Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
 
 
PLI
 
Policy
 
Project
 
Review
 
of 
 
Pastoral
 
Rangeland
 
Enclosures
 
in
 
Ethiopia
 
Alison
 
Napier
 
and
 
Dr.
 
Solomon
 
Desta
 
November
 
2011
 
 
 
Acknowledgements
 
This
 
review
 
was
 
conducted
 
under
 
the
 
PLI
 
Policy
 
Project,
 
funded
 
by
 
USAID
 
Ethiopia.
 
We
 
are
 
grateful
 
to
 
all
 
participants
 
from
 
PLI
 
government
 
partners,
 
NGOs
 
and
 
individuals
 
who
 
participated
 
in
 
the
 
review
 
process,
 
as
 
well
 
as
 
Dr.
 
Dawit
 
Abebe,
 
Dr.
 
Gezu
 
Bekele
 
and
 
Bashir
 
Abdullahi
 
working
 
with
 
the
 
Tufts
 
University
 
Africa
 
Regional
 
Office
 
in
 
Addis
 
Ababa.
 
Disclaimer
 
The
 
findings
 
and
 
recommendations
 
of 
 
this
 
review
 
do
 
not
 
necessarily
 
reflect
 
the
 
views
 
of 
 
USAID.
 
 
 
Contents
EXECUTIVE
 
SUMMARY
 
.............................................................................................................................
 
i
 
1.
 
INTRODUCTION
 
...................................................................................................................................
 
1
 
1.1
 
Background
 
...................................................................................................................................
 
1
 
1.2
 
Purpose
 
of 
 
the
 
review
 
...................................................................................................................
 
1
 
1.3
 
Review
 
methodology
 
....................................................................................................................
 
2
 
2.
 
ENCLOSURES
 
IN
 
BORANA
 
PASTORALIST
 
AREAS
 
..................................................................................
 
3
 
2.1
 
Types
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Borana
 
......................................................................................................
 
3
 
2.2
 
History
 
and
 
trends
 
in
 
natural
 
resources
 
and
 
development
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Borana
 
...................
 
5
 
2.3
 
Driving
 
factors
 
for
 
the
 
emergence
 
and
 
expansion
 
of 
 
different
 
types
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
....................
 
7
 
2.4
 
PLI
 
NGO
 
approaches
 
to
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Borana
 
............................................................................
 
11
 
2.5
 
Government
 
approaches
 
and
 
plans
 
for
 
enclosures
 
....................................................................
 
13
 
2.6
 
Perceived
 
benefits
 
and
 
risks
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Borana
 
.................................................................
 
14
 
3.
 
ENCLOSURES
 
IN
 
SOMALI
 
PASTORALIST
 
AREAS
 
.................................................................................
 
17
 
3.1
 
Description
 
of 
 
types
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
in
 
different
 
parts
 
of 
 
the
 
region
 
............................................
 
17
 
3.2
 
History
 
and
 
trends
 
in
 
natural
 
resources
 
and
 
development
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Somali
 
region
 
.......
 
19
 
3.3
 
Driving
 
factors
 
for
 
the
 
emergence
 
of 
 
different
 
types
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Somali
 
region
 
................
 
22
 
3.4
 
PLI
 
approaches
 
to
 
NRM/
 
enclosures
 
in
 
Somali
 
region
 
................................................................
 
23
 
3.5
 
Government
 
approaches
 
and
 
plans,
 
presented
 
by
 
SoRPARI
 
......................................................
 
25
 
3.6
 
Perceived
 
benefits
 
and
 
risks
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
.................................................................................
 
25
 
4.
 
IMPACT
 
OF
 
ENCLOSURES
 
ON
 
POORER
 
PASTORALISTS
 
.....................................................................
 
27
 
4.1
 
Local
 
perceptions
 
from
 
the
 
review
 
process
 
in
 
Borana
 
and
 
Somali
 
.............................................
 
27
 
4.2
 
NGOs’
 
perceptions
 
of 
 
enclosures
 
................................................................................................
 
29
 
5.
 
WAYS
 
FORWARD
 
FOR
 
STRATEGIES
 
ON
 
NRM/
 
ENCLOSURES
 
............................................................
 
31
 
5.1
 
Recommendations
 
from
 
the
 
Borana
 
workshop
 
..........................................................................
 
31
 
5.2
 
Recommendations
 
from
 
the
 
Somali
 
workshop
 
..........................................................................
 
32
 
5.3
 
Conclusions
 
.................................................................................................................................
 
33
 
ANNEX
 
1
 
 –
 
PRESENTATION
 
ON
 
ENCLOSURES
 
IN
 
BORANA
 
RANGELANDS
 
............................................
 
35
 
ANNEX
 
2
 
 –
 
PRESENTATION
 
ON
 
ENCLOSURES
 
IN
 
PARTS
 
OF
 
SOMALI
 
REGION
 
......................................
 
38
 
ANNEX
 
3
SAVE
 
THE
 
CHILDREN
 
USA
 
FRAMEWORK
 
FOR
 
PNRM
 
...........................................................
 
40
 
ANNEX
 
4
 
 –
 
LIST
 
OF
 
PARTICIPANTS
 
AT
 
NRM
 
REVIEW
 
WORKSHOPS
 
......................................................
 
41
 
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.
  • More From This User

    Notes
    Load more