" " ()

. . , . . ,
. . , . .

,
. .

2003

 316.42(470+571)(075.8)
60.5(2)73
69
:
@ .. .
:
, ,
.. ;

.. ;
.. ;

..
:
.. (., . 1, ., . 1; . 2, 4@8, 11, 13@15 ( .
..), . 9 ( . ..).
.. (. 3, 10, . 3, 4 ( . ..), . 9 (
. ..).
.. (. 12; . 3, 10, . 3, 4 ( . ..).
.. (. 16, . 2; . 2, 4@8, 11, 13@15 ( .
..).

: / . . , . .
, . . ,. . ; @
,
. . ; .: , 2003. 416 .
"
". @
@
.
, , @
.
. @
, , , ,
, , , @ , @
.

ISBN 5@88516@042@2

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
I. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10
1. :
, , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10
2.
: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .29

II.
, . .48
3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .48
4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .93
5. . . . . . . . . . . . . .128
6. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .142
7. . . . . . . . . . . .165
8. . .179
9. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .201

III.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .234
10. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .234
11. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .249
12. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .263
13. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .274
14. . . .288
15. . . . . . . . . . . . .305
16. . . . . . . . . . . .318
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .334
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .335
1.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .335
2. .341
3.
( 5 ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .376
4. ( 10
) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .398
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .401
3

, ,
, @
, , @
@
.
.
, ,
, @
, ,

, , ,
, @
.
,
? @
,
, ,
, @
@ , , @
, @
, @
, , @
.
, @
.
80@ 90@ 
. , @
, @
. , ,
,
.
.
, @
4

.

, @
,
. , @
, , ,
,
@
. @
, ,
!
@ @
, ,
, @
.
@
, @
,
,
,
. @
,
, , @
.
, , , @
, , , @
, @
, .

@
. @,
. ,
, , @
, @
. @

. ( @
, . .)
.
@,
. @
. @
@
.

.

.
@, @
@
. @
, @
,
@
. ,
, ,

. ,
@
,
.
@, @
6

. @
: , , @
, , , . , ,
, @

,
. @

. , @
@
. , @

, , . @
,
, @, @
@
, @
, @
.
@
.
, @
, , , ,
, , , @
, , @
( @
), @
, , @
, @
,
, @
, @
.
@
, @
, ,
7

. @
@
.
@
, , , @
,
.
@
, @
. @
@@
, .
,

.
,
, :
, . @
@

, , , , @
, . ., @
, @
,
. @
,
(, . .) @
, @
@ @
,
,
.

,
. @
@
8

@
. , , @
,
,

.

I.

1. :
, ,

, @
, ,
. , 
,

.
, @ . 
, 
,
(),
(),
.
@
( ) ,
. @
, , @
. @
.
@
, @
,
. , @
. ,
, ,
, , .
@
@
10

 I.

. @
@
, .

(@, , ),
().

,
.
@
.
@
. ,
, , @
,
,
, @

. @
,
, . @
, , 1993 @
, @
.
@ @
, @
@
. I .
(
II) , ,
, , @

.
@
, @
11

, .
, @
( )
, ,
: (),
, . , , .
@
. @
@
,
. @
@
,
, @
. @
,
.
,

, 
,
.

, @
.
@
,
. @
,
. @
.
, @
.
,
12

 I.

, . XX
.1.
, ., @
, @@
. @
, ., ,
,
.
, ., .,
,
.,
2. ,
@
@
, @
, . @

.
@
, , @

. ,
@
, ,
,
. @
, ,
, ,
@
, . . @

.
@
1 .: Marcuse H. Onedimensional Man. Boston, 1964.
2 . . . . 3, . 3.
13

, . . , @
, ,
. , @

, @
, , @
@ , @
.

,
. ,
@
, @
. @
, , @
@
, @
( ) .
@, @
. @
, , @
, @
,
, ..

@
, , ,
@ , ,
,
,
. ,
( ,
, @
..),
14

 I.

, @
@
.

,
, .
( )
@
. ( ) @
@
, @
, @
, ,
, @
,
. ,
,
, , @

.
@, @

@
.
.
, @
, .
, ,
,
,
.
, ,
( , @
). @
, ,
, @
15

. , (
), ,
.

.
@, @
. ,
, , ,
, . @
, ,
.
, ,
,
, .
( ) , @
. @
, ,
.
. @
90@ XX @
@
, @
.
@
. @
,
() @
().

,
,
@
.
,
,
.
16

 I.

.

, , @
.
@, @
. @
,
.

( @
, , @
, ), .
,
.
, , @

. , @
, . (@
)
.
.
@, @
. @
@ @
. @
, @
.
, ,
.
. ,
.
,
, @
. , @
17

@
, @
, , @
.

,
,
.
,
.
,
, @
, , @

.
@
,
. @
,

.
@
,
, @
.

(. . ) .

,
, , @

.
, @

, @
18

 I.

. 

@
. @
, @
, @
, @
( ) @
,
( ), @

, , @
,
. @
, @
.
@
, @
,
.

. (. . , )
.
@
@
. , . .
, 1980@
. , @
, @
@
,
. , @
( ,
),
: , , .. ,
,
19

, ,
, . @
,
.
( ,
),
@
. , @

, .

, ( @
@ ,
) @
. , @
, , @
( @
).
,
@
, ,
,

.
,
@
.

1990@ . @
@
,
: @
,
. @
, @ ; @

20

 I.

, @
,
.
, @
,
@
.
,
.
@
@
.
@
,
@
. , @
,
() , @
,
.
, @
, @
.
90@ XX @
.
@
.
@
@
, 1993 @
,
. , . 2 @
: , @
. , @
. @
@
21

. ,
.
, @
, , @
@
. . 3
, ,
, @
@
,
.
@
.
. , @
,
. @

, @
, , @
, @
. , @
,
. ,
. 3 , @
, . 4 , @
,

. . 3 @
, @
, , ,
, @

, . 5
3 (.. 65@79) .
. 6
.
22

 I.

@ . , @
@
.
. 1 . 7 :
, @
, @
. , @
, @
, @
.
. 8
, , @
, , @
. , @
. @
, @
@
. , @
,
. @
@
, ..
@
.
,
, ,
@
. @

,


.

@
, @
23

. , @
, ,
@
, .
, @
@
.
, @
@
, @
. @
, . .
, . ,
, , @
, @ @

. , 1995

. @
, ,
, @
, @
. ,
, @
VIII,
, , @
, @
, @
.
37, , @
@
@
,
. , @
@

24

 I.

,
. , 90@
XX . 1997
@
, 1998

, @

, 2000 @

. @
@
. ,

, @
, , @
@
. 2003 @
@
, @
, ,
, .
1995 @
7
( ), @
. @
,
, @
.
@
, @
@
, @
@
.
, (@
25

)
@
, @
, @
, ,
.
,
,
.
@
, @
,
. @
@
, @
, @
90@ @
, ,
, @
, @
,
, .
, @
,
@
.
(1997 ) @
,
;
,
.
@
, , @

. , @

26

 I.

, @
, @
. , , @
,
,
, @
@
. , @
.
2000 @
, @
,
, @
.
() @

. @
2001 @
@
, @
. @
@
, @
, @
, @
@
@

. ,
2003 @
.
.
, @
,
. @

27

(, @
, ),
@
,
, @
. @
@
.

, @
( @

, , , ). @
@
. , @

, @
, .
@
,
. ,
,
. @
, , , ,
( ,
), , @
(
), @ @
, , ,
@
.

28

 I.

2.
:

@
@, .
@
@
,
.
. ,
, (
, , ; ,
, , ). ,
, , @
, ,
,
@
, ,
,
. @
,
.
@
; , @
, @
. , ,
XX ,
,
1, @
, .
1 ., : . . 10. ., 1940, . 718.
29

. ,
.
@
. , ..1 @
, ..
..2. @
: , @
, .
,
@
. @
@
, @
. , , XX @
, , ,
.
@
60@70@ XX
. @
..3, @
(,
..)4.
, @
, @
, ,
. . @
, @
. ,
1 ..
XX // . ., 1969.
2 .., .. . .,
1973, 2732.
3 , .: ..
"" . // .
1975.  ., 1976.
4 .. .  .: , 1989.
30

 I.

. ,
,
, @
@
. .
, XX ( @
XXI ) @
.
(
)

.
, , @
, . .
:
@
.


/ , 
, 

( ).
, @
@
.




, 

.
@
, . @
,
31

( , )
.

, @
, . @
@
. @
. , @
,
, . . @
. @
,
.
, XX XXI
@ ( @
) , @
. ,
, ,
90@ XX . @, @

, @
. ,

. ,
( ) @

. ,
, @
, , . .
@@
,
. @
@ @
. @
.
32

 I.

, ,

,
@
(, , ).
@
@ .
, @

. , @

1992 . @
@
,
. ,
, , @
. ,

(, , @
). @
, , @
, @,
@
.
@ @
90@ XX ,

. @
,
@
. @
@
, @
, @ , @
, @
, , . @
33

,
. , @
@
( @
), @
. @
, ,
,
.
@
.
,
. @
, @
@
, , @@
( @
).

, , ,
.
, .
(
)
, .
@ @
@
, , @
, @
. , @
, @
. ,
@

. @

34

 I.

@

. , , @
, @
@
, , @
.

@
, ,
,
.
@
(@
, , @
, ),

. ,

, , , @
. ,
2002 @
@ . ,

,
, @
.
, @
.

, /
, @
. , @
@
, @
, @
35

( , , @
. .).
@
@
.
.
, @
, ,
.
, @
,
. @
.
,
,
@
. , @
, @
,
,
, . @
, ,
, , @
, @
, .
@
,
1996 . @
2000 . @
, 2000 .
@
.
, .
, , , @
,
36

 I.

. , @
, ,
, .
@
, @
, @
@
. , @

, @
. ,

,
2000 . @
. ,
.

, @
,
, , @
, @
.
(@
), ( @
), (
) . ,

( @
), , @
,
. ,
@
,
, @
, @
.
37

(@, @
), @
. @
, @
, ,
, @
, ,

.
( ) @
@ ,
@
.
@
@
@
, @ @
, @
@ .

@
.
, ,
. @
,

,
. @
.



. @
@
, . @
38

 I.

@
. @
. @
@
.
.
, @
. , , @
. , @
,
@
. , @
@
, 1998 2001 @

, @
.
@
,
@ .
. @, @
@
. :
, , @
. .
@
. @
, , @
, , .

, @

. @
. @
. , @@
, @
39

. @
,
@
. ,
, , @
, ,
,
, .
@
(,
). @
, .
, @
@
,
@
, . @

@
, @
.
@
, @
. , @
@
, .
( ) @
,
. , @
@
, @
( , 1995 .

, @
). @
, @
40

 I.

, .

. , @
, ,
, @

@ . ,
,
@

.
, @
90@ @
@ @
.
, , @

,
, . @
.
,
.
@
, 2001 . @
,
. @
.
. @
@
, 90@ .
@
, .
@
, @

.
41

1993 2002 @
@
. , , @
@
.
.
. @
@
, , @
, @
. , 2002 @
, @
,

.
@
( @
, @
) , @
,
@
.
@
35 , ,
.
@
. @ @

( @
) @ .

. @

. 90@
XX ,
,
42

 I.

, @
. @
@ 1 2002 . @
( ),
,
. @
, (
* @
),
.
@
@
. , @
, @
@
,
.
@
,
.

(. 11) , @
@
, ,
,
, @
, , @
, .
..
* "" "Schoffen" (
..
) "Schoffe" ( ),
"" "". (
, , 
)
. ,
.
 .
43

, @
. @

.
,
, @
, , @
, @
.

. @

( @

).
@
.
@,
.
@
.
,
.
,
2001 .
@
,
, @
, @
, @
. ,
@
, , @
, , @
,
44

 I.

@@

.
@
,
@
, , @
@

.
, @
@
, @
.
@
. ,
(@
)

, @
.
()
. @

.
,
.

. , @@@
( @
), (
, )
,
@

.
45

@
,
@
, @

.
,

.
, @
, @
@
(
) @
.
,
, @
@
. ,
, @
, .. ,

.
@,
@
.
@, @

. @
@
@
,
@
.
@
.
46

 I.

@, @
, @
.
, , @
@
, @
.

47

II.

,

3.


, 
, , 
, 
, 

.

XX @
XXI @
,
, , @
.
@
, .

, @
, , .
,
@
,
, @
@
, @
48

 II. ,

,
. @


.
, ,
. @
:
, @
, , @
, , @
() @
. @
(@
, ,
, , @
,
, ..).

, @
,
, ,
.

@
(, ..). @
,
,
, ,
. @
@

, @
.


49

, ..
.

, @
@
. @
@
, @
@
. @

@
, @
.
, @
@

:
;
;
.
@
,
, @
,

,
,
. , @
: 16 1998
()
@
@ ( ) @

. , , @
@ @
50

 II. ,

@. @
, , @
, , @ .


, . @
,
, ( @
, 1985) (
, 1989). ,
@
, @
(1993 .), : @
( 1994 .), @
( , 1995 .),
(1997 .).
:
( , 1995 .); @
( , 2000 .); @
( ,
2000 .), ( @
, 2001).
(
@),
@ ,
@
( )
.
, @
( @
, , @
, ..).

@
, @
. ,
51

@
,
@
, , @
, @
@
1. @
.
(Idasa, Institute of Democracy for South
Africa) @
,
.
1990@ @
. (IBP
International Budget Project) 1997 50
, 14 . @
2000 100 @
25 .
,
, , , ,
, @
.

, , @
(public) . @
@
@
@
.

@
@
.
1 . : Applied Budget Work. Ed. by I. Shapiro, Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities  Wash., 2002.
52

 II. ,

( )
.
, , @
,
;
, @
@
.

,
. @

.
@
@
.
, @
. @
, @
@
, .
@
:
;
;
;
@
.
/
. ,
@
.
@
.
.
53

, /:
,
, @
;
;
;
@
.
, @
@
.
@
,
( , , @
) (@
, , )
.
, @
:
;
;
.
@
: , , . @

(Center for Research and Training in Economics,
CIDE) . @
, .
, .
, ,
.
: , @
,
.
,
, , @
54

 II. ,

, , @
, @
.
@
. @
@ 2002 , @
. @
@
, .
2001 @
@

.

@
( @
), :

;

(. @);
@
();
;

( ).
1998
,

, . @
@
(), @
. @


(, , ,
55

@) ( @
, ). @
(@
), ,
. @
, .

@
.

, . , @
, @
, ..

@
,
.

