Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Vulnerable Groups

Vulnerable Groups

Ratings: (0)|Views: 46 |Likes:
Published by Thanga pandiyan

More info:

Categories:Types, School Work
Published by: Thanga pandiyan on May 16, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/19/2013

pdf

text

original

 
77
Human Rights andVulnerable Groups
T
he initial documents outlining human rights principles do not single outany particular group for special treatment.The Universal Declaration oHuman Rights and international covenants on political and economicrights generally do not contain provisions that favor a particular group.Certainly those documents prohibit discrimination on the basis ofgender,age,nationalorigin,property,and other classifications.The documents also promote families,motherhood,and children.However,nothing within those documents details spe-cial human rights treatment for any particular group.After all,considering the uni-versal nature ofhuman rights,why should a particular group be given additionalattention? Would not this defeat the purpose ofviewing human rights as somethingfor everyone,and not restricted to a special group?Within the United States,laws exist to protect women,children,and the elderly;persons with disabilities;cultural,ethnic,and religious minorities;and othersagainst discrimination.In some states,agencies in charge ofinvestigating discrim-ination have titles that include the term “human rights”(e.g.,in Illinois there is aDepartment ofHuman Rights).Without considering the competency ofthoseagencies in determining discrimination,the notion that human rights refers only todiscrimination is misleading.Human rights cover a vast range ofhuman needsessential for a meaningful existence.Why focus on human rights as something thatresembles a crutch for those more susceptible to negative treatment? Unfortunately,this use ofhuman rights in a purely discriminatory context does little to explain thetrue meaning ofhuman rights.Instead,human rights may even take on an unin-tended derogatory meaning when viewed only in the context ofdiscrimination.Yet,despite the importance ofviewing human rights within a universal contextand not simply as something for the disadvantaged,instances arise when particulargroups often require more attention to ensure human rights ofthose groups.This does not mean that these groups are being elevated above others.The term
CHAPTER 5
05-Reichert-4902.qxd 3/13/2006 4:18 PM Page 77
 
vulnerable 
refers to the harsh reality that these groups are more likely to encounterdiscrimination or other human rights violations than others.
What Is a Vulnerable Group?
In a human rights sense,certain population groups often encounter discriminatory treatment or need special attention to avoid potential exploitation.These popula-tions make up what can be referred to as vulnerable groups.For example,considerthe following:In the United States,only 6 percent ofboard seats within public companies areheld by minorities,with only 13.6 percent held by women (“Who Is Running theShow?”2004);Child abuse by parents and others is a major problem throughout much oftheworld,with special departments having been created to investigate complaints of child abuse (United Nations,1989);Within the United States,African Americans continue to experience subtle,if not overt,discrimination in the form ofinadequate educational facilities,lowerincomes than others,disproportionate number ofmales in prison,and so on;Elderly persons frequently find themselves victims ofscams and other schemesthat cost them dearly financially and otherwise (United Nations,1999);Ethnic cleansing or even genocide continues to occur in some parts ofthe world,with milder forms ofdiscrimination on the basis ofnational or ethnic originoccurring elsewhere;Persons with disabilities often have no recourse to decent employment or ade-quate treatment;andHIV-AIDS afflicts large numbers ofpopulations in many countries (UnitedNations,2004).Circumstances in which a particular group encounters obstacles or impedimentsto the enjoyment ofhuman rights could continue indefinitely.The idea that allthings are equal within the application or distribution ofhuman rights remainsidealistic and outright naïve.For these reasons,human rights advocates haveemphasized the significance ofvulnerable groups and the need to pay special atten-tion to the human rights ofthose groups.When people are in unequal situations,treating them in the same manner invariably perpetuates,rather than eradicates,injustices (van Wormer,2001).
Women as a Vulnerable Group
In societies around the world,female status generally is viewed as inferior and sub-ordinate to male status (Bunch,1991).Societies have modeled their gender-roleexpectations on these assumptions ofthe “natural order”ofhumankind.Historic
78
UNDERSTANDING HUMAN RIGHTS
05-Reichert-4902.qxd 3/13/2006 4:18 PM Page 78
 
social structures reflect a subordination offemales to males.This subordinationoccurs withinthe organization and conduct ofwarfare,the hierarchical ordering ofinfluential religious institutions,attribution ofpolitical power,authority ofthe judiciary,andinfluences that shape the content ofthe law (Bunch,1991).The historic subordination,silencing,and imposed inferiority ofwomen are notsimply features ofsociety but a condition ofsociety (Cook,1995).Legal preceptstraditionally exclude women from centers ofmale-gendered power,including leg-islatures,military institutions,religious orders,universities,medicine,and law.
Women’s Rights Are Human Rights
Soon after the adoption ofthe Universal Declaration ofHuman Rights in 1948,criticism ofits language arose.The declaration refers to “manand uses the pro-noun “he”when discussing individuals.While drafters ofthe declaration did notappear to intentionally exclude women from human rights,central concerns aboutthe male focus have persisted (Morsink,1999).Subsequent human rights docu-ments did little to correct the male orientation ofhuman rights until 1980,whendelegates from the United Nations endorsed the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms ofDiscrimination Against Women (United Nations,1980).Since then,the concept that human rights are for women,as well as men,has gained significantmomentum,ifnot always put into practice.
Convention on the Elimination of AllForms of Discrimination Against Women
The most prominent human rights document concerning the human rightsofwomen is the Convention on the Elimination ofAll Forms ofDiscriminationAgainst Women (CEDAW).This convention became effective in September 1981,and at least 170 countries have approved the convention.The United States is oneofthe few countries that has not ratified the convention.
Provisions of CEDAW 
The focus ofCEDAW is elevating the status ofwomen to that ofmen in the areaofhuman rights.Countries that agree to follow human rights principles containedin CEDAW recognize that the “full and complete development ofa country,thewelfare ofthe world,and the cause ofpeace require the maximum participationofwomen on equal terms with men in all fields(United Nations,1981,preamble).Adherents to CEDAW note “the great contribution ofwomen to the welfare ofthefamily and to the development ofsociety,which so far is not fully recognized.
Human Rights and Vulnerable Groups
79
 
05-Reichert-4902.qxd 3/13/2006 4:18 PM Page 79

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->