Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
12Activity
P. 1
Order Exonerating Todd Willingham

Order Exonerating Todd Willingham

Ratings:

5.0

(1)
|Views: 102,121|Likes:
Published by Scott Cobb
Judge Charlie Baird drafted this order that would have exonerated Todd Willingham. The order was suppressed by a higher court's ruling. Texas executed an innocent person.
Judge Charlie Baird drafted this order that would have exonerated Todd Willingham. The order was suppressed by a higher court's ruling. Texas executed an innocent person.

More info:

Published by: Scott Cobb on May 20, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/10/2014

pdf

text

original

 
0
OD [AG 9??[A KOR[YOB[ BMWY[OD @DK HMY[Y@XOR BMWD[_, [GQ@ROD YG: ®®B@FGYMD [MKK ^OLLODNA@F ® DM$ K&0&KB 05&05558?®®MUODOMD @DK MYKGY MH [AG BMWY[
Md Rgu{gfigy 9;, 9505, {ag Ug{o{omdgyr, GWNGDO@ ^OLLODNA@F `dk U@[YOBO@^OLLODNA@F BMQ, {ag rwyxoxodn h`fol mh B@FGYMD [MKK ^OLLODNA@F, holgk `Ug{o{omd {m Bmdxgdg ` Bmwy{ mh Odpwoy `dk hmy ` Kgbl`y`{omd {m Ygfgk Odjwy {m ^ollodna`f‟rYguw{`{omd Wdkgy {ag [gq`r Bmdr{o{w{omd$ ^ollodna`f a`k iggd bmdxob{gk mh `dk gqgbw{gk hmyfwykgyodn aor {aygg k`wna{gyr$ [ag Ug{o{omdgyr ygpwgr{gk ` ag`yodn ~agygod gxokgdbg bmwlk igmhhgygk {m uymxg {a`{ ^ollodna`f ~`r ~ymdnhwll gqgbw{gk$ Md Mb{migy 0;, 9505, {aor Bmwy{bmdkwb{gk ` ag`yodn !agyg`h{gy “{ag ag`yodn‖/ `dk ygbgoxgk kmbwfgd{`y gxokgdbg `dk r~myd{gr{ofmd, uygrgd{gk i Ngy`lk A$ Nmlkr{god mh Nmlkr{god, Nmlkr{god ( Aollg3 I`yy Rbagbc mh {ag Oddmbgdbg Uymjgb{, `uug`yodn
 uym a`b xobg
3 `dk hmyfgy [gq`r Nmxgydmy, {ag Amdmy`ilg F`yc ^ao{g$
¥0
@h{gy b`yghwl bmdrokgy`{omd mh {a`{ gxokgdbg `dk {ag `ynwfgd{ mh bmwdrgl, {ag Bmwy{ dm~gd{gyr {ag hmllm~odn hodkodnr, muodomdr, `dk mykgyr:
O$ RWFF@Y_
[aor Bmwy{ mykgyr {ag gqmdgy`{omd mh B`fgymd [mkk ^ollodna`f hmy fwykgyodn aor {ayggk`wna{gyr$ Od lona{ mh {ag mxgy~aglfodn, bygkoilg, `dk yglo`ilg gxokgdbg uygrgd{gk i {agUg{o{omdgyr, {aor Bmwy{ amlkr {a`{ {ag R{`{g mh [gq`r ~ymdnhwll gqgbw{gk B`fgymd [mkk^ollodna`f$^gonaodn {ag gxokgdbg uygrgd{gk i {ag Ug{o{omdgyr od h`xmy mh ^ollodna`f‟r gqmdgy`{omd`n`odr{ {ag gxokgdbg uymkwbgk `{ aor {yo`l, {aor Bmwy{ bmdblwkgr {a`{ {ag Ug{o{omdgyr a`xg ram~di blg`y `dk bmdxodbodn gxokgdbg {a`{ dm yg`rmd`ilg jwymy ~mwlk a`xg bmdxob{gk ^ollodna`f odlona{ mh {ag dg~l korbmxgygk gxokgdbg$Od 955;, ^ollodna`f uymxokgk {ag Bmwy{ mh Byofod`l @uug`lr `dk Nmxgydmy Yobc Ugyy~o{a gqmdgy`{odn gxokgdbg$ [a`{ gxokgdbg ~`r ondmygk, `dk ^ollodna`f ~`r gqgbw{gk$
¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥
0
¥
[ag bwyygd{ D`x`yym Bmwd{ Kor{yob{ @{{mydg, Amd$ Y$ Lm~gll [amfurmd, kgblodgk {aor Bmwy{‟r odxo{`{omd{m `{{gdk {ag ag`yodn `dk {m mhhgy `d gxokgdbg ag ~oragk hmy, `n`odr{, my md `d orrwg!r/ uygrgd{gk i {ag Ug{o{omdgyr$Odr{g`k, [amfurmd lgh{ {ag bmwy{ymmf `dk ygpwgr{gk ` r{` mh uymbggkodnr hymf {ag [aoyk Bmwy{ mh @uug`lr$ @ r{`~`r orrwgk
`h{gy 
{ag ag`yodn bmdblwkgk$ [ag r{` ygf`odgk od ghhgb{ wd{ol {mk`$@kko{omd`ll, {aor Bmwy{ odxo{gk [ag Nmxgydmy, R{`{g Uymrgbw{odn @{{mydg, R{`{g Hoyg F`yra`ll, `dk R{`bCwcgdk`ll, ^ollodna`f‟r gq&~ohg `dk fm{agy mh {ag {aygg kgbgkgd{r, {m `{{gdk {ag ag`yodn `dk {m mhhgy gxokgdbghmy, `n`odr{, my md `d orrwg!r/ uygrgd{gk i {ag Ug{o{omdgyr$ G`ba kgblodgk {ag odxo{`{omd$
¥
 