, @
( ) @
,

.

@

1:
:

;
1 .., .. .., .. "

 ", ,
28  6 2002 ., .
56

 II. ,

;
@
.
:
, @
@
;
;
.
@
: ,
@
, @
. ,
, ,
.
@
,
.
, @
@
@
@
, @
.
@
.
1. 
.
@
, , , , @
1%, , , @
95%*. @
* ,
"" .
57

.
@
, , ..
. , , @
,
(, ,
.).
, @
, , @
, @
. @
@
@
@
1.
,
( @
),
, @
(), , @

, .

,
,
@
.
@
:

@
1 .., .., .., ..

"" 2001.
58

 II. ,

,
, @
, @
;
@@
, , @
, @
;

@
@ , @
.
@
() @
, ,
,
.
@
@
58 , 55, @
.
1. .
2. .
3. .
4. .
5. .
.
, , @

,
:
@

;
, @
;
59

@
; @

;
,

; @
;
@
; @
@
( @
); @
; @
@
;

; @
@
;
@
.


,
:
@

;
@
;
@
,
;
( @
).
60

 II. ,

@ , @
:
, @
;

,
@
;

; @
@
@ ;
@
;
@
; @
;
;
@
@
;

; @
;

; @
(,
) @
;
@
@
, ; @
@
.

61

,
:

;
,
, @
@
; @
;
@
( @
); ,

, @
;
, @

.
, ,
,
:
@
@

;


@
; @
;

.

,
( @
; @
62

 II. ,

@
), : @
(
@
,
; @
@
; @

)

(@

;

).
: @
, @

,
.
@
, , .
@
@

@
. @
@
@
.
, @
:
@;
;
.
63

@
@
,
.
@
, :
() @
;
;
, , .
, @
, , @
/.
@ @
:
@
, @
( );
@
;
;

.
, @ @
,
, / @

, . @
, @,

1.
64

 II. ,

1. 

, ,
@ @@
, @
,

.
, @
, , .
, ,
, @
, , @
. , , @
, , /@
, , ,
.

@
:
@
(,
, ),

,
.
65

, @, @
; @, @
@
, @
(
); @,

.

2. 

@

.
2 @
,
@
.

,
.
@
, .
66

 II. ,

() @
, @
@
,
.
@
:
1. @
.
2. .

, .


, @
.
@
@
.
, @
,
:
;
;
, ,
;
@
.

, , @
:
1. ;
2. ;
3. ;
4. ;
5. . @
67

@
, @
, @

.
,
,
:


, @
,
;
( )
1 2000., @

( 9 1999. 159@3

). @

@
;
@
@ , @
,
@;
, @
, , @
( )
, @
,
;
@

;
@
68

 II. ,

, @
;

,

;
, , @
;
, , @

, @
, ;
,
, @
.
,
@
, @
:
@
@
,
;

,
(, )
, @

;

@
,
;
@
,
69

@
;
@
, , @
;

. , @
,
, @
: , @
;

.
, ,
,
, @
, .
, @
. ,

, @
1.
2.


. ,
:
@

;
;
@@
1

"" www.transparentbudget.ru/rus/transparency.htm
70

 II. ,

;
@
@
.

( ) @
, , @
( ,
, , @
. .).
:









.
:
1) @
,
@
, :
@
( );
( );
@

.
2)

, , , @
.
71

:
;
;
;
;
.

:
;
(, ...);
, @
.
3) ,

( ), ,
.
@
(
) @
; @
3@5 ;
( @
, @
, ,
,
@
, ;
) @
( , @
;
;
@
).


@
72

 II. ,

,
1.
, @
, @
@
,
(). @
,


.
@

, ,
.
@
@ ,
, , @
. ,
.

@
; ,
( @
, ).
,
,
@
, .

( @ @
), @
1 ..
//
: . ..  .: , 2002.
73

, .
:

;
;
;
@
.


@
, @
(, @
, @
, ). @
,
, @

, ..
@
@
, .
@
, @

( @
).
, @
: , , @
.
@

.
.
@ . @

74

 II. ,

,
@
.
, @
, , @
, , @@
( ) ,
. @
, , @
, . @

.
, @
, @
@
( ).
@ @
,
.
, @
, @
, ,
@
.
3.
@
@
, @
,
.
,
@
@
.
, @
@
75

;
, , ,
.

, ,
@
, ( 3)1

3. 

, @
, .
1) , ,

, ,
@
/.
@
,

. , , @
1 : ./ .
...  "".  , , 2002.
76

 II. ,

, @
, @

.
2) ,
, @
( @
). @
, @
@

. , , @
: @,
,
; @,
PR
@
, . , @
,
@
,
.
@
@
@
.
3) , , (
), @
@
, (
), @
@
. ,
, @

77

. @

.
,

@
; , @
. @

: ,
, , @
. @

@
. @
,

.
.
@
.
1. @
.
2.
, .. .
3. ( )
.
(
, )
(, ..,
, , ),
.
4. ( .. @
), @
.
5. ( .. @
78

 II. ,

).
6. ( .. ).
7. @ @
, ..
8. @
.
9. @
.
10. @
, @
, .
11. , .
12. ,
, , , , @
, , @
, , , @
, , ..
13. .
14. ( ..
).
15.
( , @
).
16.
@
.
17. @
, .. , , ,
.. ( ..
, ).
18. @
.
19. (, @
,
) @

79

.
, @

. @
,
@
, . @
@
, @
, @
,
, .

@
.
, @
.

,
,
. @
.
@

, @
,
, @
, @
: ,
, .
,
1.
1  . ( 
) . :
./ . ...  .: , 2002. 220.
80

 II. ,

:

;

, @
@
@

.
:
, @
@
;

;
@
;

.

, @
,
.
.
, @
, ,
.
@
@
, @
.
@
@
, @
@
, , .
81

@

, @
, @
. .
1. .
1.1. .
1.2. @
, ,
.
1.3. :
( );
( );
;
, ;
;
, , @
@
;
, .. @
;
;
, @
.
1.4.
, ,
, ,
, @
@
.
1.5. @

( ..
@
),

82

 II. ,

.
1.6. , @
,
.
2. .
2.1. ,
, .
2.2. ( @
), ,
, ,
.
2.3.
, , @
, , @
, .
2.4. , ,
, , @
, ( @
) ,
, ,
.
2.5.
( ,
).
2.6.
( ) .
2.7. (
) , @
, ,
.
2.8.
.
2.9
, ,
, ,
@
83

, , @
.
2.10
, ,
,
.
3. .
3.1. @

, ,
, ,
.
3.2. ,
@
, ,
, .
3.3.
, @
@
.
3.4. ,
@
(
), :
;
;
, ;
;
.
3.5. ( @
) @
, , .
3.6. ,
, , , ,
( @
)
84

 II. ,

:
;
, ;
;
, ..
;
( , );
( );
;
( ).
3.7. , , @
@
@
, .. @
, @
( ,
).
,
, @
,
, .

( , @
, ,
, , ),
@
.
;
,
. @
(). ,
,

.


85

.
, @
, @
, @
. @
,
, ,
, .

()
, @
@
.
@


( ),
.
,
,
:
(
, @
, , @
);
( @

,
,
);
, @
@
.
,

, @
86

 II. ,

, ,
.
@
@ @

. @
,
@
, , @
.
@
, @
. @
,
, @
/ .
, @
@

, .
,
.
@
@
, @
.
@
,
,
.
, ,
, @
.
@
, @
. @
87

: , @
, , ,
, . @
@
.

:
,
.

, @
.
:
, @
; @
, @
; @
, ; @
@ .
@

, 2@ @
, 5@ , , @.
4. 
.
@

@ @
.


,
@
,
. @
@, , , @
88

 II. ,

, , , , @@
, , .
:
, @
;

;
;
;
@
@
;
@
,
.
@


:
( @
, , );
(, ,
, , @).


(
@). 20
8
@ 2000@2001 20 ;
@ 2001@2002 6 +24 @;
@ 4 @
.

2000@2001 . , @
,
@
89

, , , , ,
.
@ .
2001@2002 . @

(@, ).
,
, @
, .
@
,
.

2001@2002 .
:
@ @
@,
;
@
@
@;
@@
@

;
@

@
, @
@


(. 3).

,
90

 II. ,

, :
@
;

;

@
.
@
@

, @
. @

@
.

. @
, @

, @
.
@
@
:
1. .
2.
,
@
.
3. @
( , ).
4. @
( @
, ).
@ @
91

.
,
@
, @

. , @
@
, @
@
,
, . @
@
, .
2000 . @
,
.

, ,
. ,
@
.

92

 II. ,

4.

20@ XX .
90@ XX , @
, .
, 1920@ ,
,
,
. , 
,

, 


( 
) .
, ,

:
 

,
, () 
,
, 
() .

@ @
1994 . @
@
@
93

. @

( )
@ @
( ). 1992 (
)
. @
@
( ,
), @
@ ( @
@
@
). @
@
@

.
,
@
, @
() ,
. @
@
1995
1.

.
, @
, 72
,
. @
(
1 ., . . . .:
" " (), 1995.
94

 II. ,

17)1 @
( 18)2.
,
, @
.
, , .
1998
, @
@
.
, @
@
@

,
. 2000
@
.
, @
,
, . , 1997@
1999

@

@ @
. @
,
@
,
1995 . @
,
, @
1 , 1995, 21, . 1930.
2 , 1995, 33, . 3340.
95

.
, , .
,
,
,
, (@
) @
.
, @
(, ), @
@ @
, ,
, @
@
. , 1998
, ,
1. @

. ,
, ,
@ @
, @
,
, , @

.
@
@
:

1 .., .., .., .. 

? . : , 2000.
96

 II. ,

01.09.2003.

(
(
)
, )

4.

5.

6.

7.

(
, )

1.

( .)

2.

3.

8.

9.

( .)

10.

11.

12.

13.

. .

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

. . .

21.

22.

23.

24. ..
25.

26.

97

27.

28.

29.

30.

31.

32.

, .

33.

34.

35.

36.

( .)

37.

38.

39.

40.

, .

41.

42.

43.

44.

()

( .)

45.

( .)

46.

47.

( .)

48.

( .)

49.

50.

51.

52.

53.

( .)

54.

( .)

55.

( .)

56.

( .)

57.

( .)

98

 II. ,

, ,
@
, @
. , @
,

2000 ,
,
(), , @
, @
. @
@
, , (, , ),
, .
@
,
2001 .

, , ,

@ ,
. 7
: ,
, @

.
@
1.
@
, @
. @
, @
1 Arnstein S.R. A Ladder of Citizen Participation // Journal of the American Institute of
Planners, vol. 35, 4, 1969, July.
99

, :
@ ;
;
;
.
@

@
.



.
@, @ @
, @
, @
.
,
(,
), @
@
. , ,
, .
,
. , @
, @
, , @
, . @
1990@
, @
, ,
( , @
, @
).
, , @
,
100

 II. ,

. ,
.
, , @
. ,
, @
.
, , @

.
, @
, (@
, @@
), , @
,
, , @
. , , @
, @
.
@
, @
.

.
,
() ,
,
@
, .
, ,
@
. @
@

.
@
. @
101

, , @
. @
@
. ,
, , ( ) @
.
@
.
, @
@
.

, @
.
@
@
.


() . @
(
779@783 ), @

, . @
.

(
(@
1057@1061 , @
, , @
1). @
, @

1 , 1999, 19, . 2302.

102

 II. ,

.
, @


, @
,
.

. , @
764 ,
,
, ,

.
, @
, .
,
.
@
. @
@
, @
. @
, , @
, :
@
;
@
;
@
.
103

,

( ).

,


,
.
,
, .
,
,
. ,
,
,

,
1.
, @, @
, @
. @, @
. @, @
.
, , @
, .. , @
.
.
,
@
.
1 : 
.. : . .:
Charities Aid Foundation (CAF) , 1998. 150 .
104

 II. ,

105

.


, @
. @
@
, , ,
. , @
, .. , @
.
,
@
, ,
( ),
.
.
, , @
. , @
(
) , @
. @
@
.

, , ,
.
, @
.
. @
, ,
,
.
, @
.
106

 II. ,

.

@
, @
() . @

. ,
, @
(,
, @
).
() 
.

,
. , @
, 764 ,
.
@
,
, , @
, :
@
@
;

@
.
.

.
@
, (
) .
, @
, @
107

( ), ,
, .
, @
,
: @
@
, @
@
@ @
. , @
(@
), (@) / (@
) .
.
, , @
. @
() @
.
@
,
. @
, ,
@
. ,
@

, ,
,


. @
, @
@ @
.
@
108

 II. ,

@
. @
@
:
) (, @

, );
) ( @
,
).
(@
)
@
.
,
@
, ,
@
25% .

@ ( , @
), (,
.). , ,

100%@ @
, .
.
@ , ,
, ,
,
, @
(), (@
) , @
.
@
, @
109

@. @
, @
,
.
.

.
@
. @
@

. @
, @
.
@

,
. @
. @

,
, .

@

.
1. .
1.1. @
@
, , , ,
,
. , @
@
. @
, .
110

 II. ,

, @
, @
, @
1994 1999 . , , @
1 @
,
, .
, @
:
26 1995 .
594
2;
@
( 33 @
)3;
08 1997 305
@
, 4;


@


, @
22 @
1997 , 14705.
@
, , @

1 , 1994, 34, . 3540.
2 , 1995, 28, . 2669.
3 , 1995, 35, . 3506.
4 , 1997, 15, . 1756.
5 , 1998, 3, . 345.
111

. @
, , @
.
, , @

, @
.
. @
.
1

@

)
)

"

"

( )
, ,
( .. )

"

"

)
(,
)

( )

, ,

) @
,

,

@

,
@

I II
( @ )

) ,
@
(), ()
, ,@

)



)

112

(),

@
(
, ,
..)

,

,
,

 II. ,

, @
@
. .
) .
, , @
, . @
,
@
(). @
(). (
), ,

(social contracting). , @
,
@ . @
,
.
) .
@
, ;
, , @
, , .
) .
@
, , . @
, (.. @
), , , @
, 
. @
,
,
, ( @
). , @
,
, , @
, ,
113

, *.
,
, @
.
) .
779@783
( 39)1. 793, ,
:
( 702 729) 
( 730 739) 
,
779 782 ,

( .).

, @
. , @
709 :
709.
...2. 

( .). ,
(.
).

