Peer Review Worksheet grading criteria:Assignments will be graded according to these criteria:
presentation in terms of grammar, spelling, and punctuation
and assignment parameters
Effective use of
thoughtful and developed arguments
clarity and presentation
, including document design, visual elements, useof headings.
Professionalism a- Pretty confident this will be bumped up in furtherdrafts in areas that are lacking, but budgeting, scheduleand whatnot are on target Genre b It will get there, right now it is a little too much like
asking for a bank loan rather than ‘LOOK, at this great Idea I have.’ Sell it = layout, color, sample, etc
. but it is a
draft, mine doesn’t have all that yet either.
Source Use b Pretty sure it will get there.Argument Quality b You have a good idea, but need to really hone in on a
smooth narrative, selling a cohesive idea. It’s in there,
but you have to further it and refine it a lot.Design/Presentation c
Again, it’s a draft, so it is expected that you have it, but
make sure in the end it is there: color, graphics, layout Overall b It is in there, but it needs to be reworked a few times,definitely could make this a really solid sale though!
You’ll write a 1
-page letter to your partner and attach it to this worksheet, in which
you’ll provide detailed feedback on their paper. Use examples (quotations) from
their work and suggest changes. The idea is to avoid vague, general reactions to