Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recent developments
Botswana Implications of the collapse in commodity prices – Reuters/Jefferies Commodity Price Index
Since the Reuters/Jefferies commodity price index peaked 500
at the end of June 2008 at 462.72, it has dropped (by 42% 450
to 268.32 at the end of October) to levels last seen in 400
DRC
2005. Most notably, the international oil price has dropped 350
by almost US$100 per barrel to date, since it peaked at
300
US$147 earlier this year. This has significant implications
Ghana 250
for oil-driven economies like those of Angola and Nigeria
that depend heavily on oil revenues to build up their 200
international reserves, finance their fiscal spending, and 150
Kenya invest in their oft-neglected non-oil sectors. Given the 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
continent‟s dependence on commodities, the effects of
lower commodity prices have been swift and pervasive. Other than oil, metals prices are also on a downward
slide. The price of copper, which is often used as a bellwether for the health of the global economy, has more
Malawi
than halved since it peaked at US$8 900 per tonne in July. Zambia, and to a lesser extent the Democratic
Republic of Congo, has been significantly affected by the lower price. For the first time in ten quarters, Zambia‟s
trade balance went into negative territory in the third quarter of 2008 because of the poor copper price. As such,
Mauritius Zambia‟s current account deficit is expected to deteriorate, its international reserves are on a downward path,
fiscal revenue is being squeezed, and mining-related foreign direct investment is likely to slow. The prices of
agricultural raw materials, and food and beverage commodities have not been left unscathed: their price indices
decreased by 25% and 18% respectively between July and October 2008. For major agricultural raw material
Mozambique
producers, such as the West African countries that depend on cotton for foreign exchange earnings, this is
significant. Similarly, exporters of beverage commodities, including cocoa in Ghana, tea in Kenya and coffee in
Uganda, have also had their export earnings shaved as a result of the fall in price of their main export
Namibia commodities. On the upside, lower food prices are favourable for major food-importing countries and the cut in the
fuel price will significantly lower the region‟s transaction costs, particularly those of landlocked countries.
Nevertheless, these gains are modest relative to the massive drop in earnings that several countries in the region
Nigeria have experienced. The year 2009 will be one of weaker external sectors, contracting fiscal spaces, and a
slowdown in the remarkable growth momentum that was experienced earlier this decade.
DRC – Despite all the peace accords signed (morbid 1999 Lusaka agreement, Pretoria accord in 2002, and 2008
Tanzania peace deal), peace and stability in the DRC continue to be overshadowed by violence in the North and South Kivu
areas. As discussed in our January 2008 report (Blueprint: Finally, a peace deal but major challenges ahead), the
current administration‟s ability to face and deal with the ghost of its past is instrumental in the overall stability in the
country. Two major issues all the peace agreements have not been able to address are: first, the future of the
Uganda Banyamulenge (Congolese ethnic Tutsis), who, apart from tracing their origins to Rwanda, have had domicile in the
DRC since before independence, and, second, the presence of the rebel forces, which are remnants of army forces
from neighbouring states. The current government‟s failure to address the issue of the decentralisation of the
Zambia political system has aggravated the problem. There is still a dire need to offer provincial administrations more
responsibility for local decision making. Overall, even the presence of a 17 000 strong UN peacekeeping force will
not be enough to oversee any DRC peace agreement that does not include the neighbouring states (Rwanda,
Burundi, Uganda and Angola).
Botswana
Inflation continues to climb, but may have peaked. Policy rate left unchanged at 15.5% in October. The Bank
Botswana‟s consumer price index averaged 7.1% in 2007. This of Botswana‟s (BoB) Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) kept
year inflation has continued its upward trend, from single digits the bank rate, the policy rate, unchanged at its meeting on 21
to 15.1% y/y in August. In September inflation eased to 14% y/y. October. The MPC last raised the bank rate by 50 bps to
Overall inflation continues to breach the central bank‟s upper 15.5% in June. The committee noted that inflation is likely to
limit of the medium-term target of 3-6%. Food and non-alcoholic ease into 2009. Monetary policy, however, remains restrictive
beverages have been the main drivers of the inflation rate, rising to contain second round effects and pressures from
by over 18% y/y every month since January and by 20.4% y/y in consumption taxes and administered prices. The real policy
September, the highest for many years. Transport inflation rate was low at 1.5% in September. Monetary policy is more
peaked at 37.4% y/y in July but eased to 27.8% y/y in influenced by the BoB‟s medium-term inflation forecast and
September. Inflation is largely imported from South Africa, less by credit growth. Rates are expected to remain at these
where inflation as started to ease. We expect inflation to have levels, but a global slowdown could imply a more
peaked and to average about 12.5% this year. accommodative policy stance.
18 18
17
15
16
12 15
14
9 13
6 12
11
3 10
0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Prime rate Bank rate
3m BoBC Bank rate f'cast
Source: Bank of Botswana Source: Bank of Botswana
High inflation rate drives weaker pula. Botswana has a Diamond production still robust. The diamond sector
crawling band exchange rate system, which was introduced in continues to dominate the economy, despite efforts to
2005. The central bank set the trading band at ±0.5% around diversify the country‟s export and production base. The
central parity. The band rules out a large and unexpected weaker pula in recent weeks will help push export earnings
adjustment in the exchange rate. Botswana‟s relatively high higher. However, although diamond resources could be
inflation rate implies that the pula should weaken proportionately depleted by 2029, production volume is expected to increase
in line with expected inflation differentials with its main trading until 2015 and then decline, according to research. Unless the
partners. Despite the crawling band system, the pula weakened economy is more diversified, livings standards could drop as
sharply in October against the US dollar and traded at an export earnings decline. Botswana produced 31.8 million
average of BWP7.71/USD compared to BWP6.82/USD in carats in 2005, up from 20 million in 2000. Export earnings
September. We expect the pula to trade at an average of were USD3 359.2 million in 2007. In the third quarter 2008
BWP6.81/USD this year and BWP8.21/USD in 2009. exports were USD1 055.6 million compared to USD1 073.1
million in the same quarter last year.
