Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
6Activity
P. 1
Lisy, Preliminary Remarks for the Comparative Study of Mysticism: Mysticism is, What Unio Mystica is, Communio Viatorum 54, 2012, pp. 88-107.

Lisy, Preliminary Remarks for the Comparative Study of Mysticism: Mysticism is, What Unio Mystica is, Communio Viatorum 54, 2012, pp. 88-107.

Ratings: (0)|Views: 294|Likes:
Published by Keren Mice
I found his article very interesting and useful in its new perspective. It is obvious that the author follows Huss' and Balagangadhara's approach and his final argument is based on Wittgenstein. We can, however, understand his article as a polemic with: The Origins of Jewish Mysticism written by Peter Schäfer, who is trying to criticise Boaz Huss for His essentialist approach. Interestingly, the author mentioned in the article that a part of the material was already discussed at the international conference Rethinking Religion in India III. I followed for some time links of its participants and it seems to me there is a research group using Balagangadhara's approach from different countries and from various fields in Humanities. If you follow their links it is possible to find more books and articles focusing on the comparative study of religion and most of them you can download for free. And all those studies share a common ground (framework). It is Balagangadhara's framework very well argued in his book: Heathen in His Blindness. Note, there are scholars who sharply disagree with him. The whole scientific discussion is very interesting and inspiring and leads to the new directions in the study of mysticism (religion). Compare with other studies in my collections.
I found his article very interesting and useful in its new perspective. It is obvious that the author follows Huss' and Balagangadhara's approach and his final argument is based on Wittgenstein. We can, however, understand his article as a polemic with: The Origins of Jewish Mysticism written by Peter Schäfer, who is trying to criticise Boaz Huss for His essentialist approach. Interestingly, the author mentioned in the article that a part of the material was already discussed at the international conference Rethinking Religion in India III. I followed for some time links of its participants and it seems to me there is a research group using Balagangadhara's approach from different countries and from various fields in Humanities. If you follow their links it is possible to find more books and articles focusing on the comparative study of religion and most of them you can download for free. And all those studies share a common ground (framework). It is Balagangadhara's framework very well argued in his book: Heathen in His Blindness. Note, there are scholars who sharply disagree with him. The whole scientific discussion is very interesting and inspiring and leads to the new directions in the study of mysticism (religion). Compare with other studies in my collections.

More info:

Published by: Keren Mice on Jan 31, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/27/2013

pdf

text

original

 
š;sá
É 
tš=Éš3
s
EÉ 
Ee
E
 
š
it
š
šá 
i,t 
i 
s
it
šĚ 
tš+ÉĚ
Ě+12.={
=
=
FT
'r=/>
EEÉ=
;EŤ
.?Ť
á 
É 
i:š+
iÉE+
i!IeE 
:ť?s5
i-JaÉ š="==::
É 
t
šE
ť
 
Ť
š
r
 
?
,Ť
:1
EžE
í;ša.
i 
Ě
É 
E
tÉi 
:š 
tĚ:
žEF
?:*"É:
š
Ě
šĚ
š
2w
i :E<ť
!Eg=
=ĚŤ!
Fn
o=o-b
št.aEÉ 
EĚ
;
=
qe!=
' E=-oFto
=
-
Í
'IP=Eg =
- 
s;q=
=79Qc(}E
?zze=$=
9;
É 
ŽE= 
E
2=EĚ=ž8*
=ž=č"
Ě
(Y
=t=E4c=e
b
=
a=EÍ
7;
Žž&sg=ĚÉ' 
E
=?aE=
u
=iH=E;č aě
=9eE
=E
gy=
=,
7
i $EšH=' 
É'*=
5=9
?
3ť'Ežš
=#:E:áEá
h
a.e
=
=a:^P
Ó :o9E*É:=
3čiěgÉ 
E
ťĚ
3
g
>
á=8UE!?E
EE_^^
.=
5
q
o
F
r
3
&
Ž
É
4
r
N(
rH>-
ď 
o-:
b?
o)
-u
LVJ+.!\
-?-.=<Fu--'čt*;-,^>
.u
.^OCou:o\(=-.:oÉ--Vš
_
I3=!d
,9i!
Eš
=
'!E?
?Ú
q
S
c
<9
!rL!-^
OOU:H!H7
L*
g=>o
!U
ajsšŇ\=
-sP
P
ErF
L9o{(1acÚ-{-
g
á9
š
9
-4ž2><
a=e(=>ooF>t=-r!eť== *vÚ&r-LU>g'=w=-
(
i=-A^-erLyc''v-v
._>':
=
F
=
f 6
Ed
-Ě>Ňav
-^:_
<
-o
c
qZ
b
3E*
i.:L=
 32 LÉ 
=
E
Ě
ě
;
ž
E
É 
g
É 
E
r
É 
i 
š
E
Ě
!
Ě
9
a
'Ž
t
E
p
E
E
:
 
