2
FD WAH XDFWHG SWBWHS GFSW]FCW C@X]WJ@] WAH S@XWAH]D GFSW]FCW @J OFSSFSSFUUFLBCIS@D GFZFSF@DG]$ @]NV WBFW\. HSR$. M]FBD JHG@]IB. UNBFDWFJJSNBX]FH ]@WA. NHBA NBQ. bdg W@OObcNH]BDZS$ CFZFN BCWF@D D@$ 3<2=/cz/=15 AW[/N]BGHO@C]BW UB]WV @J OFSSFSSFUUF. GHJHDGBDWSSHC]HWB]V @J SWBWH OFSSFSSFUUF.MB]BI AXSSHFD @MBOB. @MBOBJ@] BOH]FCB. DBDCF UHN@SF.G]$ BNZFD @DBIB. N@]HWWB JXGGV.OFCABHN BSW]XH. L@AD G@HS. L@ADG@HS 2/255OFSSFSSFUUF GHO@C]BWFC UB]WV HQHCXWFZH C@OOFWWHH
‖S
OHO@]BDGXO M]FHJ @J BXWA@]FWFHS FD SXUU@]W @JO@WF@D J@] LXGKOHDW @D WAH UNHBGFDKS
C@OHS D@[ wah Ghjhdgbdw. wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv. wa}`xka fws k`zh}dfdk hdwfwv. wahOfssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv Hqhcxwfzh C`oofwwhh
!„OGHC‟&
. bdg mv bdg wa}`xka fws xdgh}sfkdhgc`xdshn bdg. ux}sxbdw w`
Jhg$ ]$ Cfz$ U$
2=!c& bdg
N$ X$ Cfz$ ]$
;!m&!7&. ah}hmv u}`zfghs wah C`x}w {fwa fwsOho`}bdgxo `j Bxwa`}fwfhs fd sxuu`}w `j fws O`wf`d j`} Lxgkohdw `d wah Unhbgfdks. bs j`nn`{s<
MBCIK]@XDG
2$
@d Jhm}xb}v 27. =52= @}nv Wbfw|. b Cbnfj`}dfb }hsfghdw bdg nfchdshg bww`}dhv fd wabw swbwh. jfnhg buhwfwf`d fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w `j wah Jf}sw Lxgfcfbn Gfsw}fcw `j Afdgs C`xdwv. Ofssfssfuuf bkbfdsw wahOfssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv bdg wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh `j Ofssfssfuuf shhifdk b ghcnb}bwf`d wabw wahU}hsfghdw `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs. Mb}bci Axsshfd @mbob. fs d`w c`dswfwxwf`dbnnv hnfkfmnh w` a`ng wah
`jjfch `j U}hsfghdw `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs mhcbxsh ah fs d`w b „dbwx}bn m`}d cfwf|hd‟ `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs.
bs }hrxf}hg mv B}wfcnh =. Shcwf`d 2 `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs C`dswfwxwf`d$ Y@}fkfdbn Cf}cxfw C`x}w Uhwfwf`d.
