Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
Wagner et al v Swarts et al US Courts, NY

Wagner et al v Swarts et al US Courts, NY

Ratings: (0)|Views: 397|Likes:
Published by Kathy E. Gill
Case 1:09-cv-00652-GLS-DRH Document 77 Filed 11/17/11.

New York state recently prevailed in a lawsuit filed by a motorcyclist rights group challenging the constitutionality of "Motorcycle Only" Police Checkpoints.

MICHAEL WAGNER, LEVI INGERSOLL, KEN FENWICK and SIDNEY ALPAUGH,
Plaintiffs, 1:09-cv-652
(GLS/DRH)
v.
DAVID J. SWARTS et al.,
Defendants.

Case 1:09-cv-00652-GLS-DRH Document 77 Filed 11/17/11.

New York state recently prevailed in a lawsuit filed by a motorcyclist rights group challenging the constitutionality of "Motorcycle Only" Police Checkpoints.

MICHAEL WAGNER, LEVI INGERSOLL, KEN FENWICK and SIDNEY ALPAUGH,
Plaintiffs, 1:09-cv-652
(GLS/DRH)
v.
DAVID J. SWARTS et al.,
Defendants.

More info:

Published by: Kathy E. Gill on Jan 06, 2012
Copyright:Public Domain

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/06/2012

pdf

text

 
VNETFD XTKTFX DEXTPEHT HLVPTNLPTJFPN DEXTPEHT LI NF] ULPB \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ OEHJKFC ]KMNFP# CFYE ENMFPXLCCBFN IFN]EHB knd XEDNFU KCQKVMJ#Qckenteiix#;715/hy/960*MCX,DPJ%y. DKYED G. X]KPTX ft kc.#Dfifndkntx. \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ KQQFKPKNHFX7LI HLVNXFC7ILP TJF QCKENTEIIX7
Qplnfp# Qplnfp Ck} IepoOETHJFCC C. QPLNFP# FX[.91 Fkxt 40
nd
XtpfftNf} Ulpb# Nf} Ulpb ;1;96
ILP TJF DFIFNDKNTX7
JLN. FPEH T. XHJNFEDFPOKNDLVMCKX G. MLMCEKNf} Ulpb Xtktf Kttlpnfu MfnfpkcKxxextknt Kttlpnfu MfnfpkcKc`knu LiiehfTjf HkqetlcKc`knu# NU ;0004
Mkpu C. XjkpqfDextpeht Hlvpt GvdmfOFOLPKNDVO/DFHEXELN KND LPDFPE. Entpldvhteln
Qckenteiix Oehjkfc ]kmnfp# Cfye Enmfpxlcc# Bfn Ifn}ehb knd Xednfu
Hkxf ;715/hy/11960/MCX/DPJ Dlhvofnt == Iecfd ;;,;=,;; Qkmf ; li 84
 
Kcqkvmj hloofnhfd tjex khteln kmkenxt dfifndkntx#
;
kxxfptenm hckeoxqvpxvknt tl 40 V.X.H. §§ ;5:8 knd ;5:: ilp yelcktelnx li tjfep hlnxtetvtelnkcpemjtx en hlngvnhteln }etj dfifndkntx― eoqcfofntkteln knd fzfhvteln lioltlphuhcf hjfhbqlentx. *
Xff 
Hloqc.# Dbt. Nl. ;.% Qfndenm kpf tjfqkptefx― hplxx/oltelnx ilp xvookpu gvdmofnt knd qckenteiix― olteln ilp hckxxhfpteiehkteln. *
Xff 
Dbt. Nlx. 9;# 94.% Ilp tjf pfkxlnx tjkt ilccl}#dfifndkntx― olteln ilp xvookpu gvdmofnt ex mpkntfd# knd qckenteiix―oltelnx kpf dfnefd.
EE. @khbmplvnd
0
En 011:# tjf Nf} Ulpb Xtktf Qlcehf eoqcfofntfd k Xtktf}edfOltlphuhcf Fnilphfofnt knd Fdvhkteln Enetekteyf *–Enetekteyf‟% tl kddpfxx tjf–kckpoenm enhpfkxf en oltlphuhcf hpkxjfx . . . lyfp tjf qkxt dfhkdf#‟ kndtjf fxhkcktenm –nvo`fp li oltlphuhcfx tpkyfcenm Nf} Ulpb―x plkd}kux.‟*Dfix.― Xtktfofnt li Oktfpekc Ikhtx *–XOI‟% ¹ ;# Dbt. Nl. 9;# Kttkhj. ;.% Enkddeteln tl k qv`ceh enilpokteln,fdvhkteln fcfofnt# tjf Enetekteyf hkccfd ilp
;
Kctjlvmj tjf Hloqckent cextx ovcteqcf dfifndkntx# tjf qkptefx# yek xteqvcktelnx#dexoexxfd tjf hckeox kmkenxt tjf okglpetu li tjfo. *
Xff 
Dbt. Nlx. 44# 49# 4=# 4:# 45# 61.% Tjfpfokenenm dfifndkntx kpf Dkyed G. X}kptx# Hjkep li tjf Mlyfpnlp―x Tpkiieh Xkiftu Hlooettff#kx }fcc kx Okglp ]ecceko Xqpkmvf# Cefvtfnknt Dknefc Ckpben knd Cefvtfnknt Geo Jkcyfpxfn# kccli tjf Nf} Ulpb Xtktf Qlcehf.
0
Tjf ikhtx kpf vndexqvtfd vncfxx ltjfp}exf nltfd.
0
Hkxf ;715/hy/11960/MCX/DPJ Dlhvofnt == Iecfd ;;,;=,;; Qkmf 0 li 84
 
