Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Brief of Plaintiff and Counterclaim Defendant-Appellee Google

Brief of Plaintiff and Counterclaim Defendant-Appellee Google

Ratings: (0)|Views: 60|Likes:
Published by Eric Goldman

More info:

Published by: Eric Goldman on Apr 03, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

04/27/2012

pdf

text

original

 
20840-085
Otl\\i\l!~~
COURTOFAPPEALSTENTHAPPELLATEDISTRICTFRANKLINCOUNTY,OHIOGooglcInc.,CaseNo.t1AP-t003
PlaintiffandCountcrclaunDefendant,
v.
ONAPPEALFROMTHEFRANKLINCOUNTYCOMMONPLEASCOURTmyTriggers.com,Inc.,JudgeJohnP.Bessey
DefendantandCounterclaimPlamnff
RegularCalendarBRIEFOFPLAINTIFF/COUNTERCLAIMDEFENDANT-APPELLEEGOOGLEINC.
David
1.
Shroyer(0024099)ColleyShroyer
&
Abraham,LPA536SouthI-l1ghStreetColumbus,OH4.1215(()14)22t:1-()..j.53lames
A.
Wilson(0030704)
Kenneth
J.Rubin(0077819)Vorys,Sater,SeymourandPeaseLLP52East
Gay
Street,P.O.Box1008Columbus,OhIO43216-1008(614)464-5606
StanleyJVLChesley
W.13.MarkovitsWaite,Schneider,Bayless
&
ChesleyCo.,LPA1513Fourth
&
VineTower
I
WcstFourth
Street
Cincmnan,
01110
45202(51:))()21-0267Jonathan
M.
Jacobson(ProHacViceApplication
Pending)
WusonSonsiniGoodrich
&
Rosati,P.e.1301Avenueofthe
Americas
NewYork,NY10019(212)4~7-7700CharlesF.RulcJonathanKanterjoseph
J.
BialDalllcl
J.
HowleyCadwalader,Wickersham
&
TaftLLP70USixthStreet,N.W.Washington,DC2001(202)8(j2-2200
/1tt(J""~J'J
.fIJr
PIt/lIIl!!/
and
COllllklrl(/illlJ)~/~lId<IIII-_
/JppC/lecC(Jogle
JII~·.
·~II()m~J/.'orDtjeJId<1II1<lilt!C{JlIlIlI:rt:/llllll
P
/'Iilll(j}-./ippellcllll
lI(fI1iggfJ/:r.t"OIlI,
lilt.
,f?
~
..,...
~'
~
,-'>-)
-~:
~
...
.
.:':
..
-0/
....-..-1
r-;
-s
...:::.C::::-.
,
-'!_.~
s
&
.::r;--~
.......
...........'I
--&
~
~."0
"11
.
~-~.
'
c";j
<
r-:
~
....
'
::-
...
,).
.........
"":",./.
~
-:~.._'(v.
.....
).
..
~.~
,
........
........
March1,2012
 
20840-086
TABLEOFCONTENTS
"rl\BLEOFABBH..E.VIl\"rIONSviiCROSS-ASSIGNMENTSOFElU~ORPURSUANTTORC.2505.22viiiI.IN1"I~ODUC1"ION1II.S"rA"rEl"IJ~N'rOFTJ-IEC1\SE21\.ProceedingsBelow2B.FactualBackground31.AllegationsoftheSACC3NewandDiffercntAllegationsintheTACC7
lIT
S'fANDARDOFREVIE\'V'
7
IV.SUiVIIVIARYOF,\RGU1\:IEN'!'~
'v,
t\1~GU1"IEN1·
9
ATheVulcnnncActCounterclaimWasCorrectly
Disnusscd
91.No
antitrust
injury
9
NoconspIracy
14
B.TheMotionForLeavetoAmendWasCorrectlyDClUCdHi1.myTnggcrs'proposedamendmentimproperlycontradicteditsoriginalcounterclaim17Theproposedamendmentwasfutile193.my'TnggcrsdidnotshowthatItcould"marshalsupport"fortherevisedallegations244.Theamendmentwouldhavebeenunfairlyprejudicialifallowcd25C.AffirmanceIsAlsoAppropnateontheAlternativeGroundthattheInsufficiencyoftheConspiracyAllegationsDoomstheEnureClaim27D.AffirmanceIsAboAppropnatcontheAlternativeGroundthattheCOAPrecludesApplicationoftheValentineActHere30
\'I.
CONCLlTSION35CJ~I~1'lFIC1\·rE
or
SER\TICl~36
 