9[ag R{`{g mh [gq`r a`r ` kw{ {m gdrwyg {a`{ rwba ` {y`ngk dgxgy a`uugdr `n`od$ [m {aorgdk, {ag Lgnorl`{wyg or gdbmwy`ngk {m gd`b{ bmfuygagdroxg lgnorl`{omd {m gdrwyg {a`{ `d oddmbgd{awf`d lohg or dgxgy `n`od {`cgd od {ag d`fg mh {ag Bo{ozgdr mh [gq`r$B`fgymd [mkk ^ollodna`f rwhhgygk {ag wl{of`{g odkondo{ mh igodn uw{ {m kg`{a hmy `byofg {a`{ ag kok dm{ bmffo{3 {a`{ odkondo{ or f`ndohogk i {ag h`b{ {a`{ {ag byofg hmy ~aoba ag~`r ~ymdnhwll gqgbw{gk ~`r {ag jwr{l ygxolgk byofg mh holobokg$Dm bmwy{ mh l`~ b`d iyodn i`bc {ag lohg mh B`fgymd [mkk ^ollodna`f$ Am~gxgy, ~g b`dygr{myg aor yguw{`{omd `dk ~myc {m gdrwyg {a`{ hw{wyg odjwr{obgr mh {aor f`ndo{wkg ~oll dgxgy igh`llm{agyr$
OO$ JWYORKOB[OMD@L R[@[GFGD[
[ag [gq`r Lgnorl`{wyg a`r ~orgl ygbmndozgk {a`{ mwy byofod`l jwr{obg rr{gf or dm{ugyhgb{, `dk rmfg{ofgr oddmbgd{ fgd `dk ~mfgd `yg bmdxob{gk mh dmdb`uo{`l byofgr `dk rwhhgy{ag lmrr mh {agoy loigy{$ Od `d `{{gfu{ {m ygfgk {amrg forb`yyo`ngr mh jwr{obg, {ag Lgnorl`{wyggd`b{gk {ag [of Bmlg @b{$
Rgg ngdgy`ll
[gq$ Box$ Uy`b$ ( Ygf$ Bmkg, [o{lg 7, Ba`u$ 052$
9
 Am~gxgy, ugya`ur od {ag amug {a`{ `d oddmbgd{ ugyrmd ~mwlk dgxgy ig gqgbw{gk, {ag Lgnorl`{wyga`r dm{ gd`b{gk ` rofol`y r{`{w{my rbagfg {m `kkygrr ` bl`of mh ~ymdnhwl gqgbw{omd$ [ag h`b{{a`{ {agyg or dm{ ` r{`{w{g my ` ywlg uymxokodn ` ygfgk hmy ~ymdnhwl gqgbw{omdr kmgr dm{ fg`d {agUg{o{omdgyr `yg ~o{amw{ ` hmywf$ O{ or `qomf`{ob {a`{ “Jwr{obg or {m ig kgdogk dm mdg ~am rggcr o{amdgr{l hymf ` bmwy{ mh l`~$‖[ag hy`fgyr mh {ag [gq`r Bmdr{o{w{omd ygbmndozgk {a`{ ro{w`{omdr ~mwlk `yorg ~agyg `dodkoxokw`l‟r yguw{`{omd ~mwlk ig a`yfgk `dk {a`{ {ag bmwy{r fwr{ ig mugd {m uymxokg ` ygfgk$Rugbohob`ll, {ag Ug{o{omdgyr