Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
See Premium Plans
 
Case
N
o .
SCSL-2003-01-TT
H
EP
RO
SEC
U
T
ORO
FT
H
ESPECIALC
OUR
TV.C
H
A
R
LES
GH
A
N
KAYTAYL
OR
W
ednesday , 16
M
ay 201209 . 30 a .
m
SE
N
TE
N
CI
NG H
EA
R
I
NG
T
R
IAL C
H
A
M
BE
R
I I
BeforetheJudges:
Jus t i ce
R
i cha rd Luss i ck , Pr es i d i ngJus t i ce Te r esa
D
ohe r t yJus t i ce Ju l i a Sebu t i nde
ForCha
m
bers:
M
s
D
or een K i ggundu
M
s
D
i ana
G
o f f
M
s
H
e l en
W
or snop
M
s Yae l
R
o t hsch i l d
M
s E l i zabe t h Budn i t z
M
s
R
ebecca Bro
w
n i ng
Forthe
R
egistry:
M
s F i de l
m
a
D
on l on
M
s
R
ache l I rur a
M
s Za i nab Fo f anah
FortheProsecution:
M
s Br enda J
H
o l l i s
M
r Ja
m
es C Johnson
M
r
N
i cho l as Kou
m
j i an
M
r
M
oha
m
ed A Bangur a
M
s
N
i na Tavako l i
M
s
R
u t h
M
a r y
H
ack l e r
M
s Le i gh La
w
r i e
M
r Chr i s t ophe r San t or a
M
s Ka t hr yn
H
o
w
a r t h
M
s
U
l a
N
a t ha i -Lu t ch
m
an
M
r Ja
m
es Pace
M
r Có
m
an Kenny
M
s
D
an i e l l e F r i t z
FortheaccusedCharles
G
hankayTaylor:
M
r Cour t enay
G
r i f f i t hs ,
Q
C
M
r Te r r y
M
unya rd
M
r
M
or r i s Anyah
M
s Logan
H
a
m
br i ck
M
s A l exandr a Popov
M
r
M
i chae l
H
e r z
M
s Sz i l v i a Cseva r
M
s
H
ab i ba t ou
G
an i
M
s Ca r l y Lenho f f
M
r Ja
m
es Ka
m
a r a
O
fficeofthePrincipal
D
efender:
M
s C l a i r e Ca r l t on-
H
anc i l es
 
1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829
09:31:5209:32:3609:32:5509:33:1909:33:43
C
H
A
R
LES TAYL
OR
16
M
AY 2012
O
PE
N
SESSI
ON
SCSL - T
R
IAL C
H
A
M
BE
R
I I
49680
W
ednesday , 16
M
ay 2012[Sen t enc i ng
H
ea r i ng][
O
pen Sess i on][Accused Pr esen t ]T
H
E
R
E
G
IST
R
A
R
: The Spec i a l Cour t f or S i e r r a Leone i ss i t t i ng i n an open sess i on f or Sen t enc i ng
H
ea r i ng i n t he case o ft he Prosecu t or ve r sus Cha r l es
G
hankay Tay l or , Jus t i ce
R
i cha rdLuss i ck pr es i d i ng .P
R
ESI
D
I
NG
J
UDG
E :
G
ood
m
orn i ng .
W
e
w
i l l t ake appea r ancesf i r s t , p l ease .
M
S
HO
LL IS:
G
ood
m
orn i ng ,
M
r Pr es i den t , Your
H
onour s ,oppos i ng counse l .For t he Prosecu t i on t oday , Br enda J .
H
o l l i s ,
N
i cho l as Kou
m
j i an ,
M
oha
m
ed A. Bangur a , Ja
m
es C. Johnson ,
R
u t h
M
a r y
H
ack l e r , Le i gh La
w
r i e ,
N
i na Tavako l i ,Chr i s t ophe r San t or a , Ka t hr yn
H
o
w
a r t h ,
U
l a
N
a t ha i -Lu t ch
m
an , Ja
m
esPace , Có
m
an Kenny , and our i n t e rn ,
D
an i e l l e F r i t z .P
R
ESI
D
I
NG
J
UDG
E : Thank you .
M
R GR
I FF I T
H
S:
G
ood
m
orn i ng , Your
H
onour s , counse loppos i t e .For t he
D
e f ence t oday ,
m
yse l f , Cour t enay
G
r i f f i t hs ,
Q
ueen ' sCounse l .
W
i t h
m
e ,
M
r Te r r y
M
unya rd ,
M
r
M
or r i s Anyah ,
M
s Logan
H
a
m
br i ck , co- counse l .
W
e a r e a l so j o i ned by
M
s C l a i r eCa r l t on-
H
anc i l es ,
w
ho i s t he Pr i nc i pa l
D
e f ende r , and a l so ourl ega l ass i s t an t s
M
i chae l
H
e r z , Sz i l v i a Cseva r , A l exandr a Popov ,
H
ab i ba t ou
G
an i , and a l so Ca r l y Lenho f f , our i n t e rn , and f i na l l yJa
m
es Ka
m
a r a , our t ea
m
ad
m
i n i s t r a t or .P
R
ESI
D
I
NG
J
UDG
E : Thank you .
W
e l l ,
w
e have t
w
o pr e l i
m
i na r y
m
a t t e r s t o
m
en t i on . The
 
