Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Lawrence Baca on the Box Checker Phenomena

Lawrence Baca on the Box Checker Phenomena

Ratings: (0)|Views: 4|Likes:
Published by rob2953

More info:

Published by: rob2953 on May 27, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





IILP Review 2011
American Indians and the“Box Checker” Phenomenon
By Lawrence R. Baca
Former President, Naonal Nave American Bar Associaon
Who is Native American? When those who knowingly are not claim to be Native Americanto enhance their applications to college and law school, what, i anything can or should bedone? Whose responsibility is it to address the alsifcation and what should the ramifcationsbe? Does it matter? Baca’s analysis suggests that the problem may be ar more widespread than might be imagined.
Brown v. Board of Education
-th   I w, Fx S. Ch, wt:“It   pty tht  y A ty thk  th I   t   gu 
  u A ty tht th Jw py  Gy. Lk th ’ y, thI k th ht  h  t p g  u pt tph;  u tt-t  I, v  th u ttt  th t, t th     ut th.”
 th ty gup  A,   tt ty. Ntv pp  A 
w I  t. A h t  t gp wth wht t  t A I t qutht   th u t  wht t   I ty. A  btw A-A  I  tht    gup  pp tk  th h  th utu, thth   gup wh h th h  th utu tk  th. At  t wh A-A w kpt   pth  ggt, A I w bg  by p t  htu : bg p t bg wht   h-bw k yt h t by by th   phbt tht t A-A.A I   th 2.0%  th t pput. W hv th t vtg u y  gup  A  w  th t t b vk  th  vty -u. Wh w hv y vty u   wth th   th t,th   vty u  hgh ut tht  u  u . F tv tpup w  th  -t   ky t  thy . N-t y but th  t gt tt t g  w h  th  thy  t ky t ht  but bg  A I.A  tt  w, A I  t. A I  th y   pp
-gph 3). Tt 25  th Ut Stt C  “I.” N th  gup  A h thw tt t th Ut Stt C. A I  bth   gup    th ptt th v ght w   pt gup t p th p thp btw th gvt  y gz tb. I tb hv . Th   th -b
IILP Review 2011
  th ty gup  A. I tb hv gvt wth pw v th  th b. Th gvt  I tb  gz  th  ttut but w t t by th Cttut. Th gvt  vg wth pw v thpp  th vt. Th pw  I tb   ht vgty, t pwt  gt by th Ut Stt. Tb hv gvt-t-gvt thpwth th t gvt. Tb hv tt wth th  gvt. I tt wthth Ut Stt  th qu  tt wth g t. Th t pt I y th   th ty gup  A  g th thp t th  gv-t. Th thp btw A I  th Ut Stt h wy b
sui generis
. A  ut, w  uv   ut  t th y th  gup  ytth  ty  ttg  jug wh  A I. Wh  vvg I w gt t th Sup Cut t  t hgh th y th uqu   w th hv b  A I jut  tht ut. I t,  Sup Cut Jut h v h g A I k.
The governments o Indian tribes are recognizedin the ederal constitution but were not createdby the Constitution. Those governments aresovereigns with power over their people and theirreservations. The powers o Indian tribes arerom inherent sovereignty, not powers createdor delegated by the United States. Tribes havea government-to-government relationship withthe national government. Tribes have treatieswith the ederal government. Indian treaties withthe United States are the equal o treaties withoreign nations. These actors separate Indiansrom any other racial or ethnic minority groupin America in defning their relationship to theederal government.
IILP Review 2011
Th  tw pt t th ph  -I g t b I,   pt  vty pt. Th w-kw  pt A I, V D J.,  h bkCut D F Yu S
-g hu  pp wh h bv t b Wht but wh w xu t t h  th
xp  tht th gt bk th w  I  g th Chk. EvyI I kw   wth th ph: yu  t   ut, yu ght b wgI jwy,   pph; thy pp Ag  thy k, “Yu’ I, ght? I’pt Chk. My gt-gth w Chk p.” Th  t thg tht hp-p t y th   th ty gup. I’v k y  y p ty. N A-A p h v h  wh k Wht  up t th t  ut  y, “Yu’ Bk, ght? I’ pt Bk. My gth w  Wz p-
Th  thg  tu  g  w h ppt. At g  uvt th  A I tut gup tht ’t hv  ug bt wth th  but hw y Ntv tut  tuy  pu. W wy gt ub  th -  tht  t pt wth th t  wh w   pu. Wth pt t g gut h  w  th Wb, Cx I  “Bx Chk.” Lt  b vy . I’ t tkg but  wh  x   wh I t  ptty v. I’ t tkg but  wh guy bv tht h  h h  Ity  tt hw  bk. Wh I y “Bx Chk,” I’ tkg but tut wh hvbuty  b tht thy hv I htg but hk th Ntv A bx  th pp-t bu thy bv tht    gttg  bk tht thy ’t v.
I tut  th t. Th w t th t wh th w    tut tvt gup.
- thty-b tut gzt. A, b th pky tut ght t pvyw w p, h wu gv th ty tut gzt t but whhk th  bx  yu gup  yu u tt th. Th thy w tht th gty tut wu wt t t th th b  th   thty t th h. Sy wu   I k th   t UCSD   t    th th Itut  thy gv t t u. Th w twty-x   th t. Wh w vt h th t y w w ttg  I tut gzt, twty- t u thy y w’t
When I say “Box Checker,” I’m talking about studentswho have absolutely no belie that they have Indianheritage but check the Native American box on theapplication because they believe that someone else isgetting a break that they don’t deserve.

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->