,

Cb.ristopber Ess and Ross Mcitridc,

Tken by Storm. 'Ihe troubled sdmce,
polky andpoliti f
o globQl warming
yJ&r. "'
( . fCttru
UJ1' jr, d( ruu .rc
1rtlt}"'uur( ptpn).
ey Porter Books. 2002. . 320
Chstopher Boobr.
'Ihe ReU Globl Warming Disuter
( pyn rncp
mtpr).
Continuum, 2010. . 368

... / 6rr py

ptpy
. p6
y v,
v t pr

p6.

i1

1.

.
WWF ( l u Ncwwck. 28 1975, u oolou i
' i .
),

[

, ,
a
1896,
Sundy Telegph
. i u ))
Pritt
l, , c
. " ,
Eye .
': l i
, irr
,
u
; :
, , ,
, :
ul. ,
20ou

2
u
- - i. i, 1997

i
- . ,


.
1824,
a, ,
l, -
, 50 [

The Athens Reiew of books

p
, ,
2.000 )).


-
-

(IPCC),
i
20

a 0,75C a
22 .
IPCC


, 1,1C
6,4C 28 .
79 .,
a
.(...)
,
, [..:
. , 2006] 20%
3
,
a, a
)) )).
, ,
;

i !
.

, .




.
, ,
,
,
2011

tu
(
v L.
, .
l l" l
u .
l !

.
,
cl


l l,
l ()
l

l.


.

, ,
, ,

11:
mlc; cl ,
vcc; ml u cyl
ei (Jasper irkby, 2008).

- 68 8 " C190t 1999 .JQ

-.,... kc .)
- _.,... cly (40 nWY
-- r-W\6.o(10001900.JQ
..... 9 i....
-

l
.


,


(turbulence)
-

l
.

..

2000

,
l l
, , ,
, l
l
l
,
.

l,

,

l. l

l

.
l
.
a
l
. ,
,

, l ,

2011

'(

JC

l nui u . u uy, onol ,

cc; , u y (IPCC).

l l,
l,
,
l
, 2003,
i
!
(NAS),
,
IPCC
,
,
1999. ' ,
1.000


("the hockey stick cure"), ,

! 20 ,
i
C02 -

.

-
(proxy data), ,
-
l

, ..,
,
. ,

,


1400-1980 ..

15
20

"hockey stick cuve" !
.

,

, l (900-1300
..),
(1300-1850) , l

,

,
l
,

.

,
!, l
,


.
l,


, IPCC,
! ,
l co2

.

( ... ). C02,
,


, l
,

....

,

,
, l
l ,
,

( 100.000
)

( Milankoitch),

l .
! (l
),

5
,
100.000 (
l l )

, ,
,

!,
.
( The Athens Review ofbooks

51

, u
, 2007 ,
,
,
s .
,
, .
. ,
co2.
a a
,

-


. :
.



i.
,
,
,
, ,
, ,

.

.

a ,
, . ,
( official sci- ence) -


....
IPCC- l

.

3.

,
a, .
a
l ,
, .
, 2001
66
7, p


c,
. l, ,

, , l
.
,

, :

-
l
t,
'
52

[ The Athens Review ofbooks

: l , a 1927 1964. : 1935.

: , \, .

,


a
a .
,
,
u
. ,
,

8
-
, '
l
.
a




.

.
. ,

9 ,
, ,
, ,
,
.

l
.
,
, ,

:

, IPCC,
. ,
10
2006.
, , ;
IPCC u 1988
-

,
l



11
, , u
1988,
<<
. ,


,
GISS ( a
) NASA.
u ,
,
:
/
[] .

i,
-<l-

tt .

nm

,
,
(WMO)
a (UNEP),
,
ccTo
,

l ,
,
l a
,
a l ,
, v
.
UNEP
1988.
v
IPCC v
,

, ,
, Greenpeace,
Friends of the Earth, WWF En
ironmental Defense Fund,
1989 -,
,

700
,

.
<<
FAR IPCC (
) 1990
. a
,
u .
a
,
.

