Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Source: Bloomberg
RISKS TO PHILIPPINE REAL ECONOMY
• Exports – 36% of GDP (US$57bn) vs 47% ave. Asia
– 17% direct to the US but indirect adds 18% for 35%
– Export slowdown is global
– Aggregate exposure and product mix are more important
• OFWs- 12% of GDP (US$16bn)
– “Investment content” is most at-risk
• Tourism- 3% of GDP (US$4.5bn)
– Rising personal bankruptcies / bad mortgages
– 92% from non-Asean
• BPOs- 3% of GDP (US$4.5bn)
– Lost volumes from some big-ticket principals especially in the
financial sector
– Higher vacancy as office space completed 501,000sqm in 2008
from 330,000 in 2007
• Impact on overall business and consumer confidence
RP most exposed to non-Asean traffic
Tourist arrivals in ASEAN
as of 14 March 2007
in thousand arrivals
2001-2006 % to Total
Country Intra- Extra- Intra- Extra-
Total ASEAN ASEAN ASEAN ASEAN
The Philippines 13,394.6 892.9 12,501.7 7% 93%
Myanmar 2,966.3 304.8 2,661.4 10% 90%
Viet Nam 17,364.3 2,211.1 15,153.2 13% 87%
Cambodia 6,269.3 975.8 5,293.5 16% 84%
Thailand 68,019.3 17,080.2 50,939.0 25% 75%
Singapore 48,203.6 17,376.6 30,827.0 36% 64%
Indonesia 27,428.4 11,998.9 15,429.5 44% 56%
Lao PDR 4,791.2 3,483.8 1,307.4 73% 27%
Malaysia 81,681.6 62,561.7 19,119.9 77% 23%
Brunei Darussalam 2,921.1 2,571.5 349.6 88% 12%
ASEAN 273,039.6 119,457.4 153,582.3 44% 56%
Dim and dimmer
Global economy
generally slowing down
even before meltdown
Source: IMF
Domestic Demand
Annual Growth in Real Terms Domestic economy
30 similarly slowing down
25
20
15
10
-5
-10
-15
-20
-25
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
7
POSITIVE SECULAR TRENDS:
SIDELINED OR OVERWRITTEN
• Demographic transition still well on its way
– Non-traditional labor markets (eg EU) for OFWs are rising
enabling +27% deployment in the first seven months
– Adjustment to resource depletion but too slow process to
achieve stabilization and a more sustainable equilibrium
being overwritten by BRICS
• Wage convergence still at play
– Impact is suspended or sidelined as it is being overwritten
by the expediencies of the global crisis
Source: ww.worldbank.http://www.worldbank.org/depweb/beyond/global/chapter8.html
IMPACTS ON POVERTY
• First direct impact: jobs losses and stagnant
incomes
• Welfare = Jobs x Incomes less Costs
– Jobs- 1% or 310,000 jobs losses with 50,000 OFW and
260,000 domestic
– Incomes- likely to be stagnant with weaker business
formation and expansion and 1.5m new entrants yearly
– Costs- WTI now at US$70/barrel from US$147 and Rice at
below US$600/MT from US$1,272
• Increase in Welfare = Cost relief > Jobs losses
and Stagnant Incomes but:
• Pockets of “concentrated severity”
INFLATION: Peaked in August
2008 LowerCPIcommodity
MoM Infprices 2009 CPI MoM Inf
58.00
55.00
52.00
40.00
37.00
34.00
31.00
28.00
25.00
60
USD Trn
40 Central Banks
$6trn
Middle East
20 $2trn
0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
30
60
20
30
) l(U
SD
rn G
o
0
1
T
ta
10
)s(U
SD oivu
lC
trea d
In
0 0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
-20
-40
-60
-9
9
-0
0
-0
1
-0
2
-0
3
-0
4
-0
5
-0
6
-0
7
-9
9
-0
0
-0
1
-0
2
-0
3
-0
4
-0
5
-0
6
-0
7
-0
8
M
M
a
a
p
e
p
e
p
e
p
e
p
e
p
e
p
e
p
e
p
e
r
r
Philippines Thailand Malaysia Indonesia
Source: CEIC, Haver, UBS
Table 1: Indicators of pressures on ASEAN currencies
Singapore Thailand Malaysia Indonesia Philippines