BWP/USD BWP/ZAR
8.0 1.0 1,200
Page 2
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
0 Mining
Banking, Government
00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08f 09f 38.0% 16.5%
insurance
10.5%
Source: IMF WEO October 2008 Source: IMF
Foreign exchange reserves Trade balance
US$ mn months Pula million
11,000 50 35,000
30,000
9,000 40 25,000
20,000
7,000 30
15,000
5,000 20 10,000
5,000
3,000 10 0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007p
Forex reserves Import cover Exports Imports Merchandise trade balance
Source: Bank of Botswana Source: Bank of Botswana
Government budget balance - % of GDP Diamond prices (Antwerp) - US$ index, 1982 = 100
10 180
8
170
6
4 160
2 150
0
140
-2
-4 130
-6 120
02/03 03/04r 04/05r 05/06p 06/07b 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Source: IMF Source: Band of Botswana
Weights of consumer price index (CPI) constituents Botswana Stock Exchange indicators
19%
8% 20 6
11% 9% 10 3
0 0
Food Transport 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Alcohol & tobacco Housing Market cap. (lh) Domestic index (rh)
Clothing Other
Page 3
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
DRC
Significant upside risks to inflation. The gains made on Monetary policy remains tight. The worsening inflation
keeping inflation under double digits continue to fade. Consumer outlook should necessitate that the central bank tightens
inflation increased from 18.2% y/y in June to 21.1% y/y in monetary policy in the short to medium term. Short-term
September 2008. The currency stability that has helped subdue lending rates remain at 30%, having been increased from
imported inflation, especially from high food and energy imports, 24% in July 2008. We expect the central bank to raise rates
seems to be waning. This should exert upward pressures on in an attempt to curb surging money supply growth.
inflation in the medium term. The deteriorating security However, interest rates as an instrument of monetary policy
environment should also impact negatively on the distribution of are not very effective. Thus, the central bank should
consumer items from one part of the country to the other. continue to, directly, manage monetary policy by controlling
Despite improved agricultural production, the recent resumption base money through the sale of foreign exchange. This also
of conflicts in the eastern DRC is already contributing helps the monetary authority to manage excess liquidity
significantly to the upward surge in inflation. Government revised generated by large inflows of foreign aid and revenue from
its 2008 inflation target from 12% to 23.5%. commodity exports.
The franc exchange rate to depreciate. The resumption of Surging money supply. Owing to limited ability to control
unrest in the eastern DRC jeopardises any attempt of the country liquidity through other monetary policy instruments, such as
to return to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) Poverty interest rates, the central bank (Banque Centrale du Congo
Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) programme. This should – BCC) continues to control base money growth in an
lead to a significant reduction of the donor inflows into the attempt to curb inflationary pressures from large inflows of
country. Thus, we expect the exchange rate to depreciate in the foreign funds. In recent months, money supply has surged,
medium term. The slowdown in the global demand for thereby suggesting currency depreciation in the medium
commodities should also reduce commodity export earnings that term. This development has also worsened the inflation
have facilitated a stable exchange rate since 2007. The exchange outlook. We expect the BCC to continue controlling base
rate depreciated from an average of CDF554.68 per US dollar in money through the sale of foreign exchange to alleviate
September to an average of CDF561.64 per US dollar in October inflation pressures from the rapid increase in money supply.
2008.
Page 4
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
4 3.0 7% 13%
5%
0
Agriculture Mining
-2.0 Construction Manufacturing
-4 Wholesale & retail trade Transport & Comm.
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008f Trade & commerce Other
2 10000
0 8000
-2
6000
-4
-6 4000
-8
2000
-10
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008f 0
Overall balance (excl. grant)
Overall balance (incl. grant) 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Page 5
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Ghana
Inflation declines for three consecutive months. The Bank of Ghana keeps the policy rate at 17%. The
harvest season, which started in August, has provided relief Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) hiked the policy rate
from food inflation, and headline inflation declined to 17.9% by 100 basis points to 17% in July in response to
y/y in September from 18.1% y/y in August and 18.3% y/y in accelerating inflation. The central bank policy rate (prime
July. Food, which represents around 45% of the CPI basket rate) was raised from 13.5% to 14.25% in March and
of goods, rose from 7.5% y/y in August 2007 to 17.7% in again in May by 175 basis points to 16%. Following the
June 2008. This was due to the restriction of local food MPC‟s rate decision in July, average commercial bank
supply in the north of the country because of drought in the lending rates were similarly revised upwards within a
first part of 2007, followed by flooding in September coupled range of 22% to 41%. (The commercial bank rates
with the upward trend in global food prices at a time of high continue to show high spreads between deposit and
transport costs. Over the same period, non-food inflation lending rates and are also well above the Bank of
rose from 10.9% y/y to 18.9% y/y, driven by changes in Ghana‟s prime rate.) Owing to a declining inflation trend
utility prices and transport costs. The moderation in we do not expect an interest rate hike but we do expect
international crude oil prices and the improved domestic food monetary policy to remain tight in the presence of
supply on the back of the ongoing harvest season should inflationary pressures stemming from pre-election
continue to support a marginal declining trend. spending and high utility prices.
Inflation - % y/y Interest rates - %
25 35
30
20
25
20
15
15
10
10
5
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
5
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Prime 91-day t-bill Lending
The cedi continues to depreciate. The cedi lost some Favourable cocoa harvest expected. Ghana‟s Cocoa
ground during 2007 and depreciated by 5%, 7% and 17.5% Board (Cocobod) expects favourable output for the
against the US dollar, pound sterling and euro respectively. 2007/08 season as a result of improving weather
Demand pressures were exerted mainly from the golden conditions. Purchases declared by private buyers
jubilee anniversary celebration, preparations for hosting the reached 566 340 tonnes in the first 25 weeks of the
AU summit, and the continued energy crisis. In addition to 2007/08 season, which represents an increase of 10.2%
this, lower cocoa production, as a result of extreme rainfall, over the same period in 2007. Consequently, Cocobod
led to a 33.8% decline in earnings from exports of cocoa increased its initial estimate of 600 000 tonnes at the
beans and products. Despite strong international prices for start of the season to 634 000 tonnes (8% increase).
gold and cocoa, the national currency continued to Last year, the country declared total production of
depreciate in 2008 – a trend that was fuelled by a large and 614 469 tonnes, down from a record 740 457 tonnes in
burgeoning current account deficit stemming from capital 2006. The average price of cocoa bean exports
goods and oil imports. The cedi largely stabilised in August, (US$1 942.2 per tonne at the end of 2007) increased by
September and October and traded at between 7.7% to US$2 091.8 per tonne in the first quarter of this
GHc1.1543/US$ and GHc1.1660/US$. We expect marginal year. Cumulative cocoa purchases through the end of
depreciation to continue, especially in a pre-election context. September 2008 amounted to 758 908.