((2.500 IPCC,
a.


.
r
(( a

.


(Executive Summary for Polcy
Makers).
,

,
.
,
,
l,
,
-
. ,
,
2011

 ,
,
l 16

.
,

IPCC,





.

4.

,
,

IPCC.
,

.i
IPCC.
,
(... ) ,
u .i
-
-
,

.i .
,

, , ,

.






12
, ,
.


.
,

.i
.i ,

.


. ,
IPCC,

( ) -
,
, , -
,
,

, l,
,
. 1'

2011

l l .
. .

.i-.i
.

,
,
,

.

.

l
l ,

l

. ,
,

,
.i Fargo.
.
.i ,
,

.

,
.i
,

fi . ,
,
[sic].
( 1997}


14

-
.
, , -

.i


, New York
Yimes, Observer, Guardian, Independent,

Yime, Newsweek
NBC, CBS, ABC,
BBC, -
Science, Nature, Scientific Ameri
can
a ,
peer-reviews (.i
l a), ,
,
.
Yimes
,
Channel Four,
he Great
Global Warming Swindle,
, 2007,
,
15
,


(NGOs)

(Environmental Lobby Groups).

.
,
, ,


,
, ,
,

, 1993,

(F)

.

,
,

.i
.i. .i

1960. .i


.

.i
.i
.i.


(
)
.



.i. (<

.
,


.

.i .





.i

.


. ,



l .i u.i
l.
.
;
- ,
.i
, ,

\
, l
. .
l \,
l \ l , ,
,
.

The Athens Review of books ] 53

, ,

vironment New Left Review, 201

(1993), .
46-59. 2007,
,
,
,
, An Inconvenient Tnth.
, l 200.000 ,

.

l
,
l

[1977]

:
-
,
- l
. l l
l. l
. l
l;.
,

. , ,
l ,
,
-
, l l
l; .

..

, WWF.

1 , . ,
. . ,
, 1999, . 83.
2
, ,

26.4.2009.
3 Mark Maslin, Global Warming, Very Short
Introduction, Oxford Uniersity Press, 2009,
. 1 23.
4 , .
, . ,
8.3.2011.
5 , <<0

;, .
..., 32,
2011.
6 Bj0rn Lomborg, The Skeptical Enironmen
talist, Cambridge Uniersity Press,
2001.
7 )ean de Kervasdou\
;, . .
, . . , ,
2010, . 31.
8 Ian Plimer, Heaen and Earth. Global Warm
ing the Missing Science, Taylor Trade Pub
lishing, 2009.
. 9 . Dominique Lecourt, Proletarian Science?
The case ofLysenko, New Left Books 1977.
10
<<

l .
:

<<

.

p
, Q
m
t;. . Alexander
Cockbum, "'Wm-Wri with Bruce Babbitt:

The Clinton Administration Meets the En54

[ The Athens Reiew of books

'

-
;


,
- , ,
!

"!'
_ :

-

columbarium

1 , lp,

irr ,
<l
C02

1950
1960. '
, .


,

.
Scientific Alnerican, 1959,

3C
_ . Mark Maslin, .., . 26.
12 Chstopher Booker, .., . 135 274.
13 Christopher Essex and Ross citck. .., .
26-38.
14 &, , 11
, 18%
, i
11

2008,
,
, .

,

(20 13 ).

irrp (
,
"( <l"
Carbon Funds,
World Bank,
Asian Deelopment Bank.
" "
irr
" m" (.
, , .
. , .
11, 2010).

' ,
i

, ,

i

. u

VCI

15
m

, Guardian
1ime,
1985-1997, p
i.

(precautionary prin
ciple) Guardan
. Mark
Maslin, .., . 33-37.
16
World Wldlife Fund, National Wldlife

Federation, The Nature Conservan cy. Wl

demess Society pl NAFrA
. . Cockbum, ...

2011