KEAAIO

12

O
O :
OOO
O
.

O , Popper Lakatos , , .
M
. K Kuhn Ziman .
, ,
. O Kuhn Ziman (
)
.
T Kuhn .
: ,
,
.

315

ENOTHTA 12.1

12.1

OO
Kuhn,
, ,
, Kuhn (normal) 1.
.
Chalmers,
2. O Kuhn, ,
. :
E .
E 3.
A
, .4 O Hacking Losee
Kuhn
, , .5 M , Barnes:
... . .6
E ,
. K Kuhn :

.7
, Y , , ,
. ( ) .

316

ENOTHTA 12.1

KEAAIO

Kuhn,
:
. , .
, Kuhn .
.
, :
, , .,
8.
, , .. . E
9.
. B
,
:
, ,
.10
O Hacking, , ,
11. T
,
. To
,
, .
Kuhn
. , Masterman
Kuhn 12.
A , , . A Masterman :
, .. ,
, .
( ), ..

, - .. .

317

12

ENOTHTA 12.1

, ,
- .
1

() .
, .
:

O ( ) .
() ().
,
.

O .

- ( ).
- .
, , ( ) .

1/ 12
.
500 .
, .

318

ENOTHTA 12 . 1

KEAAIO

12.2

O-O
E (
)

,
.
O Kuhn
( ) . H : ;
, ( );
K :

( Popper Lakatos);
H Kuhn :
,
13. ,
,
.
E Kuhn . :

14 ,
Kuhn, : 15.
K Kuhn
:
( )
16

319

12

ENOTHTA 12.2

A
17.
M , Kuhn, :
; M (
-)
;
1 , .

.
T
I
, .
(E 6 5 .X. ), ()
(, ) 18.
T -- , , . H - , .
K . T . T . K
, .

19. E
,
( ) : , .
T , , . A -.
, , (
, 5 . .X.),
,
20.

320

ENOTHTA 12.2

KEAAIO

,
, . :
()- (), : - , -.
E , 21.

T
O A (4 . .X.),
, ( )
: M ( ) , 22.

T -
A A (3-4 .X. .) ,
23 (A )
Grosseteste.
T , Grosseteste, , , . , , , . T . E . E E (5 . .X.) 24.
T (Bacon, Witelo,
Pecham), , , N .

T /
M (, , E), A , .
O Robert Boyle, (1627-1691), I Bacon,
25.
O N O

321

12

ENOTHTA 12.2

. H Boyle
, 26.

, . .
H : Y (Hypotheses non fingo). ... H
, , . O
27 .
:
( , ),
, .28 K ,
( ), ( ) .
K Hooke
, N ,
( ) ,
: ... ...
, ... T , , .... O , .29
19
. O T. Young A. Fresnel ,
( Young Fresnel ), , , .30 E . T ()
N, (, , ,
...), .
T 19 , . M Faraday Maxwell,

322

ENOTHTA 12.2

KEAAIO

, . E
20 .
T , , Michelson Morley , . A ,

. T
.
(, ..,
), ,
.
O , , . Y
, , ,
.
O N (-)
. A

. . ,
, .
: ., (1994), : , :
. (.), : ,
, : Gutenberg, . 169-172 31

323

12

ENOTHTA 12.1

12.3

O
OOO O
( ) . :

.

. ,
(--)
.

Kuhn . H

.
M ; K , ;
, ,
, ;
, ( ,
).
Kuhn 32. E
, .
, ,
.
T . M
, Hacking, 33. A -

324

ENOTHTA 12.3

KEAAIO

.
,
, . , , ;

. Kuhn,
, : O , 34.
H .
Newton-Smith ,
.35
, 36.
.
K ( ) . K
37.
, ( )
.
,
, :
.
. ... A
.38
, . .
. .
( ), .
, Kuhn . , Newton-Smith Kuhn. K , Kuhn,

325

12

ENOTHTA 12.3

( )
( )39 (. 2 3 ).
2/ 12

1, . 400 . , .

3/ 12
2, . 2 3. 400 .

326

ENOTHTA 12 . 1

KEAAIO

12.4

OO
H . K
( )
, ,
. O ,
, , , , :
, ,
40.
M
. , Barnes Kuhn , Kuhn .41 A
Lakatos, , ,
42.
A
, ,
. , , ,

, , M A. O Kuhn 43
,
(.. , ) . , Kuhn,

,

327

12

ENOTHTA 12.4

44. H
. , , , 45.
:
K
46.
E :
, 47,
.
, :

, ( )
, ,
,
, ..
,
.48
,
,
49. :
,
,
( , ). ,
.
, Kuhn,
50.
E, ,
. M , ;51, Ziman,
52. A

328

ENOTHTA 12.4

KEAAIO

, .
Kuhn,
Y
, ,
.53
T, , ,
( , ),
Kuhn, -
( ), (
Feyerabend,
54).
4/ 12
() :
,

,
, ,
,
, .. ,
,
.
.
: 1.

5/ 12

, . . .
Introductory Readings in the Philosophy
of Science.55
: .
( ) .
(
).

329

12

ENOTHTA 12.1

12.5

M :
, ,
Kuhn, ,
(.. , , ,
)
. Kuhn
. E :
, Kuhn ,
, .
( )
, Kuhn Wittgenstein 56,
.57 E - . , ,

.

330

ENOTHTA 12 . 1

KEAAIO

12.6

O O O KUHN E
Kuhn ,
. H
. - , Kuhn,
.

Kuhn :
)
)
)
)
2
O Kuhn
H . :
.
(
) .
.
( ) .
. H .

.