ygl wumd @y{oblg 0, Rgb{omd 02 mh {ag [gq`r Bmdr{o{w{omd ~aobar{`{gr: “@ll bmwy{r ra`ll ig mugd, `dk gxgy ugyrmd hmy `d odjwy kmdg aof, od aor l`dkr, nmmkr,ugyrmd my yguw{`{omd, ra`ll a`xg ygfgk i kwg bmwyrg mh l`~$‖ [gq`r Bmdr{o{w{omd, `y{$ 0, ® 02$@dk igb`wrg {agyg or dm r{`{w{g my ywlg bmxgyodn {aor {ug mh mbbwyygdbg, @y{oblg 7, Rgb{omd1 mh mwy Bmdr{o{w{omd kgbl`ygr {a`{ kor{yob{ bmwy{r `yg {ag `uuymuyo`{g hmywf {m ag`y rwba bl`ofr$Kor{yob{ Bmwy{ jwyorkob{omd bmdror{r mh gqblwroxg, `uugll`{g, `dk myonod`l jwyorkob{omd mh `ll`b{omdr, uymbggkodnr, `dk ygfgkogr, gqbgu{ od b`rgr ~agyg gqblwroxg, `uugll`{g, my myonod`l jwyorkob{omd f` ig bmdhgyygk i {aor Bmdr{o{w{omd my m{agy l`~ md rmfg m{agy bmwy{,{yoiwd`l, my `kfodor{y`{oxg imk$ Kor{yob{ Bmwy{ jwkngr ra`ll a`xg {ag um~gy {m orrwg ~yo{rdgbgrr`y {m gdhmybg {agoy jwyorkob{omd$[gq`r Bmdr{o{w{omd, `y{$ X, ® 1$Bmdrgpwgd{l, {aor Bmwy{ or bmdr{o{w{omd`ll xgr{gk ~o{a {ag jwyorkob{omd {m bmdrokgy {agbl`ofr uygrgd{gk od {aor ug{o{omd `dk, oh rwba bl`ofr `yg x`lok, {m h`raomd `d `uuymuyo`{g ygfgk$
¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥
9
¥
[ag `b{ or d`fgk od amdmy mh [of Bmlg, ~am ~`r ~ymdnhwll bmdxob{gk mh ` dmdb`uo{`l byofg `dk kogk oduyormd$ Ag ~`r gqmdgy`{gk i {aor Bmwy{ md @uyol >, 955?$ Igb`wrg {agyg ~`r dm r{`{w{my rbagfg `x`ol`ilg hmy `kgbg`rgk ugyrmd {m rggc {m a`xg aor yguw{`{omd ygr{mygk, Fy$ Bmlg‟r rwyxoxmyr gfulmgk @y{oblg 0, Rgb{omd 02 mh {ag[gq`r Bmdr{o{w{omd$ [aor gqmdgy`{omd ~`r ygbmndozgk i Nmxgydmy Yobc Ugyy, ~am rwirgpwgd{l ny`d{gk Bmlg[gq`r‟ hoyr{ !`dk, {m k`{g, mdl/ umr{awfmwr u`ykmd$ Wdpwgr{omd`il, {ag Ug{o{omdgyr `yg gd{o{lgk {m ygl wumd {agr`fg bmdr{o{w{omd`l uymxoromd$
¥
 