. ,
,
, @
, ,
@
* ,
.
( )
.
1 , 1996, 5, .. 410, 411.
114

 II. ,

, 2 @
.
.
@
, @
, @
() () .
) @ , @
.
@
. , (, @
, ) , , @
, .
, , , @
@
.
, .
, , @
. @
, @@
, , . ,
, @
, @
.
@
. , @
, , @
.
,
, @

. .
, @
, , @
, , .
, . @
115

, , @
.
. , @
. @
, @
( ) , ,
,

@
(,
).
,
@
, , .
) .
( )

( ).
, @
( , @
) , @
( @
), @
.
.
) ,
, ()
.
,
. @
@
.
, ,
. , , ,
: @
. , @
116

 II. ,

, @
@
,
.
) .
, , @

@ ,
@
. @
, ( ),
@
, , ,
( ), @
.
,
, ,
, . @

(, @


). @
, @ @
,
,
@ @
.


.
( , ) @
.
) .

,
117

. @
(, @
).
@
.
, ,
, , @
, , @ @
.
?
, , . @
, ,

, 16 , 60 170 . @
, ( @
) , @
, , . ,
,
,
.
, @
, @
, @
, , @
.
,
, @
( )
.
, @
, @

,
.
1.2. , @
,
118

 II. ,

. ,
, , @
, @

. , , , @
,
,

( 71@73)1. @
, (, , ) 1
72 . , @
:
1.
:
) ;
,
;
;
) , , , 
, ;
) ; 
, , ; 
, .
, @
, , 2 76 @
, :
2. @

@
.
, @
@
,
1 . .: , 1993.
119

, @
. @
@
.
1.3. @
, , , @

. @
,
, @

.
, @
@ , @
@
, @
@
@
, @
.
2. .
2.1. .
, @
,
, @@

. @
@
. , @
, @
, @

@
.
2.2. .
,
120

 II. ,

@
. , @
, @

.
,
1990@ ( @

1996@2000 ,
222 26.02.1997 .)1,
, , @
. @
, @
@
@
, @
, @ .
@
, @
, @
, .
@
@
, ,
.
( , @
), @
,
.

.
@
,
1 , 1997, 10, .1231.
121

, @
@
@
. : , @
, @
; ,
,
, @
, .
@ ,
,
, @
.

. ,
,
. @
,
,
( ,
).
2.3. .
, ,
,
, (@
, 1)

, , , @
. @
@ @
, @
,

1 , 1998, 31, .3813.
122

 II. ,

() *.

@
. ,
@
, @
1.
2.4. @
.
, , @

. ,
@
, ,
, @
@
@ ( ,
@ ). @
@

.
.
. @
@

@ .
@

@
.
, @
*  .
13 .
1 .: .. .
.:  "", 2001.
123

, @

. @
,
@
. @
@

, .
2.5. .

( 4 15 251
1) ( 1 78 2)
, ,

@
. @

.
, @
. @




( , 78 ). @
@

. 3 2 251 @
,
,
, 

1 , 2001, 33 (.1), . 3413.

2 , 2000, 32, . 3339.
124

 II. ,

, 
, ,

.
@
@
( 1 2 251 ).
,
( 149 ),
. , @

. ,
@
, ,
.
@
@
, @
. @
2 34 , :
, 
.
,
, @
@
:

 


, 

.
,
, @
. , @
125

.
, (, , @
) , @
@
(@),
, , .

, ,

. @


. ,
G
G
. @
@
@
, @
.
,

.
@
(www.nan.ru)*.
@
@
,
@ .

, @
/
* 2 .
126

 II. ,

. @
, @
,

. , @
.
@
. , @
, @

.
, ,
16 , @
@
,
(, ). ,
@
, @
. , @
, , , @
1,
.

1 .., .., .. :
.
"".  , 2001.  114 .
127

5.

, , ,
. 
( 
),

. , @
. , @
, @
, , @
, @
. @
. , , @
, @
, @
. @

. , @
, / @

, ,
.

, fundatio,
fundare (, , @
.), , ,
fundus (, , @
.). @, , fun@
dus bhundhos, @
.
, ,
, .
@
128

 II. ,

, :
() (). @
, .
.

, 
/ 
, 



.
,
.

, 
,


, 
, 


.
,
,
.

@

( , , @ , ).

. @
community foundation.

129

1914 ; @
,
( 600) @
( 100), ,
. 10 .
, @
( , ) @
.
, @
.
,
90@ XX .
, @
() @
.
. @
, @@, , @
, .
. , @

( @
2002@).

, @
.
, @
, ,
, @
,
,
, . , @
@

( ) . @
, , @ @
, , @
130

 II. ,

, .
, ,
, @
. @
.
, , @

, ,

.
@
. , @
@
,
.

@
@
@
( , @
@
) @
@
,
.
@

.
@
, . @
, ,
(. .
). @
. @
@
131

, , ,
@ , ,
,
( ) . @
, , ,
, @
@
. , @
, ,
, , @
,
@
. ,
,

, , . @
, ,

.
, @
@
, ,
. @
@ ( )
, @
. @
@
@
. ,
@
.
@
(@
, ),
@
, @
132

 II. ,

. @
, @
.
.
@
, @
, , (
*) , @
:
) , @
.
:
( @
@ );
( @
@ @
, , , @
);
( @
) @
.
) , @
, @
@
. , , 20%
. , @
1999
( @
), @
( @
), 756 . , @
19,2% .
) .
* "endowment".
133

@
, . @
( , , ) @
:
) ;
) (
,
), @
;
) , @
.
@
@
,
. @
@
, @
@ ,
@
.
,
. @
, @
@ .
@
(, )
.
(, ) @
, , .

.
@
, @
,

134

 II. ,

.
, ,

, @
@
. () @
( @
, @
@
), ,
. .
@
,
. ,

@
.
@
,
, .

, :
, @
, @
@
,
, ;
, @


;
, @
, , @
, , @
, @
. , PR@,
135

,
,
, , , , @
.
, @
@
, .
( , ) @
@
@. . @
: ,
, , .
, , @
( ) ,
: ,
. .
@
.
. 1.

,
. @
: ,
@ @
, .

.
@
136

 II. ,

.
. 2.

( , ),
, , @
, , @
,
.

@
. :
) @
;
) ( , , @
. .)
;
) ( , , @
. .)
.
,
137

, @
. @
,
. @
(, @
. .), @
@
.
, @
, ,
. @

.
.
, @
.

.

, @
, @
,
.
, @
. @
,

,
, ,
(@
, ).

. @
, @
, @
138

 II. ,

, @
, , , .
, @
. ,

, , @
.
, @
.
, @
. @
. ,
@
.

() , @
(, , ) , @
, @
, .
,
@
: , ,
. ,
, @
, .

, (
, , @
) , @
, .

,
, ,
.

139

(1996@2002 ) @
, . @
, , @
@
,
, ,
. , @
, , @
,
.


(,
, , ,
. .), (
) @
.
1.
, 2.
@
@
.
:
@

@

, ,
;

1 Community Foundation. . 13.
" ". .  20002001.
2 ., : . . ., 2000.
140

 II. ,

@
, ,
, ;
,
,
, @
, . .
. @
, ,
, @
.
,
, @
, @
.

.
@
, @
, @
.
@
,
.

141

6.

.

( ) ,
, 
( 
) 
, .
.
@
, @
. @,
90@
XX . , @
. , 1997
.. .. @
, @ (, @
), @
,
1.
. @
, , @
.
. @
@
, , , , ,
, , ,
, , , 2.
, @
1 .. .. . ., 1997. . 143.
2  . . 1. ., 1979, . 603; Webster's New World
Dictionary. N. Y., 1986, p. 587.
142

 II. ,

, ( @
, @
@
), (
, , ). @

( , , , ,
) (
) , , .
@, @
(@@
, ).
,
, @
.
@, @
. , @
, @
, @
. , @
, @

,
.
. , , , @
, ,
, . @
@
.
,
, , , , @
, ,
, @
, @
. , @
@
143

, .
, @

. , @
@
,
.

@
. 1990@ @
@
. @
, @
, @
. @
, , @
, ,
. , @
, , @

@
. , @
.
( ) @
, , , ,
(@
, ),
@
. , @
,
, , @
( )
. ,
, 1990@

144

 II. ,

@
.
@
, .
1993 @
, 282 21
1993 . ,
.
@
@
( 17)1, 1995 .,

( 18)2
@
3 ( 1995 .,
). @
@
@
: 1996 @

,
4.

, @
. , @
. 398 14.06.95 . @
() @
; @
392 30.04.96 .
1 , 1995, 21, . 1930.
2 , 1995, 33, . 3340.
3 , 1995, 27, . 2503.
4 .., .. .
 1999. .: "
" (), 2000.  ..165170.
145

@
@
. ,

, @
, @
( , 390@1 25.09.96
., ., 705@ 19.12.96 . .). @
1997 .
@
.
@
, @
. 80@90@ XX

.
,
, @
@
,
. @
90@ XX .
@
: , @
() , , . . @
:
, , @
. @
,
, .
, . @
, @
@
90@ . @
, .
@
146

 II. ,

,
. @
@
, @
.

@
, , . @

@
, @



.
,
@
.
, @
, @
@
.

, @
,
. @



,
.
@ @
, ,
@
. .
147

1. , , @
. ,
,

, , @
,
. @
, @
@
, @
.
@
@
.
2.
, , @
, @
.
, @
,

1. @
, ,
,
,
.
3. ,
. , @
,
,


1 . . . .:  "
", 1997.
148

 II. ,

().
@
. ,

. ,
@
@
@
, @
.
4. , , @
,
, , @
, @
@
. , @
@
, , , 1.
, , @
, @
@
,
.

,
( )
. , @
, 1996 @
@ 2.
. 2
1 . , . , . . .
.: , 1995. 32 .
2 , 1996, 35, . 4137.
149

,
, , @,
, ,
( ,

, . . ), @, @

.
, .
13 1 (

), @
,
, , .
@
, ,
@
, .
@
. , , ,
, @
.

@ , @
, ,

, 1 78:
1. ,

:
, 

;

1 , 1995, 52, . 5110.
150

 II. ,

, 
, , 
;
,
, 
, ,

1.
@
. , , @
@
.
, , , @
@

( @
, @
, , , @
).

@
.
, , @
.
@
@
. @
, @
. ,
, @
, , , @
. , 90@
XX ,
1 , 2000, 32, . 3339.
151

@
, .
@
@
. .
, @
@
, ,
. @
, @
, , ,

, ,
,
( @
). @
, @
, , , @
. , @
, , @
, . ,

@ , @
, , ,
, @
.
. @
,
. @
, ,
, ,
, . @
, , , , @
,
@
. , , @
152

 II. ,

,
( ) .

, , .
, ( 2001 @
) , @
( 4 15 @
251 1). 2002 @
. @
@
,
( ).
2002 @
@
. ,
1 2002 .
251 14 1
:

, 
() :

, 
, 
,
;

, , ,
, 
;
,
, 
.
1 , 2001, 33 (.1), . 3413.
153

@
, , 2002 ,
, , @
,
, , @
. ,
88 , @
24 2002 ., @
. ,
2002 . @
,
.
(. )
, , @

.
,
, @
. , @
@
, ,
.
, , , @
, @
,
.
, , @
, @
. , @
1996 , @
, 2000 @

, @
.
, @@
.
154

 II. ,

. ,
,
@
. , (
) , @
.

, @
, , @
.
, , @
@
, @
.

(
, ).
,
, @


.
@
@
(, 1
2), @
, , , , @
.
:
,
,
1 ., ., ., .. ?
 . : "", 2000.
2 .. . .: CAF, 2000.
155

(, @
);
() ,
;
, ;
, ;
() ;
, @
,

, , ,
.

, ,
. , ,

.

,
,
, @
,
() .
,
2, ,
, @ , @
@
.
1. @ .
@

. ,
. @
, @
. , @
156

 II. ,

,
@
. @
.
2. @ ().
, @
, @
,
,
.
, @
; ,
.
3. .
, @
. @
, @
, , , @
. ,
, @
@
, @
, @
, @
.
,
, 13 .
4. .
,
, @
.
,
:
157

. @

. , @
158

 II. ,

.
@,
. , @
, @
.
@
( ,
, ),
, @
. ,
,
() , @
. ,
@
@
.
@, , @
,
.
( ) @
, ,
. , , @
@ @
. @

, , :
@
, , @
;
;
@
,
() @
;
( @
159

)
, ;

, , @
;
@
;
;
, @
;
@
, ;
( @
) ,
( @
).
, ,
@
( ), @
(
). @
, .
@
:
(, @@
) ;
;
.
@
.

@


@
160

 II. ,

. @
.
, ,
, @
.
1. .
, , ,
. @
@
, , @
, , ,

, .
, ,
, , @
. .
, @
.
2. ( @
()) .
@
.
2.1. @
.

, , @
.
2.2.
.
, @
. @
@
,

@
.
161

2.3. ,
.

,
, , @@
. ,
, , ,
.
@
, @

. ,

(USAID)
()
(),
,
, @
,
.. @


.
3. . @
.
,
, .
( ,
), @
@
, @
*.
4. .
* 16 .
162

 II. ,

.
4.1. (
).
, , @
@ ( ) ,
. , @

, ,
. @
, ( @
) @
.
, @
,
.
, ,
.
@
.
. ,
, , ,
,

@ .
, @
, .
: @

.
@
, @
.
@
.
, ,
.
163

4.2. .
, @
@ @
, ,
@
.
.
.

.
,
. , , @
@

. 1999 . @
248,9 . ., 447,7 . . (@
1,8), 2000 . 1160,8 . . @
( @
)
4181,9 . . ( 3,6)1.
@
.
@
, @
@

,
, .

1 .: . .// 
.  2000. .: , 2001. ..135150.
164

 II. ,

7.

@
, @
, @
.
@
, / @


@
.

(Jahrmarkt).
@
@
. , @@
, .
, , @
, @
. ,
, @
,
@
. @
,
.
, @
.
@
. XIX .
, @
. @
165

, , @

. , .
, , @
. @
, @
, . ,
,
, .

,
, @
@
. , @
@ ,
.

( , @
,
,
), @
, @
@
.


, @
.
1996 , @

()1. ,
1 .: .., .. .
"
(). , 1998.
166

 II. ,

@
@
.
@
@
, @
. @
@
. @
PR@.

, @
(), .
@
1998 1.
, , @
. ,
, @
: @
.
. @
@
.
@
.
2000 .
2001 .
2002 .
2002 ,

.
@
:
1
. . . . , 1998.
167

()

1.

1996

2.

1998

3.

1997

4.

1998

5.

1999

6.

()

2001, 1999

7.

1998

8.

