MARCUS CEDERQVIST IEXECUTNE DIRECTOR JAMES J, SAMPEL PRESIDENT FREDERIC M. UMANE ‘SECRETARY (GEORGE GONZALEZ DePuTy EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR JOSE MIGUEL ARALO PAMELA GREEN PERKINS. JULIE DENT. [ADMINISTRATIVE MANAGER. NERO GRAHAM, Je BOARD OF ELECTIONS JUAN CARLOS °C." POLANCO ane cry ctINew vor NANCY MOTTOLA-SCHACHER ‘GREGORY C. SOUMAS EXECUTIVE OFFICE, 82 BROADWAY JUDITH D. STUPP NEW YORK, NY'10004~1609 [MARYANN YENNELLA (@12)'487-5300 CComuissioneRs: FAX (212) 487-5349 avote.nye.ny.us November 10, 2008 Mr. -_ Robbins Dear Mr. Robbins: As the Democratic Commissioner of Elections from the Borough of Manhattan, I read with great concern the media accounts of your voting experience on November 4, 2008. A multiple of media sources reported that when you appeared to vote at a particular poll site (the YMCA at 125 West 14" Street), your name was not in the Poll List Book for the election district, in which you believed yourself to be a registered voter. It was further reported that you subsequently obtained an Order from the New York State Supreme Court granting your application to be allowed to vote on a voting machine at the poll site in question. During the last several days Ihave researched your voter registration history and I have discovered several facts that I must share with you. ‘My research revealed that on November 25, 1997, you registered to vote from [I — (that address currently being part of the 5th Election District of the 75th Assembly District). My research further revealed that the aforementioned registration remained in effect, until February 19, 2004, at which time you filed a new voter registration form changing your voting address to NNN (the 14th Election District of the 75th Assembly District). A copy of each of your two voter registration forms is being forwarded herewith for your reference. A review of the relevant Polll Site Books revealed that your name was properly listed in the Poll Site Book for the 14th Election District of the 75th Assembly District, that Poll Site being the Andrew Heskell Library, located at 40 West 20" Street. A copy of the relevant page of said book is being forwarded herewith for your reference.Mr. Timothy F. Robbins ‘November 10, 2008 Page 2 I would appear, based upon a review of your voter registration history, that your voting experience was less than positive because you simply went to the wrong poll site. ‘The change of voter address was not noticed earlier because you have not voted in any recent election, including the Presidential Primary in February 2008 and the Party Primary in September 2008. Thave taken the liberty of enclosing a blank voter registration form for your use should you desire to further amend your voter registration. Should you require any assistance or have any questions, please contact me directly. Respectiilly, ome Gregor G/Soumas ec: Mr. Timothy F. Robbins ‘New York, NY 10113 Mr. _ F. Robbins Commissioners of Elections Marcus Cederqvist, Executive Director George Gonzélez, Deputy Executive Director Pamela Perkins, Administrative Manager Beth Fossella, Coordinator, Voter Registration Steven H. Richman, General Counsel Troy Johnson, Chief Clerk ‘Timothy Gay, Deputy Chief ClerkNou-2S-2008 16:12 BOE i6aee3e2012 — P.02/05 New York City Board of Elections ere we [2] meet ee oe] ante ti Lag fate Nebo. loot! fy ri Tepe wnt 2 3h eee = ane EERE me nennemnese 2 J.) -. || == oo | | =~ ¢ Be orem : ee Sterne = I ommsoe ey 7 ow [25°F hr AT Tra * ipeleel TT a ened