331

12

ENOTHTA 12.6

3
O Kuhn
T Kuhn :
)
.
) E, E,
. T
.
, .
) . A
.


.
) H
.
T, ,
, Kuhn . , NewtonSmith , Kuhn .58

332

ENOTHTA 12 . 1

KEAAIO

(, , - ).

01. .
02. .
03. ,
.

04.
,
.
05. H .
06. H
.
07.
.
08. , .
09. H

.

10. K E ,
.
11. H
.
-
12. T
.
13. H
.

333

12

ENOTHTA 12.1

. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 10.

. Chalmers A.F., (1982), . 91.
3
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 10.
4
. Hacking I., (1983), . 7.
5
. Hacking I., (1981), . 2 . Losee J., (1980), . 204
6
. Barnes B., (1982), . 46.
7
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 176.
8
.. . J. Losee (1980), . 206.
9
.., . 43 Chalmers A.F., (1982), . 90-91 Losee J., (1980), . 207.
10
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 189.
11
. Hacking I., : I. Hacking (.) (1981), . 2-3.
12
. Masterman M., (1970), The Nature of a Paradigm, : I. Lakatos A. Musgrave (.)
(1970), . 93.
13
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 80-81.
14
. Chalmers A.F., (1982), . 97.
15
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 158.
16
. Hacking I., : I. Hacking (.) (1981), . 2.
17
. Chalmers A.F., (1982), . 98-99.
18
. B ., (1988), . 175-176 Kirk G., Raven J. Schofield M., (1990), . 262-264.
19
. T ., (1980), . 55.
20
. B ., (1988), . 157 Kirk G., Raven J. Schofield M. (1990), . 349-350.
21
. B ., (1988), . 182-183.
22
. Crombie A. C., (1989), . 113.
23
.., . 112.
24
.., . 112.
25
Butterfield H., (1983), . 126-137.
26
. Gillisrie C. C., (1986), . 117.
27
.., . 120.
28
.., . 121.
29
.., . 122-127.
30
.., . 371-397.
31
., (1994), . 169-172.
32
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 52.
33
. Hacking I. : I. Hacking (.) (1981), . 3.
34
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 115.
35
. Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), . 117.
36
. Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), . 118.
37
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 150.
38
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 110.
39
. Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), . 124.
40
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 94.
41
. Barnes B., (1982), . 59.
42
. Lakatos I., (1970), . 93.
43
. Kuhn. T.S., (1970), . 264, . Kuhn T.S., (1977), . 324-325.
44
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 69.
45
. Hacking I., (1982), . 59.
46
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), : I. Lakatos A. Musgrave (.) (1970), . 20.
47
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 206.
48
. Kuhn T.S., (1977), . 321-322.
2

334

ENOTHTA 12 . 1

KEAAIO

49

. Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), . 113.

.., . 116.
51
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 170.
52
. Ziman J., (1968), . 135.
53
. Kuhn T.S., (1970).
54
. Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), . 122.
55
. lemke E. D., Hollinger R. and Kline A. D., (.) (1988), . 443.
56
. Wittgenstein L., (1953), . 31-36.
57
. Kuhn T.S., (1970), . 45.
58
. Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), . 124.
50

335

12

ENOTHTA 12.1

1
: ,
[
]
(, ). :
,
. O
, ..
.
, .

2
:
. O .
. , ,
, . O
N (-)

. .
6 . . .
( )
- . . 1, . O yle

, , ,
. 19 ,
Michelson Morley
. , ,
(-).

336

ENOTHTA 12 . 1

KEAAIO

O

B ., (1988), O , A: Z.
T ., (1980), T , A: .
., (1994), : , : .
B., (.), (1994) : ,
, : Gutenberg.
Butterfield H., (1983), , .: . .
, : , . 126-137.
Crombie A.C., (1989), , .: . . , : , . 113.
Gillisrie C.C., (1986), , .: . , : , . 117.
Kirk G., Raven J. Schofield M., (1990), O , :
. K, A: M E T.

Barnes B., (1982), T.S. Kuhn and Social Science, The Macmillan Press.
Chalmers A.F., (1982), What Is This Thing Called Science, Milton Keynes: Open
University Press.
Hacking I., (1981), Lakatos philosophy of science, : I. Hacking, (.) (1981),
Scientific revolutions, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hacking I., (1982), Language, Truth and Reason, : M. Hollis S.Lukes (.)
(1982), Rationality and Relativism, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hacking I., (1983), Representing and intervening, (Cambridge).
lemke E. D., Hollinger R. and Kline A.D., (.) (1988), Introductory Readings in the
Philosophy of Science, Buffalo, New York: Prometheus Books.
Kuhn T.S., (1970), The structure of scientific revolutions, Chicago: Chicago University
Press.
Kuhn T.S., (1970), Logic of discovery or Psychology of research?, : I. Lakatos A.
Musgrave (.) (1970), Criticism and the growth of knowledge, Cambridge: Cambridge
University press.
Kuhn T.S., (1977), The Essential Tension, Chicago University Press.
Lakatos I., (1970), Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes,
: I. Lakatos, A. Musgrave, (.), (1970), Criticism and the growth of knowledge,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Losee J., (1980), A historical introduction to the philosophy of science, Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Masterman M., (1970), The Nature of a Paradigm, : I. Lakatos A. Musgrave
(.) (1970), Criticism and the growth of knowledge, Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.

337

12

ENOTHTA 12.1

Newton-Smith W.H., (1981), The rationality of science, London.

Wittgenstein L., (1953), Philosophical Investigations, . A Pears
McGuiness, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ziman J., (1968), Public knowledge, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

OO
Kuhn, T. (1981), , . . . ,
: .
Kuhn

.
(. 9-47).

338