1998

9.

1999

10.

2002

11.

()

1999

12.

2000

13.

1997

14.

2000

15.

2001

16.

1999

17.

1998

18.

1999

19.

2001

20.

()

2001

21.

2000

22.

2000

23.

2000

24.

1999

25.

2000

26.

2001

27.

1999

28.

2002

29.

2001

30.

2000

31.

1999

32.

2001

168

 II. ,

33.

2001

34.

2000

35.

2002

( )

36.

@2000 (14
)

2000

37.

@2001 (15 )

2001

38.

@2002 (15 )

2002

@
. ,
,
.
@
. @
@
, @
, @
. ,
( )
@
.
, @
, @
.
@
, @
, @
, (,
, ),
, @

, (.
. ) @
.
169

, @
, @
@
. @
, , @
, . ,
: @
. @
, @ .
, @
( ) ( @
)
.
,
: ,
,
,
. , ,
, @
, @
.
, ,
,
,
, (
) @
, , @
, . @
.
, ,
, @
.
,
,
,
170

 II. ,

. @
, , .

@ @
@
. @
, @
,
@, @, @
@ @ .
@
,
. @

@
( ).
, ,
, @
. @
, ,

,
, @
.
@
, @
@
. @
, , , @
@ .


.
. , @
@
171

. : @
,
, @
. @
, , @
, @
( ) *. , @
@
, @
.

, @

.
, , , @
, ,
, .
, ( @
, @
@
PR@) @
,
.
, @
.
, @
, ( ) @
,

*
, "compact",

. ,
.
172

 II. ,

, .
1. .
, @
, ,
.
.
@
:
( @
).
@
@
.
. @
, , .
:
, , .
PR@ , @
.
, , @
,
, @
.
( ,
,
).
.
, , @
, :
( @
,
),
@
( @
, ,
6 13 @
173

),
,
.
2. .
@
PR@. ,
@
@

@
.


() ( @

, ), @
(
).


. ,
, II
@
@2001,

(, ).
3 .
, , , @
.



. @
@
, @
( , ) @
174

 II. ,

,
, , @
.

. ,

( ,
).

, @
@
@
. ,
, .
, @
@
, , , @

.
@
, .
, @
,
.
@
( , , @
).
, @
@
. ,
, , @
, ,
175

.
@
. , ,
, , @
.
. ,
,
@, , @
, , , @
.
,
,
, .
:
, PR@ @
, @
. ( , , @
, , ) @
, @
,
@ ,

. , ,

.



. ,
, @
, ,
. , @ ,
.
, @
, .
176

 II. ,

@
. @
, , .
, @
, , @
, :
,
, ;
. @
, @
, , , ,
;

.
, @
@
,
. @
, ,
, @
@
, ,
, @
.


.
, @
, , ,
,
.
, PR@@
. , ,
, , @
,
, @
177

,
, @
, @
, .

178

 II. ,

8.


/ ,
,
, 
, 

/  .

, @
.
, @
,
. .

: .
, @
( @ , @ @
, savet), @
, @
. , : (),
(@,
kom , , , ), @
, (@, @
weid ,
, ,
@
, , vdas
@
wise ).
:
) , , ;
) .
, ,
179

. ,
, , ,
( )
. @
, .
@
.
: , , @
, , @
. , @
, . (
) @
.
@

@ . @
, .
, @
, @
@ . ,
@ ,
.


. , @
@
, @
.
:
, , @
. @
, @
. @
@
; , @
180

 II. ,

,
.

. , @
(30@80@ XX )
, , @
, ,
, .
1990@ ,
. @

, @
, @
@
. @
,
@, , @
: @
, , @ @
. , , @
, , @
.

. @
@
( : @
, , .)
. @
@
.

@

( ).
, ,
181

,
.
@
@
. @
(
@
)
,
:
. 1.

, ,
, , @
@
, .

. ,
@

, . @
@ (
)
, .
182

 II. ,

, @
29 1997 1, , ,
,

. @
@
.
, , @
, @
, @
.
, @
,
@
, .

. @

.
,
, @
,
.
@

( ).
:

1 .: .. :
//
.  1999. .: "
" (), 2000.  . 90104.
183

. 2.

, ,
. @
.
, @
( ), , ( @
, , ), @

, .
, , , @
2 .
, @
. @

,
, @
.
, @
, @


@
.

184

 II. ,

, (
)
@
. @
(, ,
) . , @
, @
( ).

, ,
, : @
,
/ . ,
,
.
, , @
,
( @
) @
.
@
@
, ( )
@
. , ( 30
2001 ) 5
II @
.
. , @
@@
, @
,
.
,
@
185

. @
, @
. ,
, @
@ @
,
,
.
. @
, (, @
) ,
.
,
, @
.
, . @
,

( 12 2000 )1 , @
.
.
, @
( ), @
, @
. ,
, @
. @
, @
.

1 : .
 2000. . .. .: , 2001.  . 258267;
.:

. : ..,
.., .., .., .., .., ..
. .. .. .: " ", 2001.
186

 II. ,

, @
.


, ,
.
, , @
@
:
,
, @
,
() @ @
@

, @
,
, @
;
, @
,
() @@
,
@@
, ,
@
@
/
;

, @
, @

,
@
187

, ;
, @
@


, @

.

:
1. .

@
.

@
, @
,
,
@
,
.
@
.

.
@
@
@ ,
. . @
@
, .
@
, ,
,
. , ,
188

 II. ,

@
@
.

, ,

. @
.
2. .

. ,
@
,
@
; .
@


. @ ,
@
(@
), @
( ).
,
@
,
.
3. .
@
, , @
( )
. @
, 
. , @
.
@
189

(, .), @
@
.

:
, , ;
, @

;
@ ;
@ @
;
;
.

, @
, @
.
1. , , .
) : ,
( , ) @
.
) :
,
;

(@
) ;
, @
@
;
(, , @
) @
;
@
@
190

 II. ,

;
@
,
;
, @
() @
;
@
@ , @
/ ;
@
.
2. , 
.
) : ( , )
, , @
.
) :
@
, , @
()
;
@
(@
, ) @
( , ) , @
: , ;
@
(, )
;
, @

@
;
@ @
.
191

3.  .
) : ( , )
, @
@ .
) :

;
, @
@@
, ,
, @@
@

. ,
@
.
,
( , , @
, . .), ,
, .
,
,
, @
. @
, , @
,
@
.
@
, @
@
. @
@
@
@
.
192

 II. ,

()
,

@
. @

@
.
(, @
@ , @@
, ).
, @
, .
@
.

.

. , @
, @
.
,
.
4. 
.
) : @
.
) :
,

, @
@
@
.
, @
,
193

, @
, , @
, @
, , @
.
( ,
, , @
, ,
).
5. .
) : ,
,
.
) :
, @
(, . .).

: , @
, ,
, @
. . , @
,

, . .
@
@ ,
,
,
@
.
@
@
.
6. .
) : , @
, ;
194

 II. ,

) :
,
, @

.
:
;
@

,
,
@
, ,
.
;
@

,
.
@
;
@
@
, .

.
:

;
@
, ,
;
@
@
.
@
195

:
;
;
;
.

@
.
,
:
;
;
.

, @
, , , @
. ,
, @ @
.
@
; @@
@@
; ,
@
, , @
, @
.
, :
) @
, , ,
;
) @

, @
;
) , ,
196

 II. ,

, , @

.
, () @
@
:

197

,


. @
, @
.
, , @
@
@
.

,
.
@, .

@
. , @
, @
, @
.
@
, @
,
@
.
.
@
, , @
, ,
,
, @
@
. , @
, , @
, , , .. @
198

 II. ,

@ . , @
, ,

. @
, ,
@
() @
. @
@
. ,
@
. @
.
@, .

. @
, @

. , ,
@
,
, ,
@
, , , @
.


.

, @
.
(. 16
), , @
, @@
.
199

@
, , , @
,
, @
@
@
. ,
@
.

200

 II. ,

9.

.



.
, ,
,
(lobia).
(lobby
@) @
, 40@ XVII @
@
. , @, @
,
. , @
( ). .
,
, @
, . @
,
@
.
, , @
@
( , @
), @
. @
, ,
. @
@
, @ .
201

, @
,
. XIX . @
@
, @
, , @
, , . @
, @
: ,
1808 . 10@
.
, , @
@
. @
, . .
, , @
, , @
, , .


. , , @
@
. @
, @
@
, @
XIX ., XVIII
., .

80@90@ . XX . , @

90@ . XX .
, .
70@80@ . XX . @
..,
202

 II. ,

,
. 90@ .
,
1992 . @
. 1995 . @
, @
(, @
) ( , @
, ) @
.
1990@ .
@ . ,
, .

. ,
,
,
,
@
@
, @
.
, @
. @
, @
, @
.
@
,
?

. , @
@
, , . @
. @
,
203

, @
@
. , @
,
@
, .
,
,
, @
. @
, @
, , @
@
, , ,

.
@
, @
, , @
, @
@
.
, @
:
1. ,
.
2.
@
.

, (
),
, .
, ,
, @
,
204

 II. ,

, ,
.
, ,
, ,
. @
@
,
, @
. , @
, : @
,
.

.
, , @
, , @
. @
, @
. , @
@
, @
@
, , @
. @
, @
, . @
, , .
, @
.
,
,
@

. @
, @
, ,
205

@
. , 2001 . @
.
.
. @
. , ,
, ,
,
. , @
, @
. : ,
.

(). @
,
, @
.
, @
( )

.
, @
,
1990@ .
,
, @
. @
.

,
@
. @
, . @
,
. :
206

 II. ,

1. :
, ..?
2. @
@ ?
3.
: ,
?
., , @
@
. @
,
1. @
, @

, .

, .
.: @
, @
@
2. @
, : ... , @
3.
@
, @
,
, @
@
,
( ) .
1 Bentley A.F. The Process of Government. Cambridge. 1967 (originally published in 1908).
2 Latham E. The Group Basis of Politics: Notes for a Theory. // "American Political
Science Review" Vol. 46, 1952. p.390.
3 Hall D.R. Cooperative Lobbying  the Power of Pressure. Tucson. 1969. p. XI.
207

@
, , @
, , . . @
,
.
@
, @
.

. @
, @
.

@
@
, , . @
@
@
, . , @
,
, . .
@. @
, , , @
.
@
, @
.
, @
, , @
.
1) (, @
) .
, @
@
. ,
208

 II. ,

, , @
@
, @
. @
.
,
, , , , @
, , , . @
.
2) .
, , @

. , @
.

. , ,
@ ,
,
,
. , ,
,
,
@
. @

.
. @
, , .
1, @
, @
,
. @
, @
1 Berry Jeffrey M. Lobbying for the People. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press. 1977. p.7.
209

, , , . ., . . @
, .
@
, .

,
.
@
. , @
,
@ @
,
. @
, @
, . @

. , , @
@
@ , @
. .
,
,
. @
, ,
.
, : @
, @
, , , @
( ),
,
, , @
. . @
.
,
, ,
, , @
210

 II. ,

, ,
, ,

. , , .
@@
, . ,
.
@
.
,
@
, @
. , @
. @

; @
, , ,
@ . @
,
,
.
, @@
,
.
, ,

. ,
1. .
(
, )
.
,
@
. , ,
, ,
, @
211

, .
2. ( ). ( @
, , ,
, @, . .,
, @
, , .
.
.)

.
, , @
,
. @
, @
.
@
, @
, @
. , @
@
@
@
, , , @
, 1.
, @
.
3. .
@
,
@

.

1 :
. / . ... ., 1997.  . 115.
212

 II. ,

, @

, .
4. @
( ), (
), @
, @
, . @
, @
, @
@
. @
.
, @
, ,
. @
1996 1998 @
. @
. @

, @
, @
, @

@
, @
.
5. , .
,
@
. @
,
; @
( @
);
@
213

; ,
.
6. ( )
(
).
@,
,
.
@ @
, ,

@.
7. .
@
, @
. @
, @
.
,
, , , , .
, , @
, , , @
@
.
,
, .
, ,
@, , ,
, @
@
, , @
,
. , @
@
,
. @
214

 II. ,

.
) ( 6000 @
, 337000 ):
1. 23 , @
. @
:
,
, @
;
, @

@, @
, , , @

, ;
, @
, @
, ,
;
@
, @
@
, , , ,
, , .
2. , @
, @

, @
.
) (50 , @
, ).
@
@
, @
@
. @
215

@
.

@
,
, . @
@
, @
. @
, @
, :
;

;
;
;
;
.
: @
, .
@
. :
1. ( @
).
2. (
, ).
3. (
).
4. @ @ (@
).
5. (
).
6. ( ,
).
7. ( , @
216

 II. ,

).
8. ( ).
9. (@
/ @
, , ).
10. (, @
).
11. () (@
, ).

, @

, , .
@
: , , @
, : , @
.
@
: , , (
).
@
@
, .
,
.

. @
, ,

. :
1. ,
;
2. ( @
);
3. ;
4. .
217

:
5. ;
6. @
( ,
/ @
)*;
7. (
);
8. ,
.
.
1. .
, @
,
, @
, , . @
, @
@
, @
.
, @
, @
,
, , ,
.
@
, @
. , @
, ,
.
2. . .
* "grassroots"

,
.
218

 II. ,

,
,
, @
, , ,
. @

, . , ,

@
, . @
, , @
.
,
, , @
. , @
,
, , @
, . @
, @
, , .
3. .
wining and dining ( @
)
.
,
, @
. (
) @
, , , , ,
, @ . .


. @
. ,
,
, .
219

4. .
, , @
.
.
5.
, ,
,
, , @
, (). @@
,
. @, @
.
@
.
, , @
,
.
()
, @
( ).
6. @.
: @
, , , @
@
, @
.
, ,
. , @
@
. @
. @
@
, , ,
. @
, , (@
, , . .)
220

 II. ,

,
, @
, @
, @

.
,
: , ,
@
. ,
. @
,
,
,
@

. , @
, @
. ,
(), (), ..
7. .
@
. @
. ,
. @
, @
, ( ) @
. @
,
, @
: ( @
, , @
, , ); @
;
,

221

.. @ @
, @
.
8. , .
,
( @
), @
,

,
@
. @
14
.
, @
@
, , ,
, . @
(
) . @
, @
,
.
, @

.
1. .
1.1. , @
.
1.2. .
1.3.
SWOT@ ( , ,
, ).
1.4. , (),
, .
1.5. @
222

 II. ,

.
2. .
2.1. .
2.2. .
2.3. (,
, , @
).
2.4. ,
.
2.5. .
2.5.1. (@
, ).
2.5.2. . ( @
@
.)
2.5.3. , @
.
2.5.4. / @
.
2.5.5.
3. ( .. ).
4. .
5. .
6. .
6.1. .
6.2. .
7. @
.
8. , .
,
, , @
.
, @
.
,
, , (
223

), ( ,
), , .
, @
,
.
, , ; @
,

, . ,
, ,
, .
,
@
, . , @
, @
.
,
@
,
@
,
.
,
, @
, .
1. @
.
@
.
, . @
, ,
. @
, ,
.
2. , @
@
224

 II. ,

. ,
, ,
.
, .
,
, @
,
.
3. . @
@
. ,
.
4. .
,
, ,

( ). , @
, @
, , @
.
5. . @

,
/ @ .
@
.
6. . ,
. @
. ,
. @
.
,
.
7. @. ,
, @
@
225

, , @
.
8. @
.
@
.
9. @
, .
. @

.
10. .

