Q$\$ \quzaka Lfqz~
@UUA@I CZFK ^BA LFQZ^ FC LI@GK\
\wii`jq|
Gd l`|a fc `kjgmqg~w gd ` |~`~q~a) lfd~akufz`dafq| `dn qdgcfzk aralq~gsa lfd|~zql~gfd g|zam`znan `| nalg|gsa$
^ba uzfsg|gfd| fc ~ba @l~ fc @qmq|~ <) 0230) lb$ >:) § :<) 0: \~`~$ :70) zai`~gdm ~f ~ba za~gzakad~fc fccglaz| fc ~ba d`sw) b`sgdm jaad qdgcfzkiw bain) jw ~ba fccglaz| lb`zman }g~b ~bagz aralq~gfd)~f ja `uuigl`jia ~f }`zz`d~ fccglaz|) `za df} bain ~f ja |f `uuigl`jia$^ba @l~ fc Oqiw 01) 02=5) 03 \~`~$ <:0) ngn df~ `jfig|b ~ba cqzifqmb u`w ig|~) `dn `d fznaz `c~az ~ba u`||`ma fc ~b`~ `l~ za~gzgdm ` d`s`i fccglaz fd cqzifqmb u`w }`| k`na gd uqz|q`dla fc i`}$^ba `nkgdg|~z`~fz fc ` za~gzan d`s`i fccglaz l`ddf~) gd fznaz ~f zalfsaz czfk ~ba Qdg~an \~`~a| `dgdlza`|a gd ~ba lfkuad|`~gfd fc bg| gd~a|~`~a) ~`ha `ns`d~`ma fc `d `iiaman nacal~ gd ~ba uzflaangdm| jw }bglb ba }`| za~gzan) `dn }bglb ba `lpqga|lan gd }g~bfq~ fjoal~gfd nqzgdm bg|igca~gka$§ 0122 Zas$\~`~$ nfa| df~ `uuiw ~f fccglaz| za~gzan fd cqzifqmb u`w$Fccglaz| fc ~ba d`sw fd ~ba za~gzan ig|~ `za df~ ad~g~ian ~f ifdmasg~w u`w$O`ka| Jzf}d) ~ba gd~a|~`~a fc ~ba `uuaii`d~) }`| ` jf`~|}`gd gd ~ba Qdg~an \~`~a| D`sw$ ^ba ua~g~gfd gd ~bg| l`|a }`| cgian `m`gd|~ ~ba Qdg~an \~`~a| jw ~ba `nkgdg|~z`~zgr fc bg| a|~`~a gd00< Q$ \$ 137~ba Lfqz~ fc Li`gk| ~f zalfsaz ` j`i`dla fc u`w }bglb |ba `iiaman }`| nqa ~f Jzf}d `~ bg| na`~b$^ba Lfqz~ fc Li`gk| cfqdn ~ba cfiif}gdm c`l~|?Jzf}d) ~ba nalanad~) }`| `uufgd~an ` jf`~|}`gd gd ~ba D`sw fc ~ba Qdg~an \~`~a|) O`dq`zw >)023:$ Fd Fl~fjaz ::) 02=:) ~ba D`s`i Za~gzgdm Jf`zn) jacfza }bglb ba b`n jaad fznazan jw ~ba\alza~`zw fc ~ba D`sw qdnaz ~ba uzfsg|gfd| fc § :< fc ~ba @l~ fc @qmq|~ <) 0230) 0: \~`~$ :70)
zaufz~an ~b`~ ba }`| gdl`u`lg~`~an czfk uazcfzkgdm ~ba nq~ga| fc bg| fccgla) `dn ~b`~ ~baza }`| dfasgnadla ~b`~ |qlb gdl`u`lg~w }`| ~ba za|qi~ fc `dw gdlgnad~ fc ~ba |azsgla$ Ba }`| `llfzngdmiw)qufd ~ba n`w i`|~ kad~gfdan) jw fznaz fc ~ba Uza|gnad~) za~gzan fd cqzifqmb u`w$ Czfk Fl~fjaz ::)02=:) ~f Oqda <5) 02=1) Jzf}d zalagsan u`w `~ ~ba z`~a fc .755 uaz `ddqk) `dn czfk Oqiw 