20840-087
TABLEOFAUTHORITIESCASES
At'/}/cIVrc(k"{gCo.
1/.
O'HollrkeCOI/.I"//:Co.,
1st.Dist,1995OhioApp.LEXIS745
(tvlar.
1,1995)10
·'111
'.
Fed.
I3lm'LlII
o]
Pn.IIJII.f,
552U.S.214(2008)34
..··J/llddOl1bopedir
Il.
"/y(Of-JeallhCare
Grp.
LP,
592F.3d991(9thCir.2010)11
___//}/I'/{/tl
I'._
·llJhlZlJluo/)/,
Inr.,
456F.3d1316(11thCir.2006)30
111.RltI!/ieldCo.
1'.
US·1
PdmlC/lI)/Co.,
495U.S.328(1990)10
B'!J'olI
1301l11l~!!,.
J
11(.
I'.
DrPet/>crCo.,
725F.2d300(5thCir.1984)30
I3r:1l/11/'1II11t'Corp.
/I.'/
i/lo/J/!J!.J',
550U.S.544(2007)
pa.Of/)/
Hdlo
I'.C'/)/"I'i.lio/l
~·1'1.
Corp..
587N.Y.S.2d1(1992)27
13m
E::;!;·I.
W·i:III.lklll
cl..
CO.
I'.
'11)/.
Olllillc
Inc.,
206F.3d980(10thCir.2000)31
J3ofkl///.MLI.I.fi/lolI
G(y
J(/!.
DI.I/.,
5thDist.,2011-0hio-58016
I3mll.IJvlkCorp.
/I.
Pllr:/;IoBIJ/III-O-/Hal./1/(:,429
U.S.477(1977)l
O,
11,12
Care
/-II/LlIII{g
&
Coolil{g
I'.
/1m.SId.,/1It'.,
427F.3d100~(6th
Or.
2005)11
CBC
DJ.f.
I'.
E.qIllJil.'\·.
[1It'.,
501F.3d569(6thCir.2009)10,21
CIII(llllltlli
[1/.1.
Co.
fl.
I.
·olk.I1J'i{g('1/!/..Im.•/1/(:,
4101110App.3d239(10th
Dist.
1987)23
Ciml/o
I'.
Heartbeat»
r!/Lit'kil/gCI/D'.,
5thDist.,2010-01110-423816
CollI/}//m.1Pa(kil/gCo.
p.
SInk,
106OhioSt.469(1922)28
COjJp('17I
1
r!/d
Corp.
I'.
J
IIdep.
Tnbe
Cort»,
467U.S.752(19~4)29
GiIIl('
c
N
Shol,r!/Jall'.1
Corp.
I'.
1311tYI7lJ-EI'lt'
Co.,
854F.2d802(6thCir.1988)11,19
DlIi~)1MOI/IIIJ/(!1I1Co.
p.
C/VII'"/-Jill
Cr:1IJt?!('~jI
AJ.I
'II,
114OhioApp.143(9thDist,19(1)28
DldddoBlt',:,
11,,:
I'.
NOI'llII~l'BII/,:Co.,
9thDist.,1994OhioApp.LEXIS2728(lune22,1994)28
DiGiO/l,11)
I'.
Ci!J
oj
OI//.'I'/'lIId,
8th
Dist.,
2011-0hio-5~7816
DIIJ/idoJllkh
/1.
131'11
c.\"
L-foJlldl,
~03F.2d1473(9thCu.1986)27
DOl/alo
Il.
Moldo»,
865A.2d711
(N.J.
Super.Ct.2005)34,35
11

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->