Cbsh 3<2=/cz/55=15/AW[/N]B G`cxohdw 2: Jfnhg 58572= Ubkh 2 `j =7
=G`cihw D`$ :. u$u$ 21/=:_$ Wbfw|
‖s
`}fkfdbn swbwh c`x}w uhwfwf`d jx}wah} s`xkaw fdlxdcwfzh }hnfhj w` mn`ci U}hsfghdw @mbob j}`o buuhb}fdk `d wah mbnn`w j`} wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdchu}fob}v hnhcwf`d. {afca {bs w` mh ahng `d Ob}ca 23. =52=$ Wbfw|
‖s
`}fkfdbn c`x}w uhwfwf`d jx}wah}bccxshs U}hsfghdw @mbob `j hnhcwf`d j}bxg b}fsfdk j}`o afs xsh `j b j}bxgxnhdw s`cfbn shcx}fwv dxomh}bdg b j}bxgxnhdw mf}wa ch}wfjfcbwh$
Wbfw|‖s `}fkfdbn
c`x}w uhwfwf`d cfwhs
Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$
« =3/28/6:2 bswah lx}fsgfcwf`dbn mbsfs j`} m}fdkfdk ah} bcwf`d fd wah Afdgs C`xdwv Cf}cxfw C`x}w. {afca fs wahu}`chgx}h j`} bd bkk}fhzhg ub}wv w` cabnnhdkh wah rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j b cbdgfgbwh fd Ofssfssfuuf shhifdkw` mh hnhcwhg w` swbwh `jjfch mv jf}sw mhc`ofdk b cbdgfgbwh fd wah ub}wv u}fob}v hnhcwf`d$=$
M`wa wah Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv Hqhcxwfzh C`oofwwhh bdg wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh jfnhg o`wf`dsfd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w w`
gfsofss Wbfw|‖s uhwfwf`d `d
dxoh}`xs k}`xdgs. fdcnxgfdk< !b& wabw fw {bsxdwfohnv xdgh} Shcwf`d =3/28/6:2. !m& wabw wah Unbfdwfjj
{bs d`w bd „bkk}fhzhg ub}wv‟ xdgh} Shcwf`d
=3/28/6:2 bdg `wah}{fsh nbcihg swbdgfdk w` m}fdk ah} bcwf`d fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w `j Afdgs C`xdwv.Ofssfssfuuf. bdg !c& wabw dhfwah} wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh d`} wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfcUb}wv Hqhcxwfzh C`oofwwhh abg bdv gxwv xdgh} wah k`zh}dfdk swbwxwh j`} u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdchu}fob}fhs.
Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$
« =3/28/2516. w` ghwh}ofdh b u}hsfghdwfbn cbdgfgbwh
‖s
rxbnfjfcbwf`ds. `wah}
wabd wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh‖s nfofwhg }`nh fd fghdwfjvfdk „khdh}bnnv }hc`kdf|hg‟ cbdgfgbwhs
j`}U}hsfghdw w` mh unbchg `d wah ub}wv u}fob}v mbnn`w$3$
@d Bu}fn 26. =52= Wbfw|. bn`dk {fwa j`x} bggfwf`dbn Unbfdwfjjs. jfnhg wah Jf}sw Bohdghg C`ounbfdw
!„JBC‟&
{fwa wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w. shhifdk. fdwh} bnfb. w` hdl`fd Mb}bci @mbob j}`o buuhb}fdk `d wahOfssfssfuuf =52= khdh}bn hnhcwf`d mbnn`w bs b cbdgfgbwh j`} U}hsfghdw `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs$
2
Fd bggfwf`d
2
[afnh shzh}bn „Unbfdwfjjs‟ ux}u`}whgnv l`fdhg Wbfw|. {a` {bs wah `}fkfdbn s`nh unbfdwfjj. `dnv
wa}hh sxca Unbfdwfjjs abzh sfkdhgwah JBC bcc`}gfdk w` wah C`x}w ]hc`}g$ !
Shh
G`cihw D`$ :/
27 bw =6 !O}$ Jhg`}ib‖s sfkdbwx}h ubkh& bdg G`cihw D`$ :
/27 bw 35
!O}$ Obc Nh}bd‖s sfkdbwx}h ubkh&$ O`}h`zh}. d`dh `j wah `wah} ux}u`}whg Unbfdwfjjs abs u}`zfghg c
`dwbcw fdj`}obwf`d `}
}hsu`dghg fd bdv {bv w` ghjhdgbdw OGHC‖s c`xdshn‖s }hrxhsw wabw wahv c`djf}o wahv b}h u}`chhgfdk fd wafs bcwf`d
u}` sh