Page 6
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
Weights of consumer price index (CPI) constituents Ghana Stock Exchange index
12000
7%
10% 9% 6%
5% 10000
8000
52% 4%
4% 6000
3%
4000
Food & Bev. Clothing & Footwear
Utilities Furnishings
2000
Trans. & Comm. Enter.
Health Alcohol & Tobacco 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Misc.
Source: Bank of Ghana Source: Bloomberg
Page 7
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Kenya
Stubbornly high food prices keep inflation persistently high. Sell-off of short-term government securities pushes up
Inflation edged up to 28.4% y/y in October, from 28.2% y/y in yields. The yield on the 91-day Treasury bill rate rose to
September, on the back of high food prices and an increase in the 8.52% in mid-November, from 8.12% at the end of October
price of household goods and services. Conversely, non-food and 7.7% at end-September. This increase is on the back of
inflation eased to 13.0% y/y, from 13.3% y/y. This softening in a decline in appetite for government securities from foreign
non-food inflation was largely due to a 1.4% m/m fall in the price portfolio investors due to the heightened risk environment
of fuel and power, which is likely a consequence of the sharp drop related to the global financial crisis. The policy rate, the
in the international oil price. Although the current „long rains‟ central bank rate, remained unchanged at 9%, as the
season maize harvest has improved grain supply, it has had monetary authority maintained its firm policy stance in light
limited effect on prices because of food insecurity, particularly in of soaring inflation. The decrease in the average lending
the north-east region of Kenya. This explains the downwardly rate in August to 13.66%, from 13.91% in July, is partly
sticky food prices. However, the markedly lower international oil attributed to increasing competition among banks. Only
price is favourable for the inflation outlook, which we expect to once international financial markets begin to stabilise will
improve in 2009. Inflation is projected to slip to below 20% by short-term rates cease climbing.
mid-2009.
The Kenyan shilling continues to flounder. The shilling Liquidity position stabilises. The global credit crunch has
depreciated by a whopping 7% against the US dollar in October, subdued foreign portfolio inflows, thus contributing to the
compared to the previous month, to average KES76.64/USD. deceleration of growth in net foreign assets, which in turn
The loss in value of the shilling against the greenback was has placed a damper on money supply growth. Latest
largely due to a 7.6% appreciation of the US dollar. Acute risk figures reveal that net foreign assets‟ growth slowed to 6.9%
aversion implied that investors sought safe haven assets, y/y in July, from 10.5% y/y in June, and, as such, broad
including US Treasury securities. Also in October, the shilling money (M3) growth eased to to an estimated 17.1% y/y in
strengthened by a massive 12.1% against the rand to August, from this year‟s high of 28.5% y/y in April, at the
KES7.81/ZAR, as capital flight weighed heavily on the South height of the Safaricom initial public offering. The refunds
made to foreign over-subscribers of the IPO added to the
African economy. Conversely, the shilling depreciated by a
deceleration of net foreign assets‟ growth. In line with M3,
modest 1.2% against the euro, to KES/EUR101.93. In the short
reserve money growth also moderated to 19.0% y/y in July,
term the shilling will be volatile and undervalued, however, once
from 19.3% y/y in June. Monetary expansion is expected to
the cumulative effects of the various rescue packages kick in,
be subdued in early 2009.
the shilling should stabilise.
70 8 6
60 6 0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
KES/USD KES/EUR KES/ZAR (rhs) Broad money (M3) Reserve money
Sources: Bloomberg, Standard Bank Group est. Source: Central Bank of Kenya
Page 8
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
Source: Kenya National Bureau of Statistics, Standard Bank est Source: National Bureau of Statistics
Page 9
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Malawi
Inflation accelerated to 9.3% y/y in September. Inflation Monetary Policy Committee keeps the policy rate
followed global trends, accelerating from 8.7% y/y in July, flat. In view of the current inflationary pressures
mainly due to fuel and maize price increases. In spite of high stemming from high international oil prices as well as
oil prices, inflation recorded the lowest rates in decades in accelerating money supply growth, the Monetary Policy
2007 and averaged just below 8%. However, oil prices that Committee maintained its monetary stance at its
kept reaching new highs as well as a marginal seasonal meeting, and kept the bank rate at 15% and the liquidity
increase in food inflation towards the end of last year saw reserve requirement at 15.5%. Despite the government‟s
overall inflation starting to increase moderately from a intention to encourage private-sector-led development of
historical low of 7.1% y/y in September 2007 to 8.2% y/y in the economy, we expect monetary policy to remain tight
March 2008. Although inflation eased in April and May due in order to contain inflation expectations. However,
to the seasonal decline in food costs, the upward trend should inflation drop to the estimated levels of below 7%
continued in June. High oil prices and increased government presented in the 2008/09 budget, we expect interest
spending ahead of the 2009 election as well as money rates to be brought down to around 12%, as projected in
supply growth pose further upside risks to overall inflation. the 2008/09 budget, in the second quarter of 2009.
