ISSN 1348-9-089

Seikeiken Research Paper Series

2002~8 ~

The Institute of Politics and Economy

2002~8

jj

..
'"

Jliffi*~D . !I!'<~~ifjSl-t~::$'-OOfg~~c~ V'C V~*'~? A r=lmrtfg;g" tr:~;t;SJ 7Jl2002iF 6 Jl 9 S, !f.i&EE*~OO!m~~~~=~m~-r:OOn~n~ Lt.:o ~t;ft~ (!fLfi] S3*~~'d:&\ t~~;9r1iJfJeml;!!!.) ::1-7'1 *-7' . ~ ~~ - C: Vm#1~- (1X.iJit*~. nm -Ei"*~~ j:~~), 'gi\'ij!t#t (Ji;~ ti:l'*~
$t*) rjlj]E:G')~i1i.a:§trt,
G')~~~,

~*lM~7J~:f.J;:ft:bn~tLt.:o

;:(l)V~*,V?A

- ) (7)Jfif: -r: C 3? ~ L tz;

±~~(Mffi$A~~~m1iJf~ffl,~ffi*~~'~~~~~~7'

OO~(7)~~
@~O)M9;!

Ii e. 1:01;:· . • • . . . • .'. . • .". • . • . . . . • .". . • • . 6 77 f,1'.:=..7- 7'~~$~ ~~ 8"

...........••......... ..•.....•.•.•.••..•••.
10

Cffl.tE JitJ:l:f~- (~~*~.U'fiiJ#**~~®:t:t) I

lfLz:.:tz;-M15t; OIiJj~*~M' ij!l~~#-e ~7 -MH~)

....-,
, ••••

1
5

;Jj:MfIJ;~ir~~~

~ffi~.~
(1k~J;t~)

~A C: ~J:.i';;!iB±~

11

*OOrd:J~4ftblff)rtfra •......•.•

, . , .•

, •.•.

'13 ·16 18

~Jt11n~cIi:;*~~(1),~,m
••••.••••...••........•.• .....•.•.

~,*I;: t:v '1"" Q OO~iit "!AA$-(l)ftt.l)--C:(1)OO~rt:

OO~~

'8~~~m(5GII}HiJ*$:~~);
...••..•....•...••

·22
22

• . . . . . . • • . . .•.•.•..•
", •••••••••••

, • 23
• 24 ···········26 32

~~C: OO(ll!},$ ••••••••••••

1963if.12Ji 7 B O)TE8~J~

(JjjHI¥l~)

IN,jUflJ.1&'¥IJm.
(1ItiER;:~)

, . . • . . . • . . • .'. • . . . . • . .• . 30 .
••.••....• " •••••. ·38

....,....................

Mftf;t .. "

".S*Q')*~nf~.(l)..-1tffl-"4
{tfMJ"" ..•.•
"

".. " ..•

.• , ....

(-Wilf~!1i'SL*$~f./1f~~) ···38 • • • • • • • • • • • • • 40

rSSN 1348-90&9

Seikeiken Research Paper Series

W8iP~.~~~~
~21Q)
2003~ 7 J3
Iij"fB~A
i$( frs ~ lit Wf ;t !'DR*~~ . ~~J'Q:~t / ~-

The Institute of Politics and Economy

w rp g;g a~ ~ ::t .-6>

m2[QJ
2003£p.7 Jj

lttlillitAifk

JR**~.Ql'~~~lN--t/5'-

7h ~ lJHi.If ?t

:.(!)¥tl'E-iIHi, 2003i¥ 4 ~ 26a, rIJfi~' 7" -( 77:' ~~ht~2~~(!)Y/~'l?A rWm~~~~xQJ

0)

