Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword or section
Like this
4Activity

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Nuclear Power - Scholars

Nuclear Power - Scholars

Ratings: (0)|Views: 7,817|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Dec 16, 2008
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

10/16/2011

pdf

text

original

 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
1ScholarsNuclear Power Good/Bad
***NP DA***.................................................................................................................................................................7 NP Good DA – Shell.......................................................................................................................................................8 NP Good DA – Unq – NP High Now..............................................................................................................................9 NP Good DA – Link – ↑ Alt. Energy ↓ NP...................................................................................................................10 NP Bad DA – Shell........................................................................................................................................................11 NP Bad DA – Link – ↑ Alt Energy ↑ NP.......................................................................................................................12 NP Bad DA – Link – Cap and trade ↑ NP.....................................................................................................................13 NP Bad DA – Link - Carbon Tax ↑ NP.........................................................................................................................14 NP Bad DA – Link - CO2 Emission Restrictions ↑ NP................................................................................................15 NP DA – Unq – Alt Energy Low Now..........................................................................................................................16 NP DA N/U Alt Energy Increasing Now...............................................................................................................17***NP Good***............................................................................................................................................................18***Electricity***..........................................................................................................................................................19 NP Good - Electricity Scenario 1/2...............................................................................................................................20 NP Good - Electricity Scenario 2/2...............................................................................................................................21 NP Good – Electricity - Demand Risks Blackouts.......................................................................................................22 NP Good – Electricity - Blackout=Economic Collapse................................................................................................23 NP Good Electricity - NP Solves Blackouts.............................................................................................................24AT: Electricity – No Blackouts.....................................................................................................................................25AT: Electricity – No Impact - Blackouts ......................................................................................................................26***Warming***............................................................................................................................................................27 NP Good - Solves Warming .........................................................................................................................................28 NP Good - Warming - A/T: NP produces greenhouse gases.........................................................................................31 NP Good - Global warming outweighs.........................................................................................................................33AT: Warming – No Solvency - Timeframe....................................................................................................................34AT: Warming No Solvency GHG Emissions.........................................................................................................37AT: Warming – No Solvency – Requires 1500 Plants..................................................................................................39AT: Warming - No solvency – Transportation Overwhelms.........................................................................................40AT: Warming – No Solvency – capacity.......................................................................................................................41AT: Warming – No Solency – cost................................................................................................................................42AT: Warming - Impact Calculus: NP Risks o/w Warming............................................................................................43***Energy Independence***........................................................................................................................................44 NP Good - Energy Independence Scenario...................................................................................................................45 NP Good – Energy Independence – US Dependent SQ................................................................................................46Energy Independence – Impact – Wars.........................................................................................................................47Energy Independence – NP Solves...............................................................................................................................48AT: Energy Independence ...........................................................................................................................................50***Hegemony***.........................................................................................................................................................51 NP Good Heg Scenario 1/2.......................................................................................................................................52 NP Good – Heg Scenario 2/2........................................................................................................................................53 NP Good – Heg – NP Key to Leadership......................................................................................................................54 NP Good – Heg – Technical Leadership.......................................................................................................................56AT: Technical Leadership – US Leader SQ..................................................................................................................57***Space***.................................................................................................................................................................58 NP Good – Space Scenario 1/2.....................................................................................................................................59 NP Good – Space -Uniqueness.....................................................................................................................................60 NP Good – Industry Expansion key to Space...............................................................................................................61 NP Good – Space - Key to Colonization.......................................................................................................................62 NP Good – Space – Colonization O/W.........................................................................................................................66 NP Good – Space – AT: Solar Solves............................................................................................................................67 NP Good - Space - militarization inevitable................................................................................................................68 NP Good – Space - Militarization key to Heg..............................................................................................................69AT: Space – Exploration = Militarization.....................................................................................................................70AT: Space – Militarization = extinction........................................................................................................................72***Coal***...................................................................................................................................................................73 NP Good - Coal Scenario.............................................................................................................................................74 NP Good – Replaces Coal.............................................................................................................................................75
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