8 25
4 15
0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 5
Overall Inflation Non-food inflation 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Food inflation Prime-avg Bank rate 91-day t-bill
Source: National Statistics Office Source: Reserve Bank of Malawi
Kwacha stability ensured through RBM intervention. The Tobacco auction floors more than doubled sales.
authorities attach importance to exchange rate stability as an The tobacco auction floors had processed about
intermediate measure in maintaining macroeconomic 143 million kilograms valued at US$348 million as at the
stability. The kwacha remained relatively stable against the end of July 2008. In value terms, the quantity is almost
US dollar in the first three quarters of 2008 and averaged double that posted for the whole season last year
MWK140.35/US$, MWK140.63/US$ and MWK140.69/US$ (US$185 million). As at 22 August, 168.7 kilograms of
respectively. In October, the kwacha was slightly weaker at the green gold had been sold, earning US$412.3 million
MWK140.82/US$. The economy is into the seasonal lean – an average price of 244 US cents per kilogram. Out of
period following the end of the tobacco auctions. The the total sold, burley contributed 145.9 million kilograms
pressure on foreign reserves from fertilisers and oil imports (86.5%) whereas flue-cured contributed 20.9 million
will remain a concern for some time, although the kwacha is kilograms (12.3%). All foreign currency payments for
expected to receive some support from donor funds and the tobacco sold in Malawi are now made through the
authorities. The RBM is expected to continue intervening in central bank and not through commercial banks as in the
the foreign exchange market and we therefore expect the past. The onset of uranium exports next year will be an
kwacha to trade within a narrow band of MWK140/US$ and additional source of support for the local currency.
MWK142/US$.
220 22
300
180 20
250
140 18
100 16 200
60 14
150
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
2004 2005 2006 2007
USD EUR ZAR (rhs)
Source: Bloomberg Source: Tobacco Control Commission
Page 10
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
150 2.5 0
-500
100 2.0
-1000
50 1.5 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Foreign reserves Import cover Imports Exports Trade Balance
Weights of consumer price index (CPI) constituents Malawi Stock Exchange index
5% 4% 6000
6%
6%
5000
9%
4000
58%
12%
3000
2000
1000
Food Housing
Clothing & footwear Misc. 0
Beverage & tobacco Transport 2006 2007 2008
Household operation
Source: Central Statistics Office Source: MSE
Page 11
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Mauritius
Continued pressure on inflation from high food and oil Bank of Mauritius cuts the repo rate to 7.75%.
prices. Headline inflation has been on a declining trend Against the backdrop of a reduction in policy interest
since July last year but remained relatively high at around rates by the US Federal Reserve and the Bank of
9%, largely as a result of the pass-through effects of high England as well as potential downside risk to economic
food and energy prices. The appreciation of the rupee in the growth stemming from decelerating growth in major
first four months of this year dampened the impact of trading partners, the BoM cut the repo rate by 25 basis
mounting import prices, and inflation came marginally down points to 9% in February, lowered it further to 8.5% in
to 8.8% y/y in May. After remaining level during June, March and in May by 50 basis points to 8%. In view of
inflation accelerated to 9.1% y/y in July and to 9.5% y/y in growing demand-side pressures on inflation and no
August and 9.8% y/y in September. Once again the main slowdown in food and fuel prices, the BoM increased the
pressure came from food and fuel. With oil prices showing a repo rate on 21 July to 8.25%. On 31 October the BoM
softening bias and food prices expected to plateau, external considered the resilience of the domestic economy in the
pressures are easing, although domestic pressures such as light of the exceptional circumstances characterising the
strong demand are expected to remain. Our expectation is domestic and global economic and financial situation
that overall inflation will slightly exceed the 8.6% average and decided by consensus to reduce the repo rate by 50
projected in the 2008/09 budget. basis points to 7.75%.
Inflation - % y/y Interest rates - %
14 14
12 12
10
10
8
8
6
6 4
4 2
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
2
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Prime rate Bank rate
Lombard Rate Repo Rate
Source: Central Statistics Office Source: Bank of Mauritius
Rupee depreciated further in October to MUR30.04/US$. Tourist arrivals increased by 5.5% in the first half of
Supported by FDI inflows, record tourism earnings and the 2008. Tourist arrivals increased to 455 758 compared to
depreciation of the US dollar on currency markets, the rupee 432 113 for the same period in 2007. Gross tourism
appreciated by 9% in the first quarter of this year to a four- receipts for the first six months amounted to
year high of MUR25.5/US$. In April this trend was reversed Rs22 170 million, an increase of 12.2% compared to
when the rupee averaged MUR26/US$, MUR26.5/US$ in Rs19 752 million for the same period in 2007. The sector
May and MUR27.2/US$ in June. This was mainly on account continues to play a large role in terms of attracting FDI
of continued deterioration of the current account as import and is one of the main drivers of the country‟s economic
prices, particularly food and fuel, pushed up the import recovery. Given the construction timeframe of current
balance. The extent and duration of the global downturn will hotel projects, the sector should receive a substantial
play a large part in export demand as Mauritius is closely increase in capacity through 2008 and 2009. Despite
linked to international financial markets and the majority of this, the sector may experience even negative growth in
its export demand (more than 50%) comes from Europe and revenues through 2008, because of the dismal
the US. The current account will therefore remain under performance through the second half of the year, as the
pressure. FDI and tourism receipts should lend some effects of the global financial crisis start hitting
support to the rupee. consumer‟s disposable income.
40 5.0 50000
35 4.5 40000
30 4.0 30000
25 3.5 20000
20 3.0 10000
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
0
MUR/USD MUR/Euro MUR/ZAR (rhs)
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Page 12
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
10
-6 200
-7 0
00/01 01/02 02/03 03/04 04/05 05/06 06/07 07/08 08/09 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Weights of consumer price index (CPI) constituents Stock Exchange of Mauritius index
8% 9% 10% 2200
4%
16% 2000
9%
1800
13%
22% 4% 1600
5%
1400
1200
Clothing, footwear Housing, water, electricity 1000
Health Transport 800
Communication Furnishings, household 600
Recreation, culture Education 2005 2006 2007 2008
Restaurants, hotels Miscellaneous goods, services
Source: Central Statistical Office Source: Bloomberg
Page 13
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Mozambique
Inflation slowed to 10.3% y/y in October, from 10.7% in Higher short-term interest rates signal tightening in
September. This deceleration was due to a slowdown in food policy to curb monetary expansion. The yield on the 91-
inflation to 15.2% y/y, from 16.1%. However, this softening of food day Treasury bill rose again in September to 13.95%, from
inflation was not due to falling prices, but rather a low base effect. 13.89% in August. This increase reflected the tightening of
Hereafter, food inflation is expected to accelerate in the short monetary policy, to ensure base money met its end-quarter
term as the lean season has begun. Price pressures from fuel ceiling targets. The lending rate, which increased to 18.61%
prices have moderated, on account of the sharp drop in the in August, fell to 18.36% in September, thus resuming its
international oil price. As such, the rent, fuel and utilities‟ price long-term downward trend. Conversely, the policy rate, the
index remained unchanged in October, and that of transport standing lending facility, remained unchanged at 14.5%,
increased by a modest 0.1% m/m. In the short term, price mostly likely because the real policy rate has not been
pressures will stem from food prices; however, a high base effect compromised by a concomitant surge in inflation. Monetary
in the tail end of 2008 is likely to subdue annualised food inflation. policy is expected to remain firm in the short term, on
Thus, a modest decrease in inflation is projected over the short account of the approaching festive season, and thereafter to
term and a return to single-digit inflation in the first quarter of ease as inflation decelerates in 2009.
