From:
Sent:
To:Cc:Subject:Attachments:
Mcguire,JamesFriday,February17,20125:26PM'Rickers.Amy'Bowers,Chris;Haskel,PeterRE:ColumbiaPacking[MH-MHDOCS.FID735657]
~J
DSCOOO64.jpg;SC00059.jpg;DSC00060.jpg;DSC00061.jpg;DSC00062.jpg;
DSC00063.jpg
Amy-TorecapandprovidearesponseyouandIwerepresentDuringsewer,andcodecomplianceissues,butyourrequesttheCityconductedanandassociatedwalkthrough,wereviewednotconcludethatalllife/safetyissueswereatwhichbothsanitaryPriortotoday,ColumbiaPackinghasnotprovidedanaccurate,updatedschematictotheCity,despitetheCity'sstandingrequestforsuchadocumentsinceatleastJanuary25,2012.Weagainthismorningrequestedanupdated,accurateschematicfromColumbiaPacking,alongwithrelateddiagramsshowingconnections.Youprovideduswithdocumentsthisafternoon,whichwerebroughttoPretreatmentforreviewandconsideration.YoualsorepresentedtomethatadditionaldocumentsweregoingtobebroughtbyColumbiaPackingdirectlytoPretreatmenttodayforreviewandconsideration.Iamunawareofwhetherthosedocumentshavebeenprovidedornot.Finally,youprovideduswithupdatedStormwaterPollutionPreventionPlan("SWPPP")documentstoremedytheshortcomingsintheSWPPPdocumentsyoupreviouslyprovide(1
to
theCity,
ThesewerebroughttoStormwaterManagementforreviewandconsideration,
Also
thisafternoonandafteryouprovidedtheschematicsandotherdocuments,aCityinspectordiscoveredanadditional,unidentifiedpipeattheColumbiaPackingfacility.ThishiddenpipewasreadilyiDeatedbytheCityinspectorbecauseithadanaccesspointcoveredbyalargemetalsheetinthemiddleoflarge,mowedfield.ThehiddenpipedoesnotappearonanyofthedocumentsColumbiaPackinghaspreviouslyprovidedtotheCity,butappearstoextendtowardstheColumbia
Packing
facilityinonedirection,andtowardsCedarCreekintheotherdirection.AColumbiaPackingworkerdugthehiddenpipeoutbyhand,andCitypersonnelviewedit.WhenIaskedwhetheryouOrColumbiaPackinghadknowledgeofthehiddenpipe,nobodyclaimedtohaveanyknowledge,Moreover,althoughyouandothersfromColumbiaPackingclaimeditwas"coHapsed,"
the
attachedphotosshowthatitwasclearlynot"collapsed"inatleastonedirection.Inaveryshortturnaroundofanhourorso,CityinspectorsreturnedtotheColumbiaPackingfacilitytoinspectandvideotapethispipeviaclosed-circuittelevision("CCTV").Atthistime,theCityhasnotmadetheconclusionthat"thereisnopotentialfordischargeorcrossconnection,"Indeed,asColumbiaPackingwellknows,apipethatisobstructedbymaterialscanresultinillicitdischargesiftheproperprecautionsarenottaken.GiventhecircumstancesandfactssurroundingColumbiaPacking'sviolations,theCitytakesthepresenceofunauthorizedpipesattheColumbiaPackingfacilityveryseriously.Moreover,thefactthatCityinspectorsarediscoveringadditionalpipingatthefacilityatthislatedatecastsseriousdoubtonwhetherColumbiaPackinghasbeendiligentin
.
disclosingallexistingpipesaspartoftheinformationithasbeenprovidingtotheCity.
\
Forthesereasons,amongothers,itwouldbeinappropriatefortheCitytogivethedocumentsprovidedthisafternoonanythingotherthananattentiveandcarefulreview.Whendocumentsarereceivedwithonlyafewbusinesshoursleftintheday,itisunreasonabletoexpectthattheycanbeproperlyreviewedandconsideredonasame-daybasis.TheCityagreesthatthepipeshouldberemoved,butanyremovalshouldtakeplacewithaCityinspectoron-site,Becauseoftheheavyrainsexpectedthisweekend,itdoesnotseemadvisabletoremove
tile
pipethisweekend.Nevertheless,inanefforttoaccommodateyou,theCitywillprovideaninspectoroncallovertheholidayweekend.IfColumbiaPackinginsistsuponremovingthepipethisweekend,pleasecalltheCity'sStormwaterHotline
at214-948-4407
toarrangeforaCityinspectortobepresent.Inaddition,ifanattorneyfor42