3 ~ 3 O)~m*'1:Ml

'1:To

O)~~~*~~~b

~~O)~/*~?A~,
t/:7~o)
rrm~l~lFllC~J

A.~~l~~*~~~Q.**~~'.~.~
~1.-\?:'~"(:',

£lllfV--3~~!V

Otoj{@p
1;:0

.:ttl"J!~~*~f,lj*)

tJ~ t;, . r**~D!II¥-tl"B;;~

~c~JJEJVJO)~Uii,\\(J

t.J~G rlAAm'f~m~ I~Uli@]ji1RJ 0);f3~i-1*l-e:, :ff~t~W!liil~IT 5 :. ~ n~"t:'-e:"1 ~f,:o ~ r:l O)~'1df~ t ~ Ie, :to=-..AJ;::.'¥9.*~~1r* ~ ~-c,,\t;:t~?5, -t:-h~tpli)lem~ ~t;:O)i.J~:' O)¥&

vvr , ~tdIiiS.t?sg ~Iv (~j~*~4i1fU)

'iStf-eTo
~&f0)~

.mJR*~~. 1ji~m.:tf:tstt~7'~O)IMIM~1iG;tvC
;tHe--B:;),
(~jN~I£;) ,e01.- \~~tF~

1 §JI3O)~/iJ{V:?A

rWm~~=a:-~:tQJ1:1:, 2002&:P6Y.1 S, 9
r~.O)~~C:~:(£J

r:m7t1:~~~~IEI~*J (-g-IISf~mI£;L rl3*O)*Wm~~O)M.J

t ~'t4-§lO)m
2 @] § O)¥a~~O),::·mm~:}.3mH,\v\t;:

(m

~t,:o -to)r.c.~t4-1ID~ IPleel:. 3 it%:ct-e§E

V~

ff~n-c:}.3 tl ~To
m 1 @]O)~~~

To

J~~:m~mtt;g-.Ef:;45 ~~ill!!WJO)~IJ¥~
-·- . 9l.;t"'(~t.:.t(7)l:4'&C1)n~Mli.

£!fO-3

L (Jt(Jii:~~mtt*it~~J.lH!l5!fijJO·

...

, •••.

,' 5

"

t'

".'

~. , 1

Seikeiken Research

Paper Serie:

"1:!·~7,~
I - __ ~ ~

2005

MI~jU~.A. i&;aft~iJf~PJf
136..,0073 ~J;'~lffiir g~tftP I-j-·~ ~ TEL 03-56 3-3325 FAX 03-5683-3326
E-mail: office@seikeiken.or.jp Web: http://www.seikeiken.or.jp/

.. ~

~BrtJ~g~~x~
~3[Q]
20051f. 3

Jl

JltEHm}.. 1&~. ff: b't iiJF Jt Wi' *H.::k:i:~ . i~,lWa~'{:l4t:/5'-

·.. ~,___

.ffi*.~~.~.~~.~m~~ •)~~~-~~*-~-~l"Mffi •
~gj

·**g~·.~.fit~~-~ :.It;;t -5 J ~ llf:;}11 lIF"ltfi~""(' 2004 (.JROO~**~~),

(~~*$~~~~,-

••
~

3@~~~~*~~A r.$~~~ 12 Jj t: f*'l1ll! v\ t: V~ t. t: , ~tff~ (.!f!.

{~-

lltilfjH~t4t~~-:~H,,~), m# 1=l*~l\\ll$-~tf:~#t~~-1-t;;~~n ~ 3.ff:~mi'lil: .=~t.1i-

(j£**.

~.,~.~.~~.ffiffbh*l,ko~~~~*~~AV~.~~.~(M
ffi~A~~&_m~ffi,
L tc
0

.JR*~~·.~RMt~~-)

~.tf:~*~~*

!m~~v\a:0
7:/7

.!J!z:..:kM171; CJli:-**g'§:~· ij(tj,lJf#t/'7-tilJiD

__

3
5

f;::t3 It -5 .,*!&!r.V~~;fij; f3

*11! I: J: 611!~.t&~
••

~07j9~~

*~.**~~
'=iRm
mj:j:f~-

IlfJ IEW":!IJ (J![*OO~*!¥=~~)

..,

(J!l!m*. ~.w.W;jSj-t/':7-TAAr.ll)

13

1"1 :Y1.::.t:"t6~~v·~~

(~~*$:~*~. E*(1)~4'>}!t{£j(;jSj-t/':7-#OO{-I;;*)
~•••••••••••••••••• ~ ••••••••••••• u . .................. n ao ~ ~ .

