Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OBJECTIVES
At the end of Chapter 1, you are expected to: Examine the various ways in which interest rate can be explained Analyse the factors that impact on interest rate. Discuss models of interest rate determination. Develop the relationship between interest rate and inflation.
OVERVIEW
The financial decision making by individuals, businesses or government, to a large extent, depends on the interest rate prevailing at the time the decisions are made as well as on the expected interest rate movements in the future. Therefore it is important to understand what is meant by interest rate, how is interest rate determined, what is the relationship between the interest rate and inflation. This chapter will discuss the interest rate determination and factors that affect interest rate.
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-1
Managing the finance function in a government or governmental organization is known as Public Finance. Financial management in a business is called Business Finance and if the business is set up as a corporate entity, the function is called Corporate Finance. Financial management for individuals is called Personal Finance, which for rich individuals, it will be Wealth Management. Irrespective of the entity, most, or even all financial decisions are based upon interest rate. In this chapter, we will discuss: i.) ii.) iii.) iv.) v.) What is interest rate? How is interest rate determined? What factors cause changes in interest rate? How is interest rate quoted? What is the relationship between inflation and interest rate?
SU1-C1-2
SIM UNIVERSITY
that time he will also receive income of I2. Thus, his consumption at time 2 will be I1 (1 + r) + I2 or C1 = 0 and C2 = I1 (1 + r) + I2. On the other hand, another individual may decide to borrow money against his future income and consume everything at time 1 and will consume nothing at time 1. In this case, he will borrow I2 / (1+ r) at time 1 and his consumption at time 1 and time 2 will be: C1 = I1 + I2 (1 + r) and C2 = 0 The above two cases are extreme cases. Consider an individual who plans to consume C1, which is less than I1. The surplus amount of (I1 C1) will be lent in the market at r %. This will result in an income from investment of (I1 C1) * (1 + r). The amount of income at time 2 will be I2. Thus, total consumption at time 2 will be (I1 C1) * (1 + r) + I2 . Note that the amount of consumption C2 is dependent on the amount of consumption C1. If one chooses to consume less at time 1, there will be more consumption at time 2 and vice versa. Thus, one can choose how much to consume at time 1, by deciding how much consumption is required at time 2 based on the interest rate. Another possibility is that an individual plans to consume more than the current income at this time by borrowing money at r %. In this case, his consumption at time 1 will be C1 = I0 + x where x is the amount borrowed. Since this amount will have to be repaid with interest in time 1, the amount to be repaid will be x (1 + r) leaving consumption at time 2 to be C2 = I2 (C1 I0) (1 + r). In this case also, the consumption at time 2 is dependent on how much the individual consumes at time 1. The consumption possibilities can be drawn as a diagram wit the two axes representing consumption in time 1 and time 2 respectively as follows:
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-3
C2 I1 (1 + r) + I2
I1 + I2/(1 + r)
C1
Figure 1: Consumption possibilities When C1 = 0; C2 = I1 (1 + r) + I2 and when C2 = 0; C1 = I1 + I2 (1 + r) The slope of the line is the interest rate (1 + r). When C1 increases, C2 decreases and vice versa. As there are many such consumption possibilities that exist, how should an individual choose his consumption at time 1 and time 2? This above diagram shows the consumption possibilities for interest rate r. What will happen if interest rate increases to r+ or decreases to r-? When interest rate increases, the amount of consumption in time 2 will increase for the same consumption at time 1 for an investor who has surplus and lends this money. On the other hand, a person who borrows money for consumption in time 1 will find the amount of consumption in time 2 will be lower for the same consumption in time 1. If interest rate decreases to r-, amount of consumption in time 2 will decrease for the same consumption at time 1 for the lender and will increase for the borrower. This is shown in figure 2.
SU1-C1-4
SIM UNIVERSITY
C2
r-
r*
r+
C1 Figure 2: Consumption Possibilities for Different Interest Rates Figure 2 shows that an individual has to choose his consumption at time 0 and time 2 from very many opportunities available, which depend on the interest rate. In case interest rate is known, the task is simpler because he can choose either the amount of consumption at time 1 or at time 2 as the other will be decided on the amount chosen for the first. If he chooses a particular C2, the amount of C1 will be fixed based on C2 and r. Similarly, if he chooses a particular C1, the amount of C2 will be fixed based on C1 and r. However, the individuals should be able to choose C1 and C2 independent of each other, which requires that the interest rate is determined endogenously based on C1 and C2 and not exogenously causing interdependence between C1 and C2. How does an individual choose C1 and C2 in the absence of known interest rate? Assume that the individual chooses a low C1 at time 1. This will result in higher consumption C2 at time 2. This means that he is foregoing current consumption C1 for a higher consumption C2. This can also be said as that the individual is substituting the future consumption for the current consumption. How much of substitution would be required to forego current consumption? This would depend on the individuals utility function for consumption. The common utility function for individuals drawn between C1 and C2 is shown in figure 3.