2009.
Inflation - % y/y Interest rates - %
25 30
20 25
15 20
10 15
5 10
0 5
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Overall Food Non-food
Prime Standing lending facility 91 day t-bill
Source: Instituto de Nacional Estatistica Source: Banco de Mocambique
Metical holds firms against hard currencies. The metical Base money stock breaches target ceiling in
depreciated by a modest 0.6% against the US dollar in October, September. Although base money contracted by 0.8% y/y
compared to September, to MZN24.20/USD. Evidently, the in August, its subsequent 2% m/m expansion in September
central bank is managing the value of the local currency against to MZN17 495 million led it to exceed the target, for the end
the US dollar to ensure that it does not veer off the central of the third quarter of 2008, of MZN17 347 million. On an
bank‟s seemingly preferred exchange rate for 2008 of annualised basis, base money growth continued to slow, as
MZN24.00/USD. As fundamentals and external events in recent it has done since June, to 13.1% y/y in September, from
months suggest a weaker metical, the fact that the local currency 15.2% y/y in August. Money supply (M2) growth also
has not depreciated against most hard currencies implies that softened in September to 23% y/y, from 2008‟s high of
the central bank is using foreign reserves to prop up the metical. 26.2% y/y in July. The approaching festive season is
The metical‟s appreciation of 17.3% and 7% against the rand expected to spur an acceleration in money supply growth in
and euro respectively, to MZN2.47/ZAR and MZN32.14/EUR, the last quarter of 2008, and, thereafter, monetary
was amplified by the depreciation of the rand and euro in expansion is expected to moderate. As fuel price pressures
October. As global financial markets stabilise, the metical is have eased, other than food prices, excess money supply
projected to recover against the euro and rand. will be elevated as an inflation risk in 2009.
Exchange rates Money supply - % y/y
40 4.8
35
36 4.4 30
32 4.0 25
28 3.6 20
24 3.2 15
20 2.8 10
16 2.4 5
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Page 14
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
Source:IMF, Instituto de Nacional Estatistica,Standard Bank est. Source: Instituto de Nacional Estatistica
Gross foreign reserves & import cover Trade account – US$ million
US$ millions months
2000 10 900
750
1600
8 600
1200 450
6 300
800 150
4 0
400
-150
0 2 -300
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Foreign reserves Import cover
Exports Imports Deficit
Source: Instituto de Nacional Estatistica Source: Banco de Mocambique
-4 2300
-5
1900
-6
-7 1500
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008p 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
13% 5% 1500
10% 1000
5% 500
52%
0
1% 3% -500
3%
2% -1000
2% 2% 2% -1500
Food & non-alcoholic drinks Dwellings,water,elec., gas & fuels -2000
Transport Mobile dwellings, hhold equip. & main.
-2500
Clothes & footwear Health
Leisure, recreation & culture Communications 2006 2007 2008p 2009p 2010p
Alcohol & tobacco Restaurants & hotels
Miscellaneous Education
Foreign borrowing Amortisation Direct investment
Page 15
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Namibia
Inflation levelling off. Namibia‟s inflation is largely imported Monetary policy rate remains unchanged. Namibia‟s
from South Africa through close trade links. Inflation has risen monetary policy focuses mainly on securing the 1:1 peg to the
steeply since a low of 0.9% y/y in May 2005 to 12% y/y in rand by holding sufficient foreign exchange reserves under the
August and September this year. Inflation is mainly driven by Common Monetary Area (CMA) agreement. The CMA also
high food prices and transport prices. Food inflation reached a limits Namibia‟s policy independence as there are no
high of 18.8% y/y in July and September, the highest for restrictions on capital flows within the area. Namibia‟s policy
several years; in 2004 and 2005 there were short bouts of rate, the bank rate, is 10.5%, which implies a negative real
food deflation. Transport prices rose by 18.1% y/y in August, policy rate of 1.5%. The last MPC meeting was on 16 October,
but fell to 15.4% y/y in September. Food and transport but no statement was released. The next meeting will be on 18
inflation may have peaked as prices are trending lower in December. We expect interest rates to remain unchanged this
South Africa and elsewhere on the back of the much lower year, but lower rates may start to materialise from the second
crude oil price. We expect inflation to average 10.2% this quarter of next year onwards as inflation is expected to start
year. falling.
20 20
16 16
12
12
8
4 8
0
4
-4
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Prime rate Bank rate 91-day TB
CPI Food
Source: Bank of Namibia Source: Bank of Namibia
The Namibian dollar relatively stable, but vulnerable. The Money supply. Broad money supply (M2) rose by an average
Namibia dollar (NAD) is pegged at par to the South African of 20.8% in 2006 and 19.6% in 2007. This year M2 rose from
rand (ZAR) under the CMA agreement. The rand is legal N$27 030 million in the first quarter to N$28 004 million in the
tender in Namibia, but not vice versa. The sudden appreciation second quarter on 2008, an increase of 3.5% q/q. Net foreign
of the US dollar against most developed and emerging market assets rose by 4.5% q/q; and domestic claims fell by 1.5% q/q;
currencies has driven the rand/Namibian dollar substantially whereas other items declined by 6.4% q/q. Domestic claims to
weaker. The NAD/ZAR is expected to trade at an average of the private sector (consisting of individual households and
NAD9.80/USD in the fourth quarter of 2008; and private non-financial businesses), other financial corporations
NAD8.22/USD for the whole of 2008. Next year the forecasts and parastatals rose by 1.9% q/q. Credit growth to businesses
are: NAD8.80/USD in the first quarter; NAD8.50/USD in the was marginally lower. However, credit growth to individuals
second quarter and NAD8.25/USD in the third quarter. The was higher as personal loans rose driven by individuals facing
average for 2009 is NAD8.4/USD. The expected 12-month the rising cost of living.
trading range is NAD8.00-12.00/USD.