31

32
35 38

ill

"7;1-!1"j)

(1)~ItrJ!~

(:it~lNI~)
(*-~?/») ::1-7.-(*-:7-

. 42

~t::j:r~

49

·rSSN 1348-908Y

Seikelken Research

Paper Series
No.1l

r-----~~

Seikeiken Research Paper Series

fi,rP~.~~;t.@
~41Q)
2006ip7A

JttEH$A

~ ~ ~ m Wf Jt ~Dj(*~g . lAAm.~~-e "/1-

\,

The Institute of Politics .and Economy

Seikelken RC~llJ[m::h Prj~r ;Wl<a:S

No, J J

~fP~lIe~;;t.Q
~4@
2JJ06fjS. 7 }!

atF1H'k}... if", itcl ~ "->;: til' 1l ~Ii JtO?::k!B'I' t:i<nrH::,.· 9 .-

.'

.:',.,,'

:::.O)fIH5'-:IH±, 2005ipI2JHO~, @~nkm4~~t7)V~*~?Ar~m~.~~~~J t7)~To

J.l ~,

ttJ4i:fK' 7-177:::'

t7)~~*""C:'OO O)~~~~~~~t
oj ~ oj

~t ~:7 -""C:'I"±, 20021¥0)[J1U.tW.*, 2002ip 8 fL 2003$. 7 fL 2005&f,3 3 @J1;::bt.::-?-C-Y/,*~? A~IMHtn L.. (~ ~ L.t.::;6~, A,@JfJ:-t-O)~fH " @J~ \;:fj; I) ~ To t~~~~ny*, =t7)-Y/,*~?A~H.L..~~~*""C:'~,t~~-~ t6tt -cr- ~ -o t.::jJl"±37J3000)d;:fll), m:(£ (2006$. 6 A *) -Z:'1';l:37J8000~A ~ ft L.. .. r of L.. (t /':7 -O)~~.:cO)ft!!.t7)-~t7)%~O')t.::b6I;:, " m:(£.:t:-(J)~i!i!:~IU:: I) k:ftlv""C:'.i3 2007&f, 3 JJ 1;:I'jj:Ill~*'f~~ ft-?-C~~ 1v\;:;jO ~ jE,;tTQ I';l:T I), ""C:'To*~IvO)-Jjt7)::'~WJ, :::'i1J.:1J~.toifJ(v\v\t.::L.~To

1)*

~.).$:~n'~mtE(J)r,,~M&:Jt:tQ ililIl,%,~ (lz:lE*$~'if~~'

r!JZfn(J)x1~J ~~i'< ~f{;*)

•.•.

.nOK*~l't
-1,

t:

p V-v

• -riJ-tJ-=\"n,t:,6ofP

\~ 1!tYf-(J)

~fI.l::r ~:t -0-~~ti~ (lfl-~m*~~~lf~~' (M)~i~~i'RWf~mml*) - 13

*It-tr

~~1ifl-ey?,-(J)v\~

~l4cl1.\'l1t
!1J;M,-O)._

±]fI~s,.~ (JtiJit*~~

·1jI:J;~aIfJlSft;/?'~!iliJfn'l*) .• , 20 • •

v: (:
•. ~ •• .....:

;Jiifn~ .040tt:k~M .~~~JlSft:;/:i;

'. '. .'. • • • • .' • • : .. •

A7

~ 7)
• • • •

'21

'1f4~' p\J_

. .....

26'
3.2

*C~

~ttt""'"

.m

• -.. " ..

'.

-.~

'"

..

..

..

..

'.'

......

....... , -,-.. -

.,
....•..•.....•....•••

2 2
<I ···10 ···11 ·····12

.........•..........•.•.•.•.

···· .... ··• .. ·· .. [·1

.................