,
@
.
11. .
@
, ,
. ,
.
12.
.
@
,
.
13. . @
, @
, @
. .
14. , @
. ,
,
@
. @
, .
226

 II. ,

15. .
,
, @
, @
,
. , @
@
.

, , @

, , , , . @
, @
, ,
. @

: , ,
. @
, , @
.
@
(. 3),
@
,
, @
. @

, . . , @
. @

@
,
. , @
( ) @
, 
227

,
(. 17), 


, 
(. 19). @
,

, 

(. 10),
,

... , 

( ) (.
16).
... 
, 
, 
... , 
... (. 43). @
() ,
, , , 
(. 13),
,

, , 
(. 14).
@
, @
. , . 12 : 
, 
,
. 

228

 II. ,


.
,
, 

, , 
. 

, , 
, .
,

, 

.
. 8 @
@@ @
:
1.
,
, 
, .
2. 
, 
, 
,
 , , 

, ,
, 

.
3. 

, 
.
229

.
@
,
. , 1992 .
, @
. @
. , 1996 . @
, @
, . @

.
1995 . @

,
. @
@
, ,

. @
(. 38)
@
@
@
. , @
@
@
, @
. , @
@
, .
(
, , @
) @
. @
@
230

 II. ,

, , ,
. ,
@
, .
,
,
. @
. @
.
1993 . . @
1995 . @

,
@
.
,
.
. @
, . @
. @
@
, @

, ,

.

,
(, , @
), . ,

,
.
, . . @
.
231

@
,
@
. @
, , , @
. @
. @

,
. @
@
.

@
,
( , @
@
, . .),
@
. @
, @
, @
. @
@
.
.
, , @
@
, @ @
. .
@
.
,
@
, .
, @
232

 II. ,

@
.
@
.
, @



.
, (. .
) @
, @
. ,
, ,
, , ,
, @
,
@

.
, @
.

.
, @
, , @
, @
@
.
, @
, @
.

233

III.

10.



,  
.
,
( ) @
( 2).
@
,
. @
, ,
.

@
, ,

. @
@
, 60@
. ,
, , , ,
234

 III.

@ , , @
. , . 36 70 % @
@
1. @
@

,

.
@
.
@
, , , , @
, .
, , @
. ,
, , , @
, , @
, @
, . @

,
.
@
70@ , @
@@
, @
, @
. @
, @
, , @

1 .. , .. . //
 , 2000, 4.  .48.
235

1.
@
(lifelong learn
ing), , , @
, @
XXI @
: ; @
, , 2.
@
:
,
,
.
, @

(, , , @
), @
@
(, , ).
@
, , @
.
@
, , @
,
, , ,
.

3,
,

1 Communication from Commission. Making a European Area of Lifelong Learning a

Reality. Commission of the European Communities. Brussels, 21.11.2001.
2 http://dvgu.ru/vido/unesko/utopia.html
3 .. .  . 1998.
236

 III.

@
, @
.

, ,
, , , @
.
, , @
.
,
, , ,
, @
, @


(, , , ,
..)*.
,
, @
@
, , .


(), . @
, @
, @
@
@
,
, @

.
* " " ,

www.eaea.org.
237

, , @
, @
,
, .
@
, @
,
, , ,
( ),
( ),
( ) .
@

, @
.
,
, , @
, @

, ,
, ,

.
, ,
@
( ),
@ 2002. @.
, @


. :
@
@
@
;

238

 III.

@

;

, @
@
.
@
@ :
@
1;
@
, ,
;
@
;
@
;

.
, @
,
, , @
. , ,
, , @
, ,
, @
, . @
, @
,
.

1 :
.., .., . . .
. .: , 2000. 143 .
239

, @


( , , @
@
), @
.
50@ . @
,
1:
. 1.

,
@
@
:

1 ().
. .: ,
2001. ..3940.
240

 III.

. 2.

@
@.
@
1: , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , .
@:

;
;

.
, @
,
@
, .
, @
@ @
,
1 . , .
. , 2(2), 1998.
241

.
@ @
, @
.
, ,
, , @
, @
. ,
, @
, @
,
:



;
, @
;

;
(, ..)
(, @
, ..) @
( , , ..);
@
( ;
@ ,
..).

,

.
@
, ,

242

 III.

.
,
(@
), , @

.
@
, , @
, , @
, ,
.
, ,
,
, ,
.
, @
. @
, .
1:
, , @
, , @

;
, @

@
;
,
, , @
, ,
;
.
@
1
. . 1994.  .23.
243

, @
, @
, .
, ,
@
:
;

, @
, ;
, @
, , , @
;
, @
;
@
(@
,
), @
;
@
.
, @
;
, ; , @
@
, ; @
, .
,
, , @
, , @
, , @
.

, ,

244

 III.

1.

:
, @
.

, @
@
. : @
,
,
, @
;
, @
; @
. , @
,
.
.


, @

, @.

: , , @
, @
, @
, , . @
@
@
. , @
1 .., .., .. . .
. .: "", 2002.  144 .
245

, , @
,
.
.
, , @
, , @
.
@
, @
,
.

.
, ,
, ,

, @
@
.
, @
, , . @
@
. @
,
. @

. @

.
, @

,
. @
. @@
,
.
246

 III.

, @

. @
,
, @
, @
.

,
, 16
, @
.
G
@
. @
.
, @
, @
. @

( , ,
).
@
:

@
( @
,
);

@
@
@
.
247

,

:
@, .. @
,
@
, @
, @
@; @
1:
( @
), @@
@
, ;
, , , @
; @
@
@,
, ,
, , ;

(, , );
;
; @
@
; ,
, @
@
@
2.

1 . ,
INTRAC. ., 2002.
2 . 13 .
248

 III.

11.

@
, @
. @
@
( ,
, , , , , @
, , .), @
.
@
, @
. 
,
, 
,
,
.
( @
) (,
, ) .
informatio , ,
, . , @

. 20@ XX @
. @
@
.
, @

.

(
, )
249

,
@
, @
. , , PR@@
PR@. @
, ,
,

@
. , PR@
PR@ @
. , PR (
)
, @
public relations, @
.
, @
, @
. , @
, ,
@
.

, @
@

. @
@
, @
( @
), . ,
, , @
, @
, .
@
250

 III.

@

.
, ,


.
@
, .
,
@ @
. @
, @
@ , @
, @
@
, , @
,
, @
. @
, @
@
,
, @
.
.
@
, @
, @
: @
, , @
@ @
, , *.
*
15 .
251

, @
. 80@90@ XX @
(. . @
) @
( @
), @
, @
. @
, 90@ XX (. . ,
@
) @
.

@
, @
,
. @

, @
,
.
,
, @
, @
.
, @
. @
, @
90@ XX XXI @
, .

, , ,
. @
,
,
252

 III.

,
. , @
@
.

, @
,

@
.

@
@
, @
,
.
@
.
.

, , @
.
, ,
. @
.
, @
.
,
, @
.

@
.
253

@
,
, . @

.
,
, ,
,
(). , ,
.

@
, , , @
@
, ,
. @
.

@
, @
, . :
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
.
. @

, @
@
, . @
254

 III.

, ,
. ,

, ,
. ,
,
, @
. , @
/ . @
, @
, .
@
.
.
,
@ (@

, @
,
),
, , (PR) .
, @
. @
.
G
@ @
@
. , 4 29
:
, , 
,
.
5 @
, @
255

:
.
.
@
, , . . @
,
. @, 2 29 :
, 
, , 
. 
, , , 
.
@, 4 29, @
, ,
:
,
, .
@,
( 24):
1. , ,

.
2.
,

,
, .
, , @
, @
.
@
. ,
@
,
. , @
,
256

 III.

, @
(,
,
, @@
.). ,
, : @,
@, ,
.
@
, ,
, @
, @
,
. , @
. @

.
@
. , @
@
,
.
, , @
, ,

.
@
.

@
(@
),
@
. , @
.
257

. @
, @
@
.
1. @

. ,
@
, , ,
, ,
.
@
, @
, @
, @@
. , @
, .
, , @
,
, @
@ @
. ,
,
@
.
,
@
,
.
, @
@
, , , @
, @
, @
@ , , ,
.
258

 III.

,
@
, @

, , @
.
, , , @
.
, .
2. @
, ,

@
. , @
, @

. @
,
@
. @
,
.
3. ( @

) ,

( ) @
. ,
,
, , , .
.
, , @
, @
, .
, ( @
) ,
259

, , , .
,
, @
, .
, , : , @
. , @
, @
,
,
, @
. ,
, . @
@
( @
).

, .
@
, @
,
, ,
.

. , ,
, , .
, , @
,
@
. ,
@
,
, @
, @
.

. @
III @
(). @
260

 III.

90@ ,
@
.
.

:
(
);
(, @
, @
, .);
@
, III
III ;
III ;
@ @
@ , , @
, , .
@
@
.
@
III
, , @

.
90@ XX @
@
, @
1,
. @
. @
@

1 :
. .
.  ., 2002.
261

1.
,
,

2. @
, 3.
@ @
. @
, @
, @
@
, ,
.
, (
) , 14 @
.
, @
@
(e@raider)4. , @
,

@ ,
.
, , e@raider
, @
, @
( ) @
,
, @ .

1 "100
". . . ..,
...  ., 2001.
2 ,
"" (.): http://www.trainet.org.
3  ", !" .: ..
.  ., 2001.
4 :
http://www.oskemen.kz/uk3_2_1a.htm#2.
262

 III.

12.

, , , , 
( , 
) 
, , 
, , 
,
.
,
, @
( @
)
.
, ,
. communicatio @
, .

@
, @ @
.


.

@
. @
,
.

@
263

,
, @
, @
.
, @
, @
, , @
, , ,
.
, , .. @
@
, , @
(, @
, , @
) @
@
( , , ..),
. @

, , @
, @
, @
, , @
.


, @
.
@
@
. @
, @
(, @
@
).
264

 III.

@
(@
, @, ,
) , @

, @
.
@

@
,
.


, ,
. , @
@
, . ,
, ,

. ,
, , @
, @
, @
, @
, @
.

, .
@
:
, ,
@
,
, @
;
265

(),
, @
,
@
(@, , ..);
@
,

.
@
:
, @
, ;
, @
;

;
, @
.

, ,
1:
,
. , @
, @
, .

() (),
.
,
, ,
.
1 . ., ., .
. . . 2001. .36.
266

 III.

(), .
, @
.
, @

, ,
@
, @
. @
, (
; ; @
, ;
..), , @
( ; @
; ,

, ..).
, ,
@
, , @
@ @
.

; @
; ;
.

, , @
.
,
, .. ,
, , ,
. @
,
.
267

,
,
80@ . . :
: ,
, ;
: ,
, / ;
:
;
: @
, , ; , ,
, ;
:
, @
.
@
, @
,
, .
,
, , @
. @
,
,
, @
. , ,
, .
,
,
.
@
, .
, , , ,
. , , @
.

268

 III.

@
, @
,
@@
, @
, @
@
, .
,
.
(, , ) ,
@
.
, . @
@
() @
.
, .

( ), :
, ; @
; , .
,
, @
, , @
, , @
, () .
@
:
1. , ( @
). @
(, @
, @
,
, @
),
269

(, @
, @
),
(, @
).
2. , @
,
,
. @
.
3. , , , @
, , , @
,
.
4. , , ,
,
.
5. ,
, : @
, .
, .

:
1. . .
1970@ 10
:
( @
);
( @
);
, (
);
(
, ..);
(
);
270

 III.

( , @
);
(
);
( ,
;
, , );
( ,
);
( ,
.. , ).
2. ,
, .
, , ..,
.
3. @
, ,
, .
4. , , @
, ,
.
()
().
5. , ..
, ,
.
6. :
, , ,
() ,
..
, @
:
;
;
KISS (Keep it short and sim@
ple ).
271

()
,
: , @
, , @
.. @
, @
.

@
, :

, @
@
;

.
@
, @
.

,
.
, , , ,
, @
.
11 .

@
.
@
,
.
, ( )
272

 III.

.
@
, @
,
, .
, @
, @
, .. @
, , @
@
.

273

13.

, @
@
.


, 
, , 
, ,
,
.
. , @
. @
,
, . , @
@ (
), @
( @
),
@
.

,
. @


,
, @
.

, @
. ,
, , @
274

 III.

. .
, .
.

@
.
( , @
, , @
. .).
@
.
.
, @
, (@
, @ .).
, @
,
,
( ,
, .).
,

.

. : @
, @

. @
,
.
, @
,
,
275

, , @
90@ XX . ,
@

(, , @
. .). @
@ .
, @
, .
1997 @

,
@
(World Learning). 25 @
, , @

(Management Systems International). @
@
100 , .

, , @
, @
. @
@
, ,
, @
. .
@
@
. @
,
( @
1996@2000 , @
276

 III.

26 1997 2221),
, , ,

@
2. @
, @
@
, , @
.
@
@
. ,
.
@
3. @
, @
, @
, .
,

.

@
.

@
,
1 , 1997, 10, . 1231.
2
"" : ..,
.., .., .. :
. .: "", 1997. . 514.
3 .: .. :
// .., ..
.  1999.  .:
"", 2000. .90104.
277

@
, @
() .

*. @
, @
, .
( @
)
(, @
), ,
(@,
).
, @
@
.
,

(), 1.
, @
,
@
, @
, .
, @
. @
, ,
* 
, , , http://ipen21.org/,
www.odn.ru, www.intertraining.org, www.ndc.org.ru, www.ipen.ngo.org.ru,
(, www.evaluatorsInstitute.com, www.eval.org
 , http://www.lshtm.ac.uk/php/phpteach.htm#ShortCourses  ,
http://www.mosaicnetintl.ca  , http://www.sfe.asso.fr  ,
http://wbln0018.worldbank.org/oed/oedevent.nsf/internetevents/
F413548458146D3F85256A69006BEE78?opendocument  ).
1 . .
. , 2000.
278

 III.