2[ag ug{o{omd `lrm rggcr {m odxmcg {aor Bmwy{‟r jwyorkob{omd wdkgy @y{oblg 79 mh {ag [gq`rBmkg mh Byofod`l Uymbgkwyg ~agygi {aor Bmwy{ ~mwlk `b{ `r ` f`nor{y`{g {m kg{gyfodg ~ag{agy`dmdg `{ {ag [gq`r Hoyg F`yra`l‟r mhhobg bmffo{{gk {ag byofg mh mhhobo`l muuygrromd `r `llgngkod {ag ug{o{omd$ Hmy {ag yg`rmdr r{`{gk
odhy`
`{ d$1, {aor Bmwy{ rugbohob`ll kgblodgr {m `b{ wdkgy@y{oblg 79$
OOO$ HODKODNR MH H@B[
@$
 
[ag HoygMd Kgbgfigy 92, 0??0, {ag ^ollodna`f ygrokgdbg od Bmyrob`d`, [gq`r, b`wna{ hoyg$^ollodna`f `dk aor {aygg k`wna{gyr, @figy, C`fgymd, `dk C`yfmd, ~gyg od {ag amwrg `{ {ag{ofg mh {ag hoyg$ ^ollodna`f ygbgoxgk fodmy odjwyogr, iw{ aor {aygg k`wna{gyr ugyoragk$Md Kgbgfigy 9;, 0??0, @rror{`d{ Hoyg Baogh Kmwnl`r Hmnn ugyhmyfgk `d odo{o`lodrugb{omd `dk odxgr{on`{omd mh {ag hoyg `dk holgk ` ygumy{$ [aygg k`r l`{gy, md Kgbgfigy 9>,0??0, F`dwgl X`rpwgz, `d odxgr{on`{my hymf {ag R{`{g Hoyg F`yra`l‟r Mhhobg, bmdkwb{gk `rgu`y`{g odrugb{omd `dk odxgr{on`{omd, `dk holgk ` rgu`y`{g ygumy{$ Im{a ygumy{r bl`rrohogk {ag hoyg`r `yrmd, `dk ` byofod`l odxgr{on`{omd gdrwgk$ Md Kgbgfigy 20, 0??0, odxgr{on`{myr pwgr{omdgk^ollodna`f$ Md J`dw`y 1, 0??9, ^ollodna`f ~`r `yygr{gk `dk ba`yngk ~o{a {ag fwykgyr mh aor{aygg k`wna{gyr$I$
 
[ag [yo`lMd @wnwr{ 01, 0??9, ^ollodna`f‟r {yo`l ign`d$ [ag R{`{g‟r b`rg ygr{gk wumd {~mbmfumdgd{r: !0/ {ag `yrmd gxokgdbg {gr{ofmd mh Hmnn `dk X`rpwgz3 `dk !9/ {ag {gr{ofmd mh Jmadd Gxgyg{{ ^gii, `d odf`{g bmdhodgk od {ag D`x`yym Bmwd{ j`ol ~o{a ^ollodna`f$ [agbmd{gd{r `dk `bbwy`b mh {ag {gr{ofmd mh g`ba ~oll ig korbwrrgk od kg{`ol od {ag rwirgpwgd{rgb{omdr$ [ag jwy bmdxob{gk ^ollodna`f mh b`uo{`l fwykgy `dk rgd{gdbgk aof {m kg`{a$B$
 
[ag @uug`lrMxgy {ag bmwyrg mh {ag dgq{ kgb`kg, ^ollodna`f gqa`wr{gk gxgy `x`ol`ilg `uugll`{g-umr{&bmdxob{omd ygfgk iw{ ~`r wd`ilg {m `{{`od yglogh$ Od Dmxgfigy mh 9552, {ag Wdo{gk R{`{grRwuygfg Bmwy{ kgdogk bgy{omy`yo$ Ramy{l {agyg`h{gy, ^ollodna`f‟r gqgbw{omd ~`r rg{ hmyHgiyw`y 0>, 955;$Md Hgiyw`y 02, 955;, ^ollodna`f holgk ` rwirgpwgd{ ~yo{ mh a`ig`r bmyuwr ~o{a {ag[gq`r Bmwy{ mh Byofod`l @uug`lr$ [a`{ ~yo{ yglogk wumd {ag “Awyr{ Ygumy{,‖ korbwrrgk
odhy`
, `rdg~ hmygdrob gxokgdbg kgfmdr{y`{odn `b{w`l oddmbgdbg$ [ag Bmwy{ mh Byofod`l @uug`lr yghwrgk{m bmdrokgy {ag bl`of$K$
 
Blgfgdb UymbgrrMd J`dw`y 98, 955;, ^ollodna`f `uulogk {m {ag [gq`r Im`yk mh U`ykmdr `dk U`ymlgr!“Im`yk‖/ hmy bmffw{`{omd mh aor rgd{gdbg my, od {ag `l{gyd`{oxg, hmy ` ?5&k` yguyogxg hymf

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->