, .....•....................

16 ······17 .. ···· .. ··<25

...............................................
(.l)~'{=:.;~.

f!;0'f:· :bt:::..

L·i:'·/")U){';{j,:t

.,··,····
< ••••

...... , .. ··· .. ············,··········

, •••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ~ ••••••••••••••

~);s:f'.~i~.!:: f¥:;illrJi'
(5)

27

'i';.~:'fT"){U\:ftrt

·..································ ..········28
.•.... 33

:;c ;-;:;:b!!lj~j
(li~I)I"I,i(it:(!)tf,t'l':JUt (G~2)ri~0~fW5i'1' (71'ii~~~jJ]lIJi1. ~~Urf(]~!~CtmrG~LE-:.~f " t.~i!.'iIOj(:i(~~~(!)trJ~I:Hz;~:J':' (8)o1!:fr-u,e;~fJ.IJre1'i·(!)vl><;{_
(9)

, '

·········· .. ·······36 ········· .. ········-4-1 ·········· ~ ·········,13 57

65

,,~,

HJ)t!'

··.... ·.. ·.. ·.. ··········· ··.. ···· .. ··

··

······· .. ·.. ···

···· .. ···GG

j\'J:)f!:: J\":f.

~Mjj';

• if.!W(!)Jg

·.. ······

·.. ······ .. ··.. ··· .. ··.. ·711

IJt,l,;i'?J.J.Jl.i1.{'-</' I· .. "
7'';''

··

·
··.. ·

·
·.. · ·

·.. ·.. ·.. ·.. ········i8

····· .. ·.. ·...... ·.. ·80 ·····• .. ·• .. 82

'.I7'-{.{.-<;..I)

l- f1'1:!::'I'·;flI0){}6IiJ .. . .. ... ..

t;''/'i-(!)If;.!
@jr,

*11.71-

0 HlJ!i rf'.U;( .. ... .. ...

.. .. .. .

.. ... .. . .. .... ... .. . ..

8·'
86

:401}lI'(1)1L{;\lUtl.:oJv''(

t?C ;j''2:, J!.[!~U;:·:'2:~I~!J!ilill~~n~.'n

87

I'CF;j<~~:i2.._7d t:

.~[)i\33l).lJt~~~j1l!IZJOW;(t'Ifal'

.C'..::'f.J~fJ1!!G: • Tl11fli1kCm

..

_._- '-. _ -- ,

..... '.~=./ .1;' -. _-' , ',_.~.

......

--,'----~-

~
;}

MI!tI )!A i& ~~~iVf ~ p)ii-r jI JftJR:*:ggg · tl~.*41! ~?z .-'

1ftl~~~iVf~~
··.·r ';.'.

2oo8~2.FJ20B
,.-

....

'

••

' .•

f.

W;1$
1

'i }[.....=. i.J-4!!t~~Ij~~O)}(..._\yI) -:;7i~~~iJ\ ~A.~1'

:"p;jijii"

-!£tH~i!O)t=&)O)~!li C -fO)fE~ ~2$

3

~am. ~~-

;~;i~ti

16

7 Y7 . ;7.;;:~;$ifu~r::;f.) It ~mrn~~ifulEl(])1"l'px

c tp@)IDll~¥Rs

LlJ*II!EA

35 45

52
58

:n..ZA~~Dll

~ "'"'"'1_:- IFi! ~ JQI.../Q~:t::llJi'{W'f9tlll l'j~,

*Jjt*~g .• !1at~1!j'-·
ti4ft1l!WiJf~~

2009~3FJ108

tJ:1t;:.

0) ~

:nftiJ~~@~ nt.:O)iJ'-i-o)~lH \ c~~

aBH'it laiS1 2 ••
3

If }[,,=1J

~f(fj0)i*~
"I)

-f

7':J T:r:.

