Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Cipro - petition for CA Supe Ct Review

Cipro - petition for CA Supe Ct Review

Ratings: (0)|Views: 37 |Likes:
Published by bmyeung

More info:

Published by: bmyeung on Mar 01, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

03/12/2012

pdf

text

original

 
Inthe
&uprtmtatourt
ofthe
&tattnfCltalifnrnia
INRECIPROCASESI
&
II
CALIFORNIACOURTOFAPPEAL·FOURTHAPPELLATEDISTRICT·NO.D056361SUPERIORCOURTOFSANDIEGO,HON.RICHARDE.L.STRAUSSNOS.JCCP4154ANDJCCP4220
SERVICEONATTORNEYGENERALANDDISTRICTATTORNEYREQUIREDUNDERBUSINESSANDPROFESSIONSCODE
§
17209ANDCRC8.29
PETITIONFORREVIEW
DANDRACHLER,ESQ.
(prohacvice)
ZWERLING,SCHACHTER
&
ZWERLING,LLP1904ThirdAvenue,Suite1030Seattle,Washington98101(206)223-2053Telephone(206)343-9636FacsimileRALPHB.KALFAYAN,ESQ.(133464)KRAUSEKALFAYANBENINK
&
SLAVENS,LLP625Broadway,Suite635SanDiego,California92101(619)232-0331Telephone(619)232-4019Facsimile
AttorneysforPlaintiffs-Appellantsandallotherssimilarlysituated
JOSEPH
R.
SAVERI,ESQ.(130064)ERICB.FASTIFF,ESQ.(182260)BRENDANGLACKIN,ESQ.(199643)JORDANELIAS,ESQ.(228731)DEANM.HARVEY,ESQ.(250298)LIEFFCABRASERHEIMANN
&
BERNSTEIN,LLP275BatteryStreet,29thFloorSanFrancisco,California94111-3339(415)956-1000Telephone(415)956-1008Facsimile
'"COUNSEL
PRESS'
(800)
3-APPEAL
PRINTEDONRECYCLEDPAPER
@
 
TABLEOFCONTENTS
ISSUESPRESENTED1WHYREVIEWSHOULDBEGRANTED1BACKGROUND6LEGALARGlTMENT8A.TheCourtofAppealWronglyEliminatedtheAbilityofaReasonableCaliforniaJurytoFindtheCiproMarketExclusionPaymentUnlawful.10B.ThePreemptionRulingIncorrectlyandImprudentlyRestrictstheScopeofCaliforniaLaw19C.TheCourtofAppealMisappliedCaliforniaSupremeCourtPrecedentbyCondoningtheTrialCourt'sBlanketOverrulingofPetitioners'EvidentiaryObjections,andbyFailingtoResolvetheObjections24CONCLUSION26CERTIFICATEOFWORDCOUNT28OPINIONDECLARATIONOFSERVICE
-1-
 
TABLEOFAUTHORITIESPageCASES
AmericanWellWorksCo.
v.
Layne&BowlerCo.
(1916)241U.S.25721
ArkansasCarpentersHealthandWelfareFund
v.
BayerAG
(2dCir.2010)604F.3d989,19
BiljacAssociates
v.
FirstInterstateBank
(FirstDist.1990)218Cal.App.3d141025
Blank
v.
Kirwan
(1985)39Cal.3d31121
Blonder-TongueLabs.,Inc.
v.
Univ.ofIll.Found.
(1971)402U.S.31316
Blumenfeld
v.
ArnesonProds.,Inc.
(FirstDist.1971)172U.S.P.Q.7622
CaliforniaAss'nofPsychologyProvidersv.Rank
(1990)51Cal.3d119
Cianci
v.
Super.Ct.
(1985)40Cal.3d90326
Classen
v.
Weller
(FirstDist.1983)145Cal.App.3d2718
Clayworth
v.
Pfizer,Inc.
(2010)49Cal.4th7589
Corwin
v.
LosAngelesNewspaperServoBureau,Inc.
(1971)4Cal.3d84219
DairyFoodsInc.
V.
DairyMaidProds.Co-op.
(7thCir.1961)297F.2d80518,21
DowChem.CO.
V.
ExxonCorp.
(Fed.Cir.1998)139F.3d147021,23,24
EdwardKatzingerCo.
v.
ChicagoMetallicMfg.Co.
(1947)329U.S.39416
-11-

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->