40
12
35
30
10
25
20
8
15
10
6
5
4 0
00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 Jan-06 Jul-06 Jan-07 Jul-07 Jan-08 Jul-08
Page 16
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
2 2.0 5.0%
0 1.5 4.5%
-2 1.0 4.0%
-4 0.5 3.5%
-6 0.0 3.0%
-8 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07
03/04 04/05 05/06e 06/07 07/08p 08/09p Fishing on board (lh) % of GDP (rh)
Source: IMF
Source: Bank of Namibia
Weights of consumer price index (CPI) constituents Namibia Stock Exchange index (monthly, overall)
21%
29% 1,100
1,000
7% 900
800
700
600
7%
500
21% 400
15%
Food & non-alc. bev. Housing, w ater, electricity 300
Transport Education 200
Misc. goods & services Other
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Source: Bank of Namibia Source: Bloomberg
Page 17
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Nigeria
Inflation remains elevated. Headline inflation remained in Monetary policy to loosen into 2009. The central bank
double digits, increasing from 12.4% y/y in August to 13% y/y in continues to focus its efforts on liquidity management to
September 2008, driven by surging energy prices. Energy prices avert the long-term inflationary pressures from fiscal
(which constitute about 18.1% of the consumer price index – expansion and high inflows of oil revenue rather than fight
CPI – basket) increased from 4.1% y/y in August to 7.5% y/y in the short-term inflationary impact of rising food prices. From
September 2008. Increased agricultural production continues to the lowering of the monetary policy rate (MPR) to 9.75% in
ease food supply problems, thereby reducing food prices. Food September, the 91-day Treasury bill (T-bill) rate declined
prices (accounting for about 64% of the CPI basket) declined marginally to average 9.08% in September from an average
from an average of 18.8% in August to 17.2% y/y in September of 9.13% in August 2008. In the short term, the fiscal
2008. However, core inflation (headline inflation, excluding food) contraction following the reduction in the 2009 budget oil
increased from an average of 3.9% y/y in August to 6.9% y/y in price to USD45/bbl from USD59/bbl in 2008 might lead to a
September 2008. We forecast inflation to average 10.7% in significant spending cut, thereby reducing inflation.
2008. However, decreased fiscal revenue might force government
to issue bonds, thereby driving yields up.
Inflation - % y/y Interest rates - %
50 20
40 16
30 12
20
8
10
4
0
0
-10
2005 2006 2007 2008
2005 2006 2007 2008
Policy rate Prime 91-day TB
CPI inflation Food Non-food
Naira exchange rate to weaken. A stable and strong naira/USD Declining money supply. Following the banking sector
remains the central policy of the central bank as is evident from reforms and positive business environment experienced
the narrow range within which the currency continues to fluctuate. throughout 2006/2007, broad money supply surged as a
However, with the significant decline in oil prices, which should result of increased credit lending. Private sector credit
lead to fiscal contraction going into 2009, we expect some extension (PSCE) declined from 103.7% y/y in April to
depreciation of the naira exchange rate to maintain the current 77.4% y/y in September 2008. This led to a slowdown in
revenue stream at the USD45 per barrel oil price set in the 2009 broad money growth from 97.1% y/y to 57.9% y/y over the
budget. That is, about 80% of government revenue is dollar same period. We expect the downward trend to continue
denominated. However, a too weak budget exchange rate might owing to the envisaged fiscal contraction that might squeeze
make it impossible to fight the double-digit inflation, as the the government fiscal space, in this way leading to a
country relies heavily on imports. Thus, going into 2009, a naira reduction in oil savings in the Excess Crude Account. We
exchange rate of around NGN126/USD should support a also expect a significant reduction in net foreign assets of
relatively healthy fiscal space while enabling the monetary the banking system. This should help slow down the growth
authority to fight inflation. in broad money supply.
Source: Bloomberg & Federal Ministry of Finance Source: Central Bank of Nigeria
Page 18
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
12 Manufacturi Telecommu
10.3 10.6 Wholesale ng, 4.0
9.4 & retail nication, 2.3 Agriculture,
10 8.6
trade, 16.2 42.2
8 6.2 6.4
5.4
6
4
2
Finance &
0
insurance, Building &
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008f 2009f 3.9 construction Oil & gas,
, 1.7 19.4
70000 100
80
60000
60
50000 40
40000 20
30000 0
20000 -20
-40
10000
-60
0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008f
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Exports Imports Trade surplus
Weights of consumer price index (CPI) constituents Nigerian stock exchange – All share index
18% 70000
4%
4% 60000
64% 3% 50000
2%
40000
5%
30000
Food & non-alcoholic bev. Hse water, elec, gas & other fuel 20000
Transport Furn & hshld equip maint
Clothing & footwear Alcohol, tobacco & kola 10000
Other 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Page 19
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Tanzania
Inflation in double digits. Headline inflation increased from Upside risk to interest rates. The developments in
9.8% y/y in August to 11.6% y/y in September 2008, mostly Treasury bill (T-bill) yields continue to provide an anchor for
driven by high energy and food prices. The food component market-determined interest rates. The increasing trend in the
(which constitutes about 55.9% of the consumer price index –CPI yields for all maturities continues and is expected to remain
– basket) increased from 11.1% y/y in August to 13.4% y/y in elevated in the short term. The 91-day T-bill rate increased
September 2008. We expect food price increases to slow down from 8.62% in August to 10.36% in September 2008. The
during this harvest period. Energy prices (which constitute about overall weighted average T-bill rate also increased, from
8.5% of the CPI basket) increased from 12.7% y/y in August to 9.47% in August to 10.17% in September 2008. As inflation
15% y/y in September as the country continues to import its full ventures into double-digit territory, we expect nominal
quota of oil. Second-round effects of high energy prices are still lending rates to increase in the short term. This should,
evident, as transport costs remained elevated at 9.7% y/y in however, help maintain stable real interest rates. Overall, the
September 2008. Thus, we expect softer oil prices and increased risks to interest rates are on the upside. Our revised end-
food supply to bring some relief in the medium term. We forecast year T-bill forecast is 11.4%.
inflation to average 9.5% in 2008.