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-5
C2
C1 Figure 3: Utility Function for Individuals This figure shows that as higher amount of current consumption is substituted by future consumption, the utility increases; however, the increase in utility is smaller compared to the amount of substitution because most individuals exhibit decreasing marginal utility of consumption. At any point in the curve, the slope is given by dC2 / dC1 which is change in future consumption divided by change in current consumption. This slope is also known as the marginal rate of substitution (MRS). As can be seen, MRS decreases as higher amount of C2 is substituted for C1. Figure 4 shows what interest rate the individual desires where the utility curve in Figure 3 is superimposed on various interest rates as shown in Figure 2. In Figure 4, the utility curve is tangential to the interest rate curve r at C* and appropriate consumption chosen will be C1* and C2*. C2
rC2*
r*
r+
SU1-C1-6
SIM UNIVERSITY
Under this model, interest rate is the marginal rate of substitution between current and future consumption and thus interest rate is actually the compensation paid to an individual for postponing the current consumption for increased future consumption. Interest rate is also explained in terms of liquidity. Ready cash in hand is highly liquid and can be used immediately by any individual if need for cash arises. On the other hand, if the individual has lent this money to someone else ad if the individual required immediate cash, it will not be available readily as he needs to collect the money from the borrower. Thus the individuals lose the liquidity of ready cash and would require compensation for parting with liquidity. Whether interest rate is compensation for postponing current consumption or compensation for parting with liquidity, these do not provide a model that can be used to determine the interest rate. Instead, these arguments only substantiate the reasons for interest rate.
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-7
individual consumption item, a basket of consumption item is often used. This basket is usually the same basket that is used for calculating the consumer price index. The real interest rate will be the increase in consumption units included in the consumer price index assuming the prices of all items in the consumption basket did not change, or inflation is zero. Real interest rate can also be the increase in consumption after adjusting for inflation where inflation rate reflects the increase in the consumer price index. The nominal rate of interest is the actual amount of interest that an individual will receive when he lends money, or nominal interest rate is the increase in the money. If we need to calculate the actual increase in consumption, we need to take the effect of inflation from the nominal interest rate. Let us look at the example of bread again. When the bread price remains at $2, or where the inflation was 0, the increase in consumption is 0.5 loaves of bread for an investment of 5 loaves, or an increase in consumption of bread by 10%. Thus, real interest rate is 10% and nominal interest rate is also 10%. When bread price increases by 10% to $2.20, the increase in bread consumption is 0. This is equivalent to real rate of 0% and nominal rate of 10% and inflation of 10%. When bread price increases by 15% to $2.30, the bread consumption falls by 0.22 loaves or by 4.4%. This gives us a nominal rate of 10%, inflation of 15% and real rate of 4.4%. This example shows that real rate, nominal rate, and inflation rate are related by the following equation, developed by Irving Fisher: (1 + nominal rate) = (1 + real rate) * (1 + inflation rate) Since interest rates are determined for future, the inflation rate should be the expected inflation rate in the future. In practice, an approximate version of the above equation is used as: Nominal rate = Real rate + Expected inflation Caution must be used in interpreting this relation. Real rate of interest is unknown and one can only estimate it from the nominal rate and expected inflation. It is very difficult to estimate the expected inflation because the consumption basket for calculation of the consumer price index contains elements, which have price volatility. Examples would be crude oil price, which affects petrol and gas prices as well as rent on properties that can be highly volatile. The nominal rate of interest is often determined by the governments as part of a tool to adjust monetary policies, which can lead to violation of this relation. This relation is a long-term relationship. However, it may not hold every short-term period. There may be periods in which interest rates are very low and inflation is higher than the nominal rates causing real rates to be negative.
SU1-C1-8
SIM UNIVERSITY
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-9
decision will depend on the interest rate prevailing in the two countries, the risk of securities available, as well as the exchange rate volatility. Economic conditions and monetary policies of the government can also impact the supply of loanable funds. If the economy is doing well with high growth and low unemployment, the disposable income in households as well as cash flow of businesses will increase resulting in increased supply of loanable funds. On the other hand, poor economic conditions with low growth and high unemployment will result in lower disposable income in households as well as lower cash flow to businesses. This would result in decreased supply of loanable funds. The government uses monetary policies to manage inflation. When the economy is doing well, increased disposable income will result in the government restricting the money supply. This restricted money supply would make the financial institutions to restrict their loans to businesses. Thus, monetary contraction would lead to lower supply of loanable funds. In case of economic contraction, the government generally increases money supply, which they hope would stimulate the economy. The banks would be willing to extend funds to businesses and thus supply of loanable funds will increase when there is monetary expansion.