Change in exchange rate
(currency per US dollar) from 4.7% 3.5% 8.2% 17.0% 19.7%
31 Dec 2007 to 28 Oct 2008
Change in FX reserves +
forward reserves since
+ 14.9bn + 10.5bn + 13.1bn + 0.2bn* - 4.2bn
December (assuming forward
reserves unchanged in Sept)
Change in FX reserves +
forward reserves from peak - 34.8bn - 23.6bn - 32.4bn - 3.5bn* - 9.1bn
(assuming forward reserves (Apr-08 peak) (Mar-08 peak) (Apr-08 peak) (Jul-08 peak) (Feb-08 peak)
unchanged in Sept)
Decline in FX reserves as a %
-13.0% -17.8% -22.4% -5.7% -18.6%
of peak reserves
Current account balance,
15.4% 3.8% 13.6% 1.9% 2.2%
Q1 2008 (% of GDP)
Current account balance,
13.5% -1.4% 19.6% -1.1% 2.0%
Q2 2008 (% of GDP)
*Note: data on forward reserve position is unavailable
Source: UBS
Chart 3: US Asset Managers
25.0
20.0
15.0
D
U
S
10.0
n
rilo
s T
5.0
0.0
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008
60% 60%
50% 50%
40% 40%
30% 30%
Percntag
Percntag
20% 20%
10% 10%
0% 0%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Swiss Unit Trusts Sweden Mutual Funds UK Unit & Investment Trusts
Canada Mutual Funds Japan Investment Trusts US Mutual Funds
Euro Money & Financial Funds
SignsCAPITAL
of economic involution-
& FINANCIAL ACCOUNT 144 Regime
1,197 of 731.3
less exports,
less imports
back Capital
toCredit:
our cave
Account
Receipts
(6)
57
30
57
600.0
0.0
Debit: Disbursements 63 27 (57.1)
Financial Account
and capital repatriation 2865
Dire ct Inve s tm e nt -514 9307
Debit: Assets, Residents' Investments Abroad 3442 4799
Credit: Liabilities, Non-Residents' 2928 14106
Investments in the Phil.
Portfolio
Investments in theflows
Phil. remain
Financial De rivative s
most significant risk -288 -544
Debit: Assets, Residents' Investments Abroad -170 -924
Credit: Liabilities, Non-Residents' -458 -1468
Investments in the Phil.
Healthy
Reserves
for now
Source: BSP
GIR to GDP Ratio
(since 1997 devaluation)
Year GIR GDP P/$ Rate GDP GIR/GDP
(US $m ) (current, Pm ) (end of period) (US $m )
25.0
20.0
15.0
10.0
Entry of virus?:
Pesos created by new forex
inflows must now be
5.0
proportionally contained
with forex outflows!
-
Jan-05
Mar-05
May-05
Jul-05
Sep-05
Nov-05
Jan-06
Mar-06
May-06
Jul-06
Sep-06
Nov-06
Jan-07
Mar-07
May-07
Jul-07
Sep-07
Nov-07
Jan-08
Mar-08
May-08
Source: BSP
NG Foreign Bonds
Change
1995 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 1995-2008
TOTAL 1,158,622 2,166,710 2,384,917 2,815,468 3,355,108 3,811,954 3,888,231 3,851,506 3,712,487 3,966,069 2,807,447
Domestic Debt 718,395 1,068,200 1,247,683 1,471,202 1,703,781 2,001,220 2,164,293 2,154,078 2,201,167 2,338,569 1,620,174
NG Direct 678,007 1,049,083 1,233,825 1,462,950 1,701,484 Foreign bonds-
1,998,926 2,161,999 73%2,198,873
2,151,784 of 2,336,275 1,658,268
Assumed 40,388 19,117 13,858 8,252 incremental 2,297 2,294 external2,294 2,294financing2,294 2,294 -38,094
for public sector
Foreign Debt 440,227 1,098,510 1,137,234 1,344,266 1,651,327 1,810,734 1,723,938 1,697,428 1,511,320 1,627,500 1,187,273
NG Direct 342,751 647,468 626,958 705,414 815,942 841,096 703,590 674,454 613,595 679,531 336,780
NG Foreign Bonds 76,144 437,570 498,645 629,037 827,400 963,846 1,017,082 1,021,916 897,653 947,906 871,762
Assumed 21,332 13,472 11,631 9,815 7,985 5,792 3,266 1,058 72 63 -21,269
Bonds/Foreign Debt 17.3% 39.8% 43.8% 46.8% 50.1% 53.2% 59.0% 60.2% 59.4% 58.2% 73.4%
