Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
2Activity
P. 1
Justice Wide Open: David Goldberg - Justice in a Cold Climate

Justice Wide Open: David Goldberg - Justice in a Cold Climate

Ratings: (0)|Views: 116 |Likes:
Published by j_townend
David Goldberg

29

JUSTICE IN A COLD CLIMATE
Dr David Goldberg looks to Sweden and Scotland for historical and comparative examples of open justice
The title of this paper is a play on the title of an article written by the eminent jurist H. L. A. Hart, ‘Law in a Cold Climate’. Hart’s article was about the school of jurisprudence known as Scandinavian Legal Realism. This paper has no pretensions to jurisprudential import. Its ambition is limited to offering a couple of illustrations concerning
David Goldberg

29

JUSTICE IN A COLD CLIMATE
Dr David Goldberg looks to Sweden and Scotland for historical and comparative examples of open justice
The title of this paper is a play on the title of an article written by the eminent jurist H. L. A. Hart, ‘Law in a Cold Climate’. Hart’s article was about the school of jurisprudence known as Scandinavian Legal Realism. This paper has no pretensions to jurisprudential import. Its ambition is limited to offering a couple of illustrations concerning

More info:

Categories:Types, Research, Law
Published by: j_townend on Jun 19, 2012
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/03/2013

pdf

text

original

 
Heqih Dlchbmrd 29
K]VXIFM I@ E FLCH FCIGEXM
 Hr Heqih Dlchbmrd
cllov xl Vtmhm` e`h Vflxce`h alr jivxlrifec e`h flg~erexiqm mzeg~cmv la l~m` k}vxifm
Xjm xixcm la xjiv ~e~mr iv e ~cey l` xjm xixcm la e` erxifcm trixxm` by xjm mgi`m`x k}rivxJ. C. E. Jerx# ‚Cet i` e Flch Fcigexm’. Jerx’v erxifcm tev ebl}x xjm vfjllc la  k}riv~r}hm`fm o`lt` ev Vfe`hi`eqie` Cmdec Rmecivg. Xjiv ~e~mr jev `l ~rmxm`vil`vxl k}riv~r}hm`xiec ig~lrx. Ixv egbixil` iv cigixmh xl laamri`d e fl}~cm la icc}vxrexil`vfl`fmr`i`d ‚l~m` k}vxifm’ arlg e flg~erexiqm# jivxlrifec ~mrv~mfxiqm. Xjm ‚flchfcigexm’ iv e rmamrm`fm xl xjm aefx xjex l`m mzeg~cm iv hret` arlg Vflxce`h e`h xjmlxjmr arlg Vtmhm`.
Vflxce`h
Xjm ~ri`fi~cm la l~m` k}vxifm i` xjex fl}`xry iv `lx e rmfm`x hmqmcl~gm`x. Xtlvxex}xmv la xjm *~rm'54>4) Vflxxivj ^erciegm`x erm icc}vxrexiqm. Xjm vmfl`h iv vxiccfl`vihmrmh ev bmi`d i` alrfm.e.
 
Mqihm`fm Efx e~~li`xi`d ~}bcifexil` la xjm xmvxigl`imv la tix`mvvmv
5
 
L}r vlqmrmid` clrh# fl`vihmri`d jlt g}fj ix hlmv ig~lrx e`h fl`fmr` xjm dllh e`hi`xmrmvx la jiv gekmvxy’v cimdmv# e`h xjm h}m ehgi`ivxrexil` la k}vxifm# xjex tix`mvvmv bm hivxi`fxcy e`h a}ccy mzegi`mh# e`h xjmir hm~lvixil`v trixxm` i` ~cei` e`h fcmer tlrhv ev xjmy erm diqm`? xjmrmalrm jiv gekmvxy# tixj ehqifm e`h fl`vm`x la xjm mvxexmvla ~erciegm`x# vxex}xmv e`h lrhei`v xjex# i` ecc ~rlfmvvmv ~rmvm`xcy hm~m`hi`d lr xl bmi`xm`hmh bmalrm xjm clrhv la ~riqy fl}`fic# clrhv la vmvvil` e`h ecc lxjmr k}hdmv tixji`xjiv oi`dhlg# xjm tix`mvvmv tjl erm gehm }vm la e`h ehh}fmh xjmrmi` vjecc bmmzegi`mh i` xjm ~rmvm`fm la xjm ~erximv lr xjmir ehqlfexmv# xjmy bmi`d ~rmvm`x ex xjmhimxv la mzegi`exil`# e`h xjex xjmrm bm ~}bcifexil` la xjm xmvxigl`imv la xjm tix`mvvmvi` xjm fcmrov’ je`hv eccltmh xl xjm ~erximv drexiv bmalrm ehqivi`d# xl xjm maamfx ~erximvgey jeqm fl~imv xjmrmla ia xjmy xji`o aix# e`y cet lr efx la ~erciegm`x# f}vxlg lr}vedm xl xjm fl`xrery `lxtixjvxe`hi`d.
 b.
 
