Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Pro View Hong Kong Decision

Pro View Hong Kong Decision

Ratings: (0)|Views: 13,565|Likes:
Published by meghank_5

More info:

Published by: meghank_5 on Feb 17, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/04/2014

pdf

text

original

 
A
HCA739/2010
A
B
IN
THEHIGHCOURTOFTHEHONGKONGSPECIALADMINISTRATIVEREGIONCOURTOFFmSTINSTANCE
ACTIONNO.739OF2010
B
c
c
D
D
E
BETWEEN
E
F
APPLEINC.1
st
Plaintiff
F
G
IPAPPLICATIONDEVELOPMENTLllv1ITED2
nd
Plaintiff
G
H
and
H
II
J
PROVIEWINTERNATIONALHOLDINGSLIl\I1ITED1
st
Defendant
('*Ja
00
~~J!lJN~~~
0
§j)
J
K
PROVIEWELECTRONICSCO.LTD2
nd
Defendant
(Plfrt
J=g
-T"
IN{7}~~~0
§'j)
K
L
L
M
PROVIEWTECHNOLOGY(SHENZHEN)CO.,LTD3
rd
Defendant
(Pl%tf4:fiC~#JI):ff~~0§'j)
M
N
YANGLONG-SAN,ROWELL
Cm~W)
4th
DefendantYOKETECHNOLOGY(SHENZHEN)CO.LTD5
th
Defendant
(p1tTa;JIt
:g~~~
Cl*#J!)~~~0
§'j)
N
oo
p
p
Q
Before:HonPoon
J
inChambersDateofHearing:28June2011DateofDecision:28June2011DateofReasonsforDecision:14July2011
Q
R
R
s
s
TT
u
u
vv
 
-2-
A
A
B
REASONSFORDECISION
B
c
c
D
1.Thisisanapplicationforinterlocutoryinjunctions,whichIallowedon28June2011.Thesearethereasonsformydecision.
D
EE
2.
Thebackgroundleadingtotheseproceedingsmaybe
F
summarizedasfollows.
F
GG
A.BACKGROUND
HH
A.I.Theparties
II
3.Apple,aUScompanyestablishedinJanuary1977,isaworld
J
renownedleaderinthebusinessofdesigning,manufacturingandmarketingofawidevarietyofinnovativeproductsincludingcomputers,iPodmediaplayers,iPhonesandiPads.IPApplication,anEnglishcompanyincorporatedinAugust2009,isaspecialpurposecompanysetupandusedbyAppletoacquiretrademarksrelatedtothename"iPad".Theyaretheplaintiffsintheseproceedings.
J
K
K
L
L
M
MNN
4.
ThedefendantscomefromtheProviewGroup.TheProview
oo
Q
Groupisaproducerofdisplaydevices.ItsmajorproductsincludeLCDmonitors,CRTmonitorsandflat-paneldigitalproducts.
It
hasoperationsandofficesaroundtheworld,includingTaiwan,MainlandChina(ShenzhenandWuhan),HongKongandEurope.ItsholdingcompanyisProviewHoldings,whichwasincorporatedinBermudaandislistedontheHongKongStockExchange.
p
Q
R
R
ss
T
T
u
u
v
v
 
3
A
A
5.
YangLongSan,Rowell("Yang"),aTaiwanese,isthefounder
B-
B
c
oftheProviewGroup.HewasatallmaterialtimesthechairmanandchiefexecutiveofficerofProviewHoldingsuntilhewasadjudicated
c
bankrupton2August2010.OthercompaniesoftheProviewGroupthat
DD
featureintheseproceedingsareProviewElectronics,aTaiwancompany,
E
ProviewShenzhenandYokeTechnology,bothbeingShenzhencompanies.YangwasatallmaterialtimestheresponsiblepersonanddirectorofProviewElectronics.Hewasalsothelegalrepresentative,generalmanagerandchairmanofbothProviewShenzhenandYokeTechnologyandremainssodespitehisbankruptcy.
E
F
F
G
G
H
H
I
A.2.Thedisputes
I
J
6.InJanuary20I0,Appleannounceditsnewtabletcomputer
J
branded"iPad".ItwasfirstlaunchedontheUSmarketon3April2010
KK
andtheninotherplacesaroundtheworldonemonthlater.Ithassince
L
becomemuchsoughtafterworldwide.AsatJune2010,over1millionunitshadalreadybeensoldintheUSmarketalone.Itssuccessis
L
MM
phenomenal.
N
N
7.InpreparationforthelaunchofiPads,Applecaused
oo
Q
investigationstobeconductedthroughouttheworldtoidentifyregisteredtrademarksassociatedwiththename"iPad"withaviewtoacquiringthem.AsMrPaulSchmidtofMessrsBaker
&
Mackenzie("B&M'),solicitorsforAppleandIPApplicationexplainedinhissecondaffidavit:
p
Q
R
R
s
"17....Apple>sproductsarehighlysoughtafterbyconsumersthroughouttheworldandthelaunchofeverynewproductbyAppleiseagerlyawaitedandthesubjectofmuchmediacoverage.Accordingly,intheleaduptothelaunchofanewproduct,Applefacesthedualchallengesofmaintainingtheconfidentialityoftheproduct(includingitsfeaturesand
s
T
T
u
u
v
v

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
txburke liked this
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->