Bonds/Debt 1.8% 20.2% 20.9% 22.3% 24.7% 25.3% 26.2% 26.5% 24.2% 23.9% 31.1%
Source: Bureau of Treasury
29
NG Debt Service 1999-2008
(in Pm)
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008*
TOTAL DEBT SERVICE 205,396 227,843 274,439 357,959 469,990 601,672 678,951 854,374 614,069 610,300
Interest Payments 106,290 140,894 174,834 185,861 226,408 260,901 299,807 310,108 267,800 299,500
Domestic 74,980 93,575 112,592 119,985 147,565 169,997 190,352 197,263 157,220
Foreign 31,310 47,319 62,242 65,876 78,843 90,904 109,455 112,845 110,580
Principal Payments 99,106 86,949 99,605 172,098 243,582 340,771 379,144 544,266 346,269 310,800
Domestic 61,552 45,429 54,038 80,944 147,322 222,405 253,492 380,939 284,017
Foreign 37,554 41,520 45,567 91,154 96,260 118,366 125,652 163,327 62,252
As % of GDP 6.90% 6.79% 7.56% 9.03% 10.89% 12.35% 12.47% 14.16% 9.24%
* Preliminary estimates
32
NG Contingent Debt 1990-2008
Domestic Foreign TOTAL Total
YEAR Debt (Pm) Debt (Pm) (Pm) to GDP Ratio
Source: BSP
Loans to Deposit Ratio of Philippine Banking System
100.0%
95.0%
90.0%
80.0%
75.0%
70.0%
65.0%
60.0%
Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De Ma Je Se De
Source: BSP
Loans versus Deposits
Loans now outpacing deposits
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
(10.0)
(20.0)
(30.0)
(40.0)
Source: BSP
PHILIPPINE POLICY RESPONSES
• Largely bracing for a US slowdown, not a global
economic downturn cum financial meltdown
• P75bn economic stimulus package approved by
PGMA in Jan 2008, incremental spending for:
– Social welfare for the poor
– Food production
– Tax relief for the middle class
– 1% NG deficit to GDP vs balanced budget
• With escalating deterioration, government must
proportionally step up national effort
STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK
1. Real economy first.
2. Preemptive than reactive
3. If to assist financial economy,
bias for the depositor, not the
banker
PHILIPPINE STIMULUS PACKAGE 1
1. Rice self-sufficiency policy: DA budget
augmented by P11bn in 2008
2. Cheap food strategy: NFA losses ballooned
to P32bn from P8bn
3. Tax relief to middle class: minimum wage tax
would increase take home pay by P36bn
annually
4. Conditional cash transfer: budget increased
form P298m to P5bn in 2008 and elevated as
main tool for poverty reduction.
5. Katas ng VAT: various cash grants
amounting to P7.5bn
STEPPING UP
• Settle for modest economic growth from 6-8% to
3-4%
– Needs less capital
– Establish credibility
– Reduce revenue program to more reasonable targets
• Prioritize the real economy:
– Retain spending aggregates at P1.4trn
– Keep NG deficit at 1.5% of GDP
• Deficit-driven interest spikes could just be offset by adverse
impact on private capital outlays
– redirect discretionary budget to human capital
formation
• From growth inducing infra to poverty-relieving social
services
STEPPING UP
• Recasting 2009 budget immediately doable
response of the Philippines to the escalation
in global crisis:
– reduce revenue targets by P53bn
– redirect discretionary budget to human capital
formation
• From growth-inducing infrastructure (capital outlay) to
poverty-relieving social programs (MOOE for social
welfare)
• From expansion of productive capacity (new
construction) to productivity enhancing measures
[rehab/maintenance]
• More human capital formation (health and education)
than physical capital formation.
