UNITEDSTATESPATENTANDTRADEMARKOFFICE
CommissionerforPatentsUnitedStatesPatentandTrademarkOfficeP.O.Box1450Alexandria,VA22313-1450
STERNE,KESSLER,GOLDSTEIN
&
FOXP.L.L.C.1100NEWYORKAVENUE,N.W.WAS~INGTON,DC20005HAYNESANDBOONE,LLP
IP
SECTION2323VICTORYAVENUESUITE700DALLAS',TX75219(ForPatentOwner)(ForThirdPartyRequester)
Interpartes
ReexaminationProceedingControlNo.
95/001,159
Filed:March24,2009For:U.S.PatentNo.7,177,998
MAILED
MAY
112012
cemw.
REEXAMINATION
UNrr
DECISIONGRANTINGPETITION
Thisisadecisiononpatent
owner'spetition
paperentitled,"RENEWEDPETITIONUNDER37C.F.R.
§
1.183FORWAIVEROFC.F.R.
§
1.955,"filedonApril20,2012.Thepatentownerrenewedpetitionunder37CFR1.183isbeforetheOfficeofPatentLegalAdministration.Therenewedpetitionunder37CFR1.183isgranted.
BACKGROUND
1.OnFebruary13,2007,U.S.PatentNo.7,177,998("the'998patent")issuedtoWare
etal.
2.OnMarch24,2009,arequestfor
interpartes
reexaminationofthe'998patentwasfiledbyathirdpartyrequester,whichrequestwasassignedcontrolno.
95/001,159
("the'1159proceeding").3.OnMay26,2009,reexaminationwasorderedinthe'1159proceeding.4.The'1159proceedingprogressedtothepointwhere,onOctober3,2011,theOfficeissuedasecondnon-finalOfficeaction.5.OnNovember3,2011,patentownersubmittedaresponsetotheOctober3,2011Officeaction.