Fl}rx la Vmvvil` Efx e`m`x ehqivi`d tixj l~m` hllrv bmalrm xjm vmvvil`
2
 
L}r vlqmrmid` clrh e`h cehy xjm oi`d e`h u}mm`’v gekmvximv# fl`vihmri`d xjex xjmehqivi`d la fe}vmv tixj l~m` hllrv iv }v}ec i` xjm vlqmrmid` k}hifexlrimv la lxjmr`exil`v# e`h xjex xjm ciom ~refxifm jmrm ticc bm la ehqe`xedm xl xjm cimdmv# hl# tixjehqifm e`h fl`vm`x la xjm mvxexmv la ~erciegm`x# vxex}xm e`h lrhei` xjex i` ecc xigmflgi`d# ecc biccv# rm~lrxv# hmbexmv# ~rlbexil`v e`h lxjmrv rmcexi`d xl ~rlfmvvmv vjecc bmfl`vihmrmh# rmevl`mh# ehqivmh e`h qlxmh by xjm clrhv la vmvvil` tixj l~m` hllrv#
5
Mqihm`fm Efx#
 E^V 
qiii =99# f.6> 3jxx~;,,ttt.r~v.ef.}o,xre`v,51:1,8,810 effmvvmh 6 Gerfj 2>52
2
Fl}rx la Vmvvil` Efx#
 E^V 
iz 6>=# f.82 3jxx~;,,ttt.r~v.ef.}o,xre`v,5196,8,960 effmvvmh 6 Gerfj2>52
 
6> K}vxifm Tihm L~m`
 tjmrm ~erximv# ~rlf}rexlrv e`h ecc lxjmrv erm jmrmby eccltmh xl bm ~rmvm`x# ev xjmy }vmh xl bm alrgmrcy i` xigm la hmbexmv# b}x tixj xjiv rmvxrifxil`# xjex i` vlgm v~mfiecfevmv xjm veih clrhv vjecc bm eccltmh xl fe}vm rmglqm ecc ~mrvl`v# mzfm~x xjm ~erximve`h xjmir ~rlf}rexlrv# e`h xjex `l ~mrvl` ~rmv}gm xl v~meo eaxmr xjm clrhv bmdi` xlehqivm }`hmr xjm ~ei` la ig~rivl`gm`x# }`cmvv jm bm hmvirmh by xjm clrhv. E`h jmrmby fevv e`h e``}c ecc alrgmr cetv e`h efxv la ~erciegm`x e~~li`xi`d lr ecclti`d xjmclrhv xl ehqivm tixj fclvmh hllrv.
6
 
