Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
13Activity
P. 1
[TechCrunch]: Denial of Motion To Dismiss Antitrust Case Against Apple, Google, Intel, Intuit, Adobe, Pixar, and Lucasfilm

[TechCrunch]: Denial of Motion To Dismiss Antitrust Case Against Apple, Google, Intel, Intuit, Adobe, Pixar, and Lucasfilm

Ratings: (0)|Views: 53,561 |Likes:
Published by TechCrunch
Read analysis of why the motion was dismissed and what happens next in the antitrust case at TechCrunch http://techcrunch.com/2012/04/19/steve-jobs-antitrust/
Read analysis of why the motion was dismissed and what happens next in the antitrust case at TechCrunch http://techcrunch.com/2012/04/19/steve-jobs-antitrust/

More info:

Published by: TechCrunch on Apr 19, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See more
See less

07/10/2013

 
 
0
C`sm Oe/; 00'CQ'62=6>'LJIERDMR HR@OTNOH NO V@RT @OD DMO^NOH NO V@RT DMAMOD@OTS„ KENOT GETNEO TE DNSGNSS9 DMO^NOHL]C@SANLG„S GETNEO TE DNSGNSS
0234=18:>06000203040=01080:0>26202223242=21282:
   ]  o   n   t  m   d   S   t  `   t  m  s   D   n  s   t  r   n  c   t   C  e  }  r   t
   A  e  r   t   j  m   O  e  r   t   j  m  r  o   D   n  s   t  r   n  c   t  e   a   C  `   l   n   a  e  r  o   n  `
 ]ONTMD ST@TMS DNSTRNCT CE]RTOERTJMRO DNSTRNCT EA C@LNAERON@S@O KESM DNQNSNEONO RM; JNHJ'TMCJ MGVLE^MM@OTNTR]ST LNTNH@TNEOG`stmr Decimt Oe/ 00'CQ'62=6>'LJI
ERDMR HR@OTNOH NO V@RT @ODDMO^NOH NO V@RT DMAMOD@OTS„KENOT GETNEO TE DNSGNSS9DMO^NOH L]C@SANLG LTD/„SGETNEO TE DNSGNSS
TJNS DEC]GMOT RML@TMS TE;
@LL @CTNEOS
 Bmaerm tjm Ce}rt `rm Dmamod`ots„ Kenot Getneo te Dnsgnss tjm Ceoselnd`tmd @gmodmdCegvl`not *“Kenot Get/‗., MCA Oe/ 8>, `od Dmamod`ot L}c`sanlg Ltd/„s Getneo te Dnsgnss*“L}c`sanlg Get/‗., MCA Oe/ :3/ Tjm Ce}rt jmld ` jm`rnoh eo tjm getneos eo K`o}`r~ 21, 2602/J`qnoh ceosndmrmd tjm v`rtnms„ s}bgnssneos, `rh}gmots, `od tjm rmlmq`ot l`x, tjm Ce}rt HR@OTSNO V@RT `od DMONMS NO V@RT Dmamod`ots„ kenot getneo te dnsgnss, `od DMONMS L}c`sanlg„sgetneo te dnsgnss/
N/
 
B@CIHRE]OD
Tjns ns ` ceoselnd`tmd cl`ss `ctneo bre}hjt b~ mgvle~mms `llmhnoh `otntr}st cl`ngs `h`nosttjmnr mgvle~mrs, `ll ea xjeg `rm jnhj'tmcj cegv`onms xntj ` vrnocnv`l vl`cm ea b}snomss no tjm S`oAr`ocnsce'Snlnceo Q`llm~ `rm` ea C`lnaeron`/ Vl`notnaas cj`llmohm `o `llmhmd ceosvnr`c~ `geohDmamod`ots te anz `od s}vvrmss mgvle~mm cegvmos`tneo `od te rmstrnct mgvle~mm gebnlnt~/
C`sm=;00'cq'62=6>'LJI Dec}gmot00> Anlmd64%0:%02 V`hm0 ea 2>
 
 
2
C`sm Oe/; 00'CQ'62=6>'LJIERDMR HR@OTNOH NO V@RT @OD DMO^NOH NO V@RT DMAMOD@OTS„ KENOT GETNEO TE DNSGNSS9 DMO^NOHL]C@SANLG„S GETNEO TE DNSGNSS
0234=18:>06000203040=01080:0>26202223242=21282:
   ]  o   n   t  m   d   S   t  `   t  m  s   D   n  s   t  r   n  c   t   C  e  }  r   t
   A  e  r   t   j  m   O  e  r   t   j  m  r  o   D   n  s   t  r   n  c   t  e   a   C  `   l   n   a  e  r  o   n  `
Tjm Ce}rt rmcntms tjm a`ct}`l `llmh`tneos `s vlmd no tjm Ceoselnd`tmd @gmodmd Cegvl`not*“C@C‗., MCA Oe/ 1=, `od `s nodnc`tmd no k}dncn`ll~ oetncmd dec}gmots/ Tjm Ce}rt tjmo rmce}otstjm vrecmd}r`l b`cihre}od/
@/
 
