Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Al La Madhhabiyya

Al La Madhhabiyya

Ratings: (0)|Views: 51 |Likes:
Published by chefyousef

More info:

Published by: chefyousef on May 20, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/21/2012

pdf

text

original

 
 1
3
TheDebatewithShaykhNāTheDebatewithShaykhNāTheDebatewithShaykhNāTheDebatewithShaykhNāiruddiruddiruddiruddīnalīnalīnalīnal----Albānī Albānī Albānī Albānī
Dr.ShaykhMuammadSa‘īdRamaānal-Būī
TranslatedbyM.MerzaandM.A.AbsiRevisedbySuraqahAbdulAziz
òîjç‰ß@ýÛa 
 APreview APreview APreview APreviewofalofalofalofal----LāLāMadhhabiyya:Madhhabiyya:Madhhabiyya:Madhhabiyya:
 AbandoningtheMadhhabsisthemostdangerousBid‘ahThreateningtheIslamicSharī‘ah
Releasedby www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com& www.marifah.net www.marifah.net www.marifah.net www.marifah.net1428H.
1111
 
1111
Forthcomingat
 www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com
.Thispreviewisaspecialinternet-releaseby
 www.marifah.net www.marifah.net www.marifah.net www.marifah.net
 whichdiffersfromtheprintedversionofthebookinseveralways.Theforeword,allfootnotes,titlesandsubtitlesfoundinthispreviewhavebeenaddedbythepublisher.Shaykhal-Būī’soriginalfootnotesasfoundinthebook‘Al-LāMadhhabiyya’havebeenpresentedaspartofthemaintext.Thepreviewhasbeenexcerptedbythepublisherfromdifferentpagesintheoriginalbookwithreferencetothepagenumbersmadeinthefootnotes.
 
 2
CONTENTSCONTENTSCONTENTSCONTENTS
PublishersForeword3TTTTheDebatewithheDebatewithheDebatewithheDebatewithShaykhShaykhShaykhShaykhalalalal----Albānī Albānī Albānī AlbānīIntroductiontotheDebate4Shaykhal-AlbānīsFirstPoint5
TheTitle‘al-LāMadhhabiyya’
 ATerminologicalDiscussion5
Shaykhal-AlbānīsSecondPoint7
TheStatementsofShaykhal-Khajnadī
MisunderstandinghisWords

ExcusinghisExpressions9InResponsetohisRequest10 AdditionalNotestotheDebate AdditionalNotestotheDebate AdditionalNotestotheDebate AdditionalNotestotheDebatePrayingBehindaFollowerofanotherMadhhab11TheMadhhaboftheMessengerofAllah
13
 
TheMadhhaboftheCompanions15TheAftermathoftheDebateTheAftermathoftheDebateTheAftermathoftheDebateTheAftermathoftheDebateFalseRumorsaboutShaykhMulRamaānal-ī16ShaykhMullāRamaānsStatement17
 
 3
PublishPublishPublishPublisher’sForeworder’sForeworder’sForeworder’sForeword
ThisisapreviewoftheforthcomingEnglishtranslationofShaykhMuammadSa‘īdRamaānal-Būī’sgroundbreakingwork,
al-lāmadhhabiyyaakharubid‘atintuhaddidual- sharī‘atal-islāmiyya 
.Thisworkwasoriginallywrittenin1969asarefutationofMuammadSulānal-Ma‘ūmīal-Khajnadīal-Makki’swork“
 AreMuslimsobligatedtofollowoneoftheFourMadhhabs?
”whichwastranslatedintoEnglishandpublishedas“TheBlindFollowingofMadhhabs.”InthelatereditionsofthisbookShaykhal-Būīincludedfurtherdebateshehad with
LāMadhhabī  
scholarsandcounter-repliestosomeoftheirsupposed‘refutations’..In1995,ShaykhNuhHaMimKellertranslatedanexcerptfrom
al-LāMadhhabiyya 
which wastitled,‘WhyDoesOneHavetoFollowaMadhhab?DebateBetweenMuhammadSa‘idal-ButiandaLeadingSalafiTeacher.’Thisarticlewaspublishedontheinternet
2222
andeventuallyreachedthestaffof‘SalafiPublications.’Inresponse,theyattemptedtorefuteit,describingthecontentoftheireffortsas“Numerousrefutationsagainstal-Butiwhotries,bycleverlydevisedarguments,tonullifythewayoftheSalaf,claimingthatSalafiyyah
3333
wasonlyashortandhistoricalperiodoftime.”Thetwoarticlestheyproducedwerereleasedon-linein1999havingbeenexcerptedfromthebook,
al-ta‘aubal-madhhabiyyahiyaal-bid‘ah 
,which waswritteninresponsetoShaykhal-Būī’s
al-LāMadhhabiyya 
.Inthispreviewfrom
al-LāMadhhabiyya 
weintendtofocusspecificallyonthedebatewithShaykhMuammadNāiruddīnal-Albānīwhich‘Salafipublications’referredtoas‘
Imamal-  Albani’sSubjugationofal-Buti.’ 
4444
ThiswasfurtherdescribedintheirarticleasAsummarisedtranscriptofameetingthattookplacebetweenImaamal-Albaniandal-Butiandinwhichal-Butiwasleftwithnowheretoturn.Includesadiscussionoftaqlid,madhhabsetc.”Unfortunately,nineyearson,aresponseinEnglishremainedlacking,andmanymayhavebeenmisledintobelievingafalseoutcomeofthedebatewhichhadoccurred.Whathadbeenpresentedby‘SalafiPublications’was,ofcourse,notthecompletestory.After
al-ta‘aubal- madhhabiyyahiyaal-bid‘ah
 wasreleasedandfalserumorsbegantospread,Shaykhal-Butipublishedasecondeditionofhisbookinwhichhehimselfrespondedtothesenewdevelopments.Thiswas,infact,asearlyas1970,manyyearsbeforethearticlesof‘SalafiPublications’wereevenwritten!OurpreviewathandisacompilationofonlysomeoftherepliesbyShaykhal-ButifoundinthelatesteditionofhisbookwhichissoontobereleasedinitsentiretyinEnglish.Wepraythatthisbriefpresentationwill,inshā’Allāh,clarifysomeofthemisconceptionsbroughtforthbythosewhosoughttodistortanddeceive.AndallsuccessisfromAllah!
 
2222
http://www.masud.co.uk/ISLAM/nuh/buti.htmhttp://www.masud.co.uk/ISLAM/nuh/buti.htmhttp://www.masud.co.uk/ISLAM/nuh/buti.htmhttp://www.masud.co.uk/ISLAM/nuh/buti.htm
3333
‘SalafiPublications’isherereferringtoanotherbookbyShaykhal-Būtī,
al-salafiyyamaralatunzamaniyyatunmubārakatun,lāmadhhabismī  
.Itstranslationisalsoforthcomingat
 www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com www.sunnipubs.com
.However,neitherofthetwo‘numerousrefutations’areactuallyinrefutationofthisbook.
4444
http://www.salafipublications.com/sps/sp.cfm?subsecID=NDV06&articleID=NDV060001&pfriendhttp://www.salafipublications.com/sps/sp.cfm?subsecID=NDV06&articleID=NDV060001&pfriendhttp://www.salafipublications.com/sps/sp.cfm?subsecID=NDV06&articleID=NDV060001&pfriendhttp://www.salafipublications.com/sps/sp.cfm?subsecID=NDV06&articleID=NDV060001&pfriend====

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->