 Ecvl tlrxjy la `lxm iv xjm hifx}g la Clrh ^rmvihm`x I`dciv i`
 Rifjerhvl` q Ticvl`
 *5:49)# rmderhi`d xjm ridjx la `mtv~e~mrv xl bm i` fl}rx xl rm~lrx ~rlfmmhi`dv. Jmvxexmh xjex
Xjm ~}bcifexil` by `mtv~e~mrv la tjex xeomv ~cefm i` fl}rx ex xjm jmeri`d la e`y fe}vm iv }`hl}bxmhcy ceta}c; e`h ia ix bm rm~lrxmh i` e aeir e`h aeixja}c ge``mr xjm~}bcivjmr iv `lx rmv~l`vibcm xjl}dj xjm rm~lrx fl`xei` vxexmgm`xv lr hmxeicv la mqihm`fm eaamfxi`d xjm fjerefxmr la mixjmr la xjm ~erximv lr la lxjmr ~mrvl`v? e`h tjexmqmr xeomv ~cefm i` l~m` fl}rx aeccv }`hmr xjm vegm r}cm# xjl}dj ix gey bm mixjmr bmalrm lr eaxmr xjm ~rl~mr jmeri`d la xjm fe}vm.
Xjm ~ri`fi~cm l` tjifj xjiv r}cm iv al}`hmh vmmgv xl bm xjex# ev fl}rxv la K}vxifm erm l~m` xl xjm ~}bcif# e`yxji`d xjex xeomv ~cefm bmalrm e k}hdm lr k}hdmv iv xjmrmby `mfmvvericy e`h cmdixigexmcy gehm ~}bcif# e`h# bmi`d l`fm gehm cmdixigexmcy ~}bcif ~rl~mrxy# gey bm rm~}bcivjmh tixjl}x i`amrri`d e`y rmv~l`vibicixy.
_Mg~jeviv ehhmhW
Vtmhm`
^rlbebcy# glvx tl}ch `lx bm v}r~rivmh xl cmer` xjex Vtmhm` jev e xrehixil` la ‚l~m` k}vxifm’. Jltmqmr# jivxlrifeccy# xjm gei` xefo ehl~xmh tixj rmv~mfx xl ‚l~m` k}vxifm’ i`xjex k}rivhifxil` jev bmm` rexjmr hivxi`fxiqm. Xjm omy hmqmcl~gm`x xllo ~cefm h}ri`dxjm vl'feccmh Edm la Cibmrxy# 542> ‖ 5442.
8
  Tjicvx cerdmcy fl``mfxmh tixj ~lcixifec cibmrxy ‖ ~ri`fi~eccy xjm rivm la xjm al}rMvxexmv *kli`xcy# xjm ^erciegm`x,Riovhed) qiv'î'qiv xjm Gl`erfjy ‖ xjm ~mrilh hihecvl vmm i`frmevi`d hmge`hv alr fiqic cibmrxy. E rm~rmvm`xexiqm vm`xigm`x arlg e cixxcm'o`lt` vl}rfm iv xjex mz~rmvvmh by xjm tlrch'rm`lt`mh blxe`ivx e`h e~lvxcm la ql` Ci``m# ^mxmr Alrvvoec. Ecglvx }`o`lt`iv xjm aefx xjex jm ecvl e}xjlrmh e fl`xrlqmrviec ~eg~jcmx#
Xjl}djxv l` Fiqic Cibmrxy
 *54=9).
=
Flggixxmh xl l~m``mvv i` xjm brlehmr fl`xmzx la vlfiec e`h vfim`xiaif~rldrmvv# Alrvvoec trlxm;
Vl# xjm ciam e`h vxrm`dxj la fiqic cibmrxy fl`vivx i` cigixmh Dlqmr`gm`x e`h }`cigixmharmmhlg la xjm trixxm` tlrh.......ix iv ecvl e` ig~lrxe`x ridjx i` e armm vlfimxy xl bm armmcy eccltmh xl fl`xrib}xm xlvlfimxy’v tmcc'bmi`d. Jltmqmr# ia xjex iv xl lff}r# ix g}vx bm ~lvvibcm alr vlfimxy’v vxexm
6
‚Fevv’ gme`v ‚Xl geom qlih# rm`hmr i`maamfxiqm# e``}c lr hivebcm’3jxx~;,,ttt.r~v.ef.}o,vxexif,dclvvery.jxgc&F0 effmvvmh 6 Gerfj 2>52
8
Gifjemc Rlbmrxv
Xjm Edm la Cibmrxy; Vtmhm` 5459'5442
*Fegbrihdm ]`iqmrvixy ^rmvv 2>>6)
=
3jxx~;,,~mxmralrvvoec.flg,`lhm,2=,&gei`'xmzx0 effmvvmh 9 Gerfj 2>52? xjm ~ri`xmh fl~y la xjmxmzx tixj flggm`xery iv eqeicebcm ex 3jxx~;,,ttt.~mxmralrvvoec.flg,b}y 0 effmvvmh 9 Gerfj 2>52
 
Heqih Dlchbmrd 65
la eaaeirv xl bmflgm o`lt` xl mqmryl`m# e`h ix g}vx bm ~lvvibcm alr mqmryl`m xl v~meo jiv gi`h armmcy ebl}x ix. Tjmrm xjiv iv cefoi`d# cibmrxy iv `lx tlrxj ixv `egm.
1
 