Inflation - % y/y Interest rates - %
15 25
20
12
15
9
10
6
5
3
0
0 2005 2006 2007 2008
2005 2006 2007 2008 Central Bank Rate
Comm.Bank Lending Rate
Overall Non-food Food Treasury Bills
Source: National Bureau of Statistics Source: Bank of Tanzania
The shilling exchange rate remains relatively stable. Export Slowdown in money supply growth. Tight monetary policy
performance continues to determine fluctuations in the exchange and a strong currency have facilitated a slowdown in money
rate as the economy is heavily dependent on the agriculture and supply growth. In fulfilling its primary mission of “price
commodity sectors. Increased demand for tourism services and stability”, the Bank of Tanzania (BOT) aims to control
continued inflow of donor aid should continue to support a strong inflation by influencing the growth of broad money through
currency. The slowdown in the world commodity demand might targeting reserve money. Announcing the June 2008
dampen mining exports, thereby leading to slight depreciation of monetary policy statement (MPS), the BOT specified a target
the currency. However, strong performance in tourism and of reducing money supply growth (both M2 and M3) to 18%
tourism services has provided an anchor for currency stability, each by end June 2009. Extended broad money (M3)
and is expected to continue in the medium term. Having declined from 27.1% y/y in March to 20% y/y in July, while
appreciated from an average of TZS1 160.33 per US dollar in M2 declined from 33.6% y/y to 25.3% y/y over the same
August to an average of TZS1 159.16 per US dollar in period. We expect monetary policy to remain tight to contain
September, the shilling depreciated to TZS1 230.13 in October inflationary pressures from large donor inflows.
2008 following the bleak inflation outlook.
Page 20
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
-7 0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008f Transportation Travel (Tourism) Other Services
Source: Bank of Tanzania & IMF 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Source: Bank of Tanzania
Weights in consumer price index (CPI) constituents Capital account - US$ million
6.9% 6.4%
1.4% 6000
55.9% 8.5% 5000
Page 21
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Uganda
Inflation consolidated its slowdown in October. Inflation Global financial crisis curbs foreign appetite for Treasury
slowed to 14.5% y/y in October, from 15.2% y/y in September bills. The yield on the 91-day Treasury bill jumped to 10.4% at
and 15.8% y/y in August. In the short term, overall inflation is the end of October, from 8.6% at the end of September, on the
projected to ease on the back of softening non-food inflation. back of a surge in investors‟ risk aversion for emerging
Lower fuel and transport prices are expected to subdue non- markets, as global financial conditions deteriorated. The policy
food inflation. The sharp drop in the international oil price to a rate, the rediscount rate, is also likely to have climbed in
fraction of its peak in 2008 has dampened inflationary October, from 15.2% in September. In recent days, there have
pressures. However, food insecurity in the region is expected been tentative signs that the cumulative interventions by
to put upward pressure on food prices. As the weighty item in developed world Treasuries and central banks are beginning to
the consumer price index (food) has a price that is downwardly take effect, thus easing risk aversion, which may explain the
sticky, the softening of inflation is expected to be moderate. As moderation of the 91-day Treasury bill rate to 9.2% in early
such, single-digit inflation is only projected to return in the November. As conditions stabilise short-term interest rates are
second quarter of 2009. projected to moderate.
The shilling weakens significantly. Uganda was not The rate of monetary expansion slows. The global financial
untouched by the massive sell-off of emerging market assets crisis has heightened risk aversion, particularly of emerging
during the volatile month of October for global financial market assets, and has as a result slowed capital inflows into
markets. Investors sought safe haven assets, including US Uganda. Liquidity has thus moderated as is evident from the
Treasury securities, which boosted the value of the US dollar in slowdown of base money growth to 17.3% y/y in September,
October, and thus explains the Uganda shilling‟s 9.7% from 21.7% y/y in August. Similarly, broad money growth
depreciation against it to a monthly average rate of decelerated in August to 25.4% y/y, from 28.3% y/y in July.
UGX1 805.3/USD. The shilling depreciated by a relatively The softening of monetary expansion reduces the challenges
modest 1.3% against the euro, to UGX2 394.7/EUR. However, of sterilising large foreign exchange inflows and as a result
the Ugandan currency appreciated by 9.9% against the rand to improves the authority‟s chances of containing base money
UGX184.03/ZAR, largely on account of the latter currency‟s below the ceiling target. Slower monetary expansion will also
excessive weakness due to massive capital flight. As reduce the upside inflationary risk that stems from too much
conditions improve in international financial markets, the money chasing too few goods.
shilling is projected to recover modestly before stabilising.
Page 22
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
6
9.4 8.9 9.1 9.2
4 8.6 Mining and
Hotels &
6.6 quarrying
Restaurant
s 1%
2 Constructio
3% n Electricity Manufacturi
Wholesale 11% and water ng
0 & Retail 1% 9%
2004 2005 2006 2007e 2008p 2009f Trade
11%
Source: Uganda Bureau of Statistics, IMF, Standard Bank est.