2ScholarsNuclear Power Good/Bad
 NP Good - Coal Hurts Environment.............................................................................................................................76AT: Coal - No Tradeoff.................................................................................................................................................77***Medical Isotopes***...............................................................................................................................................78 NP Good – Medical Isotopes Scenario 1/2...................................................................................................................79 NP Good – Medical Isotopes Scenario 2/2...................................................................................................................80 NP Good – Medical Isotopes - Shortage.......................................................................................................................81 NP Good – Medical Isotopes – Key US Health System...............................................................................................82 NP Good – Medical Isotopes -Solves AIDS.................................................................................................................83 NP Good – Medical Isotopes - Solves AIDS- Diagnosis 1/2........................................................................................84 NP Good – Medical Isotopes - Solves AIDS- Diagnosis 2/2........................................................................................85 NP Good – Medical Isotopes - Solves AIDS- Diagnosis Ext. .....................................................................................86 NP Good – Medical Isotopes – Cancer.........................................................................................................................87AT: Medical Isotopes – No Shortage............................................................................................................................88AT: Medical Isotopes – AT: AIDS Impact.....................................................................................................................89***NP Bad***..............................................................................................................................................................90 NP Bad – Laundry List..................................................................................................................................................91***Terrorism – Attacks***...........................................................................................................................................92 NP Bad – Attacks Scenario...........................................................................................................................................93 NP Bad – Attacks – NP Plants Targeted........................................................................................................................94 NP Bad - Attack - NP Plants High Risk.......................................................................................................................95 NP Bad – Attacks – Impact - Extinction.......................................................................................................................96 NP Bad Attacks - Impact- 100,000s people..............................................................................................................97 NP Bad – Attacks – Impact - Radiation........................................................................................................................99 NP bad – Attacks – Impact - Economy.......................................................................................................................100 NP bad – Attacks – Impact - Econ Internal link..........................................................................................................101 NP bad – Attacks – Impact - Econ Internal link..........................................................................................................102NP Bad – Attacks - Fuel pools ..................................................................................................................................104 NP Bad – Attacks – AT: Plants Secure........................................................................................................................105 NP Bad – Attacks - A2: Attack Impacts Exaggerated.................................................................................................107 NP Bad – Attacks - A2: Facilities won’t explode........................................................................................................108AT: Attacks – Low Risk..............................................................................................................................................109AT: Attack – Plants Secure..........................................................................................................................................110AT: Attack – No Impacts.............................................................................................................................................111***Terrorism – Theft***.............................................................................................................................................112 NP Bad – Theft - Scenario...........................................................................................................................................113 NP Bad – Theft – Link Ext..........................................................................................................................................114AT: Theft – Security Solves........................................................................................................................................115AT: Theft – No Technical Expertise............................................................................................................................116AT: Theft – No Impact – Dirty Bombs........................................................................................................................117AT: Theft – No Impact – Suitcase Nukes....................................................................................................................118***Proliferation***.....................................................................................................................................................119 NP Bad – Prolif Scenario............................................................................................................................................120 NP Bad Prolif - Link Ext.........................................................................................................................................121 NP Bad Prolif - Link - Breeder Reactors...............................................................................................................124AT: Prolif – No Link...................................................................................................................................................125AT: Prolif - Leadership Solves....................................................................................................................................126AT: Prolif - Inevitable.................................................................................................................................................127***Organized Crime***.............................................................................................................................................128 NP Bad - Organized Crime Scenario 1/2....................................................................................................................129 NP Bad - Organized Crime Scenario 2/2....................................................................................................................130AT: Organized Crime..................................................................................................................................................131AT:Organized Crime – No Economy Impact..............................................................................................................132***Accidents***.........................................................................................................................................................133 NP Bad - Accidents.....................................................................................................................................................134AT: Accidents..............................................................................................................................................................138***Natural Disasters***.............................................................................................................................................140 NP Bad - Natural Disasters ........................................................................................................................................141