, ( , @
@ @
@
), @
.

@
, @
, @
.
:
,
(
, .), @
, @
,
;
, @
, (@
, . .) @
, ,
.
@
. , @
@ ,

.
,
. (
) @
, @
. . ), , , @
.
@
, , @
279

. , , ,

@ .
, @ , @
@
, . @@

, , @
.
, @
, @
, .
@
.
, @
@
. ,
,

, , @
. @

. @

,
.

. , .
@ ( @
, ). .
) @
.
) (
, @
@
). :
280

 III.

,
, ,

.

@
, @
@
@
. , , @
.
) . .
) . @
, @
, @

. @
@
, @
.
,
@ , , @
@
.
.
, ,
, , , @
, , .
, @

.
@, @
. @
,
. @
, ( @
281

) @
,
. ,
.
@, @
. @
, (.
, ) .
, @
@
,
, .
, , @
, @
.
. @
,

.
@,
.
@
, ,
@
, ,
,
.
@,
@
.
.
, , @
, @
.
282

 III.

@
1.
@
,

(, , @
, ), @
, , :
, () @
. , @
@
, .

@

.
, @
, :

();
;
( ,
) @
() @
()
.

, :
( , @
, ,
);
1

, 1998, 31, .3813.

283

(.. , @
, , @
).
,
.
, @
. ,
, .
,
.

(
@
, , @
), ,
( , , @
@ ).
:

.
, , @
, .

, @

, @
( ).
@
,
(, SWOT@
, , Q@ .). @
. @
@
.
@
284

 III.

. ,
:
;
, ( @
);
,
@
,
.
, , @
:
, ;
, @
;
, ,
;
@
.

@
.
1. ,
, @
, , .
@
@
. @
@
.

.
, @
@ @
, ,
285

1.
2. @

@ @
( @
), . @



. ,
, @

,
. ( , @
) @
, @
,
.
,
@
@
, , , , @
.
3.
. ,
, :
, @
, @
;
@
@ @

1 . : .., .., .., ..
.
. :. 2002.
286

 III.

@
.

,
,
@
. @
@
@
. ,

@
. ,
,
.

287

14.

, .

(). @
,
,
, , , ,
.
. @
coalitus, coalitio @
, , , @
. coalescere, @
co , alescere , .

,
.
,
, . . @
( ) , @
, @
. , , @

, @
.
, , @
. @
,

. @

.
@
288

 III.

.
, ,
, @
.

(,
,
, @
).
. , @
, @
, @
. , @
, . ., , , @
.

, . . @ ,
. @
@
. ,
. @
, @
( @
), , ,
, . @
, 80@ XX , @
1932
,
, @
, @
.
,
30@ XX , ,
@ @
289

. , ,
1930@ 1990@ .
@
.
,
, .., ,
. ,
, @
, @
, @
, @
.

, , @
90@ XX @
XXI . , ( @
) ,
,
. @
, @
,
, , , @
, @
.
, @
, .
@
, ,
. @
@
, @
, @
, ,
, . @
, @
, @
290

 III.

,

. @
@
XX XXI .
(,
, ), @
, @
.

@
@
,
, .

, , @
( ), @
, ( )
.
XX . @
,
, ,
... @
, @
.
XX @
, @
, @
, .
.. @
, .
.. ,
@
, , @
, ,
291

, 1. @
@
, ( , ).
, @
, @
.

, @
@
, , , @
(. . ) . @
@

.
,
, @
. ,

, , , @
. @
@
. ( ) @
@
. , , @

@
, ( @
), (
) , @
@
, @
. ,
1 .. . . . 1. ., 1989, . 117.
292

 III.

, @
,
, @
. , , ,
,
. @

/ , ,
.
, , ,
. @
, , @
. ,

.
, @
. , @

, @
(, , @@
. .).
@
, . ., , @
.
,
, @
, , , ,
,
.

:
;
;
.
@
293

. @
@
. , @
@
@ .

, , , @
.
, @
@
@
.
,
, ,
@
@
. @
, , 5, 8 9
.

,

,
,
.

.
1. , .

.
2. , , @
.
.
3. , , @
294

 III.

, (@
, , ,
. .).
4. @
, @
.
. ,
, ,
, , , @
, .
5. , , @
.
,
@
.
6. ( @
), , @
,
.
7. @
, @
.
8. @
, .. @
, @
, ,
. @
(
, @
. .) () @
.
9.
.
@
, , @
, @
295

.

.
1. .
.
@
,
@
, . ,
@
.
, , ,

.
.
) . , @
(@
, , .) @
.
) .
, .
.
) ( @
). .
,
.
) .
, , @
, @
.
, @
.

) .
, , @
, .
296

 III.

2. .
, ,
, , , (@
) ,
, @ . @
, , @
@
. @
. , @
, , @
@
.
:
) . @
@

.
) .
. @
, , , @
, .
) (
).
,
. , @
, @
, ,
(
) . @
,
.

. @
, @
) .
, , @
297

,
.
, @
, @
.
3. .

,
, , ,
,
.
@
, @
, @
.
, , .
@
.
) .
, @
, ,
@
. , ,

, @
.
@
:
) . @
,
,
.
@
,
.
) . ,
298

 III.

.

,
, .
G
@
. @
, (). @
()
@
( 121@123). @

@
. @
()
, ,
. , , @
(), (
@
, ).
()
, ()
.
()

. ,
.
() @
,
. , ,
@
.
@
(), @
(). @@
299

@
.
, @
, , @
, .
@
. ,
@
, @
, @
, @
, @
.
, , @
, , (),
.

,
. @
, ,
, , .
,
. @
@
, @
, @
, @
.
,
(
).
, ,
. @
, ,
. @

300

 III.

, , ,
,
. @

, , @
.
, @
, (), @
.
. ,
( ),
: ,
(@
) , ..

,
, ,
@
, @
(,
).
. @
@
. @
. , @
@
,
.
,
@
. @, @
. @,
@
, @
, @
301

. @,
,
, ,
,
. @, @
,
,
, @
.
, @, , , @
@
.
, , , @
, @
.
, ,
.
@
. .
1) !. , @
, @
, @
1. ,
2001 ,

@
.
, @
.
@
,
, @
1 .. . .:
"" "....", 2001.  256 .
302

 III.

(,
@
).
2) , @
1998 . @
@
@
. , @
1, @

,

, @
, , .
3) .
2002 . , @
,

,

@
, @
(4 @
5 @
, @, @
). @
, @

.
, ,
@

1 . : 100
. ./ .
.., ...  .: ,
2001.  128 .
303

, @
,
@
, @

, @
, @
.
,
, @
@
, , , @
@
.
, , @
.
,

, @
, , @
@
.
,
.

:

304

 III.

15.

, @
,
, @
. @
. 


, ,
,

. (
)
(ressource).
, @

.
, @
, . @
, ,
( @
fund@raising ), @
() ,
, @
, , @

/ ,
. @
.
(, @
) , @
, 11 12 .
305

.
@
@
. , @
, @
,
(, ).


. @
, , @
, :
. 90@
;
;
@
( ) @

.

. ,
, @
.

,
,
( @
),

, .
, @
, , .
306

 III.

, @
. , @
. , ,
,
. @
@
.
, @
@
. , @

@
, , @
. @

,

, @
.

, @
@
.
, @
.
1. , .
2. @
, , .
3. @
.
4. ,
.
,
307

, @
.
5. @
@
,
, . . , @
.
6. @
,
@
, @
.
7. @
.
8. , , @
, , , @
.
@
. , @
, 1.
, @
, @
@, @
. , @
, @
( ). @
@
. ,
, , , @
, @
, , ,
,
1 , : .., ., .., .
. . 
.: , 2000.  196 .
308

 III.

. ,
@
,
@
@
.
, @
@
. ,
@
@
,
, , @
. ,
, , @
, @
, @
.
, .

,
. @
.
@, ( ), . . @
, ( ) @
. @
@ , ()
.
@
, /
.
, @
( , @
).
. , @
, .
309

,
(, , . .); , @
@, . @
, @ @
, , @
( , ,
. .). @
, @
, , ( @
), ..
@

@
.
, , , @
.
@,
@
/ @
.
@
. ,
@
@ @
. @
( ) @
.
@, / @
@
.
, @
, , ,
@
@
. @
, , @
310

 III.

. , @
, ,
, @
.
, @
, , , @
, @
. ,
,
. @
, , @
.
1)
. @
, , @
, @, ,
, @
@ @
.
. ,
, @
@ @ @
, @
() @ @
. @
,
@
.
2) ,

. ,
,
,
,
.

311

, @
@
, @
@

.
,
, @
@
. , , @
@
.
@
. @
, @
@
, , ,
*.

,
@
. ,


,

. ,
, @
. @
, @
,

.
* 4 .
312

 III.

,

. ,
, @
, , @
.
G
, @
@@
. , @

( , @
). , @
@
. , @
FIDO@net. ,
@
, @
. , ,
, @

.
@
. , @
, @
( ,
), @

(, , .), @
,

,
. ,
, 1995
313

, 1. @
@
, @

, , , @
. ,
, @
@
.
, , @
,
. , ,
,
, @
. @
.

@
, 2,
(@
, 3). @
4 .
, @
@ @
, @

1  ,
. .: ..,
.., .. "
() ".//
. ., 2001, . 3843; ..
// , . 2937.
2 .. , .. . .  .:
"", 1995.  32
3 .., .., ... :
.
"".  , 2001.  114 .
314

 III.

@
@
.
@
@
.

() @
. ,

@
. @
, 72 ,
149 , , @
( ),

. @
34 , 2 :
, 
,
.
@
@
, 6, .
@
.

,
.
, @
@ ( @
), @
@@
315

. ,
,
@
,
, @
.

@@
, @
. @

. @
@
.
@
, 16
.

, , ,

, @
@
. 10
.
, ,
2001 , @


. @
. ,
@
@
, ,
@
316

 III.

1.
@

.
@

, , , @
.
@

@
@ (
e@raider),
.
@@
, @
. @
@
, , @
, @

.
, @
@
, @
, @

, ,
, , .

1 :
.  2002. / . ...  .:
, 2002.  368 .
317

16.

( @
) , @
@ @ @
. .
@
( , ,
), @
@
,
( ).
, @
()
, 
.
,
,
,

, 
.
@, , @

.

,
, ,
@
, ,
,
@
318

 III.

.


.
, @
.

, , .. @
, @
.

@
@
. , @
@
@
. ,
@
@
. @,
. @,

, , @
.
@
. @
, , @
@
@
.
@
, @
319

@
@
.
@
.

, @

, , @
, , @
.

@
.
1. , ,

.
@
. ,
, @
, , @
@
, @
. @
( @
) @
. @
. .
@
@
.
@
@
,
. .
320

 III.

@
.
. @
() @
(1998@2000 ) @
@
, , @
.
@
@ ()*. @
.

, (@
, , @
@
, @

* . 80
100 . . ,
400 000 .
321

, @
, @ @
), .
, .
@
, @
, @

1. ,
, @
, G
.
, @
, , @
@
(). , @

. ,
@
, , 15@20
@
@,
, , @
, .
, ,

, ,
,
.

1 : .., ..,
.. .
./ "
".  .: , 2001.  ..4652.
322

 III.

, , @


, (1,2),
, ,
.
, ,
@
3.
, @
.
,

, ( ) @
.
@
, @
,
.

@
. , @
, (2000 ),
(2001 ) (2002 ),
:


;
1 Peirce D., Grabosky P.N., Gurr T.R. "London: The Politics of Crime and Conflict, 1800 to
the 1970s', in J.R.Gurr, P.N.Grabosky, R.C.Hula. The Politics of Crime and Conflict,
Beverly Hills: Sage, 1977.
2 J.Braithwaite. Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge University Press, 1989.
( : .. , .  .:
" ", 2002.)
3 Putnam R. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton (N.J.):
Princeton University Press, 1993. (P p: . p
p. .: Ad Marginem, 1996.)
323

,
;
, @
, @
;
III @
, @
@ ;

.
, @
@
, @
,

@
. , @
, .
.
,
@
, ,
. ,
. 1999@2002 @


,
@
@ .
2.
; , 
; 
, ; 
, 
.

324

 III.

, ,
@
,
. , @
, @
, @
.
@
(,
, ..) @
, 
, .

@
( ) ,


. @
, @
,
(
), .

10
.
3.
.
, @
(), @
.

@ @
.
@ @
, , @

325

(). , , @
, ,
@
.
, @
, , @
. @
, , :

.
, , @
. @
, @
( ). @
,
, , @
, / @
.
.
, ,

.
@
@
, @
. @

:
G
G
;
G
;
;
;
;
326

 III.

G
(
, @
);
G
;

.
, :

;
()
;
@
,
(@
) .
@
@
, ,
.., , @
@
.
, @
, @

,

,

. ,
@
@
, , @
. ,
, @
327

, ,
.
@
@
.
4. 
PR.
, @
@
,
@
. ,
,
.
, @
@

. @
,
.

. , @
:
PR@ @
.
.

. , @
@
, @
, ,
. ,
@
.
, @
, 
328

 III.

.
,
, , @
.
,

, , @
, , @

.
5. , 
().
,
.
, , @
,
:
;
;
.
,
, @
, @
.
,
. @
,
, 5 .
, @
, @@
. @ @
, ,
. @
(,
), @
@, , , @
329

,
.
6. .
3 @@
@
. , ,
, ,
.
, @
( , @
)
@
@
. ,
, @
III @
( ).
@
@

, , , .
7.

.

(, , @
, , , , @
), ,
. @

.
@
. @
( 
) @
.
330

 III.

,
, , @
. .
) , , ,
, @
@
; , @
, @
.
) , @
, , , @
, @
, ,
.
) , (), @
, @
, @
: , @
, , @
, @
, @
, , .
) , ,

,
,
, ,
.
) @
() ,
, @
, @
.
8.  
.

331

, , @
, .

, @@
. , @
@
,
@
. @
@
, ,
, @
.
G

@ , ,
, @
@ . @

, , @
.
, @
, @
.

(@
, , @
, ), @
.
,
@
, , @

332

 III.

. @
, .
, homo
sapiens, .
. , @
, , ,
,
. @
, @
@
, @
, G
.

