Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
7Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
It's Official - Denise Minger now Exposed as DEBUNKED - The China Study - Troubleshooting the Non-Vegetarian Rawfoodsos Paleo Fallacy and Mark Sisson Robb Wolf Quack Diet Myth

It's Official - Denise Minger now Exposed as DEBUNKED - The China Study - Troubleshooting the Non-Vegetarian Rawfoodsos Paleo Fallacy and Mark Sisson Robb Wolf Quack Diet Myth

Ratings:

3.2

(5)
|Views: 5,434|Likes:
DENISE MINGER OF RAWFOODSOS HAS NOW BEEN FOUND DEBUNKED. WORK FOUND FLAWED.

1. DENISE MINGER WAS FOUND USING IMPROPER UNADJUSTED RAW UNIVARIATE STATISTICAL CORRELATIONS THUS DEBUNKING HER OWN CONCLUSIONS.

2. DENISE MINGER FAILED TO UNDERSTAND THE CHINA STUDY'S RESEARCH FINDINGS.

3. DENISE MINGER PICKED OUT ONLY 1/18th OF THE DATA IN THE CHINA STUDY AND ONLY CHERRY PICKED AND LOOKED AT A TINY 0.05 PORTION. ABOUT WHICH SHE TURNED OUT TO BE ALSO INCORRECT AS WELL.

4. DENISE MINGER IS A 23 YR OLD "ENGLISH MAJOR" WITH NO MEDICAL DEGREE, NO CERTIFICATION IN PHYSIOLOGY, BIOCHEMISTRY, OR HUMAN NUTRITION, NOT QUALIFIED IN MATH OR STATISTICS, NO EXPERIENCE WITH ACTUAL PATIENTS, NO EXPERIENCE WITH HEART SURGERY, AND IS NOT LICENSED TO PRACTICE MEDICINE, OR TO DISPENSE HUMAN NUTRITIONAL OR MEDICAL ADVICE TO THE PUBLIC.


-

[Paraphrased Transcript of the Discussion of all the Flaws in the work of Denise Minger]

Details:


Denise Minger published a critique of the book, The China Study, entitled as follows:

"Fact or Fallacy? « Raw Food SOS: Troubleshooting on the Raw Food Diet"-Denise Minger


NOTE:
Ms. Denise Minger is simply an English major, not a statistician nor an epidemiologist.
(Background and academic credentials are certainly not everything..but..background in the field, and especially peer review, all give one perspective and insight that is not otherwise attainable.)



DENISE MINGER DEBUNKED:

The response to Denise Minger can be divided into 3 parts:

•Denise Minger's Misunderstanding The China Study's objectives and research findings.

•Denise Minger's Excessive reliance on the use of unadjusted correlations in the China database.

•Denise Minger's Failure to note the broader implications of choosing the right dietary lifestyle

Denise Minger, The China Study, Rawfoodsos, debunked, mark sisson, paleo diet, omnivores carnivores vegetarian vegan crossfit lowcarb "raw food" nutrition health paleolithic primal solution, archeology, archaeology, archaeologists, archeologists, paleontology, paleontologists, africa, jaws, teeth, dentition, weston price, weston a. price, fangs, incisors, canine teeth, carnivorous, omnivorous, humans are, humans were, designed to be, evolved to be, evolved as, have always eaten, meats, natural, nature, homo sapiens, homo erectus, homo habilis, hominids, hominins, scientific, science, skulls, flat, pointy, sharp, bicuspids, plant eaters, herbivores, four stomachs, primates, gorillas, apes, chimpanzees, mouths, chew, chewing, cranium, big brains, dha, fish oil, dr joseph mercola, rawfoodsos, denise minger, robb wolf, paleo solution, archevore, anthony colpo, fred hahn, seriousstrength, don matesz, art de vany, arthur devany, dr kurt harris, proteinpower, dr barry groves, dr bg, barry groves, wapf, inuit, masai, lifespan, longevity, dentist, molars, grinding, stoneage, prehistoric, ancient, ancestors, ancestral, foods, arctic, eskimo, alaska, tanzania, lucy, robustus, loren cordain, grains, wild animals, spears, tools, stone tools, fire, invented fire, discovered fire, australopithecus, australopithecines, afarensis, africanus, boisei, paranthropus, musk deer, chinese water deer, not designed to eat, not evolved to eat, not meant to eat, digestive tract, digestion, herbivorous, False, Fallacious, Nutrition, Claims, Misinformation, Fraud, Diet, Lowcarb, Estrogen, Phytoestrogens, Wapf, Paleo, Meat, Raw, Milk, Dairy, Bodybuilding, Rich, Source, Soy, Vegan, Vegetarian, Fda, Health, Protein, Kaayla T Daniel, Mary G Enig, Sally Fallon, Morell, Weston A Price, Foundation, Crossfit, Loren Cordain, Mark Sisson, Richard Nikoley, Primal Diet, Paleo Solution, Brian White, Internationalnaturalhygienesociety, Naturalhygienesociety, Freetheanimal, Panu, Neanderthin, Omnivores, Carnivores, Michael Eades, Robb Wolf, Art Devany, Arthur De Vaney, Greg Ellis, Barry Groves, T Colin Campbell, China Study, B-12, Grassfed Beef, Heme Iron, Lierre Kieth, Vegetarian Myth, Cave
DENISE MINGER OF RAWFOODSOS HAS NOW BEEN FOUND DEBUNKED. WORK FOUND FLAWED.