Ž
3É 
;
=É;
=
E
E
-eÉ 
E
E
$
va=E=caa=
9
ž;
 
E3
E
:
,
É 
á
g
-9É'E
F
*
č 
s
9
j
9
E
H3=
Ú
Ě
-Ž
e
\qc.5!šŽ=:?3.
=
>sĚž
F
-1
ÉťE
ě
:
r
i 
Ši 
E
y
Ě
 
3 
Ě
 
5
sÉÉ 
:?
:3
izÉšÉ:É 
iZ 
g
 
+
E
;
žÉEE
:
7 
?
e
3
'"š
9
;
p
;
=:á
ÍÉĚĚEEť
Í
aEEEEÉ$
F
*
-ěE
==á=
ťY;z5.Ě
8
.EPĚ.=ž8
2
E
;9
;É i E=za3;
;=
iÝJÝ
UJ
.=
ě-=EFlč š
b=
El"
.=
lE
-
Ý
e
ar-
=Oq
t 
!"
A
'r-
F
(
Fa-
^
9
t
9=
=
a
L
ín=š
'Ýul \
;šE
ž=
Ň
1=
e
c
=š
=
E=
a-oD
'
 
a
l
b
b
.o
_
a-
a?
o
lF
n
\
,
-a
9tr
(n.a
-Úta.od*
(h:aLir.J2
-
--
!>
!
s-
'š
.2<
7>^
Ž+Ž
*c.š:oEo>=>=
d
'*u:aďž'ua
oÓÓo5U-too-:dE-
e^(e
VOV
NÝ
a
6EEE:EsÉ 
É*a
;
E
* 
ŽEžť
':bÉ;E=
E
!
Ě
g
aĚEÉ;ž;Ér}a;ž;
i;e
š
H
:
E
 
áEieÉ 
ÍEÉ:eEĚ
;!a
=
ž
Ť
;ěE;ž
E;EŤ
ÍaĚ
i 
ĚÉE5ág
iĚšEeE
.ť
pŤÉEÉ!
;cĚ=?2tE
ť
=
:
:EE}F=
E=š
ÉEH=É
ž
s
E
=
á
áÉĚyE
tE 
iĚEgá-
?
e
Ě;ťtE
E
EĚE
š
EEě
;
šá
=
;É*
E
ě
tš
ÉĚ
;
e
;YlrS
'E
L=L
'9žEHÝ9
:
* D.-ť
o]
.Á-o=o
3Ě==Ě" 
Ť
L=Cv
&a ,y Zc
.
.LŇ
=}
I:sE
IP
-o_
Ěs
-]
a
r
{S
=
F--
:ža+
c
iaťČ 
',Ž;
j
}Ú=aEE
'C
eĚá=
2
l12u9=a;(G
o
4='cŽ;=
c
?2Y;E=
2
9>lkTc
o
';=Éas'=.
=>9_=La<oO
92-J<q
iE=':š
EÚŤT
-7EU
?
+
Ú
ď
*
E
f
3
š*
?
oqÉ ;:ts=-s.=ěť
E9š
<:*_
.
-
=|9UšŇš
íč;E
t*
Ťšť
9ĚYg+?e:
e
E
a&
S
t=;
===-=-<C-Ž=,ž
-}=:-;F
=7.2ip=.=
.v
1
s
č 
_=
c,:
9r5
t-==.ccEq-=\=?->ZU
áŤg
 
