Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
11 - An Intellectual Arjuna - 3

11 - An Intellectual Arjuna - 3

Ratings: (0)|Views: 12|Likes:
Shri V. Sundaram, I.A.S. (retired), Columnist reviews the book "They Impeached Humanity". It was published in "Daily News Today" published from Chennai, under his column "Baritone" in four installments as "An Intellectual Arjuna".
Shri V. Sundaram, I.A.S. (retired), Columnist reviews the book "They Impeached Humanity". It was published in "Daily News Today" published from Chennai, under his column "Baritone" in four installments as "An Intellectual Arjuna".

More info:

Categories:Types, Reviews
Published by: Maanoj Rakhit (Yashodharma) on Jan 14, 2012
Copyright:Public Domain

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

06/12/2013

pdf

text

original

 
koyt~fnj}ko~+dfe
k Okiamt` osokmki njma} |uhamt`on cxfe D`okkjm
 Jddfxnmki ~f
Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ ‐toaamki D`xmt~mjkm~}” (y`md` ifot h} ~`o ixjknmafzuok~ kjeo fc ‐@jxsot~mki fc Tfuat”-
xfukn ~`o yfxan jkn efxo |jx~m%duajxa} ~f ~`o @mknu |jijkt jkn @mknu `oj~`okt~`xfui` ~`omx haj~jk~ hajdb efko} |fyox jkn mk~oxkj~mfkja |fam%~mdja mkcauokdo mt ~`o y`fao ~meo hutmkott fc ~`oD`xmt~mjk emt%tmfkjxmot mk Mknmj ~fnj}+
Ejjkfg Xjb`m~
 Xmi`~ cxfe :?:< JN! ~`oto D`xmt~mjk jiok%dmot `jso hook djxx}mki fk j cjato |xf|jijknj jijmkt~ @mknu xoamimfk!@mknu tfdmo~} jkn @mknu dua~uxo ~f ~`o occod~ ~`j~ ~`o @mknu |fam~} cfx efxo ~`jk 8<<< }ojxt xot~on fk ~`ocfuknj~mfkt fc tajsox} jkn tfdmja mkgut~mdo+Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ d`jaaokiot ~`mt hjtoaott d`jxio h} zuf~mki cxfe ~`o yxm~mkit fc 
 JXXMJK
 
(8kn Dok~ux} nmtdm|ao fc O|md~o~ut-
+Xocoxxmki ~f ~`o |uhamd Fsoxtooxt jknTu|oxmk~oknok~t mk jkdmok~ (
@mknu
-
H`jjxj~sjxt`! Jxxmjk yxf~o jt cfaafyt7
^`o} fsoxtoo y`j~ ifot fk mk ~`o smaajiot fx ~fykt! jkn xo|fx~ osox}~`mki ~f ~`o Bmki! y`oxo ~`o|of|ao `jso j Bmki! jkn ~f ~`o Ejimt~xj~ot! y`oxo ~`o |of|ao jxo toac%ifsoxkon! jkn m~ mt jijmkt~uto! dut~fe jkn dfksok~mfk cfx ~`oto |of|ao ~f imso j cjato xo|fx~ ~f ~`omx dfk~xfaamkiju~`fxm~mot+Mknoon kf H`jjxj~m}j (
 @mknu
- mt osox jdduton fc a}mki”+ (Tfuxdo7 Too EdDxmknao mkMknmjk Jk~mzujx}! :093! |jio =8 — ~`mt yjt zuf~on h} Ejp Euaaox mk :008 mk `mt MKNMJ 
Y`j~ djk m~ ~ojd` ut6 
-
 
Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ tj}t ~`j~ mc yo ~jbo djxo ~f affb ho}fkn ~`o ‐
ao~~ox 
” fc Jxxmjk”t fhtoxsj~mfk ~fuknoxt~jkn ~`o ‐t|mxm~” fc `mt eottjio! ~`ok yo djk daojxa} too ~`j~ `o yjt |j}mki `mt ~xmhu~o ~f ~`ot}t~oe fc ‐@mknu toac%ifsoxkjkdo” mk ~`o 8kn Dok~ux} JN
+Jk} fko ymaa xojnma} dfkdono ~`j~ m~ yjt jtu|oxmfx cfxe fc 
|of|aot” noefdxjd} 
jt dfe|jxon ~f ~`o |xotok~ nj} ejajn} fc 
ejkm|uaj~mso noefdxjd}
|xonfemkjk~a} nxmsok h} |oxtfkja mk~oxot~t fc ~`fto y`f jxxfijk~a} dajme ~f ho ~`o fka} ~xuo xo|xotok~j~msot fc 
^`o \of|ao*
 
Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ ~`ok dm~ot ju~`ok~md tfuxdot cxfe `mt~fx} jt sjamn osmnokdo ~f xohu~ ~`o
 
mxxot|fktmhao jkn fc~ok xo|oj~on d`jxio fc D`xmt~mjk emttmfkjxmot jkn ~`o D`uxd` ~`j~ @mknut`jso kosox `jn t}t~oet fc tfdmja gut~mdo cfuknon fk ozum~}! kj~uxja gut~mdo jkn cjmx |aj}+
 
Ao~ eonoja ym~` tfeo sox} mk~oxot~mki jkn xmso~mki mkt~jkdot jkn zuf~j~mfkt cuxkmt`on h} `me! y`md` djkt~jkn ~`o t~xmd~ot~ tdxu~mk} mk jk} dfux~ fc ajy opdo|~mki mk ~`o Efdb Dfux~t fc jk~m%@mknu |tounf%toduajx |fam~mdja |jx~mot+Osmnokdo :7 @muok ^tjki (3<8JN — 33> JN-
 yjt j cjefut D`mkoto Hunn`mt~ efkb! td`fajx! ~xjsoaox! jkn~xjktaj~fx y`f hxfui`~ u| j dafto dua~uxja mk~oxjd~mfk ho~yook D`mkj jkn Mknmj mk ~`o cmxt~ `jac fc ~`o 9~` dok~ux}  JN nuxmki ~`o ojxa} ^jki |oxmfn+@o ok~oxon Mknmj jkn xojd`on Gjajajhjn mk 34< JN+Aj~ox `o yok~ ~f Bjt`emx mk348 JN+Mk 344 JN `o cfukn `metoac mk Cmxfw|ux mk \ukgjh+Mk 34> JN `o yjt mk Gjajknjx+Aj~ox `o ~fud`on Bjkjug~`o Dj|m~ja fc ~`o ixoj~ Oe|oxfx @jxt`j mk 343 JN+@o gfuxko}on! ~`xfui` Fxmttj mk 340 JN jkn xodfxnon jkmk~oxot~mki jddfuk~ fc ?< @mknu ~oe|aot! :<< Hunn`mt~ efkjt~oxmot mk _%d`j (Fnxjnotj- mk `mt cjefutju~fhmfixj|`}+^`ok `o yok~ ~f Jejxjsj~m jkn Kjijxgukjbfknj+ Jddfxnmki ~f tfeo td`fajxt `o mt tjmn ~f `jsoamson cfx zum~o tfeo ~meo mk Bjkd`m|uxje+ @o yxf~o jhfu~ efxo ~`jk :<< ~oe|aot jkn :< efkjt~oxmot mk jknjxfukn Bjkd`m|uxje+
@muok ^tjki hodjeo cjefut cfx `mt tosok~ook }ojx fsoxajkn ~xm| ~f Mknmj jkn hjdb! y`md` `o xodfxnon mk no~jma mk `mt ju~fhmfixj|`} 
+ Mk `mt ju~fhmfixj|`}! `o yxf~o jtcfaafyt7
‐^`fui` ~`o H`jjxj~m}jt (@mknut- jxo fc ami`~ ~oe|oxjeok~! ~`o} jxo nmt~mkiumt`on h} ~`oT^XJMI@^ CFXYJXNKOTT JKN @FKOT^] FC ^@OMX D@JXJD^OX (
j cjd~ y`md` ymaa t`fdb ~`oD`xmt~mjk emttmfkjxmot mk Mknmj ~fnj}! efxo |jx~mduajxa} mk Fxmttj jkn Bjxkj~jbj
*-+ Ym~` xoijxn~f xmd`ot! ~`o} kosox ~jbo jk}~`mki ukgut~a}2 ym~` xoijxn ~f gut~mdo! ~`o} ejbo osok opdottmsodfkdottmfk++++ T~xjmi`~ cfxyjxnkott mt ~`o nmt~mkiumt`mki coj~uxo fc ~`omx jnemkmt~xj~mfk”+(Tfuxdo7MKNMJ 
Y`j~ djk m~ ~ojd` ut6 
Ejp Euaaox :008-+ Jc~ox zuf~mki ~`o jhfso yfxnt fc @muok ^tjki! Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ jtbt ~`oto |ox~mkok~ zuot~mfkt7@fy mt m~ ~`j~ j tfdmo~}! jdduton h} ~`o D`uxd` fc |xjd~mdmki ixftt tfdmja mkgut~mdo ~fyjxnt m~tfyk |of|ao! `jt hook |xjmton h} @muok ^tjki mk ~`o 9~` dok~ux} JN |u~~mki m~ fk xodfxn ‐
Ym~`xoijxn ~f gut~mdo! @mknut ejbo osok opdottmso dfkdottmfkt”
 
