~ ~

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF PAULDING COUNTY

STATE OF GEORGIA
This case came before the Court on Wednesday, April 6, 2011 for a hearingron
MICHAEL L LOWE,
'"
*
Plaintiff,
'"
'"
CIVIL ACTION FILE
v.
*
EUSA M. LOWE,
'"
'"
*
NO.: 08-CV-1124-JO
. ~
.."
:::)
""M
r
:n
'::J
Defendant.
'"
."-..,."
." o
ORDER
~
...,
,()
~
m
Defendant's Motion to Set Aside, Motion for New Trial, and Renewal of Request for
Rule 12 Sanctions Based Upon the Continuing Fraud Committed by Attorney Martin E.
Val buena In the above-entitled case. Plaintiff appeared through counsel and
Defendant appeared pro se. After reviewing the file, pleadings, briefs filed with the
Court and applicable case law and hearing argument, and It appearing to the Court for
meritorious reasons and for other good cause shown, It Is therefore Ordered,
Adjudged and Decreed:
Defendant's Motion to Set ASide, Motion for New Trial, and Renewal of Request
for Rule 12 Sanctions Based Upon the Continuing Fraud Committed by Attorney
Martin E. Valbuena is Denied.
IT IS SO ORDERED this ~ day of April 2011.
pw;:;a
Martin Enrique Valbuena;"Esq.
Ga. State Bar No.: 723164
Attorney for Plaintiff
210
"
FILED IN OFFICE
"'''OLDING COUNTY, nt.
IN THE SUPERlOR COURT OF PAULDING COUNTY " APR 20 PIt It, 31
STATE OF GEORGIA
TInA W. SHl'I.TON
MICHAEL L. LOWE, )
) '........CJ&f' ...T5
Plaintiff. )
v. ) CIVIL ACTION FILE
) NO. 08-CV-1 124-JO
ELISA M. LOWE, )
)
Defendant
AFFIDAVIT OF INDIGENCE OF APPELLANT
COMES NOW Elisa M.lowe and after being duly swom by the underliigned
officer authorized by law to administer oaths, swears and deposes as follows:
That ram Elisa M.lowe. defendant 10 the above-captioned matter. and that I wish
to appeal from an adverse decision 10 this matter but because of my poverty I am unable
to pay cost or to post a supersedeas !:lood (if required).
My indigence has already been recognized by the Paulding Superior Court as I have already been
appointed a Publk Defender for a related but different action in this Superior Court NO. 09-C&-000665
Submitted this 20th day of April 2001


Appellant c..:;:::r
ProSe
279 Crossroods states Drive
Newnan, GA 30265
404704-7058
Sworn to and subscribed before me
on this .,. Day o!
Notary Public:
My commission Expires 12 -/1- 7p1/
211
FILED I
fI" lit 01",,. N OFFICE
.. COU"'T
"APR 't.(;,.
20 ", ", 37
IN mE SUPERIOR COURT OF PAULDING COUNTYT'\I JI W $
STATE OF GEORGIA ,.A...... TON
MICHAEL L. LOWE, ) . r ---rJ
)
Plaintiff, )
v. ) CIVIL ACTION FILE
) NO.08-CV1124-JO
ELISA M. LOWE, )
)
Defendant.
CERTlFICATE OF SERVICE
COMES NOW, Elisa L Lowe, and certifies that she has filed the following document In the aoove-captioned
case and shows that she has mailed, via registered mail, a copy to Martin Valbuena. attorney of record for the
Respondent:
AFFIDAVIT OF INDIGENCE OF APPELLANT
Said documents were mailed. via U.S. Registered Mail. to Plaintiffs Attomey of Record as follows:
Martin Enrique Valubena
113 Village Walk, Suite B
P.O. Box 1125
Dallas. Georgia 30132
S0::Z"-'L
tJ
, / 11.
-
Petitioner
ProSe
212
.. .. ..
..
i-
Court of Appeals
of the State of Georgia
ATLANTA, MAY 25, 2011
The Court ofAppeals hereby passes the/allowing order:
APPLICATION NO. AIID0382
ELISA M. LOWE V. MICHAEL L. LOWE
---:) ",...,
Upon consideration of the Application for