á 
'ď
,r?E 
*B
s+
Fať
É g5
;
ě
É 
i 
e
 
Ť
E
iE
 
É 
t
 
i 
E
E
?e 
í;
É;
?
22
 
?E
3
!
:
É 
i 
g
É É 
*
?ť
É 
E-E
E
Ť
H
=
*
i;
ĚsE
g;
á
 
ť
E
 
Ě
E
5
?
EÉá
Ě
Ě
Ě
'zÉ 
H
iŤ 
É 
Ě
;E
ť
:
*=
É 
í;
iE
É 
n
l 
*
Ě
 
;
;
ĚÉěE
E+;
rs
j 
g 
E
;
EĚ
I
Ě
ĚE
ÉáE
 
eĚ
š
Ě|*rž?3\ 
E 
vaÉiE
'Ž
1
ÉÉi 
E
ž
!
É!É iáE
I
$
É 
E
;
'H
Ěryu
E
t+
E
ÉE53*
c
o
 
O
C^
\
.
'
l>
o:
i\L
=
'{l
.s
É 
\
q
>
_%Ť
i34\E,
E
qO
?
E
EĚEE
:
I
í:š
ŽP=zEx6:;E_e-
:
šEi 9h+:E':9o=oCÚ
;-
ézJ=šEEBšE
;pěÉI
9ÉĚ
+
š
H
?ŤEEeEEš*
ép=
52I
7Ť:E=H3ég==ušĚ;L
É-d
E
F
E:E:E[ĚEEz
;P$E
!
E
E,:šĚ:;
E*Ěá
=e5
E.šN
)
pE a;ěEŤ:á=u8E
=*H=
Ž* ŤQ5E=ĚE9
Ť=a=
Ec
=
E
EĚ=ěĚÉĚ
tĚaE
==06;qťě95"=9JŽC
=(Á}čda=E=z9=:áÉ:
<Ť^Y
i
=
i=
;E:*TrEE
*gÉiĚ
3Él
=
:E
9EšEgě;Z
E
s
-F:É 
E*1?Ež 
EFE
C
i
E
".;ěE
Ť
E
?P+
:
lĚ
(Yl
i =.=Ě í,a2Ž.9==l-;=;{l 
_
Es-
s=r_==ž_Ú=EEa=EĚťFšc
P
Ě
A
:
E
u
;EEEš
E
áEB
rži?=-U
=ť"?Ť
=
q
5 H= 
E:š
a
;
é
E
l 
9
9
E
9Es
g5
5
g
Ě
=
I
e
o
o
.oSA
.
v
'Ť
é="
>
cS
-u+gš
.
.
\u=!>-2ě!
>=
% š
'=s-u
šE
!
ť(
UUi"
:?
.e
tvP
.=
!D
vH
.I-Q
t
s
EšoŇtčU6
= 
É 
áŤs
š
E
É!
s
!
:
s
t
-F<+
-cš.šq:a<
O=>Šl.\
;
=
2
É'Ň
;
ť
š
5
s
:
eaE=E
==
r
;ě
ě
Ú
yŤ
=ŠTBÉ
+E
<
=.ššE
O8
0Ěv-Ega
i:
;
s
E
a
.
. 
:
.9=*EI
r
E
P?!ĚF
:gĚĚ
-^š>.L\š
o_=<š_q*Ňa
.=Ňá 
=3
HÉš1s
-^{-JUU{i=<=*cc.-r=_%'š-š
+
ÉšŤ=
s
 
š
š
a
.a
_r\-
t
=
šŽ
É 
š
 
s
q
i 
g
Ť
i 
1a':> šl
? !Ť
3s
sF
š
s
\
t
;g
E
E
E
á#
3
7
'E 
g
E
*
ě
iě
iÉE 
E
ižFŤť
gĚ
u
E
é
š
Ě
i 
É 
s
*
 
B
9
!
E
šE
 
EÉ 
!
E
á 
*
E
E
Ě
i
E
EE 
$
g
E
áE
a
Ě 
g
 
šÉ
iÉ i 
ĚÍ
ÉE
E
ĚEE 
g
E
;E 
g
tegt
gE
g*
Ě
iÉ 
ísĚe
ě
E
 
á
EÉ 
;g
E
a
q
3
E
E:
E6
u
E
$
E.g]É 
#ĚĚĚĚ
ÍEEE5
p
61

Activity (6)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
Keren Mice liked this
shirii liked this
shirii liked this
Ron Krumpos liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->