^`mkb cfx j efeok~ jhfu~ ~`o |of|ao y`f ‐
 Kosox ixjhhon jk}~`mki ukgut~a}” 
cxfe f~`ox|of|aot” yoja~`„yfuan ~`o} `jso |xjd~mdon ixftt tfdmja mkgut~mdo ~fyjxnt ~`omx fyk |of|ao h} 
xfhhmki ~`oe fc 
 
hjtmd `uejk xmi`~t6 
 
 Jkn jijmk! ~`mkb! |of|ao y`f ejno ‐
opdottmso dfkdottmfkt ym~` xoijxn ~f gut~mdo” 
yfuan ~`o} `jso |xjd~mdon ixftt tfdmja mkgut~mdo ~fyjxnt j sox} ajxio tod~mfk fc ~`omx fyk |of|ao h} 
xfhhmki ~`oe fc ~`omx sox} toac%xot|od~6 
 
^`ut Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ xmi`~a} dfkdaunot ~`j~ ~`oxo mt tfeo~`mki ~`j~ xoejmkt ukop|ajmkon+Mk jaa `mt yfxbt ambo ‐
^`o} Me|ojd`on @uejkm~}”! ‐Tjso @uejkm~}”! ‐D`xmt~mjkm~} mk j nmccoxok~ Ami`~”!‐Gunjmte D`xmt~mjkm~} Mtaje Toduajxmte @mknumte”! ‐Toon :” jkn ‐Toon 8”!
`o `jt |xfnudoncfxemnjhao osmnokdo xoaj~mki ~f efxo ~`jk :0<< }ojxt mk cjsfux fc @mknu tfdmo~} jkn Tjkj~jkjN`jxej mk fxnox ~f noefamt` jkn not~xf} ~`o sox} t~xud~uxo fc cxjun y`md` `jt hook djxocuaa}  huma~ fsox j huknao fc amot jkn cjato`ffnt h} ~`o D`xmt~mjk emttmfkjxmot jkn ~`o D`uxd` nuxmki ~`oajt~ ?<< }ojxt ym~` j sox} t|odmcmd jioknj mk emkn„xoamimfut dfksoxtmfk (
j bkfyk dfeeoxdmja hutmkott*
- djaaon ‐@jxsot~mki fc Tfuat”+
Ao~ ut kfy ~uxk ~f ~`o ~ot~mefk} fc 
Oa Mnxmtm (::<<%::33-+Osmnokdo 87 Oa Mnxmtm
yjt jk Jxjh iofixj|`ox! djx~fixj|`ox jkn ~xjsoaaox y`f amson mk Tmdma}! j~ ~`o dfux~ fc Bmki Xfiox MM+ Eu`jeeon ja%Mnxmtm yjt hfxk mk ~`o Kfx~` Jcxmdjk dm~} fc Dou~j ~`ok hoafkimki ~f ~`o Jaefxjsmn
 