oltlphuhcf hjfhbqlentx# –k nlyfc hlnhfqt en Nf} Ulpb kx }fcc kxnktelnkccu#‟ tl pfdvhf tjf nvo`fp li oltlphuhcf hpkxjfx knd enhpfkxfyfjehcf knd tpkiieh ck} hloqceknhf. *
Xff ed.
¹¹ 0/4.% Khhlpdenm tldfifndkntx#
8
tjf qpeokpu l`gfhteyf li tjf hjfhbqlentx }kx –tl dftfhtoltlphuhcf xkiftu yelcktelnx knd enxvpf R
xeh 
_ qplqfp pfmextpkteln kndlqfpktlp hloqceknhf }etj Nf} Ulpb Xtktf―x oltlphuhcf cehfnxfpf{vepfofntx.‟ *
Xff# f.m# ed.
¹ 9.%
4
;.Hpfkteln li tjf Enetektey
Kx qkpt li jex Okxtfp―x hlvpxf }lpb kt tjf Xtktf Vneyfpxetu li Nf}Ulpb kt Kc`knu# dfifndknt Ct. Gkofx Jkcyfpxfn# tjf hlookndenm liiehfp litjf Nf} Ulpb Xtktf Qlcehf Oltlphuhcf Vnet# }pltf k tjfxex ln tjfenhpfkxenm pktf li oltlphuhcf iktkcetefx ilp pedfpx lyfp ilptu/ufkpx lcd. *
Xff 
Dbt. Nl. 9;# Kttkhj. ;4 ¹ 06.% En xl dlenm# jf hlnxedfpfd ofkxvpfx—xvhjkx plvtenf hloofphekc tpvhbenm enxqfhtelnx knd tjf kvtlol`ecf xfkt`fct
8
Qckenteiix kyfp dfifndkntx― xtktfd l`gfhteyf ex ofpfcu k qpftfzt# kx tjf tpvf qvpqlxf litjf hjfhbqlentx }kx mfnfpkc hpeoenkc entfpdehteln. *
Xff 
Dbt. Nl. 94# Kttkhj. 8 ¹ ;.% En xvqqlptli tjex hlntfnteln# tjfu pkexf t}l qpenheqcf kpmvofntx7 *;% tjf hjfhbqlentx }fpf enfiifhteyfxenhf tjfu ikecfd tl kddpfxx tjf okglp hkvxfx li oltlphuhcf iktkcetefx *
e.f.#
xqffd knd kchljlc%knd }fpf nlt fzqcehetcu pfhloofndfd `u fetjfp tjf Nktelnkc Jemj}ku Tpkiieh XkiftuKdoenextpkteln *–NJTXK‟% lp tjf Mlyfpnlp―x Tpkiieh Xkiftu Hlooettff *–MTXH‟%2 knd *0% tjfenhcvxeln li nln/oltlphuhcf fnilphfofnt liiehfpx kt tjf hjfhbqlentx }kx endehkteyf li tjf tpvfqvpqlxf. *
Xff ed.
2
khhlpd 
Dbt. Nl. 94# Kttkhj. ;; kt =/:.%
4
*
Xff kcxl 
Dbt. Nl. 9;# Kttkhj. ;4 ¹ 9# Kttkhj. 00 kt 8;# Kttkhj. 08 kt 8;# Kttkhj. 09 kt;# Kttkhj. 0= kt 8# Kttkhj. 0: kt ;.%
8
Hkxf ;715/hy/11960/MCX/DPJ Dlhvofnt == Iecfd ;;,;=,;; Qkmf 8 li 84

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->