333

,
@
.

@
. @

: , ,
, , , @
. .
.
,
, , @
,
, ,
.
, , @
@
. @
@
, ,
,
,
, @
. ,
@
. , @
,
, , @, ,
.
,
@
@
.
334

@
,

.
, (
) . @
,
, @
. @
36, 72, 108 144 @
1, 2 3 .
1.
@
. .
(@
, , , @@
, @ @, @
, , .).
.
2. 

. .
.
335

.
. @
@
@
. @
. @
. .
3.
. @
: ,
, , ,
.
4.

. @
: , ,
, , , , @
, .
5. 

.
.
. @
@
.
.
6.
. @
.
. @
. @
336

.

. @
.
. .
7.
. @
. @
. @
. @
. @
. .
8.
.
.

. . @
@
. .
@
. .
9.
. (, @
, , , )
. .
. @
.
. .
10. 

. @
337

. @
. @
. @

. . @@
. .
11.
.
@
. @
. @
. . @
. @
.
12.
. .
. @
. @
. @
. .
13. 

@
. @
@
. @
.
@
.

338

14.
. @
@
.
. @
.
. @
. .
15.
.

. . @
. @
.
.
.
16.
. @
@
. . @
. @
. @
.
.
17.
. @

. .
. . @
@
. @
. .
339

18.
. . @

. .
. @
. @
. .
19.
.
@
. @
.
.
. @ @
. .
20.
. @

. @
. .
. @
.
.

340

@
, , @
. @
,
, @
.
, @
, , @
. @
, , @
@

.
,
@
. @
, .
I.

,
@ @
@ . , @
, @
, @
.
@
341

. (1,2)
, @
( , , )
.
1.1
@ ,
@
, @
( @
),
(
, ) .

@
.
@
, @
,
,
.
1.2
@
@
. @
. @
, ,
, , , @
, @
.
, , @
, @
1 .., .., .., .. :
. .: , 1997. .. 514.
2 .., .. .
.: , 1999. .. 104155.
342

, @
,

. @
@
:
.
@
.
1.3


, @
,
, .
,
@
, , . @
, , , @
.
1.4
, @
, . , @
, @
@
. , @
@
, , ,
.

. , @
.
@
,
.
1) .
343

.
,
. @
, 1990@ 1.
,
, .
,
, @
, @
. , . ,
, @
,
:
) ;
) ( 10% @
);
) ,
@
.
,
(, )
. @
@
. @
,
.
: .
,
. @
, , @
1 
2002 .
() : , 
, . .: . .
, . 8, 2001. 96 .
344

, @
, @
25 2000 . 625 @
@
2001@2002 1. @
2.
( @
)
, @

@
.
, @
,
, . , @
,
, .
2) @
. @
. , @
.
, , @
. ,
.
@
, .
, @
.
, .
. @
@
@
, @@
1 , 2000, 37, . 3712.
2 , 1997, 41, .4705.
345

,
.
3)

. @
.
@
, @
, @
. , , ,

, @ @
.
, @
, @
@
.
4) @
30
. , @
, .
, @

.
,
,
G
.
,
, @
@
, .
@
@ ,
: ,
, @
346

, @
.
, @
@
, .
, @
,
,
@
.
@

. , @,
@
, @, @
, @
,
.
,
,

.
, .
@
.
)
. @
@
,
. @
@
, @
. @

@
.
347

(
, 1) @
, @
. , @
. @
@
, ( @
)
@
.
, @
, @
. , @
,
( @
, @
? @
?),
. @

, . @
.
,
, @
, . , @

1996@2000 ,
26 1997 2222,
@ .
) @
. @
@ @
1 ... : / . .:
"",1997. 528 .
2 , 1997, 10, .1173.
348

, @
. ,
. @
, , @
, @
, ,
.
) @
. @
@
, :
, , , , @
, , , ,
( ).
@
@
,
. , @
18 , @
. @

@
( , ),
@
, ,
,

. , @
, @
.
) . @
90@ @
( @
, @
, ,
).
349

, , ,
: , @
, .

.
, @
.
) . @

, 90@
.
(
, @ ) @
.

.
, @
, .
.
) ,
, , ,
,
. @
.
,
, ,
.
, @

, @
, @

, (@
).
, @
.
350

@ @

, ,
.
II.

,
, @
.

G
.
: @
, ,
(, , @
, ), @
@
, ,
@
.

XI, :
, ,
,
,
, 
1.
@
, ,
.

1 Quadragesimo Anno. Actae Apostolicae Sedis. XXIII, 1931.  p.203.

351

2.1
@
,

. ,
@
.
,
.

( , @
) . @
, (
) , , @
, , @
, ;
. , @
, @
@
.
@
@ ( , ) @
5 .
2.2 ( )
, ,
@
. , @

, ,
.

,
.

@
352

. 
. , @
, :
) ,

(, , @
, , , @
, @
, @
, ..). ,
@
@
;
) , , @
, , @
,
@
; ,
@
, ()
.
2.3
,
, ()
@
,
, . @
, , @
, ,

III , @
(, ) @
, @
, @
.
353

@
@
, 
.
@
() , @
@
.
2.4
,
, ,
1. @
, ,

,
, @
, @

, , @
, XXI , @
,
, 2.
2.5

(
), @
@
()
1 .:  .
..  .:  "", 2001  . 304; .  .
 .:  "", 2001.  296 .
2 .: Huntington S.P. The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, 1996
( .: .. ./ . .
., .. .: , 2003. 603 .
354

, @
.
2.5.1 .
, @
, @
. @
, @ @
,
, ( )
. @ @
( , )

.
@
. @
.
2.5.2 .
4
29 :
, , 
,
. , 
, .
@
,
.
@
. @
@
@
. ,
, @
.

, . @
, , @
355

@
.
2.5.3 G
.
, @
, ,
,
. , @
, @
.
@
.
@
.
, , ,

, @
@
, @

.
, , @
.
,
, @
. @@
@

.
2.5.4 .
@
.
@

, , @
. ,
356

, ,
@
@ .
@
.
@
, ,
@
, , @
.
2.5.5 (
).

,
:
) @
, :

, @
, ,

;
2001
, @
.

;
@ , @
,
@
.

.

,
.
357

) .
@
, , @
@ @ @
, @
.
) .

:
;
G ;
.

,
@
.
III.

@
, @
.
,
, @
, , @
@
.
3.1
3.1.1 G .
@@
@

. @
@
358

. @

@ . ,
, @
.
@ @
. @
, @
, , , , .
, , @ ,

, , @
, , @
.
, @
,
@
.
@
@
, @
, @
@
,
, .
@

.
, @
,
() .
3.1.2 .
, @
, @
@
@ @
359

, , ,
, .
@
,
, .

, ( @
1) @
@
, .
@ @

, @

() .
, @
,
. , ,
@
, , @
@
.
@
@
.
,
, @
.
, , G

. @
@
, @
1 , 1998, 31, .3813.
360

.
3.1.3 .
, @
, , @

, @
, @
.
@


, , , .
3.1.4 G
.

( )
,
() @
( , @
3.2.3 ), @
, @
@
.
@, @
, @
,
, @
@
, @
( , @
, ..).
3.1.5 .
@
,
@
.
361

.
@

@
. @
,
( deliberate @
, ). @
,

1.

@
@
. @
.
3.1.6 ( ).
,
, @
/ , @
( ). @
@
, @
, .
, @
, ,
.
( , *), @
@
, @
1 ., : " " .
. . . / . ...  .: ,
2002. 176 .
* .
.: http://pravo.org.ru/direct/iv/ak.htm
362

.
3.1.7 .

( @
), , @
@
, .
,
, , @

( , @
), @
.
, , @

: ( ), , ,
.., @
, @
: , ,
.
@
, @
, 1
32 .

. ,

.
,
@ . @
.
, @
, , @
.
G
, GG
363

,
.
3.2 
@
.
3.2.1 .

, @
, , @
, .
, , @

(), . @
@
, @
, @
@
.
,

.
,
,
, @

.
,
,
, @

.
3.2.2 .

, @
@
364

(, ,
, ), @
.

( @
) .

. 
 ,
, @
, @
@
. @
(@
, , @,
.) , @
.
, , @
,
, ,
, , .
, @

, . @
2 34 @
:
, 
.
3.2.3 () GG
.
@ @
@

.
@
@
365

, @
.
@
@
. 

@
@

, @
. @

@
.

, , @
,
,
,
.
.

@
, 

.

.

.


:
,
;
;
366

;
, ;
, @
, ;
, ;
.


@
.
, 
, ,
, @
,
 .


.
@
@
, .
,

.

,
, @
. @
, @

.
. ,
, ,
, @
.
@
367

@

, @
, , @
. @
, @
,
18 ,
.
.
, @
@
, @
, ,
.
@ @
.

,
.
@
,
, (
, ) .
3.3
@
,
, , @
@
. @

(),
( @
) @
. @
368

@
.
@
G
, @
,
.
3.3.1 .

( 90 ) , @
(, , ) @
, @
@
.
@
@
() .
:
@, ,
, @
,
( @
@ ),
, @

.
( )
, @
( , ), @
(, .).
3.3.2 .

, , @
,
@
, , @
369

. @
, 6@7 , @
.
, ,

,
., ,
2000 , 2001 ; @
2002 , 2003
,
*. @
, @@
@
@
.
3.3.3 (, )
.
, @
,

. , @
, .
, @
, @

() /
(), , ..:
)
() @
;
, @

; ,
*
: www.civilforum.ru, www.nan.ru.
370

,
.
) @ , @

;
() /
, @
@
.
) @@
,
() / ,
;


, , @
.
) @
;
@
.
.
@
,
, . @
@
@
.
@
,
@
@
, .
@
@
, , @
371

,
:

@
, @

/ .
@


1 78 @
1.
, @
( @
, @
),
.
) , , @

.

,
, , , @
, @
() / , @
, , @
@
.

@
,
(, ,
@
).
1 , 2000, 32, .3339.
372

,
. @
,
(,
, @, )
.

,
@

(, @
) .
@
@
, , .
3.3.4 G ( G
, ).
@@
@
.
. ,
, . @
, 1 @
2, @
,
(
). @
@
1 " " : 
. . / . ...  .: , 2002.  176 .
2  , ,
, 
, . 
.: 
: . . / . ..,
.., ...  .: , 2003.  160 .
373

, @
.
3.3.5 , G
G .
@
@
(, ) @
@ ( @
) .
@

. ,
, ( , @
, ) . @

, @
@
, .
,
, ,
,
, G
() @
, @
: , .
@
,
@
, @
, .
51 1 @
@@
@ @
1 , 1995, 21, .1930.
374

, @
.
@
, @
.

.


16 .

375

( 5 )
@
. @
,
, , , @
, ., @
: @,
0,350,
0,413 0,425 . @
, @
, , @
@
; , @
.

,
(0,330 0,380). @
, @
,
,
, ( ).
,

, @

@
. 62,5% ,
,
. @
20% ( @
376

), @.
@ ,
. ,
@
,
0,725 ( ) 0,925
( ), (0,550)
().
, (
90% @
). , , @
, (90%), ,
, .
,
, @

(0,578 @
; 0,625 @; 0,683 @
; 0,719 @ ).
(0,400). @
66% ,
. 30% @
@ 50% @
. ,

,
60% @,
37% ,
. 40%
,
(
@
10%).
@

, @
377

,
. @
, @,
, 0,625 (
) 0,688 ( ). @
, , @@
, , .

, @
. @ 25%
, ,
@ (0,500).
, @
,
@
@.
@
@
. ,
, @
,
,
( . @ 90%
, @ 70%, @ 67%,
63%, @ @ 60%).
@ 30% @
,
.
,
25% ,
20% 17%.
@
, , @
(0,570) @ (0,670).

( @
378

)
(0,750), @
(0,700) (0,633) @
. @
, @
, @
, @
, .
@ , @
, 0,4 0,6. @
, @
@
, @
30%, 12%, 10% .
@
@
, , @
0,440 ( ) 0,575
(@). @
(83%) @
(60%), , @

.
@
: 30% , @
; 40% @ @
; 30% @ . @
, , @
@.
,
, (@
0,700) @
, , @
@
.
, @, @
379

( 66% 88%)
, @
.
, 37,5% ,
.
@

@, @
(0,539) @
(0,572). (50%) @
, @
@ (44%).
.
@
0,303 ( ) 0,475
(@). @
:
(66% @ 90%) ,
@
.
@
, , @
@
. @
(0,330), @

@
.
@ (60%)
,
, @
, 30% , @
.
, ,
,
, @
380

@ (0, 550 0, 568)

, @
@

( ).
@

.



, ,
: @,
, , @
@
; 70% @ @; 66% @ @
57% @ . 30% @
@, 33% 29%
,
.
,
, @
. @
, @ (0,550),
(0,357 0,458).
@, @
(55% @ 83%) , @
, . @
60% , @

; @ @
22% .
@ @
20% ,
.
,
381

, @
, ,
@
. ,
71% @
, 50% @ , 43% @ , 20%
@ , @ @
.
@ 55% @
,
@
( @ 40%, 20%, @
14%), 44% ,
, @
. @
( ),
@ (0,715).
@ (0,358), @
(0,330) (0,275)
(
).
90% , 80% @
55% @ ,
(
@, , @
, ,
@ 2001. 668
. ). @@
44% , ,
( , @
@ @
, ,
5%, 1%). @
, @
. @
. ,
382

/ @
( 29%),
, , 50% 17%.


, @
(0,413 0,408), @ (0,650 0,568)
(0,600 0,500)
.

@
.
@
@ ;
@
; @
3 5 , @
(2 3 ), @
.
, , @
() @
: ( @
@
) ( ); @
; (@
) ;
;
.
@
@@
(0,600), (0,333) @
(0,373) .
,
@
:
, , @
383

, ; @
;
; ; @
; ; @
; @
;
. ,
, @
(0,533) @ (0,510),
,
(0,392) (0,310) .

,
:
0,875 ( ). @
: 50% ,
, 50% , @
( @
57%, 40%,
10%). ,

.

, @
: , @
;
; @ @
; ; (, @
, ..).
, @
, @
: ,
@ (0,630) @
(0,243).
@
, (@
384

),
(77% @)
,
.
@ 22% ,
.
, @
, @ .
, @
, .