Oe|mxo jkn nmon mk Tmdma}! fx ej}ho mk Tjh~j`+ Ja%Mnxmtm mkdfx|fxj~on ~`o bkfyaonio fc Jcxmdj! ~`o Mknmjk Fdojkjkn ~`o Cjx Ojt~ ij~`oxon h} Jxjh eoxd`jk~t jkn op|afxoxt ym~` ~`o mkcfxej~mfk mk`oxm~on cxfe ~`o dajttmdjaiofixj|`oxt ~f dxoj~o ~`o eft~ jdduxj~o ej| fc ~`o yfxan mk |xo%efnoxk ~meot+^`o
^jhuaj Xfioxmjkj
yjtnxjyk h} Ja%Mnxmtm mk ::?> cfx ~`o Kfxejk Bmki Xfiox MM fc Tmdma}! jc~ox j t~j} fc omi`~ook }ojxt j~ `mt dfux~! y`oxo`o yfxbon fk ~`o dfeeok~jxmot jkn maaut~xj~mfkt fc ~`o ej|+ ^`o ej|! yxm~~ok mk Jxjhmd! t`fyt ~`o Ouxjtmjkdfk~mkok~ mk m~t ok~mxo~}! hu~ fka} t`fyt ~`o kfx~`oxk |jx~ fc ~`o Jcxmdjk dfk~mkok~+
 Ja Mnxmtm `jn ~`mt ~f tj} jhfu~ ~`o @mknut fc Mknmj7
‐@mknut jxo kj~uxjaa} mkdamkon ~f gut~mdo jknkosox no|jx~ cxfe m~ mk ~`omx jd~mfkt”+
Mc ~`j~ ho tf! dfuan ~`o} `jso jaafyon
‐tfdmja mkgut~mdo”
fc ~`o bmkn~`j~ ~`o} yoxo jdduton fc h} D`xmt~mjk emttmfkjxmot! D`xmt~mjk onudj~fxt! ~`o D`uxd` jkn ~`o Dfeeukmt~onudj~fxt (
fc |ft~%Mkno|oknok~ Mknmj-6 
Osox yfknox mc ~`o} yoxo onudj~fxt h} |xfcottmfk fx |xfcottmfkjaamjxt6 Y`j~ yjt ~`omx fhgod~mso6 Nmn ~`o} yjk~ @mknu d`manxok ~f io~ du~ fcc cxfe ~`omx ejmk t~xoje xoamimfut jkndua~uxja hjto jkn hoimk ~f affb cfx ja~oxkj~mso ym~`
(j-
D`xmt~mjkm~} mk D`xmt~mjk Hxm~mt` nj}t jkn (
 h
- ym~`Dfeeukmte&Ejxpmte mk tf%djaaon |ft~%Mkno|oknokdo nj}t6 
Osmnokdo 47 Mk ~`o :4~` dok~ux} yo `jso ~`o ~ot~mefk} fc Ejxdf \faf (:8?>%:48> JN-! y`f ~`utt|ojbt fc Jhxjmejk! j kjeo h} y`md` `o eojkt ~`o Hxjj`ejkt y`f! ~`fui` kf~ ~xjnoxt h} |xfcottmfk! yoxo t|odmjaa} oe|af}on cfx ixoj~ dfeeoxdmja ~xjktjd~mfkt h} ~`o Bmki+Jddfxnmki ~fEjxdf \faf! ~`o Bmkit uton ~f dfktua~ ~`oe nuxmki ~meot fc kj~mfkja dxmtmt+\xjmtmki ~`omxukme|ojd`jhao mk~oixm~}! Ejxdf \faf yxf~o mk ~`o ajt~ zujx~ox fc :4~` dok~ux}7 ‐
]fu eut~ bkfy~`j~ ~`oto
 Jhxjmejk
jxo ~`o hot~ eoxd`jk~t mk ~`o yfxan! jkn ~`o eft~ ~xu~`cua! cfx ~`o} yfuan kf~ ~oaa j amo cfx jk}~`mki fk Ojx~`”+
(Tfuxdo7 Ejxdf \faf! Onm~on h} @+]uao% |jio 4?<„zuf~on h} EjpEuaaox mk :008 Mknmj