SU1-C1-10
SIM UNIVERSITY
aggregate loanable demand for funds. The equilibrium interest rate is determined when aggregate demand for loanable funds equals the aggregate supply. This is shown in figure 5.
iH i* iL S
D
Q* If the actual interest rate iL is lower than the equilibrium interest rate i*, it means that there is a shortage of loanable funds supplied compared to the demand. Those who are in need of finds would be prepared to pay a higher interest rate to obtain the funds which, in turn would induce the suppliers of loanable funds to increase the supply. This process will continue until equilibrium interest rate i* is reached. Similarly, if actual interest rate iH is higher than i*, there will be oversupply of funds compared to the demand. Since the suppliers have excess funds, which they would like to invest, they will be willing to accept a lower interest rate causing demand for loanable funds to increase. This process will continue until the interest rate decreases to reach the equilibrium interest rate.
Supply of Funds
The factors that affect the supply of funds to shift includes the total wealth of the suppliers, the risk of financial securities, future spending needs, monetary policy objectives and economic conditions.
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-11
As total wealth of suppliers of funds, which includes households and businesses, increases, the total amount of funds available for investment will increase at every interest rate. This will cause the supply curve to shift to the right. This shift will result in oversupply relative to demand causing disequilibrium in the market. In order to restore equilibrium, the interest rate will decrease, which will decrease the supply of funds and increase the demand for funds. This process will continue until a lower equilibrium interest rate is reached. Thus, an increase in total wealth would result in a decrease in the interest rate. On the other hand, if the total wealth decreases, it will result in an increase in the interest rate. If the risk of the financial security decreases, it will become more attractive to suppliers of funds. Thus, at every interest rate, the supply of loanable funds will increase, causing the supply curve to shift to the right. This shift to the right will cause oversupply relative to demand, causing interest rate to decrease. In case the risk of financial security increases, the suppliers of funds will be reluctant to make any investment in these securities causing supply of funds to decrease. Thus, at every interest rate, supply of loanable funds will decrease, causing the supply curve to shift right. The decrease in supply will cause a disequilibrium in which there is over demand relative to supply. It will be resolved with an increase in interest rates. Thus, any increase in the risk of financial security will cause interest rate to increase. If the investors have high near-term spending needs, the amount of loanable funds will decrease at every interest rate. This will cause the supply curve to shift to the left. When the supply curve does shift to the left, there will be a disequilibrium causing higher demand relative to supply. This will result in an increase in the interest and equilibrium will be reached at a higher interest rate. On the other hand, if near-term spending needs decrease, the supply curve will shift right and cause oversupply relative to demand. This will result in the equilibrium interest rate to decrease. If the government decides to increase the money supply and increase the economic growth, the supply of loanable funds will increase at every interest rate causing the supply curve to shift to the right. This will result in a decrease in the equilibrium interest rate. In cause the government decides to decrease the money supply in order to cool down the economy, the supply of loanable funds will decrease at every interest rate causing supply curve to shift to the left. This will result in an increase in the equilibrium interest rate. If the economic condition in a country improves relative to other countries, flow of funds to that country will increase. If there is an increase in the funds flow from foreign participants, the supply of loanable funds will increase at every interest rate causing a shift in the supply curve to the right. This will result in a decrease in the equilibrium interest rate. On the other hand, if other countries have a higher economic growth, the local investors would shift their funds to better performing economies,
SU1-C1-12
SIM UNIVERSITY
causing supply of loanable funds to reduce. This will result in the supply curve shifting to the left and equilibrium interest rate increasing.
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-13
The money supply can be changed through any of the following methods: i.) ii.) iii.) Open-market operations Discount rate Reserve deposits by financial institutions
Discount Rate
Discount rate is the interest on loans made by the Central bank to depository institutions such as the commercial banks. If the discount rate increases, it would cost more for commercial banks to get funds from Central Bank whereas a decrease in discount rate would reduce the cost of commercial bank to obtain funds. The discount rate is the basic interest rate in the economy decided by the Central Bank and changes in discount rate would be used for adjusting the money supply. The Central bank would decrease the discount rate if the purpose is to stimulate the economy through increase in money supply. If the purpose is to cool down the economy and reduce inflation, the Central Bank would increase the discount rate which would, in turn, decrease the money supply.
will reduce the money supply. In case the Central Bank wants to increase the money supply, it can decrease the reserve ratio. When reserve ratio is reduced, the amount of cash that can be lent by the bank increases which would increase the money supply. Central Bank can choose either or a combination of these three strategies to influence the interest rate.