A`ct}`l B`cihre}od
]olmss etjmrxnsm oetmd, tjm aellexnoh `llmh`tneos `rm t`imo areg tjm C@C `od vrms}gmd tebm tr}m aer v}rvesms ea r}lnoh eo Dmamod`ots„ getneos te dnsgnss/
Smm G`rdmr q/ Levm{
, 4=6 A/3d44=, 448 o/0 *>tj Cnr/ 2661./ Tjm Ce}rt `lse t`ims k}dncn`l oetncm ea dec}gmots areg ` rml`tmdDmv`rtgmot ea K}stncm *“DEK‗. noqmstnh`tneo `od cnqnl l`xs}nt tj`t `rm rmamrmocmd no tjm C@C er`tt`cjmd `s mzjnbnts te tjm Dmcl`r`tneo ea Cjrnstno` K/ Brexo *“Brexo Dmcl/‗., MCA Oe/ 8>'0, `odtjm Dmcl`r`tneo ea Dm`o G/ J`rqm~ *J`rqm~ Dmcl/‗., MCA Oe/ >3/ @ ce}rt “g`~ t`im oetncm ea vrecmmdnohs no etjmr ce}rts, betj xntjno `od xntje}t tjm amdmr`l k}dncn`l s~stmg, na tjesmvrecmmdnohs j`qm ` dnrmct rml`tneo te g`ttmrs `t nss}m/‗
]ontmd St`tms mz rml/ Rebnoseo R`ocjmrn`Cntn{mos Ce}ocnl q/ Berome, Noc/
, >80 A/2d 244, 24: *>tj Cnr/ 0>>2./ @ ce}rt g`~ `lse t`im k}dncn`loetncm ea tjm mznstmocm ea g`ttmrs ea v}blnc rmcerd, s}cj `s ` vrner erdmr er dmcnsneo, b}t oet tjmtr}tj ea tjm a`cts cntmd tjmrmno/
Smm Lmm q/ Cnt~ ea L/@/
, 2=6 A/3d 11:, 1:>'>6 *>tj Cnr/ 2660./ TjmCe}rt g`~ ceosndmr dec}gmots rmamrmocmd no, b}t oet `tt`cjmd te ` cegvl`not xntje}t ceoqmrtnoh `getneo te dnsgnss note eom smminoh s}gg`r~ k}dhgmot/
Smm Sx`rt{ q/ IVGH LLV
, 481 A/3d 8=1,813 *>tj Cnr/ 2668./
0/
 
Tjm V`rtnms
Dmamod`ots nocl}dm tjm aellexnoh jnhj'tmcj cegv`onms xntj vrnocnv`l vl`cms ea b}snomsslec`tmd no tjm aellexnoh cntnms no C`lnaeron`; @debm S~stmgs Noc/ *“@debm‗., S`o Kesm9 @vvlm Noc/*“@vvlm‗., C}vmrtnoe9 Heehlm Noc/ *“Heehlm‗., Ge}ot`no Qnmx9 Notml Cerv/ *“Notml‗., S`ot` Cl`r`9Not}nt Noc/ *“Not}nt‗., S`ot` Cl`r`9 L}c`sanlg Ltd/ *“L}c`sanlg‗., S`o Ar`ocnsce9 `od Vnz`r,Mgmr~qnllm/ C@C
 
 ±± 01'26/Vl`notnaas Gncj`ml Dmqnom, G`ri Ancjtomr, Snddj`rtj J`rnj`r`o, Br`odeo G`rsj`ll, `odD`onml Steqmr *cellmctnqml~ “O`gmd Vl`notnaas‗., `ll xerimd `s seatx`rm mohnommrs aer segm ea tjmDmamod`ots/
 Nd 
/ ±± 20'28/ Gr/ Dmqnom xerimd aer @debm no tjm St`tm ea X`sjnohteo areg Ectebmr
C`sm=;00'cq'62=6>'LJI Dec}gmot00> Anlmd64%0:%02 V`hm2 ea 2>
 