1. DENISE MINGER WAS FOUND USING IMPROPER UNADJUSTED RAW UNIVARIATE STATISTICAL CORRELATIONS THUS DEBUNKING HER OWN CONCLUSIONS.

2. DENISE MINGER FAILED TO UNDERSTAND THE CHINA STUDY'S RESEARCH FINDINGS.

3. DENISE MINGER PICKED OUT ONLY 1/18th OF THE DATA IN THE CHINA STUDY AND ONLY CHERRY PICKED AND LOOKED AT A TINY 0.05 PORTION. ABOUT WHICH SHE TURNED OUT TO BE ALSO INCORRECT AS WELL.

4. DENISE MINGER IS A 23 YR OLD "ENGLISH MAJOR" WITH NO MEDICAL DEGREE, NO CERTIFICATION IN PHYSIOLOGY, BIOCHEMISTRY, OR HUMAN NUTRITION, NOT QUALIFIED IN MATH OR STATISTICS, NO EXPERIENCE WITH ACTUAL PATIENTS, NO EXPERIENCE WITH HEART SURGERY, AND IS NOT LICENSED TO PRACTICE MEDICINE, OR TO DISPENSE HUMAN NUTRITIONAL OR MEDICAL ADVICE TO THE PUBLIC.


-

[Paraphrased Transcript of the Discussion of all the Flaws in the work of Denise Minger]

Details:


Denise Minger published a critique of the book, The China Study, entitled as follows:

"Fact or Fallacy? « Raw Food SOS: Troubleshooting on the Raw Food Diet"-Denise Minger


NOTE:
Ms. Denise Minger is simply an English major, not a statistician nor an epidemiologist.
(Background and academic credentials are certainly not everything..but..background in the field, and especially peer review, all give one perspective and insight that is not otherwise attainable.)



DENISE MINGER DEBUNKED:

The response to Denise Minger can be divided into 3 parts:

•Denise Minger's Misunderstanding The China Study's objectives and research findings.

•Denise Minger's Excessive reliance on the use of unadjusted correlations in the China database.

•Denise Minger's Failure to note the broader implications of choosing the right dietary lifestyle

Denise Minger, The China Study, Rawfoodsos, debunked, mark sisson, paleo diet, omnivores carnivores vegetarian vegan crossfit lowcarb "raw food" nutrition health paleolithic primal solution, archeology, archaeology, archaeologists, archeologists, paleontology, paleontologists, africa, jaws, teeth, dentition, weston price, weston a. price, fangs, incisors, canine teeth, carnivorous, omnivorous, humans are, humans were, designed to be, evolved to be, evolved as, have always eaten, meats, natural, nature, homo sapiens, homo erectus, homo habilis, hominids, hominins, scientific, science, skulls, flat, pointy, sharp, bicuspids, plant eaters, herbivores, four stomachs, primates, gorillas, apes, chimpanzees, mouths, chew, chewing, cranium, big brains, dha, fish oil, dr joseph mercola, rawfoodsos, denise minger, robb wolf, paleo solution, archevore, anthony colpo, fred hahn, seriousstrength, don matesz, art de vany, arthur devany, dr kurt harris, proteinpower, dr barry groves, dr bg, barry groves, wapf, inuit, masai, lifespan, longevity, dentist, molars, grinding, stoneage, prehistoric, ancient, ancestors, ancestral, foods, arctic, eskimo, alaska, tanzania, lucy, robustus, loren cordain, grains, wild animals, spears, tools, stone tools, fire, invented fire, discovered fire, australopithecus, australopithecines, afarensis, africanus, boisei, paranthropus, musk deer, chinese water deer, not designed to eat, not evolved to eat, not meant to eat, digestive tract, digestion, herbivorous, False, Fallacious, Nutrition, Claims, Misinformation, Fraud, Diet, Lowcarb, Estrogen, Phytoestrogens, Wapf, Paleo, Meat, Raw, Milk, Dairy, Bodybuilding, Rich, Source, Soy, Vegan, Vegetarian, Fda, Health, Protein, Kaayla T Daniel, Mary G Enig, Sally Fallon, Morell, Weston A Price, Foundation, Crossfit, Loren Cordain, Mark Sisson, Richard Nikoley, Primal Diet, Paleo Solution, Brian White, Internationalnaturalhygienesociety, Naturalhygienesociety, Freetheanimal, Panu, Neanderthin, Omnivores, Carnivores, Michael Eades, Robb Wolf, Art Devany, Arthur De Vaney, Greg Ellis, Barry Groves, T Colin Campbell, China Study, B-12, Grassfed Beef, Heme Iron, Lierre Kieth, Vegetarian Myth, Cave