,
, .
@ 30% , @
, 40% @ @
.
, @
(@ 20%) @
, (@
10%). @, @
, , @
, ;
; @
, @
(? ? ?) @
.
@

,
, @
,
( @
100%, 80%, @ 77%,
60%).
, @
385

(0,700) @
(0,720) .
,
@ . @
(77%) ,
. 55% @
@.
44% @ 62%
, @
, .
@
(0,704 0,888).
@
@
. , ,
(87%) ,
. @ 50% @
, (@
20%, 25%,
11%) (20%).
@ (0,675).
,
, @
@
.
, . @
(80%) (71%) @
,
( 40%, 33%,
@ 22%), @ @ 77%
, .

.
,

@
386

. @
,
.
@
. , @
@
, @
77% @ 55% @
, . 22%
@ 11% ,
@
.
,
@ @
(0,550 0,523) (0,350)
(0,292) .
,
@
,
@ (62,5%) ,
(@
30%, 29%, 20%).
(60%
) , @
(@ 37,5%,
29%, 20%). @
@
@ (0,344),
(0,550) (0,644) , @
.
, @
, 25% @ ,
(
) 5% ; 37,5% @
@ , @
, 37,5% , @
387

, @
( @ 0,625).
@
(77%), (80%) (70%) @
, @
, 55%
(22% @ @, 30% @ @
, 57% @ ) , @
, 22% @ . @

@,
(0,850 0,880).
(,
)
@
. @: 55,5% , 44,5% @
. , @
, , @
, , .
@@
, (0,700 0,800).
(62,5%) @
,

, (40% @@
). , @
, 80% @
, 60% @.
,
@
,
,
, @
, , @. , @

@ (0,400).
388

, @
@
, @
, @
(55,5% @ @). @
44,5% , @
.
,
. @
@ (0,715).
@
@
@
@
(, , , @
). @
.
, , @ @
3% 7%
( , 50%).


,
@ (0,675 0,627).
@
.
,
, , @
@
. , @
, 44% @, 43% @
, 57% @ , 50% @ @
20% @ . @@
(33%) ,
, , @
.
389

,
, .
(100% @@
, 86% ) , @
,
. , @

@ (0,990; 0,925).
, , ,
71% @ 30% @
, @
(
88%, 100%, 60% ). 30% @
, @
, @
, , 40%
( ) ,
.
@ , @
@

( @,
,
, ,
).
,
, @
, @ (). , @
, ,
.
@
.
, @
, ,
( @
), , @
390

(@ @ 50%). @
, @
, @
, , , , @
(@ @ 33%, @
@ 22%) @
(@ @11%).

@,
(0,715 0,825).
@
(
, ), 37,5% @@
, , .
, , @
(80%), 25% @@
. @, @

,
@
. @ 37,5% @
, @
,
,
, ; @
;
.. ,
, , @
. @
@ (0,625),
0,415@0,500.
,

, (@ 57%) @
, ,
.
391

, ,


, @.
@ 43% ,
.
, @
, , @
.
@. , @@

.
@ (25%) @
,
.
(@ 75%) , @
(
50%, 43%). 40% @
, 43% 20% ,
@
. @
@
.
@ .
@

.
,
, , (44%
@)
(@ 55%).
@
@, @
. ,
, ,
, 10% .
392

@
, @
.
(43%) ,
, , 57%
( , @
, 12,5% 37,5% ).
, @
(83%) ( @
) .
@
. , , @
@
, , , @

, .

@,
@,
. @
, ,
, ,
,
@ . @
, ,
, ,
, ,
, .
, ,
@
.

( ) @
(0,572@0,725) @
(0,800).

393

@ (0,792), @
(0,600@0,666).
@
@
@@
: 0,653 0,594.
(@
) .
,
(, ,
) @ @
(55% @@
). , , @
, 30% 37,5% , @
(@ 11%),
@ ,
. ,


(0,650) (0,688) ,
@ (0,468).
, ,
@
@ ,
(11% @).
, @
( @ 71%, @ @ 66%,
@ 60%, 40%). @
@
, (0,550),

@ (0,385).
,
,
@ ,
(@ 75%).
394

@
@
@ (0,775).
@

.
, @
. @ @
( ):
,
(@ 37,5%)
(@ 50%).
, , @
(
, ,
..), 10%
@. ,
(0,780 0,750),
, 0,625 0,656.
@

@ (0,608) ,
, (0,450)
(0,400). , @
(43%) ,
(
@ ,
, , @@
.)
.
@
, (
).

395

4

( 10 )

.


10.30@11.30
11.30@12.00
12.00@12.30
12.30@13.00
13.00@14.30
14.30@17.30

17.30@18.00

.
@ .
: ?
.

: ?
.


.
.

10.00@10.45
10.45@11.30
11.30@12.00
12.00@13.00

13.00@14.00
396

.
. .
.

.
.

,
: .

14.00@15.00
15.00@17.00

17.00@17.30
17.30@18.30
18.30@19.00
19.00@20.00

9.00@10.00
10.00@10.45
10.45@11.30

11.30@12.00
12.00@14.00

14.00@15.00
15.00@16.00

16.00@16.30
16.30@17.00
17.00@19.00

.
.

(
?). .
.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.


.
.


().
.



.
.
.
.
,
.
.
397

G

( )
10.00@10.30
10.30@11.30

11.30@12.00
12.00@12.30
12.30@13.00
13.00@13.30
13.30@15.00
15.00@15.15
15.15@16.30
16.30@17.00
17.00@18.30
19.00@20.00
20.00@22.00

9.00@10.00
10.00@10.30
10.30@11.30
11.30@12.00
12.00@13.00
13.00@13.30
13.30@15.00
15.00@16.30
16.30@17.00
398

.

. @
.
.
, .
.
?
.
.
().
.
.
().
.
".

.
.

.
.

().


.

.
.

17.00@18.30

19.00@20.00
20.00@22.00

9.00@10.00
10.00@10.30
10.30@11.30
11.30@12.00
12.00@13.15
13.30@15.00
15.00@16.30

16.30@17.00
17.00@18.30

19.00@20.00

9.00@10.00
10.00@11.30
11.30@12.00
12.00@13.30
13.30@15.00
15.00@16.00

16.00@16.30
16.30@17.00
17.00@18.30

.
.
.

.
.
.
.
.
.

().
.

, ,
.
.

.
.
, .
.
.
.
.
().
.

.
.
.
.
.
399

18.30@19.00
19.00@20.00
20.00@22.00

9.00@10.00
10.00@10.30
10.30@11.30

11.30@12.00
12.00@13.30
13.30@15.00
15.00@16.30

16.30@17.00
17.00@17.30
17.30@18.30
19.00@20.00

400

.
.

.
().
.
.

.


.
.
().
.

:
.
.
.
@.
.

1. .., .., ..
() @
.// @
. ., 2001. . 38@43;
2. .. .
. .: , 1999. 384 .
3. .., .., . .
. . .: @
, 2000. 143 .
4. .. @
//
. ., 2001. . 29@37.
5. .. . .:
, 1989.
6. .. ( @
). .:
, 1990.
7. .. @
. .: ....,
2001. 256 .
8. .., ..
. ., 1973, 27@32.
9. .., .., .., ..
? .
: , 2000.
10. .. . .
. 1. ., 1989, . 117.
11. .., .., .. @
: . .
401

, 2001. 114 .
12. .. @
// @
. .:
, 2001. @ . 5@28.
13. . , . @
. @
2(2), 1998.
14. ..
XX // @
. ., 1969.
15. .., .. @
.
(). @
, 1998.
16. . .
. . ,
2000. 72 .
17. .., ..
// , 2000, 4. .48.
18. .., .., ..,
..
2001.
19. .., .. ..,
..
, @
, 28 6
2002 . .
20. .., .. @
. @
@. .:
, 2001. 60 .
402

21. . . ., 2000.
22. .. @
@
// : .
.. , , 2002.
23. .. : @
. .: , 2001. 248 .
24. .., .. , @
@ , @
. .: , . @
/ .., ... @
8, 2001. 96 .
25. .., .., ..
, , .,1996, 115 .
26. ., ., ., . @
:
. .
.: , 1997. 176 .
27. . . . . 3, . 3.
28. .. : / .
.: ,1997. 528 .
29. . @
. NDI. , 1994.
30. .. . .: @
, 2001. 304 .
31. .., .., .. .
. . .: ,
2002. 144 .
32. ., ., . @
. . , 2001. . 36.
33. .. : @
403

. Charities Aid Foundation (CAF)

, , 1998., 150 .
34. .., .., . . . @
.: , 1995. 32 .
35. .., .., .., ..
: . .:
, 1997 90 .
36. .., .. @
. .: , 1999. .. 104@155.
37. .., .., .. @
.
./
. .: , 2001. ..46@52.
38. .., .. @
. 1999. .: , 2000.
..165@170.
39. .. ./ . .
., .. .: ,
2003. 603 .
40. .. . (.) @
. 1992.
41. .. .
. 1998.
42. .., ., .., .
. @
. .: , 2000. 196 .
43. 100 @
. . .
.., ... ., 2001. 128 .
44. . . . : @
.., .. .: @
404

( ) , 2002. 80 .
45. . .. .: @
, 1997.
46. . . . . .: CAF,
2003. 84 .
47. . / . ..@
. . .,
1997. 204 .45.
48. : . / . ..@
. . . .: , 1999. 272 .
49. . @ . .: @ @
, 2001. 296 .
50. : . .
/ . ... .: , 2000 272 .
51. . 2000.
. .. .: , 2001.
52. . 2001.
.: , 2001.
53. . 2002.
.: , 2002.
54. @
. . ./ . .. . .:
, 2003.
55. ,
, INTRAC. . 2002.
56. .
. .: , 2001.
57. . .
. ., 2002.
58. . . .
405

: , 2002. 140 .
59. : @
/ . .. @
.: , 2002. 220 .
60. () @
. @
. . / . ., ..
.: . ..@
, 1999. 116 .
61. @
./ .
.. ... .:
, 2001.
62. :
. / . .. ., 1997. . 115.
63. . . ...
: "", 2000.
64. : @
. . / . .., ..@
, ... .: , 2003. 160 .
65.
. . 1994. .23.
66. @
. . .
. .. .: @
, 1999. 160 .
67. :
. . . . . ... ... .:
, 2003. 136 .
68. @
. . . .
, 1999. 148 .
406

69. @
. . . .
.. .: , 2000. 148 .
70. . . / .
.., .. .: , 2001. 128 .
71. . .
... : "", 2000.
72. : . 1@2.
/ . ... .: @ , 2002.
73. : @
. . / .
... .: , 2002. 176 .
74.
().
. .: , 2001. .. 39@40.
75.
. . . .
.. .: , 2001. 282 .
76. @
. . . @
. , 1998.
77. Arnstein S.R. A Ladder of Citizen Participation // Journal of the
American Institute of Planners, vol. 35, 4, 1969, July.
78. Bentley A.F. The Process of Government. Cambridge. 1967
(originally published in 1908)
79. Berry Jeffrey M. Lobbying for the People. Princeton: Princeton
Univ. Press. 1977. P.7
80. Braithwaite J. Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge
University Press, 1989. ( : .. @
, . .: @
, 2002.)
407

81. Hall D.R. Cooperative Lobbying @ the Power of Pressure.

Tucson. 1969. P. XI.
82. Latham E. The Group Basis of Politics: Notes for a Theory. //
American Political Science Review Vol. 46. 1952. P.390.
83. Marcuse H. One@dimensional Man. Boston, 1964.
84. Peirce D., Grabosky P.N., Gurr T.R. London: The Politics of Crime
and Conflict, 1800 to the 1970s, in J.R.Gurr, P.N.Grabosky, R.C.Hula.
The Politics of Crime and Conflict, Beverly Hills: Sage, 1977.
85. Putnam R. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern
Italy. Princeton (N.J.): Princeton University Press, 1993. (P
p: . p p. .: Ad
Marginem, 1996.)
86. Salamon L. Americas Nonprofit Sector: A Primer, 1992.
87. Applied Budget Work. Ed. by I. Shapiro, Center on Budget and
Policy Priorities Wash., 2002.
88. Communication from Commission. Making a European Area of
Lifelong Learning a Reality. Commission of the European
Communities. Brussels, 21.11.2001.
89. Community Foundation. . @
1@3. . . 2000@2001.
90. Guidelines for Laws Affecting Civic Organizations/ Edited by
L.Irish, K.Simon, ICNL, 1997. 121p.

1. .. .. @
. ., 1997.
2. @ . ., 1979.
3. . ., 1936@1941.
4. Websters New World Dictionary. N. Y., 1986.
408

1. . .: @
, 1993.
2. , 1994,
34, .3540.
3. , 1995,
21, .1930.
4. , 1995,
27, .2503.
5. , 1995,
28, .2669.
6. , 1995,
33, .3340.
7. , 1995,
35, .3506.
8. , 1995,
52, .5110.
9. , 1996,
5, .. 410, 411.
10. , 1996,
35, .4137.
11. , 1997,
10, .1173.
12. , 1997,
10, .1231.
13. , 1997,
15, .1756.
14. , 1997,
41, .4705.
15. , 1998,
3, . 345.
16. , 1998,
31, .3813.
17. , 1999,
19, .2302.
409

18. , 2000,
32, .3339.
19. , 2000,
37, .3712.
20. , 2001,
33 (.1), . 3413.
G
1. http://asi.ru
2. http://nan.ru
3. http://osi.ru
4. http://civilforum.ru
5. http://strateg.spb.su
6. http://democracy.ru
7. http://legislature.ru
8. http://demokratia.ru
9. http://hse.ru
10. http://cafrussia.ru
11. http://cip.nsk.su
G

12. : http://ipen21.org/, www.odn.ru,
www.intertraining.org, www.ndc.org.ru, www.ipen.ngo.org.ru,
13. www.evaluatorsInstitute.com, www.eval.org ,
14. http://www.lshtm.ac.uk/php/phpteach.htm#ShortCourses
,
410

15. http://www.mosaic@net@intl.ca ,
16. http://www.sfe.asso.fr ,
17.http://wbln0018.worldbank.org/oed/oedevent.nsf/
internetevents/F413548458146D3F85256A69006BEE78?open@
document ).
18. (compacts):
http://pravo.org.ru/direct/iv/ak.htm
19. ( @
): http://www.trainet.org.
20. :
http://www.oskemen.kz/uk3_2_1a.htm#2
21. :
http://dvgu.ru/vido/unesko/utopia.html
22. :
www.eaea.org.

411


( )
117449, , . 10@.
. (095) 126@3475; (095) 126@1064;
E@mail: nan@nan.ru;
http://www.nan.ru

. ., . .
09.09.2003 .
6086 1/16
. 52
1500 . 16
@
129515, . , . , 13