.... - ::;Jr.:".--.";
Appeal, it is ordered that it be hereby GRANTED. The
. ,
file a Notice of Appeal within 10 days of the date of ..
c'
The Clerk of SUPERIOR COURT is directed to include a
"
order in the record transmitted to the Court of Appeals. -c- =?
98032
08CV1124
'.'t>
Court ofAppeals ofthe State of Georgia
Clerk's Office, Atlanta
MAY 25 2011
I certify that the above is a true extract from
the minutes of the Court of Appeals of GeOrgia
Witness my signature and the seal oj said court
hereto affixed tlie du:y and year last above above written.
Clerk.
f{., $ 4-?--r
I
213
-----
---
O) -CY - Ilo,Y0
0
,
Ms. TREVA W. SHELTON
CLERK, PAULDING SUPERIOR COURT
ROOM 1023
280 CONSTITUTION BLVD.
DALLAS GA 30132
AllD0382
214
98032
,,
Court of Appeal.
of the State of Georg.a
A'l'LUII1'A, ~ 2 ., 201.1
1M Ccutt of~ Mreby pasw thefol/IJKfl1ts orde:
APPLICATION NO. AllD0382
.EloISA M. LOW V. MICHARL L. LOWIS
upon consideration of the Application for Discretionary
Appeail, it 1s ordered that: :it be bereby GRANTED. The Appelll.Ult may
file a Notice of Appeal within 10 days of the date. of this order.
The Clerk of SUPERIOR COIlRT is directed to .include a copy of this
order in the record transmitted to the court of Appeal.
o8CV1l.'i1,
,..-1 ~
Court ofAppelll.r ofthe Stale -of GffNg/Q
Ckrlc's ()jJlal, .4.tkmta
NAY 25 2011
J ~ that th, abel'll iI a true utrtICIfro!n
the minlltel ofthe Court of~ of GeOrgia
WftMSI nty ligrrtltUn and the ,_fsaid court
hmto ajJtxid tlie dIrj and year /Qst aJiqve abtNe written.
Cleik. .
{{.,.1'41--"
215
Gmail- Images in "Fwd: Court Docs" Page 13 of43

...
--i------ ..11. .aD-II
--, B /:l
I T SUPERIOR COURT OF DEKALB COUNTY
.. STATE OF GEORGIA
COWETA COUNTY CIVIL ACTION
RE,
FlLENO.04-V-32

ATTORNEY'S LIEN


Delia T. Crouch. Attorney at Law. claims a lien on all property conveyed. tnmsferred, or
otherwise placed into the possession of MICHAEL L. LOWE. and the conveyor is hereby
notified ofsaid claim oflien. Said lien is being served and filed pursuantlo O.e.O.A. 15-\9-14
in the amount 0($11,040.87 and said lien shall be superior to 1111 other liens Cl:cpt tax liens and
flO person shall be at liberty to satisfy s.uch action herein. judgment or decree until the lien or
claim Qfthe attomey's is fully satisfied.
Further Affiant saith not.
Respectfully submincd,

DliLIA T. CROUCH'"
GA Slate Bar No. 198353

< .... - ,...,.


_C"/r

n""
n
!'oJ oor-,

:::::'. -0 ..
;<:- X ....
. P "l ""'=
PM" === (')
;1>::0 N r I"'i
::>; Q) 1"1
8/412616
216
--
.

:;a
Page 1 of2
"" '-I
llIB SUPERIOR COURT OF PAULDINO COUNTY
STATE OF OEOROIA
CAPITAL ONE BANK
-, I ::;:'l

,,"J
Plaltrtljf,

YS. '
1r.l
".1
MICHAEL I. LOWE

IUDGMF..NT
WHEREFORE. it appcari", 10 1his Honorable Coun thII this eM is In ."11, II is heidi)'
ORDF.RE.D. ADJUOOED IIId Df.CREED thII judplll is hmby ORANTED
.... J)efcndlal iathe __orSI23S.11 princIpIJ.S621.04 intmll, S.OO " filellIId III r.oun