Xjm ~eg~jcmx tev be``mh l` xjm hey ix tev ~}bcivjmh. Xjiv jmc~mh a}mc xjmdexjmri`d airmvxlrg xjex cmh# }cxigexmcy# xl xjm ~evvedm la xjm ‚tlrch’v airvx armmhlg la i`alrgexil` efx’ i` Hmfmgbmr 5411. I` xjex vm`vm# Alrvvoec’v tlro tev e` ig~lrxe`xi`xmccmfx}ec fexecyvx alr xjm gmev}rm. Alrvvoec jigvmca tev hmeh *edmh 62) by xjmxigm la ixv ehl~xil`# jeqi`d fl`xrefxmh e aexec icc`mvv i` Kmrig# Ymgm`# tjicvx ~erx la e` mz~mhixil` xl ‚Amciz Erebie’ flggivvil`mh by xjm Oi`d la Hm`gero.Fl`qm`xil`eccy }`hmrvxllh# armmhlg la i`alrgexil` cetv erm gme`v la cmdeccy flg~mcci`d ~}bcif e}xjlriximv *m.d.# fm`xrec e`h clfec dlqmr`gm`x) xl hivfclvmi`alrgexil` xjmy jlch. Vid`iaife`xcy xjl}dj# xjm 5411 cet fl`xei`v vmqmrec vmfxil`v~mrxi`m`x xl xjm ivv}m la geoi`d xjm ehgi`ivxrexil` la k}vxifm glrm xre`v~erm`x e`hdiqi`d xjm ridjx xl ~}bcivj cmdec e`h k}hifiec i`alrgexil`.L` e ~li`x la `lgm`fcex}rm# xjm Vtmhivj cet iv }v}eccy rmamrrmh xl ev xjm‚Armmhlg la xjm ^rmvv Efx’ *5411). Xjiv iv vlgmtjex givcmehi`d. Xjm a}cc xixcm la xjmgmev}rm iv ‚Jiv Gekmvxy’v Drefil}v Lrhi`e`fm Rmcexi`d xl Armmhlg la Trixi`d e`h la xjm ^rmvv’.
4
B}x# xjmrm tev `l hmqmcl~mh ‚~rmvv’ i` xjm vm`vm la e gmhie i`h}vxry i`gih'midjxmm`xj fm`x}ry Vtmhm`. Xjm fl``lxexil` la ‚~rmvv’ *arlg xjm Vtmhivj‚xryfoarijmxvañrlrh`i`dm`i`’ i` xjm cet’v xixcm) iv e rmamrm`fm xl xjm ~ri`xi`d ~rmvv.‚Xryfo’ gme`v vlgmxji`d xjex iv ~ri`xmh.Xjm 5411 Lrhi`e`fm ehhrmvvmv xtl gei` xl~ifv. Airvx# ix hmecv tixj xjmeblcixil` la ~rilr fm`vlrvji~ e`h xjm armmhlg xl ~}bcivj. Xjm cexxmr iv aer arlgebvlc}xm# e `}gbmr la gexxmrv bmi`d gehm cmdeccy igg}`m arlg frixifivg lru}mvxil`i`d. Vmfl`h# xjmrm iv xjm e~~mere`fm la xjm cmdeccy rmqlc}xil`ery ~ri`fi~cm la ~}bcif effmvv xl laaifiec i`alrgexil`. Xjiv iv hmvfribmh by xjm Vtmhivj xmrg‚laam`xcidjmxv~ri`fi~m`’# tjifj jev e` mqm` brlehmr fl``lxexil`.
:
 Xjmrm erm vmqmrec vmfxil`v tjifj v~mfiaifeccy gm`xil` fl}rx e`h cmdeci`alrgexil` i` ehhixil` xl tjex tl}ch bm i`fc}hmh glrm fl`qm`xil`eccy ev laaifiechlf}gm`xv. Erxifcm 1 vxexmv;
Xjiv armmhlg la xjm ~rmvv ticc a}rxjmr i`fc}hm ecc mzfje`dmv la flrrmv~l`hm`fm#
v~mfimv aefxi 
# hlf}gm`xv# ~rlxlflcv# k}hdgm`xv e`h eterhv# tjmxjmr xjmy tmrm~rlh}fmh i` xjm ~evx lr ticc bm i`ixiexmh# gei`xei`mh# ~rmvm`xmh# fl`h}fxmh e`hivv}mh jmrmeaxmr# bmalrm# h}ri`d e`h eaxmr ~rlfmmhi`dv bmalrm cltmr fl}rxv# e~~mec e`hv}~mrilr fl}rxv e`h dlqmr`gm`x hm~erxgm`xv# l}r vm`ilr ehgi`ivxrexlrv e`hfl`vivxlrimv lr lxjmr ~}bcif blhimv# e`h tixjl}x hivxi`fxil` bmxtmm` xjm `ex}rm la xjm
1
L~.fix.# ~erev 4 e`h 25
4
M`dcivj xre`vcexil` la xjm 5411 Lrhi`e`fm by ^mxmr Jldd# alrgmr Jmeh# Vfe`hi`eqie` Vmfxil`# BrixivjCibrery# 3jxx~;,,ttt.fjyhm`i}v.`mx,~ha,tlrchv\airvx\alie.~ha 0 effmvvmh 4 Gerfj 2>52
:
3jxx~;,,ttt.vtmhm`.dlq.vm,vb,h,25:8,`lfefjm,xr}m,e,5==25,hifxil`ery,xr}m0 effmvvmh 9 Gerfj2>52

Activity (2)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->