More info:

Published by: FACTREVIEWCOMMISSION on Dec 31, 2011
Copyright:Attribution

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/04/2014

pdf

text

original

 
DENISE MINGER OF RAWFOODSOS HAS NOW BEEN FOUND DEBUNKED.WORK FOUND FLAWED.
1. DENISE MINGER WAS FOUND USING IMPROPER UNADJUSTED RAWUNIVARIATE STATISTICAL CORRELATIONS THUS DEBUNKING HER OWNCONCLUSIONS.2. DENISE MINGER FAILED TO UNDERSTAND THE CHINA STUDY'SRESEARCH FINDINGS.3. DENISE MINGER PICKED OUT ONLY 1/18th OF THE DATA IN THE CHINASTUDY AND ONLY CHERRY PICKED AND LOOKED AT A TINY 0.05 PORTION.ABOUT WHICH SHE TURNED OUT TO BE ALSO INCORRECT AS WELL.4. DENISE MINGER IS A 23 YR OLD "ENGLISH MAJOR" WITH NO MEDICALDEGREE, NO CERTIFICATION IN PHYSIOLOGY, BIOCHEMISTRY, OR HUMANNUTRITION, NOT QUALIFIED IN MATH OR STATISTICS, NO EXPERIENCEWITH ACTUAL PATIENTS, NO EXPERIENCE WITH HEART SURGERY, AND ISNOT LICENSED TO PRACTICE MEDICINE, OR TO DISPENSE HUMANNUTRITIONAL OR MEDICAL ADVICE TO THE PUBLIC.-[Paraphrased Transcript of the Discussion of all the Flaws in the work of Denise Minger]Details:Denise Minger published a critique of the book, The China Study, entitled as follows:"Fact or Fallacy? « Raw Food SOS: Troubleshooting on the Raw Food Diet"-DeniseMinger NOTE:Ms. Denise Minger is simply an English major, not a statistician nor an epidemiologist.(Background and academic credentials are certainly not everything..but..background inthe field, and especially peer review, all give one perspective and insight that is nototherwise attainable.)
 
DENISE MINGER DEBUNKED:The response to Denise Minger can be divided into 3 parts: •Denise Minger's Misunderstanding The China Study's objectives and research findings. •Denise Minger's Excessive reliance on the use of unadjusted correlations in the Chinadatabase. •Denise Minger's Failure to note the broader implications of choosing the right dietarylifestyleDENISE MINGER'S FAILURE:A. Denise Minger's failure understanding the book’s objectives. Denise Minger failed to understand that the findings described in the book are not solelybased on the China "survey data".As explained in the book The China Study, it drew conclusions from *several* findingsand it is the *consistency* among ALL the various findings that matter.These principles also collectively and substantially inferred major health benefits of whole plant-based foods.Unfortunately, this issue of biological plausibility too often escapes the attention of "statisticians", who are more familiar with 'number crunching' than with actual biologicalphenomena.Denise Minger:- user of microsoft excel- english major- no authorization to practice medicine- no certification in nutrition- has a food-blog.Note: [Minger addresses] only 1 chapter of the China Study book [which] was devoted tothe china "survey project", which is only one, in a chain of experimental approaches.
 
(Minger's blog postings only addressed 1 out of 18 chapters of the China Study. 1/18th.)Doctor T. Colin Campbell- American Biochemist- Emeritus Professor of Nutritional Biochemistry- CORNELL UNIVERSITY- Author of over 300 scientific papers- Dr. Campbell's china study work described by the NYT as "The Grand Prix of Epidemiology"- B.S. Pennsylvania State University- M.S. in Nutrition & Biochemistry- Ph.D in Nutrition- Ph.D in Biochemistry- Ph.D in Microbiology- Research Associate at MIT, Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge- Department of Biochemistry & Nutrition, Virginia Tech- Cornell University (Ivy League), Division of Nutritional Sciences- Senior Science advisor to the AICR, American Institute for Cancer Research- Physicians Committee Advisory Board - PCRM- Member of the U.S. NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES- Expert panel on Food Safety- Honorary Professorship, Academy of Preventive Medicine, ChinaCHINA STUDY EVIDENCE SUPPORTED:Because of the uniqueness of the China database, the evidence was highly supportive.One of the unique characteristics of this survey was the "traditional" dietary practices of this cohort of people. Mostly, they were already consuming a diet largely comprised of plant-based foods..thus making our final observations that much more impressive.In the book, we summarized findings from *other* research groups for a variety of Diseases, to determine the consistency of ours with their findings..One of the mostcompelling parts of this was the fact that so many of their findings, published in goodpeer-reviewed journals, had been..ignored and/or distorted..for a long time there hasbeen, an intentional effort..to denigrate studies..of plant-based diets. The fact that therehas been resistance, oftentimes hostile and personal..speaks volumes.

Activity (7)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Dalyn Luedtke liked this
Jim Kolan liked this
vasifu liked this
nicklasr liked this
Rhodowood liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->