High Quality
Open the downloaded document, and select print from the file menu (PDF reader required).
(
DAVIDM.LOUIE2162
(
(
AttorneyGeneralofHawaii
2012
,.li~1l21~
Pl'1I:54
HEIDIM.RIAN3473JILLT.NAGAMINE3513REBECCAE.QUINN8663DeputyAttorneysGeneral465SouthKingStreet,Room200Honolulu,Hawaii96813Telephone:(808)587-3050Facsimile:(808)587-3077.AttorneysforDepartmentofHealthStateofHawaii
H.CHIHG__
--CLERK
INTHECIRCUITCOURTOFTHEFIRSTCIRCUITSTATEOFHAWAI'IDUNCANSUNAHARA,)
)
Plaintiff,)
)
vs.)
)
DEPARTMENTOFHEALTH,STATE)OFHAWAIl;LORETTAFUDDY,IN)HEROFFICIALCAPACITYAS)DIRECTOROFTHEDEPARTMENT)OFHEALTH,STATEOFHAWAIl;)JOHNDOES1-10;JANEDOES1-10;)DOECORPORATIONS1-10;DOE)PARTNERSHIPS1-10;ANDDOE)GOVERNMENTALENTITIES1-10,)
)
Defendants.)
)
CNILNO.12-1-0006-01RAN(DECLARATORYJUDGMENT)MOTIONTODISMISSCOMPLAINT,FILEDONJANUARY3,2012;MEMORANDUMINSUPPORTOFMOTION;DECLARATIONOFJILLT.NAGAMINE;EXHIBIT"A";NOTICEOFMOTION;CERTIFICATEOFSERVICEHEARINGDATE:
t'YJc(.f(....h
<!6..J
~o
L'1
TIME:
q;
,?O
a.rn.
JUDGE:Hon.RhondaA.Nishimura
MOTIONTODISMISSCOMPLAINT,FILEDONJANUARY3,2012
DepartmentofHealth,StateofHawaiiandLorettaFuddy,inherofficialcapacityasDirectoroftheDepartmentofHealth,StateofHawai'i("Defendants")byandthroughtheir
447079_!.DOC
('
attorneys,DavidM.Louie,AttorneyGeneral,andHeidiM.Rian,JillT.Nagamine,andRebeccaE.Quinn,DeputyAttorneysGeneral,herebymovethisCourtforanorderdismissingPlaintiffsComplaint,filedonJanuary3,2012("complaint").DefendantsrequestdismissalofPlaintiffscomplaintforPlaintiff'sfailuretostateaclaimuponwhichreliefcanbegranted.ThismotionisbroughtpursuanttoRule7oftheRulesoftheCircuitCourtsoftheState-ofHawaii,andRule12(b)(6)oftheHawaiiRulesofCivilProcedureanditisbasedonthememoranduminsupportofmotionandtherecordsandfilesherein.Dated:Honolulu,Hawaii,January24,2012.DAVIDM.LOUIEAttorneyGeneralStateofHawaiiJLT.NAGAMREBECCAE.QUINNDeputyAttorneysGeneralAttorneysforDefendants
447079_I.DOC
2
(
(
DAVIDM.LOUIE2162AttorneyGeneralofHawaiiHEIDIM.RIAN3473JILLT.NAGAMINE3513REBECCAE.QUINN8663DeputyAttorneysGeneral465SouthKingStreet,Room200Honolulu,Hawaii96813Telephone:(808)587-3050Facsimile:(808)587-3077AttorneysforDefendantsINTHECIRCUITCOURTOFTHEFIRSTCIRCUITSTATEOFHAWAI'IDUNCANSUNAHARA,)
)
Plaintiff,)
)
vs.)
)
DEPARTMENTOFHEALTH,STATE)OFHAWAII;LORETTAFUDDY,IN)HEROFFICIALCAPACITYAS)DIRECTOROFTHEDEPARTMENT)OFHEALTH,STATEOFHAWAII;)JOHNDOES1-10;JANEDOES1-10;)DOECORPORATIONS1-10;DOE)PARTNERSHlPS1-10;ANDDOE)GOVERNMENTALENTITIES1-10,)
)
Defendants.)
------------------------)
CIVILNO.12-1-0006-01RAN(DECLARATORYJUDGMENT)MEMORANDUMINSUPPORTOFMOTIONTODISMISS
MEMORANDUMINSUPPORTOFMOTIONTODISMISS
I.
INTRODUCTION
OnJanuary3,2012,PlaintifffiledhisComplaint("complaint")againsttheDepartmentofHealth,StateofHawaii("department")andLorettaFuddy,inherofficialcapacityasDirectorof
447828_l.DOC
Add a Comment