• -=E:-=E:-{ ~ 3

J!.~!!t~J.llmU~0)~j]:i~-;t-7}[,,!:: A ~~~~BO)~.m~

-iJ\ bJ7.t.:13*~O)~m

.~
~Jt~1.J!l 4

**_

13;<$;0)¥fOO)t.::&')O)tW:~[gJ (::as(t'@~~JHiJf~cJN~O)~~c r
24

~m~.
I) -

12

19t.~~1!!(::iiix 0-3

-!J ':J dO)

2-:JO)lli:::J J-. "":/

c !-= t>
44
50

A~/O)i*~.

7:/!-=~~-'~~~-

5 ~ •• ~~~.~~OO~.~·~.~&Ui-O)~O)$~.~~m ·'::4 Xt.::.!§~;£(:: -:)(.\ -c O)fJJ~(y.]1iJf~ ;~JIlI:

67

t-t.·.ifJt;~O)JaJ!

71

.,\ ~•• tlra .~ ..

.'
\

-.

83

.t

.~ O " ~;""::""
-~

. .

,",
,',

_.

~ .

..

.". '

'~'.

-I"

..

3A."~::7
7J'

+-.::~ a:.Il.L

:l:tt~~T
lJ!~:k$JJC

ii'
.0 \._ ~'"
L

--' 0

~ ~ ~
tJ1

Sit

* :a: * 00
<
~ ~ ~

tt
Ii

Ii ~; }~, iE ~ ix ~ ~ $: 1:: It' i![ ~ m; I;: ~ (J) :t ~ =r 5t; ill :a: ;:t -e ~ -5 - + L.. -e ;Ill ~ :1L 1:" Ii T );: r> tj ~ ~ f.t. -5 ~ ~ J: 00 <, ~ -J -t Jf Jj; ~ (J) IR :F t: -J I±I ~ fA t: i!.II! 00 :fL ~ (J) 00 ~ ~ a~ ~ lb ;fil (JJ) ;gr ~ I§l g 4i Ii ¥ ~ ~ ~

!:i1;

00 ~

-.

It' m

"*

•+
--'-

;ft z,

ill .If- .i <b

t:.

(J)

•
§

* *

f;t

Ie:
"?

1l:. ~ (J) 'li£ ~ ;I!J: -r; l.m 7a T T

.!f- ~ z, #

t~

zre "'"

*
~

lfi14

m.
~ ~ 1

:f-Il
-l: :,.-

**
J:
0f!)

i1ir --. 13

f,j1J

?\::

31.>
l;'

'0

~~ L 00
'--

"" mi. 'J ttfI ~ (' 1t

iji!:

ili

mi
~

"'?

C'
1,' f!)

F:l

IF- !I'll

-k
JJY.f

c!.-

7.t:

m
~

-j'/

7"

J~ !!W
~
'-

1.11

lJ.i.
-I:
;..-

~ :tl
? I

jG

~r
t:
A

(J)
.".

Pi]

t
t

t:: -!F

~;:

9 1 l-

Iv "C ~

49

20

12

11B.f1l20~'.(J 945) 3 fJ lOB, 1Q)j AO):'!{!:~~l1iJnt~bht.:!J~O)rzn\ G 60~. 1:~JJb t.:A/.( O)jt~#~O)}g(..n!;: ~ Gnt.:ftJ,iMJiIlt"'\'>.ttl!i~,U~tA -i:"O)iIlT O)Ak (:J:? -cfl!-c Ghr,)' Gh, 4-1:::-'C"O)1tl:j}~:a:;ilh T~~*"9.
250 50Ilm

ff*.

~~WMt~~-~G~<~-~~*~~*L~.

c ? t.:illllJj",\,>ftJ,~JiIlf~

tljtl T < t.:. ~

~.o

~O)~,Ak~m

7.
8.

m1;'i·t3lllJ~~,,"" J:!n~rlilJ""""""."'"""

.', ,'26 ..."",, ..<29"

"

""

1IO;tk~~ ·1I.I:1J.l1!$1t:'--Y.-~I~
• ;t;:~7)itIl.t~:; q OJ-;:-;], 0) I ~!frliJtii"d_ T~IJ~ht" "

3.2"