bdgwabw wahv {fnn u}`zfgh sfkdhg unhbgfdks bdg u}`uh} c`dwbcw fdj`}obwf`d$ Bggfwf`dbnnv. hbca bdg hzh}v hobfn shdw w` Unbfdwfjj
ObcNh}bd abs „m`xdchg mbci‟ w` wah xdgh}sfkdhg c`xdshn$
!Wah `dnv c`dwbcw fdj`}obwf`d {bs h/obfn bgg}hsshs$& Wbfw| fs bd
bww`}dhv {fwa b afsw`}v `j bwwhouwfdk w` }hu}hshdw Unbfdwfjjs cabnnhdkfdk U}hsfghdw @mbob‖s hnfkfmfnfwv fd swbwhs {ah}h
sah fs d`w
Cbsh 3<2=/cz/55=15/AW[/N]B G`cxohdw 2: Jfnhg 58572= Ubkh = `j =7
3w` wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv bdg wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh `j Ofssfssfuuf. Wbfw| bdg wah dh{Unbfdwfjjs
dbohg bs ghjhdgbdws U}hsfghdw @mbob. @mbob j`} Boh}fcb !wah U}hsfghdw‖s u}fdcfubn
u`nfwfcbn cboubfkd c`oofwwhh&. Dbdcv Uhn`sf !d`{ wah ofd`}fwv nhbgh} `j wah X$S$ A`xsh `j ]hu}hshdwbwfzhs bdg j`}oh} cabf} `j wah =551 Gho`c}bwfc Dbwf`dbn C`dzhdwf`d&. G}$ Bnzfd @dbib!]hkfsw}b} `j wah Ab{bff Ghub}wohdw `j Ahbnwa&. N`}hwwb Jxggv !Gf}hcw`} `j wah Ab{bff Ghub}wohdw `j Ahbnwa& bdg Ofcabhn Bsw}xh !C`oofssf`dh} `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs S`cfbn Shcx}fwv Bgofdfsw}bwf`d&$Wah JBC cfwhg
Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$
« =3/28/6:3. {afca fs wah u}`chgx}h j`} cabnnhdkfdk b cbdgfgbwh {a`jfnhg w` }xd fd wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d. bs wah mbsfs j`} wah dh{ cabnnhdkh w` U
}hsfghdw @mbob‖s cbdgfgbcv
j`} U}hsfghdw fd wah D`zhomh} =52= hnhcwf`d fd Ofssfssfuuf$ Wah JBC bns` bgghg b jhgh}bn ]FC@cbxsh `j bcwf`d bkbfdsw wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv bdg wah dh{ ghjhdgbdws. mxw d`w wah Shc}hwb}v`j Swbwh$ Bs `j wafs gbwh. d`dh `j wah dh{ ghjhdgbdws abzh mhhd sh}zhg {fwa u}`chss `} `wah}{fshbuuhb}hg fd wah cbsh$7$
Wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh. l`fdhg mv wah OGHC. }ho`zhg Unbfdwfjjs
‖ cfzfn
bcwf`d w` wafs A`d`}bmnh C`x}wmbshg `d wah hqfswhdch `j b jhgh}bn rxhswf`d b}fsfdk j}`o wah jhgh}bn ]FC@ cnbfo fdcnxghg j`} wah jf}swwfoh fd wah JBC$
nfchdshg w` u}bcwfch nb{$
Shh. h$k$. ]a`ghs z$ ObcG`dbng
. :;5 J$ Sxuu$=g 23:3. 23:1 !22wa Cf}$ =556& !
„Mhcbxsh `j wah
bnnhkhg x}khdw dbwx}h `j wah }hrxhsw. wah C`x}w {bfzhg fws n`cbn }xnh wabw }hrxf}hs c`xdshn bgofwwhg
u}` abc zfch
w` bss`cfbwh n`cbnc`xdshn$ Fw mhcboh buub}hdw gx}fdk wah ahb}fdk `d wah o`wf`d wabw wah C`x}w+s {bfzh} `j wafs n`cbn }xnh {bs b ofswbih bs c`xdshnbmxshg ah}
u}` abc
zfch u}fzfnhkhs$‟&
9
Jb}}b} z$ @mbob
. D`$ =52=CZ=22361 !Kb$ Jxnw`d C`xdwv Sxuh}$ Cw$ Jhm$ 28. =52=&
!ghdvfdk Wbfw|‖s }hrxhsw j`} bgofssf`d u}` abc zfch j`} jbfnx}h w` c`ounv {fwa }xnhs buunfcbmnh w` sboh&$
Bs sxca. jx}wah}
}hjh}hdchs w` „Unbfdwfjjs‟ fs {fwa`xw u}hlxgfch w` OGHC‖s c`dwhdwf`d
wabw Wbfw| fs wah `dnv bcwxbn unbfdwfjj. j`} wah }hbs`ds swbwhg$
Cbsh 3<2=/cz/55=15/AW[/N]B G`cxohdw 2: Jfnhg 58572= Ubkh 3 `j =7
2012-05-04 - MDEC Memo in Support of Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings
1.2K
Reads
5
Readcasts
0
Embed Views
Recommended
More From This User
Notes
Load more