 
3
C`sm Oe/; 00'CQ'62=6>'LJIERDMR HR@OTNOH NO V@RT @OD DMO^NOH NO V@RT DMAMOD@OTS„ KENOT GETNEO TE DNSGNSS9 DMO^NOHL]C@SANLG„S GETNEO TE DNSGNSS
0234=18:>06000203040=01080:0>26202223242=21282:
   ]  o   n   t  m   d   S   t  `   t  m  s   D   n  s   t  r   n  c   t   C  e  }  r   t
   A  e  r   t   j  m   O  e  r   t   j  m  r  o   D   n  s   t  r   n  c   t  e   a   C  `   l   n   a  e  r  o   n  `
2661, tjre}hj K}l~ 8, 266:/
 Nd/
± 01/ Gr/ Ancjtomr xerimd aer Notml no @rn{eo` areg G`~ 266:tjre}hj G`~ 2600/
 Nd/
 ± 08/ Gr/ J`rnj`r`o xerimd aer L}c`sanlg no C`lnaeron` areg K`o}`r~ :,2668, tjre}hj @}h}st 0=, 266:/
 Nd/
 ± 0:/ Gr/ G`rsj`ll xerimd aer @debm no C`lnaeron` areg K}l~2661 tjre}hj Dmcmgbmr 2661/
 Nd/
 ± 0>/ Ano`ll~, Gr/ Steqmr xerimd aer Not}nt no C`lnaeron` aregK}l~ 2661 tjre}hj Dmcmgbmr 2606/
 Nd/
 ± 26/O`gmd Vl`notnaas v}rvert te rmvrmsmot tjm aellexnoh o`tneoxndm cl`ss ea sngnl`rl~ snt}`tmdnodnqnd}`ls;@ll o`t}r`l vmrseos mgvle~md b~ Dmamod`ots no tjm ]ontmd St`tms eo ` s`l`rnmd b`snsd}rnoh tjm vmrned areg K`o}`r~ 0, 266= tjre}hj K`o}`r~ 0, 2606 *tjm “Cl`ssVmrned‗./ Mzcl}dmd areg tjm Cl`ss `rm; rmt`nl mgvle~mms9 cerver`tm eaancmrs,gmgbmrs ea tjm be`rds ea dnrmcters, `od smoner mzmc}tnqms ea Dmamod`ots xjemotmrmd note tjm nllncnt `hrmmgmots `llmhmd jmrmno9 `od `o~ `od `ll k}dhms `od k}stncms, `od cj`gbmrsst`aa, `ssnhomd te jm`r er `dk}dnc`tm `o~ `svmct ea tjnslntnh`tneo/
 Nd/
 ± 36/
2/
 
DEK Noqmstnh`tneo
G`o~ ea tjm a`ct}`l `llmh`tneos no tjm C@C cegm dnrmctl~ areg txe cnqnl cegvl`nots anlmdb~ tjm DEK no tjm ]ontmd St`tms Dnstrnct Ce}rt aer tjm Dnstrnct ea Cel}gbn` *tjm “D/C/ DnstrnctCe}rt‗./
Smm
Kenot Get/ ='1/ Vl`notnaas rmamrmocm tjmsm dec}gmots no tjm C@C, `od betjDmamod`ots `od Vl`notnaas j`qm `tt`cjmd dec}gmots areg tjm DEK l`xs}nt te tjmnr brnmanoh/
Smm
J`rqm~ Dmcl/ Mzs/ @'B9 Brexo Dmcl/ Mzs/ @'A/Areg 266> tjre}hj 2606, tjm @otntr}st Dnqnsneo ea tjm DEK ceod}ctmd `o noqmstnh`tneo noteDmamod`ots„ mgvle~gmot `od rmcr}ntgmot vr`ctncms/ C@C
 
 ±± 3, 000/ @atmr rmcmnqnoh dec}gmotsvred}cmd b~ Dmamod`ots `od notmrqnmxnoh xntomssms, tjm DEK ceocl}dmd tj`t Dmamod`ots rm`cjmd“a`cn`ll~ `otncegvmtntnqm‗ `hrmmgmots tj`t “mlngno`tmd ` snhonanc`ot aerg ea cegvmtntneo / / / te tjmdmtrngmot ea tjm `aamctmd mgvle~mms xje xmrm lniml~ dmvrnqmd ea cegvmtntnqml~ ngvert`otnoaerg`tneo `od `ccmss te bmttmr keb evvert}ontnms/DEK Cegvl`not `h`nost @debm, mt `l/ *“DEK@debm Cegvl/‗., J`rqm~ Dmcl/ Mz/ @, `t ±± 2, 049 DEK Cegvl`not `h`nost L}c`sanlg *“DEKL}c`sanlg Cegvl/‗., J`rqm~ Dmcl/ Mz/ D, `t ±± 2, 0=, 229 C@C
 
 ± 002/ Tjm DEK `lse dmtmrgnomdtj`t tjm `hrmmgmots “xmrm oet `ocnll`r~ te `o~ lmhntng`tm cell`ber`tneo,‗ “xmrm g}cj bre`dmr tj`o
C`sm=;00'cq'62=6>'LJI Dec}gmot00> Anlmd64%0:%02 V`hm3 ea 2>

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->