Loukovit and Rogozen: Questions of Metrology and Status. In Cook 1989, 10111.
60
NIKOLA THEODOSSIEV
. 1991: Persian, Thracian and Greek Gold and Silver: Questions of Metrology. In Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. and Kuhrt, A. (eds.), Achaemenid History 6: Asia Minor and Egypt: Old Cultures in a New Empire (Proceedings of the Groningen 1988 Achaemenid History Workshop) (Leiden), 3139. . 2002: Scythian and Thracian Antiquities in Oxford (Oxford). Ylmaz, Z. 1996: Kirklareli tmlsleri (Kirklareli). . 1997: akilli tmls kurtarma kazisi ve restorasyon alimalari. In VIII. Mze Kurtarma Kazlar Semineri (Ankara), 20318. Yordanov, K. 1990: Politicheski otnosheniya mezhdu traki i skiti. Vekove 19.5, 512. . 1998: Politicheskite otnosheniya mezhdu Makedoniya i trakiiskite darzhavi (359 281 g. pr.Hr.) (Studia Thracica 7) (Sofia). Jordanov [Yordanov], K. 2003: Achaemenido-Thracica: Attempts at Political and Administrative Control (ca. 515466 BC). Thracia 15 (In honorem annorum LXX Alexandri Fol), 3954. Yordanov, K. and Velkov, V. 1984: Dobrudzha prez I hil. pr.n.e. Geti. In Istoriya na Dobrudzha, vol. 1 (Sofia), 72123. Youroukova [Yurukova], Y. 1976: Coins of the Ancient Thracians (BAR Supplementary Series 4) (Oxford). Jurukova, J. [Yurukova, Y]. 1979: Les invasions macdoniennes en Thrace et les trouvailles montaires. In Hackens, T. and Weiller, R. (eds.), Actes du 9me Congrs international de numismatique, Berne, septembre 1979 (A.C.I.N)/Proceedings of the 9th International Congress of Numismatics, 2 vols. (Louvain-la-Neuve/ Luxembourg), 21525. Yurukova, Y. 1992: Monetite na trakiiskite plemena i vladeteli (Monetni sakrovishta ot bulgarskite zemi 1) (Sofia). Zahrnt, M. 1997: Die Perser in Thrakien. In Actes. 2e symposium international des tudes Thraciennes. Thrace ancienne (Komotini), 9199. Zazoff, P. 1991: Bildchiffren der skytho-thrakischen Kunst. HamBA 18, 16780. Zazoff, P., Hcker, C. and Schneider, L 1985: Zur thrakischen Kunst im Frhhellenismus. AA 1985, 595643. Zhivkova, L. 1974: Kazanlashkata grobnitsa (Sofia). Zournatzi, A. 2000: Inscribed Silver Vessels of the Odrysian Kings: Gifts, Tribute, and the Diffusion of the Forms of Achaemenid Metalware in Thrace. AJA 104, 683706.

Ancient Thrace During the First Millennium BC

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Ancient Thrace During the First Millennium BC

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

COLLOQUIA ANTIQUA 1

PEETERS LEUVEN PARIS WALPOLE, MA 2011

List of Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC*

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

I would like to thank Prof. K. Clinton for his consultation.

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

ANCIENT THRACE DURING THE FIRST MILLENNIUM BC

You might also like