Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more ➡
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Add note
Save to My Library
Sync to mobile
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
×
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Reply Brief of Defendent and Counterclaim Plaintiff-Appellant My Triggers

Reply Brief of Defendent and Counterclaim Plaintiff-Appellant My Triggers

Ratings: (0)|Views: 936|Likes:
Published by Eric Goldman

More info:

Published by: Eric Goldman on Apr 03, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See More
See less

04/28/2012

pdf

text

original

 
..
,
nRI~INAL
....,
-"·~0~
)
c:::a
:;/~
~.~
....,
fT1
::E
::;'
_-
)
;
""--l"
~-.
r-":
c:>:~
0
N
:;:;:r---
."
W
....::..fT1
CJ
-0
'~-OO
Cl
::x
G_
'J
c:
z:-
C·
~1
:;.(l
..
""
_::r-
--!
"
"-
(,f)
W
-_'"I-
N
'--
(
~
,
,
,
20847-026
COURTOFAPPEALSTENTHAPPELLATEDISTRICTFRANKLINCOUNTY,OHIOMYTRIGGERS.COM,INC.,
CaseNo.11AP-I003
Plaintiff-Appellant,
v.
ONAPPEALFROMTHEFRANKLINCOUNTY,OHIOCOURTOFCOMMONPLEAS
OOGLE,INC.,
Defendant-Appellee.
REPLYBRIEFOFDEFENDANTANDCOUNTERCLAIMPLAINTIFF-APPELLANTMYTRIGGERS.COM,INC.
David
I.
Shroyer
COLLEYSHROYER
&
ABRAHAM,L.P.A.
HosterandHighBuilding536SouthHighStreetColumbus,OH43215-5674Telephone:(614)228-6453StanleyM.ChesleyW.B.Markovits
WAITE,SCHNEIDER,BAYLESS
&
CHESLEYCO.,L.P.A.
1513Fourth
&
VineTowerIWestFourthStreetCincinnati,OH45202Telephone:(513)621-0267CharlesF.Rule
(ProHacVice)
JonathanKanter
(ProHacVice)
JosephJ.Bial
(ProHacVice)
DanielJ.Howley
(ProHacVice)
DerekW.Moore
(ProHacVice)
CADWALADER,WICKERSHAM
&
TAFTLLP
700SixthStreet,N.W.Washington,DC2000ITelephone:(202)862-2200
AttorneysforPlaintiff-Appellantmy'Iriggers.com.Tnc.
 
20847-027
TABLEOFCONTENTS
Contents
I.Introduction.....................................................................................................1II.FactualBackground2III.mytriggers'ValentineActClaimWasImproperlyDismissed3A.myTriggershasAdequatelyAllegedAntitrustInjury3B.myTriggershasAdequatelyAllegedUnlawfulConspiratorialAgreements7IV.TheTrialCourtErredinDenyingmyTriggers'MotionforLeavetoAmend9V.Google'sCross-Appeals13A.TheValentineActProscribes"Unilateral"Conduct14B.TheCommunicationsDecencyActDoesNotPreemptStateAntitrustLaws18VI.Conclusion20
-1-
 
20847-028
TABLEOFAUTHORITIES
CASES
AcmeWreckingCo..Inc.v.O'RourkeConst.Co.
(OhioApp.1stDist.1995),1995WL841885
Almediav.Amazon.com.Inc.
(lithCir.2006),456F.3d1316'"19
BrownShoeCo.
v,
UnitedStates
(1962),370U.S.2945
BenEzra.Weinstein
&
Co.v.Am.OnlineInc.
(10thCir.2000),206F.3d98019
BrunswickCOIp.v.PuebloBowl-O-Mat.Inc.
(1977),429U.S.4775,6
CentOhioSaltCo.v.Guthrie
(1880),35OhioSt.66615
Crane
&
Shovelv.Buycrus-ErieCo.
(6thCir.1980),854F.2d8026
DartDrugCorp.v.Parke.Davis
&
Co.
(D.C.Cir.1065),344F.2d17317
e3601llsightLLCv.ComcastCOIp.
(N.D.Ill.2008),546F.Supp.2d60519
FTCv.Beech-NutPackingCo.
(1922).257U.S.4418
Goddardv.Google,Inc.
(N.D.Cal.2008),2008WL524549018.20
HolomaxxTechs.Corp.v.MicrosoftCOIp.
(N.D.Cal.2011),2011U.S.Dist.LEXIS94311619
Hooverv.Smith
(1984),12OhioSt.3d19,13
fndeckEnergySen's.v.ConsumersEnergyCo.
(6thCir.2000),250F.3d9726
Kinderstart.com,LLCv.GoogleInc.
(N.D.Cal.2007),2007U.S.Dist.LEXIS2263712
Kissengerv.ColumbusMacadamCo.
(OhioCom.PI.1900).11OhioDec.13715
KIOI"s,Inc.v.Broadway-HaleStores
(1959),359U.S.2075.6
-11-

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->