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
3ScholarsNuclear Power Good/Bad
AT: Natural Disasters..................................................................................................................................................142***Environment***....................................................................................................................................................143 NP Bad - Water Pollution Scenario.............................................................................................................................144 NP Bad – Water Pollution – Link Ext.........................................................................................................................145 NP Bad – Ocean Pollution Scenario...........................................................................................................................146 NP Bad – Species Scenario.........................................................................................................................................147AT: Pollution...............................................................................................................................................................148***Human Health***.................................................................................................................................................149 NP Bad - Radiation - Extinction ................................................................................................................................150 NP Bad - Radiation = Cancer......................................................................................................................................151 NP Bad - Radiation = Mutation .................................................................................................................................152 NP Bad - Mutations = Extinction................................................................................................................................153AT: Radiation – Radiation Good.................................................................................................................................154AT: Radiation - Very small amounts...........................................................................................................................156A2: Plutonium Dangerous for Health.........................................................................................................................157****Nuclear Waste****.............................................................................................................................................159Waste Impact – Radiation = Death..............................................................................................................................160AT: Waste – Impacts Exaggerated...............................................................................................................................161AT: Waste Impacts - Radioactivity natural..................................................................................................................162AT: Waste Impacts – small quantities.........................................................................................................................163AT: Waste Impacts – ≠ Death......................................................................................................................................164AT: Waste Impacts – No Transport Risk.....................................................................................................................165 No New Plants w/o Waste Plan [1/2]..........................................................................................................................166 No New Plants w/o Waste Plan-Social Acceptance [1/2]...........................................................................................168 New Plants w/o Disposal Plan [1/4]...........................................................................................................................170 New Plants w/o Disposal Plan-Social Acceptance [1/1].............................................................................................174Yucca Bad DA – Shell [1/3]........................................................................................................................................175Yucca Bad DA-1NC [2/3]...........................................................................................................................................176Yucca Bad DA-1NC [3/3]...........................................................................................................................................177Yucca Bad-Uniqueness-Won’t Open [1/2]..................................................................................................................178Yucca Bad-Uniqueness-Won’t Open-Obama .............................................................................................................180Yucca Bad-Link-New Plants.......................................................................................................................................181Yucca Bad-Link Ext/AT: Won’t open till 2010...........................................................................................................182Yucca Bad-Internal-Plan’s Dumped At Yucca [1/1]....................................................................................................183Yucca Bad-Transport-Terrorism..................................................................................................................................184Yucca Bad-Earthquakes-Plutonium Leaks..................................................................................................................185Yucca Bad-Waste Leak Inevitable..............................................................................................................................186Yucca Bad-Geologically Unstable-Floods..................................................................................................................187Yucca Bad-Water Contamination-Ground Water........................................................................................................188Yucca Bad-Water Contamination-Water Table...........................................................................................................189Yucca Bad-Transportation-Accidents.........................................................................................................................190Yucca Bad-Transportation-Radiation..........................................................................................................................191Yucca Bad-Volcanoes..................................................................................................................................................192Yucca Bad-Won’t Solve-Rainwater............................................................................................................................193Yucca Bad-Won’t Solve-Rock fall & Microbes..........................................................................................................194Yucca Good-Uniqueness-Will Open [1/2]..................................................................................................................196Yucca Good – AT: DA - Link Turn.............................................................................................................................198Yucca Good-Nuclear Leadership................................................................................................................................199Yucca Good-Stops Reprocessing-GNEP [1/1]............................................................................................................200Yucca Good-Stops Reprocessing-GNEP-Prolif..........................................................................................................201Yucca Good-k2 Solve Waste.......................................................................................................................................202Yucca Good-Terrorism................................................................................................................................................203Yucca Good –Better than Dry Cask Storage...............................................................................................................204Yucca Good – TAD Storage solves.............................................................................................................................205Yucca Good-Environmentally Neutral........................................................................................................................206Yucca Good-Stops Interim Storage.............................................................................................................................207Yucca Good-Stops On Site Storage............................................................................................................................208

Activity (4)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
mgalalm liked this
Kcross9 liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->