Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
EurekaHedge_The Truth About Art Funds

EurekaHedge_The Truth About Art Funds

Ratings: (0)|Views: 206 |Likes:
Published by artvest

More info:

Published by: artvest on Jan 18, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/18/2012

pdf

text

original

 
 The Truth About Art Funds
Michael Plummer, Principal and Jeff Rabin, Principal Artvest Partners LLC 
The outstanding performance of the art market over the past 10 years, coupled with the trepidation many haveabout financial markets post-2008, has led to growing interest in art as an investment and increased dialogue aboutart fund vehicles.
Defining an art fund
The sheer mention of the term ‘art fund’ often stirs controversy. A contributing factor to the lack of understandingand agreement is that the term is broadly, and sometimes inappropriately, applied. Artvest defines an art fund as astructured investment vehicle with Offering Documents that is open to third-party investors for the purpose of financial gain. Everything from valuation methodology, to inherent conflicts of interest, to risk control anddiversification must be sound, well-considered and documented. Properly created, an art fund will share similaritiesin structure to financial asset funds yet take into account the crucial difference that art is the underlying asset.Specialised expertise is essential to successfully manage such an entity.Private Investment Partnerships (PIPs) are often conflated with art funds, creating additional misunderstanding.Unlike art funds, PIPs are not made available to outside investors and are simply groups of individuals who havepooled resources to invest in art or other assets.
The current art fund landscape
The scale of the art fund industry is commonly believed to be significantly larger than it is. New fundannouncements usually garner extensive attention from the press yet few actually raise capital, and those that doare typically a fraction of their intended size. It is not uncommon for funds that had stated goals of US$100 million+when announced, to have total assets under management of US$10 – US$15 million when they close on fundingand begin art buying.There are less than a handful of operational art funds investing meaningful capital — greater than US$50 million.Artvest estimates the global art fund industry to be US$1 billion, with Asian funds accounting for approximately onethird of that total.Traction has been slow for a number of reasons, most importantly apprehension about investing in a little-understood market. Another concern is the impact that unpredictable trends in fashion and taste can have on the artmarket over time. A scarcity of art fund structuring expertise has also been a detriment. These factors, along withthe absence of established long-term track records, has made the possibility of meaningful institutional investmentin art funds a challenge thus far.Further exacerbating the broader acceptance of art funds are a few notable instances of fraud and/or incompetencein the last five years — the result of unscrupulous practices by a handful of individuals that led to the loss of investor capital, numerous lawsuits and a considerable hit to the industry.More confusion comes from individuals successful in financial products venturing into the art fund space, believingthat their experience is portable. The art market is remarkably different from all other asset classes — it is opaque,illiquid, unregulated, non-commoditised and emotional. A deep understanding of the players, artists, sectors andintricacies is essential. Getting involved without this knowledge is akin to letting a child drive the family car.
Considerable due diligence is imperative
When considering an art fund investment, many critical questions must be answered such as: how is the fundstructured; are there adequate risk controls; how often is the fund valued and what is the methodology; what is theliquidation strategy; and most importantly, who are the principals and advisors, how are they compensated andwhat are their potential conflicts of interest? This is not by
 
 
any means a comprehensive list, the questions are many and engaging a true expert before committing capital toany art fund is crucial.The art fund industry is still in its infancy, so experts with authentic experience are few and far between. Lack of regulation has allowed for the unfortunate rise of self-appointed experts which has made it more difficult for potentialfund investors to separate fact from fiction. One ill-informed art fund ‘expert’ went so far as to make the erroneousclaim in an interview this past spring on the Financial Times website that art funds put a floor in the art marketduring the correction in the last half of 2008. This is a patently false claim given that the buying power of art fundswas less than 0.25% of the US$59.5 billion market turnover that year.
Opposing sides in the art fund debate
A primary disagreement in the art fund debate centers on investment versus connoisseurship. As the tradable artmarket has increased dramatically, both in terms of overall transactions and values of individual works of art,interest has expanded considerably. Many new entrants see the market as another opportunity for financial gainwhile more traditional collectors adhere to the notion that art is simply to be lived with and enjoyed.
Art funds in Asia
China and India have seen the quickest adoption of art funds. During the past five years, the number of Asian-based art investment funds has experienced unprecedented growth. Art funds first gained traction in India, but sincethe financial crisis, China has become the more important player. Artvest has also identified a number of activePIPs in Asia. Though there is little information available because they are not open to outside investors, PIPs are anincreasingly influential force in the market.Primarily, Asian art funds are focused on acquiring works by native artists and are typically able to raise capitalmore quickly than Western art funds given the region’s predisposition for tangible assets. In addition, the willingnessof Asian banks, including ICICI, Kotak Mahindra and Minsheng, to actively participate in the art fund industry hasfurther legitimised interest.Recently Indian-based art funds have encountered several critical setbacks. Many of India’s art funds havestruggled with eroding valuations, negative press coverage and rumours of difficulty honouring fund redemptions. Ithas been reported that the Securities and Exchange Board of India may soon institute stringent rules andregulations for local art funds, which will have a consequential impact on the future of India’s art fund industry.In China, however, the soaring art market has led to an increasing number of art investment funds currently raisingcapital or acquiring art. While inefficiencies in the art market in China present potentially lucrative opportunities for art funds, there are numerous obstacles that may hinder the industry’s future. For example, as the value of Chineseart continues to rise, Chinese art funds will face the challenge of raising increasingly large amounts of capital inorder to remain relevant and competitive.
The future
Despite these issues, interest in art funds continues to grow and the future is certain to see more legitimate vehiclescoming to the market. Several funds in the US and the UK are in the process of raising capital for their second or third generation funds and finding it much easier to do so, now that they have established track records.Continued global economic uncertainty combined with low interest rates has led many to seek investments outsideof traditional financial vehicles. As new art funds proliferate and investors commit more capital, due diligence willbecome more imperative and a full understanding of such issues as tax consequences, legal implications, riskmanagement, market access and collecting trends will be all the more critical.

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->