BBC News - Is Gujarat's red hot economy a myth?

PIN BBC TO YOUR TASKBAR BY DRAGGING THIS ICON

News Sport Weather Travel

TO THE BOTTOM OF THE SCREEN

Future TV Radio More
Search

Close

INDIA
Home UK Africa Asia Europe India
ADVERTISEMENT

Latin America

Mid-East

US & Canada

Business

Health

Sci/Environment

Tech

Entertainment

Video

Asia Business

China

2 May 2012 Last updated at 10:20 GMT

Share

Top Stories
China activist leaves US embassy

Soutik Biswas
Delhi correspondent
More from Soutik Eight protesters killed in Cairo Obama pledges end to Afghan war BSkyB says it is 'fit and proper' Iceman's blood is world's oldest
ADVERTISEMENT

Is Gujarat's red hot economy a myth?

COMMENTS

Is Gujarat's so-called red-hot economic growth a myth peddled by the government of the controversial chief minister Narendra Modi? Mr Modi, who was blamed for not doing enough to stop the horrific 2002 anti-Muslim riots in the state after the burning of a train carrying Hindu pilgrims, has modelled himself as a no-nonsense economic reformer leading one of India's fastest-growing states. In March, a senior minister of his cabinet told me that Gujarat has been recording scorching double-digit growth, prompting even The Economist magazine to call it India's Guangdong. "Modi Means Business" said Time magazine when it put him on the cover recently. But a raft of recent articles in the Indian media suggest that that Mr Modi's claims may be overblown.

Mr Modi has become synonymous with Gujarat's growth

Examining data on the economic performance of Indian states during a seven-year-period - 2004-11 - AK Bhattacharya, editor of Business Standard, is puzzled by Gujarat's performance. He finds that its economy grew by 6.3% annually during this period, up from average growth every year of 3.6% - a relatively low base - in a 10year period ending 2003.

Related Stories
Has Gujarat moved on since 2002's riots? An image makeover for Narendra Modi?

'Breakout' state?
More interestingly, states like Uttarkhand (13.2%), Bihar (10.9%), Maharashtra (10.7%), Tamil Nadu (10.4%) and Haryana (10.1%) recorded double-digit growth in the seven-year period under review. None of these states have the kind of hype associated with them as does Mr Modi's Gujarat, which is often called the most business friendly state in India.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-17919364[5/2/2012 4:12:52 PM]

BBC News - Is Gujarat's red hot economy a myth?

Of the five states with double-digit growth, Mr Bhattacharya notes, three are ruled by the Congress party, which has come under fire in the capital for going slow on economic reforms! So is Gujarat really the "breakout" state that Mr Modi wants the world to believe? "It has seen the most stable of governments for the last several years," Mr Bhattacharya writes. "And yet, it has seen its growth hovering around 6% for the last seven years." Is there something amiss? Analyst Salil Tripathi has written about how "of all the hype surrounding Mr Modi, the oddest are some of the claims concerning the state's economic performance". Gujarat, he says, "has done well in recent years, but it lost ground soon after the riots, picking up pace only later". Mr Tripathi writes about how states like Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh have bigger economies, and Gujarat actually spends more than it has earned, thus depleting its surpluses. Gujarat also signed on to a fiscal responsibility law only after five other states did, and 20 states preceded Gujarat in implementing value added tax. I have written in the past on how Gujarat fares the worst among Indian states in terms of overall hunger and malnutrition - 45% of children there are malnourished, according to the latest Indian Human Development report. The state also has a poor record in checking infant and maternal mortality. And as journalist Hartosh Singh Bal pointed out recently, Gujarat's ranking among states in terms of literacy (18th) had actually slipped one place, the year Mr Modi took over. "These figures belie Mr Modi's reputation as an efficient administrator" he wrote. "But you wouldn't know it reading the foreign media." So is Mr Modi a spinmeister or is there something everybody is missing?

Features & Analysis

Mystery guest
The night Osama Bin Laden came to dinner

Going underground
Can New Yorkers escape the jam to a subterranean park?

One's foreign trips

How well travelled are you compared with the Queen?

Cracked firewall?
Why China's attempts to control the web could backfire

Most Popular
Shared
Have you been where the Queen's been? Bilingualism 'enriches the brain' PE lessons 'put girls off sport' Iceman's blood is world's oldest Suu Kyi enters Burma parliament

Read
China activist leaves US embassy When Osama Bin Laden came for dinner Have you been where the Queen's been? Bodyguard star: 'I'm not Whitney' MI6 death: 'No unlawful killing' Gay Mitt Romney spokesman resigns Iceman's blood is world's oldest PE lessons 'put girls off sport' Italy joblessness at 12-year high

Your comments

Soutik Biswas
Delhi correspondent
More from Soutik

A different innings for Sachin Tendulkar

07:44 UK time, Monday, 30 April 2012 India will be watching how its cricketing god Sachin Tendulkar bats as a member of parliament. Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories
Has Gujarat moved on since 2002's riots? 01 MARCH 2012 , INDIA An image makeover for Narendra Modi? 19 SEPTEMBER 2011 , SOUTH ASIA

Six killed at Cairo demonstration

Video/Audio
New York's underground park of the future Passer-by pushes suicide man off bridge Paxman tackles Barton on England boss

Comments
Be the first to comment

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-17919364[5/2/2012 4:12:52 PM]

BBC News - Is Gujarat's red hot economy a myth?

Sign in or register to comment and rate comments. All posts are pre-moderated and must obey the house rules.

Tourists rescued from top of statue Woman admits to Tube racist rant

Share this page

6 Share

One-minute World News Japanese Harley washes up in Canada Burma opens up for tourists Obama's Afghan speech in full Tornado filmed in southern France

Elsewhere on BBC News

Speeding up growth
How one African state has left war behind and beaten most of Europe to 4G

Programmes

Fast Track
What can visitors to Burma expect as the country returns to the tourist map?

ADS BY GOOGLE

Beauty Tips For Your Skin

Gift your skin Kaya services for long lasting skin beauty. Apply Now KayaClinic.com

Roubini Global Economics

Nouriel Roubini & RGE's Analysts Examine Critical Economic Issues www.roubini.com

16 GB Pen Drive @ 499

Sandisk 16GB at 67% Off. Pay Cash on Delivery. Free Shipping. Buy Now tradus.in/16GB-Pen-Drive-499

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-17919364[5/2/2012 4:12:52 PM]

BBC News - Is Gujarat's red hot economy a myth?

Services
News feeds Mobile Podcasts Alerts E-mail news
Mobile site Advertise With Us Ad Choices BBC 2012 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

About BBC News

Editors' blog BBC College of Journalism News sources Media Action
Terms of Use Privacy Cookies Parental Guidance About the BBC BBC Help Accessibility Help Contact Us

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-17919364[5/2/2012 4:12:52 PM]