"T
. _ ....c....;:.;.1
9S
http://c1erksmt.comlWebCaseManagementlImageheader.aspx?REcrYPE=Civil&id =i42. . . 12125/2004
217
Page 2 of2
;.,
'.
wi
'-'
c-wil AcIioD File No. 07.(;VSOOo.T8
CElTIP!CAIE Of SERVICE i
]
;'

TbI: Wlllcnipod cJoQs hereby c:etIi/Y dW alnICI and oom:ct copy ,,-0
Older wu dilly savod upon !be couucl of'roeonI _II by mtlllnt a \rlf1ime N
poIIIp Jft1lIIid ria Firat C\IIs$ U. S. Mail, addreacd .... ,\ ;'::" "" ,....

;.';!; S

Mr.IoscpII Cooling ',:: 't?

MIIII1 Dneltcn, LLC
Ou Pata Wat, SuiIC 1400
m7Pata Fcny R.a
AdmIa. GA 30339
Mr. Micbael L. Lowe
3ItGarWay
Dallas. GA 30132
This f" day ofApril, 2008.
II Coarthousc Sqaare
Room30S
DIIlu. GA 30132
htlp:/lclerksDlt.comiWebCaseManagementilmageheader.aspx'lRECTYPE=Civil&id =t42... 12125/2004
218
Page 1 of2
-.
,...
-
IN THE SUP1UUOR COURT ()II PAULDING COV\'.TY
STATE OJ' GEORGIA
7! iI ..,
"''''-Cl!IIIcIkIII. u.c.

PlliiliR:
ff t CD , ..'f:
YL
!: .:,i
Midood "-'.
9 ,.j
'.11
Dot......
N
COMNIIIQN r\CQWfa
COMES NOW !he !'IIiIIIifl'in !he IClion IIId submits llii. CompIciat
\!II Ace<uIt IIId SIICa the t'oIlowintJ:
I.
The 0efaIdIm is ruidelIt of11mCOUIIty IIIIi is wililin Ihc jurisdiction ofIIIis
Coun. Tho Dtfeacllftl mar be sened II the foIIOIIriIIJ a4dress:
III OSCAR. WAY
DALLAS. GA .)01)2
2.
DefCllldlnt opcacd ad ercdit ICeOlIIlt wid! HSse CREDIT SERVICE
INC.. DefcIIdInt (aileO to I1IIie Plymetl UIIder lilt terms ad conditions of!be tecount.
lhiIckU WIll pun:hascd by the PIliDIlff'1IId !be PIIi1Ilifl' now.....the reel pany in
\nteJat In !his 1Ui1. Tbc Clll'tlll1IftOIIM ofSl.236.49 is
J.
1foIico1W1ttonIo1', teesllld Imcratawrquirod IIIIdcrO.C.O.A. f 13-1-11 has
IIem Ii-to IIId nrceiml by Iho DefimdInIt III(ft \bin 10 days prior bereco. l'tai1IlifT
!lOW ad qaIa.unew demIIId for payment orlhis oWIption suocI upon. wkII
inlerm.1IId upon !'aiM 10 ply AIIIC II provided by law wilbin 10 days Iiom I*dpl of
1IIispctitlOll, PIalntilfwill claim lIl1Omey's fees pnwided for saidobliplion.
http://clerksn.comIWebCaseManagementJImageheader.aspx'lRECTYPE=Civil&id=l65.. . 1212512004
219
Page 2 of2
,...
-
WHEREfOR, PIabltIItdemands judpcat IU follows:
a) tpincipahlllOUlll of $162.19,
b) tor an ICWl.leClItUemlIn tile..,. of SlSI.08,
e) for rcIIOIIIIIIIe 8IIOtIIey's&!es ill dltllWlOlllltof $111.22,
4) tor Court COllIS ill dIt 1IlIOOIII or$1(15.00._ fOf sucboCber
Court deems just IIIId propII'.
RespdIIIyd!miUcd.
SHAFBR LAW FIRM
ShIIer Lew Firm
3S2S JIIedma.w ROId
BuiJdI., 6, Sui. 302
AduIa, OA 30305
TeII/pfIoM (404) 237-19l"

TIIiIo is rr.. dell! coIIcdIIr. 1IriI is &11 *"""10 coIhc1. *III.
My....1.... oIIIainodwlU .. _ ...... ,..,....
bttp:llc!erksna.comIWebCaseManagementlImagebeader.aspx?RECTYPE =Civil&id:=i65.. . 12125/2004
220

0\
".: ..

