Comments on Cadiz Water Project 2011 DEIR Page 2Dear Mr. Barnes:On behalf of the Center for Biological Diversity (“CBD”), the National ParksConservation Association (“NPCA”), the California Wilderness Coalition (CWC), SanBernardino Valley Audubon Society, Sierra Club Desert Committee, the Mojave Desert LandTrust, the Morongo Basin Conservation Association, Defenders of Wildlife, the Desert TortoiseCouncil, the San Gorgonio Chapter of the Sierra Club,
Southern California Watershed Alliance,Desal Response Group and Desert Survivors, we appreciate and welcome the opportunity tocomment on the Cadiz Valley Water Conservation, Recovery, and Storage Project (“Cadiz WaterProject,” “Proposed Project” or “Project”) Draft Environmental Impact Report (“DEIR”).For the reasons set forth below, commenters request that a new DEIR be prepared for theProposed Project under the lead agency of San Bernardino County. Also, the right-of-way(“ROW”) for the Proposed Project requires Bureau of Land Management (“BLM”) approval, andthe Proposed Project, therefore, requires full review under the National Environmental PolicyAct (“NEPA”), 42 U.S.C. section 4321
et seq.
We urge the appropriate state agencies tocoordinate with the appropriate federal agencies to prepare a joint EIR/DEIS for the ProposedProject that complies with both state and federal law.NPCA is a non-profit organization whose mission is to protect and enhance America’snational parks for present and future generations. NPCA has 450,000 members nationwide andover 45,000 California members, and works with elected officials, the media, and communitiesto foster stewardship of our national treasures. NPCA has three offices in the Mojave Desert:Joshua Tree, Barstow, and Las Vegas.The Center for Biological Diversity (“CBD”) is a national, nonprofit conservationorganization with more than 320,000 members and online activists dedicated to protectingendangered species and wild places. Due to the proposed project’s significant impacts to desertsand to the development of suburban sprawl, CBD has followed the proposed project closely in itsvarious iterations through the years, and has utilized its staff biologist to review the relevantimpacts on plants and wildlife.The California Wilderness Coalition (“CWC”) protects the natural landscapes that makeCalifornia unique, providing clean air and water, a home to wildlife, and a place for recreationand spiritual renewal. With 3,000 members, CWC is the only organization dedicated toprotecting and restoring California's wild places and native biodiversity on a statewide level.Since 1976, we have empowered local communities and conservationists to be the voice for wildCalifornia.The San Bernardino Valley Audubon Society (SBVAS) is a chapter of the NationalAudubon Society, which has about half a million members nationwide. The chapter itself hasapproximately 1800 members who reside in the inland empire. Audubon members regularlyvisit the Mojave desert for birdwatching, photography, and the appreciation of nature.The Sierra Club is a national nonprofit organization of approximately 1.3 millionmembers and supporters dedicated to exploring, enjoying, and protecting the wild places of the