PHILIPPINE STIMULUS PACKAGE 2
1. CCT- Increase from P5bn to P15bn
2. Scholarship – Increase from P3bn to
P15bn
3. Food production –
1. aggressive palay procurement by NFA- 10% of
harvest, off-budget at P17bn,
2. retain P18.25/kg and do away with the access
cards
3. JPEPA agri measures at P2bn
4. Universal Philhealth – Increase by P5bn to
P17bn
CRITICAL MEASURES
1. Secure access to external financial resources
1. $84bn per ASEM at Beijing
2. US, EU, Japan to contribute to IMF
3. US, EU, Japan to create trust fund with WB or ADB which may be
accessed by developing economies
4. Another Obuchi initiative led by Japan
5. Maximize multilateral funding for ADB/WB- reflow of net repayments via
new program/project loans eg WB interest to lend $400m for CCT
6. Fortify JBIC pipeline
7. Redevelop bilateral funding outside of JBIC
2. Strengthen financial sector
1. Increase maximum deposit insurance coverage four-fold from P250T
to P1M
2. Inject new equity into PDIC (P10bn) with additional P30bn callable
from NG
3. Inspection power and bridge bank authority for PDIC
4. Inject new equity into BSP (P40bn) via MYOA to contain impact on NG
deficit
5. Unified / integrated financial supervision
– Financial Services Authority
STEPPING UP
• Settle for modest economic growth from 6-8% to
3-4%
– Needs less capital
– Establish credibility
• Prioritize the real economy:
– Retain spending aggregates at P1.4trn but adjust
revenue targets downward by P53bn
– Keep NG deficit at 1.5% of GDP
• Deficit-driven interest spikes could just be offset by adverse
impact on private capital outlays
– redirect discretionary budget to human capital
formation
• From growth inducing infra to poverty-relieving social
services
SCHOLARSHIP
• Newest priority
• Currently at P1bn at CHED and P2bn at TESDA
• Increase by P12bn to P15bn
– CHED to P11bn
– TESDA to P4bn
• 51% of unemployed between 15-24! Keep them in
school
– Expensive to create long term jobs PEZA/BOI at P2.5m/job
– Capital getting scarce
– Business prospects are not good, capital could be wasted
• College and techvoc training are public goods, i.e.
socially desirable economic activity, and should be
carriers of public subsidy
– If they get jobs, it is a bonus
JOBS: July BLES + 1.3 million
INDICATOR JUL 2005 JUL 2006 JUL 2007 JUL 2008 p
Household Population 15 y.o. and Over (000) 54,583 55,475 56,857 58,119
Labor Force (000) 35,237 35,837 36,161 37,371
Employed (000) 32,522 32,926 33,318 34,597
Less than 40 Hours (part-time) (000) 11,887 11,722 11,062+ 1.2 million
11,694
40 hours and Over (full time) (000) 20,240 20,809 22,023 22,557
Fulltime as % of Total Employed 62.2% 63.2% 66.1% 65.2%
Did not work during the Past Week (000) 394 428 233 346
Mean Weekly Hours Worked Increase in population
41.3 (1541.9
y.o. & over)
42.6 42.5
Underemployed (000) is equal to6,660
labor force increase, 7,327
7,718 7,275
therefore no increase in college enrollment
Unemployed (000) 2,715 2,918 2,824 2,750
Labor Force Partcipation Rate (%) 64.6 64.6 63.6 64.3
Employment Rate (%) 92.3 91.9 92.2 92.6
Underemployment Rate (as % of Employed) 20.5 23.4 22.0 21.0
Unemployment Rate (%) 7.7 8.1 7.8 7.4
Note:
Details may not add-up to totals due to rounding.
p -- Preliminary
Source : NSO and Labor Force Survey
Unemployment by Age Group:
(as of October 2007)
6% 3%1% 15-24
10%
25-34
35-44
51% 45-54
29% 55-64
65 and over
Total Unemployed: 2,248,000
CHEAP AND ABUNDANT FOOD
• DA budget already robust at P45bn plus
P32bn losses at NFA
• Additional P2bn for JPEPA measures to
optimize market openings
• Aggressive palay procurement- 10% of
output at P17/kg needs P17bn increase in
COB ceiling
CHEAP AND ABUNDANT FOOD
• P32bn annual loss for NFA versus its normal annual loss
of P8bn or an incremental loss of P24bn arising from the
policy.
– P8.5bn goes to farmers
– P14.5bn goes to consumers.
• Initially, if added to the additional DA budget of P20bn
(subsidy to producers), of which P10bn is for FIELDS,
food production would the biggest intervention of the
government in response to the global economic crisis at
P44bn.
• Differentially, this would mean an economic stimulus of
P28.5bn to the rural and agricultural sector.
UNIVERSAL PHILHEALTH
• 2009 budget should be landmark for
making Philhealth universal
• Additional P5bn to make it universal
coverage
RENEWABLES DEVELOPMENT: P5bn