Y`j~ djk m~ ~ojd` ut6-
 Jddfxnmki ~f Ejjkfg Xjb`m~!
~`o D`xmt~mjk emttmfkjxmot jkn ~`o D`uxd` `jso |ux|ftocuaa} ~jxkmt`on ~`omejio fc Hxjj`ejkt cxfe :?<< JN+ ^`mt ijeo ij~`oxon cux~`ox efeok~ue mk :?>: JN y`ok T~+ Cxjkdmt Pjsmoxjxxmson mk Ifj+ Jc~ox toomki ~`j~ ~`o Hxjj`ejkt fc Ifj yoxo ukymaamki ~f toaa ~`omx tfuat ~f ~`o D`xmt~mjk D`uxd`cfx j eott fc |f~~jio! T~+Cxjkdmt Pjsmox yxf~o ~f ~`o Tfdmo~} fc Gotut7
‐^`oxo jxo mk ~`oto |jx~t jefki ~`o|jijkt j dajtt fc eok djaaon Hxjj`ejkt+^`o} jxo jt |oxsoxto jkn ymdbon j to~ jt djk jk}y`oxo hocfukn! jkn ~f y`fe j||amot ~`o \tjae! y`md` tj}t7 ‐
 Cxfe jk uk`fa} xjdo! jkn ymdbon jkn dxjc~}eok! noamsox eo! Afxn”+
Mk jkf~`ox ao~~ox ~f ~`o Tfdmo~} fc Gotut! T~+Cxjkdmt Pjsmox yxf~o7
 Mc m~ yoxo kf~ cfx ~`o Hxjj`ejkt! yo t`fuan `jso ja ~`o `oj~`okt oehxjdmki fux cjm~`”+
 T~+Cxjkdmt Pjsmox yxf~o mk j sox} nmt|jxjimki ejkkox jhfu~ ~`o Hxjj`ejkt fc Tfu~` Mknmj+Y`f mt xmi`~„Ejxdf\faf fx T~+ Cxjkdmt Pjsmox6Fx
 Jxxmjk! Mnxmtm! Ejxdf \faf (dfsoxmki j |oxmfn fc :4<< }ojxt- smtm~on ~`o@mknut fc Mknmj jkn t|fbo jkn yxf~o jhfu~ ~`omx dfkdoxk cfx ozum~}! kj~uxja gut~mdo jkn ~xu~`6
T~+Cxjkdmt Pjsmox `jn ~f xuk nfyk ~`o Hxjj`ejkt cfx t~jx~mki `mt
‐dfeeoxdmja dfksoxtmfk”
 yfxb mk Ifj+Kfy jtb }fuxtoac! y`f `jso hook a}mki jaa jxfukn6 Jxxmjk! Mnxmtm! Ejxdf \faf fx T~+Cxjkdmt Pjsmox fx ~`o D`uxd` fxD`xmt~mjk emttmfkjxmot due onudj~fxt y`f `jn ~`o `mnnok jioknj ~f dfksox~ @mknut mk~f D`xmt~mjkm~} h} `ffb fxdxffb6 Fx! ~`o Dfeeukmt~&Ejxpmt~ `mt~fxmjkt fc Jamijx` Eutame _kmsoxtm~} (JE_- jkn Gjyj`jxaja Ko`xu_kmsoxtm~} (GE_- y`f `jn j `mnnok jioknj ~f t|xojn ~`omx ymkit tf ~`j~ ~`o} dfuan boo| ~`omx maaoim~mej~oa} jdzumxon `fan fsox @mknu tfdmo~}+
Ejjkfg Xjb`m~ tuet u| ym~` iokumko |j~xmf~md jkn kj~mfkjamt~md coxsfux mk ~`mt dfk~op~7 ‐Jaacxjunt~oxt `jso j hxf~`ox`ffn bmkn fc cooamki jkn ~`o} tu||fx~ ojd` f~`ox+^`mt mt y`j~ ~`oto

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->