Discount Rate
Discount rate is the interest rate that the Central Bank charges for loans provided to commercial banks. This is the basic minimum rate at which banks can obtain funds. All other interest rates in the economy are based on the discount rate.
Interbank Rate
Interbank rate is the interest rate at which one bank can borrow or lend money to another bank. This is known as Fed Funds Rate in USA. According to the reserve ratio requirement imposed by the Central Bank, each commercial bank is required to maintain a certain portion of deposits as cash. Since the cash balance at the end of each day is dependent upon the transactions of deposits and lending on that day, the cash balance at the end of the day could be highly variable. On some days, cash balance could be more than the amount required as reserve requirement and on some days, could be less than the amount required. When a bank has shortfall of cash relative to the amount required for meeting the reserve requirement, it can borrow money from some other bank which has a cash balance in excess of the need to meet reserve requirement. This rate at which one bank will lend to another bank is known as Interbank offer rate and the rate at which the bank will borrow from another is known as the Interbank bid rate. Many banks offer other loans based on the interbank rate. With globalization of financial markets, it may be necessary for banks to borrow or lend different currencies as part of the operations. This is also done in the interbank market. For example, HSBC in London may provide a US dollar loan to a British company and may not have sufficient US dollar funds to make the loan. HSBC may decide to borrow USD from Citibank to fulfill the loan obligations. There are a number of interbank rates used when interbank borrowings are based on a different currency than the local currency. Among these interbank rates, the most important rate is
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-15
known as the London Interbank rates, which can be either London Interbank Offer Rate (LIBOR), or London Interbank Bid Rate (LIBID). LIBOR is the rate at which one bank will lend to another, whereas LIBID is the rate at which one bank is willing to borrow from others. LIBOR rate will state the currency as well as the maturity of the loan contract. For example, 3-month USD LIBOR means the rate at which one bank will lend USD for three-month period. If it is 6-month JPY LIBOR, it means the rate at which one bank will lend JPY for 6-month period. British Bankers Association on a daily basis fixes LIBOR whereas LIBID is negotiated between banks. In Singapore, the term SIBOR is used whereas TIBOR is used in Tokyo and MIBOR in Mumbai. For any currency, say, USD, LIBOR will be closely related to the interbank USD rate in the USA and SIBOR, TIBOR and MIBOR will also be close to one another.
Prime Rate
T-bill rate is offered to investors who invest in T-bills. However, only governments can borrow at T-bill rate. For non-governmental entities, the major source of funds is through bank loans. While providing loans, banks would consider the credit risk of the borrower. Different businesses will have different credit risks and credit rating agencies will analyze the credit risk of the borrower and provide a rating. The bank will provide the lowest rate, known as the prime rate to borrowers who have the highest credit rating. Thus, prime rate is the rate on loans provided by banks to businesses that have the highest credit rating.
Loan Rate
The rate, which individuals and other businesses can borrow, will be based either on interbank rate or prime rate, depending on the risk involved in providing the loan. Banks will assess the risk and a premium for the risk will be added to either interbank or prime rate to determine the loan rate. The loan rate will specify the basic rate and
SU1-C1-16
SIM UNIVERSITY
the risk premium; and the loan rate will be stated as LIBOR + premium or Prime rate + premium.
SIM UNIVERSITY
SU1-C1-17
The loan rate for the first 6 months would be 6%. The annual interest at 6% on the loan of $100,000 will be $6000. However, interest is to be paid only for six months. Thus interest at the end of 6 months will be 100,000 * 6% / 2 = $3000. So interest of $3000 will be paid at the end of 6 months. Interest rate and interest payments over 3-year period can be calculated as: Payment at 6 months 12 months 18 months 24 months 30 months 36 months Loan Rate 6% 6.3% 6.8% 6.5% 6.7% 6.6% Semi-annual Interest $3,000 $3,150 $3,400 $3,250 $3,350 $3,300
If the loan is a floating rate loan, the amount of interest to be paid every period would depend on the reference rate at the time of reset, which is unknown at the time loan contract, is entered into. Thus, the borrower can face either increased or decreased interest payments at a future time. On the other hand, a fixed rate loan fixes the interest rate throughout the life of the loan and hence there is no uncertainty of interest payments at a future time.
SU1-C1-18
SIM UNIVERSITY