0)02=1) ~f Oqda 3) 02=7) `~ ~ba z`~a fc .155 uaz `ddqk$ Fd ~ba n`w i`|~ d`kan) ba ngan$^ba lfqz~ cqz~baz cfqdn ~b`~ ~ba @l~| fc @qmq|~ <) 0230) 0: \~`~$ :75) `dn fc Nalakjaz :0) 0230)0: \~`~$ <:7) }aza |ffd `c~az ~bagz ad`l~kad~ lfd|~zqan jw ~ba Uza|gnad~ `dn D`sw Nau`z~kad~ ~fgdliqna }`zz`d~ fccglaz|) `dn qdnaz ~b`~ lfd|~zql~gfd g~ b`n jaad ~ba qdgcfzk uz`l~gla fc ~baUza|gnad~ ~f ui`la }`zz`d~ fccglaz| fd ~ba za~gzan ig|~) `dn i`zma dqkjaz| fc ~ba|a fccglaz| b`n jaad |f za~gzan$ Df uzf~a|~ fz fjoal~gfd }`| k`na jw Jzf}d nqzgdm bg| igca~gka) ag~baz ~f bg|za~gzakad~ fz z`~a fc u`w$ ^ba `llfqd~gdm fccglaz| fc ~ba ^za`|qzw b`n qdgcfzkiw bain ~b`~ifdmasg~w u`w ~f za~gzan fccglaz| }`| df~ `q~bfzgan jw § 017< fc ~ba Zasg|an \~`~q~a|$Czfk ~ba|a cgdngdm| fc c`l~ ~ba Lfqz~ fc Li`gk| nanqlan) `| ` lfdliq|gfd fc i`}) ~b`~ Jzf}d }`|iam`iiw ui`lan fd ~ba za~gzan ig|~) `dn b`n zalagsan ~ba cqii `kfqd~ fc u`w `iif}an bgk jw i`}) `dn}`| df~ ad~g~ian ~f zalfsaz) `dn ad~azan oqnmkad~ ng|kg||gdm ~ba ua~g~gfd$ ^ba `uua`i fc ~ba ua~g~gfdaz jzgdm| ~b`~ oqnmkad~ qdnaz zasga}$
KZ$ OQ\^GLA ]ffn| naigsazan ~ba fugdgfd fc ~ba Lfqz~$
Ba zalg~an ~bac`l~| gd ~ba cfzamfgdm i`dmq`ma) `dn lfd~gdqan?00< Q$ \$ 1=5G~ g| df~ nadgan ~b`~ qu ~f Oqiw 0) 02=1) Jzf}d zalagsan `ii ~ba u`w ~f }bglb ba }`| ad~g~ian$^ba cgz|~ lfd~ad~gfd fc ~ba `uuaii`d~ g| ~b`~ ~ba ui`lgdm fc Jzf}d fd ~ba za~gzan ig|~ }`|qd`q~bfzgan jw i`}) `dn ~b`~ ba }`| ~bazacfza ad~g~ian ~f ~ba cqii u`w fc ` jf`~|}`gd czfk Oqiw 0)02=1) qu ~f ~ba ~gka fc bg| na`~b$§ :< fc ~ba @l~ fc @qmq|~ <) 0230) 0: \~`~$ :70) jw `q~bfzg~w fc }bglb ~ba Uza|gnad~ `||qkan ~fza~gza Jzf}d) za`n| `| cfiif}|?’^b`~ }badasaz `dw fccglaz fc ~ba d`sw) fd jagdm fznazan ~f uazcfzk ~ba nq~ga| `uuzfuzg`~a ~f bg|lfkkg||gfd) |b`ii zaufz~ bgk|aic qd`jia ~f lfkuiw }g~b |qlb fznaz) fz }badasaz) gd ~ba oqnmkad~fc ~ba Uza|gnad~ fc ~ba Qdg~an \~`~a|) `d fccglaz fc ~ba d`sw |b`ii ja gd `dw }`w gdl`u`lg~`~anczfk uazcfzkgdm ~ba nq~ga| fc bg| fccgla) ~ba Uza|gnad~ `~ bg| ng|lza~gfd) |b`ii ngzal~ ~ba \alza~`zwfc ~ba D`sw ~f zacaz ~ba l`|a fc |qlb fccglaz ~f ` jf`zn$ $ $ $ ^ba jf`zn) }badasaz g~ cgdn| `dfccglaz gdl`u`lg~`~an cfz `l~gsa |azsgla) }gii zaufz~ }ba~baz) gd g~| oqnmkad~) ~ba gdl`u`lg~w za|qi~czfk ifdm `dn c`g~bcqi |azsgla) czfk }fqdn| fz gdoqzga| zalagsan gd ~ba igda fc nq~w) czfk|glhda|| fz aruf|qza ~bazagd) fz czfk `dw f~baz gdlgnad~ fc ~ba |azsgla8 gc |f) `dn ~ba Uza|gnad~`uuzfsa fc |qlb oqnmkad~) ~ba ng|`jian fccglaz |b`ii ~bazaqufd ja ui`lan qufd ~ba ig|~ fc za~gzanfccglaz| `llfzngdm ~f ~ba uzfsg|gfd| fc ~bg| `l~$ Jq~ gc |qlb ng|`jgig~w fz gdlfkua~adlw uzflaanczfk f~baz l`q|a|) `dn ~ba Uza|gnad~ lfdlqz gd fugdgfd }g~b ~ba jf`zn) ~ba fccglaz k`w ja za~gzanqufd cqzifqmb u`w) fz ba |b`ii ja }bfiiw za~gzan czfk ~ba |azsgla }g~b fda wa`z-| u`w `~ ~bang|lza~gfd fc ~ba Uza|gnad~) `dn gd ~bg| i`|~ l`|a bg| d`ka |b`ii ja }bfiiw fkg~~an czfk ~ba d`swzamg|~az$ $ $ $‛^ba `uuaii`d~ `||az~| ~b`~ ~bg| |al~gfd `uuiga| fdiw ~f lfkkg||gfdan fccglaz|) `dn df~ ~f }`zz`d~fccglaz|) ~f }bglb i`~~az li`|| Jzf}d jaifdman$G~ kq|~ ja lfdlanan ~b`~ }aza ~ba pqa|~gfd ` da} fda) ~ba ~zqa lfd|~zql~gfd fc ~ba |al~gfd }fqin ja fuad ~f nfqj~$ Jq~ ~ba cgdngdm| fc ~ba Lfqz~ fc Li`gk| |bf} ~b`~ |ffd `c~az ~ba ad`l~kad~ fc ~ba `l~) ~ba Uza|gnad~ `dn ~ba D`sw Nau`z~kad~ lfd|~zqan ~ba |al~gfd ~f gdliqna }`zz`d~ `| }aii`| lfkkg||gfdan fccglaz|)00< Q$ \$ 1=0`dn ~b`~ ~baw b`sa |gdla ~b`~ ~gka qdgcfzkiw `nbazan ~f ~b`~ lfd|~zql~gfd) `dn ~b`~ qdnaz g~| uzfsg|gfd|) i`zma dqkjaz| fc }`zz`d~ fccglaz| b`sa jaad za~gzan$ ^bg| lfd~akufz`dafq| `dnqdgcfzk gd~azuza~`~gfd g| ad~g~ian ~f }agmb~ gd ~ba lfd|~zql~gfd fc ~ba i`}) `dn gd ` l`|a fc nfqj~fqmb~ ~f ~qzd ~ba |l`ia$
Brown v United States, 113 US 568 (1885) Statutory Construction
Brown v US at 568: In case of ambiguity in a statute, contemporaneous and uniform executive construction is regarded as decisive.
Brown v US at 571, quoting Moore: “The construction given to a statute by those… (More)
Brown v US at 571, quoting Moore: “The construction given to a statute by those… (More)
89
Reads
0
Readcasts
0
Embed Views
More From This User
Notes
Load more