Source: Uganda Bureau of Statistics
-1 120
80
-2
40
-3
0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
-4
2005/06 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09p Robusta price (rhs) Arabica price (rhs)
Page 23
Standard
Standard Bank Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Zambia
Inflation continued its ten-month climb in October to A higher interest rate environment. Short-term interest rates
15.2% y/y. Inflation in October was largely driven by food, and have increased in recent months largely on account of a
transport and communication prices. Food inflation accelerated decline in appetite for local government debt related to the
to 17.6% y/y in October, from 16.2% y/y in September, while sharp increase in investors‟ aversion to emerging market risk.
transport and communication price inflation surged to 19.2% The drop in the copper price has also reduced the appeal of
y/y, from 11.5% y/y over the same period. Food inflationary Zambian debt. As such, the yield on the 91-day Treasury bill
pressures are expected to persist in the short term, as the lean increased to 13% in the first week of October, from 12.5% in
season has just begun. Expenditure related to the recent September. Accelerating inflation and reservations about the
presidential elections is also likely to have created short-term country‟s new leadership also added to the upward pressure
price pressures. The sharp fall in the international oil price is on interest rates. Similarly, the average lending rate increased
expected to substantially dampen price pressures from fuel, to 26.7%, from 25.7% over this period. This high interest rate
utilities and transport. And, as the green harvest begins to environment is expected to persist until the global financial
enter markets at the end of the first quarter of 2009, inflation is markets stabilise.
expected to ease.
Inflation - % y/y Interest rates - %
25 50
20 40
15 30
10
20
5
10
0
-5 0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Kwacha at its weakest value against the US dollar in 18 Broad money (M3) growth drops to a two-year low in
months. Heightened risk aversion spurred the dramatic sell-off August. M3 growth slowed to 19.5% y/y in August, from 29.2%
of emerging market assets in October and led to a sharp y/y in July, largely on account of a significant decline in foreign
depreciation of emerging market currencies, including the currency deposits. The growth rate of foreign currency
kwacha. The kwacha lost 15.4% of its value against the US deposits, which constitute between 26% and 30% of M3,
dollar and 6.4% against the euro, to average ZMK4 088.1/USD slowed sharply to 0.8% y/y in August, from 9.2% y/y in the
and ZMK5 415/EUR in October. The reversion of the trade previous month. This deceleration reflects acute emerging
balance to negative territory in the third quarter of 2008, largely market risk aversion, in light of the global financial crisis, and
because of the halving of the copper price in less than six uncertainty surrounding policy continuity following the death of
months, subdued foreign exchange inflows and thus added to President Mwanawasa. Reserve money growth was also
the weakening pressure on the kwacha. The slowdown in subdued in September at 4.3% y/y, compared to 11.1% y/y in
China‟s growth momentum suggests that the demand for August, owing to a decline in growth of statutory reserves on
copper has softened and thus Zambia‟s export earnings will foreign exchange deposits.
moderate, implying a weaker kwacha in the short term.
Wwwwwweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Page 24
Standard Bank
Standard Bank Group
Group Economics
Economics
Page 25
Standard Bank Group Economics
Standard Bank Group Economics
Group Economics
Goolam Ballim – Group Economist
+27-11-636-2910
Goolam.Ballim@standardbank.co.za
South Africa
Johan Botha Shireen Darmalingam Jeremy Stevens Danelee van Dyk
+27-11-636-2463 +27-11-636-2905 +27-11-631-7855 +27-11-636-6242
Johan.botha@standardbank.co.za Shireen.darmalingam@standardbank.co.za Jeremy.Stevens@standardbank.co.za Danelee.vanDyk@standardbank.co.za
Rest of Africa
Jan Duvenage Anita Last Yvonne Mhango Victor Munyama
+27-11-636-4557 +27-11-631-5990 +27-11-631-2190 +27 11-631-1279
Jan.duvenage@standardbank.co.za Anita.last@standardbank.co.za Yvonne.Mhango@standardbank.co.za Victor.Munyama@standardbank.co.za
Botswana Angola Kenya DRC
Lesotho Ghana Mozambique Nigeria
Namibia Malawi Uganda Tanzania
Swaziland Mauritius Zambia Zimbabwe
All current research is available on the Standard Bank Group Economics home page. In order to receive Group Economics’ research
via email, all clients (new and existing) are required to register and select publications on the website. Click on
http://ws9.standardbank.co.za/sbrp/LatestResearch.do, select Register and enter your email address. A username and password will
then be emailed to you.
Analyst certification
The authors certify that: 1) all recommendations and views detailed in this document reflect his/her personal opinion of the financial instrument or market class discussed;
and 2) no part of his/her compensation was, is, nor will be, directly (nor indirectly) related to opinion(s) or recommendation(s) expressed in this document
Disclaimer
This document does not constitute an offer, or the solicitation of an offer for the sale or purchase of any investment or security. This is a commercial communication. If you
are in any doubt about the contents of this document or the investment to which this document relates you should consult a person who specialises in advising on the
acquisition of such securities. Whilst every care has been taken in preparing this document, no representation, warranty or undertaking (express or implied) is given and
no responsibility or liability is accepted by the Standard Bank Group Limited, its subsidiaries, holding companies or affiliates as to the accuracy or completeness of the
information contained herein. All opinions and estimates contained in this report may be changed after publication at any time without notice. Members of the Standard
Bank Group Limited, their directors, officers and employees may have a long or short position in currencies or securities mentioned in this report or related investments,
and may add to, dispose of or effect transactions in such currencies, securities or investments for their own account and may perform or seek to perform advisory or
banking services in relation thereto. No liability is accepted whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from the use of this document. This document is not
intended for the use of private customers. This document must not be acted on or relied on by persons who are private customers. Any investment or investment activity
to which this document relates is only available to persons other than private customers and will be engaged in only with such persons. In European Union countries this
document has been issued to persons who are investment professionals (or equivalent) in their home jurisdictions. Neither this document nor any copy of it nor any
statement herein may be taken or transmitted into the United States or distributed, directly or indirectly, in the United States or to any U.S. person except where those U.S.
persons are, or are believed to be, qualified institutions acting in their capacity as holders of fiduciary accounts for the benefit or account of non U.S. persons; The
distribution of this document and the offering, sale and delivery of securities in certain jurisdictions may be restricted by law. Persons into whose possession this
document comes are required by the Standard Bank Group Limited to inform themselves about and to observe any such restrictions. You are to rely on your own
independent appraisal of and investigations into (a) the condition, creditworthiness, affairs, status and nature of any issuer or obligor referred to and (b) all other matters
and things contemplated by this document. This document has been sent to you for your information and may not be reproduced or redistributed to any other person. By
accepting this document, you agree to be bound by the foregoing limitations. Unauthorised use or disclosure of this document is strictly prohibited. Copyright 2004
Standard Bank Group. All rights reserved.
Page 26