1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829
09:34:3109:34:5809:35:2509:35:5609:36:23
C
H
A
R
LES TAYL
OR
16
M
AY 2012
O
PE
N
SESSI
ON
SCSL - T
R
IAL C
H
A
M
BE
R
I I
49681
f i r s t
m
a t t e r i s t he de l i ve r y o f t he f u l l j udge
m
en t ,
w
h i ch i s ahuge j udge
m
en t . The Tr i a l Cha
m
be r had a i
m
ed a t hav i ng i tpub l i shed l as t
M
onday .
H
o
w
eve r , t he t echn i c i ans
w
ho
w
e r ef or
m
a t t i ng t he j udge
m
en t f or pub l i ca t i on have had cha l l enges duet o t he vo l u
m
i nous s i ze o f t he j udge
m
en t , and t hey
w
as no t ab l e t o
m
ee t t he
M
onday dead- l i ne .
H
o
w
eve r , t hey have gua r an t eed t ha t t he j udge
m
en t
w
i l l ber eady f or pub l i ca t i on be f or e c l ose o f bus i ness t h i s F r i day .
N
o
w
, t he second
m
a t t e r i s as f o l l o
w
s : Be f or e proceed i ngt oday , i t g i ves us no p l easur e t o have t o p l ace on r ecord so
m
eexp l ana t i on f or t he ex t r aord i na r y s i t ua t i on
w
h i ch occur r ed a t t heend o f t he pr ev i ous s i t t i ng o f t he Tr i a l Cha
m
be r on 26 t h o fApr i l , 2012 , on
w
h i ch da t e t he Tr i a l Cha
m
be r de l i ve r ed i t ssu
mm
a r y j udge
m
en t .
O
n t ha t da t e , a t t he conc l us i on o f t he proceed i ngs , t heA l t e rna t e Judge ,
w
i t hou t any no t i ce t o t he Tr i a l Cha
m
be r ,proceeded t o de l i ve r h i s o
w
n op i n i ons f ro
m
t he bench on t hej udge
m
en t t ha t had j us t been de l i ve r ed on t hese proceed i ngs andon t he Spec i a l Cour t i t se l f .
W
ha t t he A l t e rna t e Judge d i d
w
as i ncon t r aven t i on o f t he agr ee
m
en t , t he St a t u t e , and t he
R
u l es
w
h i chgove rn t h i s Cour t and a
m
oun t ed t o
m
i sconduc t .The purpose o f a t t ach i ng an A l t e rna t e Judge t o a Tr i a lCha
m
be r i s t ha t he can be des i gna t ed t o r ep l ace a s i t t i ng Judgei f t ha t Judge i s unab l e t o con t i nue s i t t i ng . See Ar t i c l e 12 o ft he St a t u t e .
N
o such des i gna t i on has been
m
ade i n t he pr esen tcase . Fur t he r , dur i ng t he proceed i ngs , t he A l t e rna t e Judge
m
aypose ques t i ons t hrough t he Pr es i d i ng Judge , bu t t he r e i s no o t he ren t i t l e
m
en t f or an A l t e rna t e Judge t o speak dur i ng cour tproceed i ngs . See
R
u l e 16 b i s (B) .
M
or eove r , an A l t e rna t e Judge
Search
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.
    • Notes
    Load more