(..PfI

IO'H'" I\\"<n"" South. fll!l1k1in. Tenn<S5<'C :<"'%-10 (6 IS) '9-1-!51:1
CriIaiw.IIlM-MtigoIioIt Di'mioft
SptciCll YktiMs Ultit
.. MEDIA RElEASE
Georgia Woman arrested oa C.stodiallnterfereace charges ie Frankli.
Lat.. in the evening of0312412OOll. The Franklin Poli"" Depanmenl was alertocI by the Dallas, Georgia
Police OepanmcnIthlUWO boys (lOin<! 12 yeat$ old) had been liken Ii'om their father by the ",,win..
Ella M. lAnM, in violation of. court order indicating 1IIe llIIher bad full custody of the boys. Further
information indicated Ihat EIIaa M. Lowe had !eft the State ofGeorgia and W8$ residing in Fnmklin,
T-. WarranlS bad been taken 0111 in Dallas, Georgia for Elisa M. Lowe', arrest for lnlcrfcrencc with
Child Custody (twO counts) IIId Intmlale Interference with Child Custody (twO WUIlts). A Jetter of
cxlladition for EIIaa M. Lowe was signed by the District Allorney ofPaulding County. Georgi.
The Georgia Bur_ of l........ruaation bad issued a media advisory reptding the boys' removal from the
fathers (aidenl;e in Dallas, Georgia.
On 312512008, the boys were located 81 Fnmklin area and weTI! taken inlO custody by the Franklin
Polil:e Department Special Vli:tims Unit. The boys were latta' "",oited with their fatbet at the Franklin
Police Department.
LaD: after!1oon OIl 03l2SI2OO8, EIioa M. Lowe anived at !he Fnmklin Police Depanment and was takmln10
C\lstody on'the OIII$tanding WWflUlIS, .......... was chl.Qled with Fugitive Ii'om Justice here in WiRiarnson
(..,
County. and i. awaiting extradilion IiOd< 10 Georgia wilhoUl bond.
for immedhrte Release
Sflrge,mt E. An(/el'.>I11l
etJm/er!i(lllfajranklin-gm"mm (6HJ 5Jtl-611411
WDII......... c....".,. Crime Slo.....rs wllil"lY .p to 51.080 for laform_IIOII eallecl iAto 194-44iOO a_,
IeaQ to an arnst.Dd ladlmneaf. Calle .. wID remala aaoaymOUSI IIHIy will 0II1y .... kIIowa by dI.,
cod., m .... r they 11ft issued.
<...
Page I of!
221
Page 2 of2
...
,..
-
WHEaEFOR.E. Plalatift'...judpIcoI as follows:
a) for princ:iJMlamO'Ullt of 586219.
b) (or allll:CNlld interctt mlhumounl of $ \St.oa.
e) (or 1ItOI:1Iq'" fees ill1bl:1III'lOUIII of $111.22,
d) torCollrtCOlltl i111bI:1IIIOUIIt 1)($I05JlO, IDCI rot' sue\'l oCher rellcfullIis
ColIn deems jllSt and proper.
RespcclfiIIIyMmiUed,
SHAFER LAW FIRM
9hIIcr Law Firm
3$2S PWmonr ROid
OaikIinaf. SIIiIe 302
AdIIII. OA 3OlOS
Telepllont (404)131-lcn4
FIX (404) 231-1941
TIriI.... ....
Any ......1lM ....11 __lOt_ p!IIpOIf.
bttp:llclerksntt.comIWebCaseManagementlImageheader.aspx?RECfYPE =Civi1&id =i65.. . 12125/2004
220