Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
P. 1
Twitter v. Skootle, C 12-1721 SI (N.D. Cal.; June 22, 2012)

Twitter v. Skootle, C 12-1721 SI (N.D. Cal.; June 22, 2012)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 170 |Likes:
Order denying Defendant Harris's motion to dismiss.
Order denying Defendant Harris's motion to dismiss.

More info:

Published by: Venkat Balasubramani on Jun 27, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/07/2014

pdf

text

original

 
   ]  f   h   r  m   b   [   r  l   r  m  {   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r   K  i  }  z   r
   G  i  z   r   `  m   F  i  z   r   `  m  z  f   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r  i   g   K  l   e   h   g  i  z  f   h  l
<:;2=7408<3<<<:<;<2<=<7<4<0<8:3:<:::;:2:=:7:4:0
<
Bmgmfblfr A}{rhf Kelzn `l{ jmmf bh{oh{{mb gzio r`m kl{m& R`m rizrhi}{ hfrmzgmzmfkm thr`kifrzlkr kelho h{ fir l{{mzrmb ldlhf{r bmgmfblfr Dlzelfb M& @lzzh{&
 
   ]  f   h   r  m   b   [   r  l   r  m  {   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r   K  i  }  z   r
   G  i  z   r   `  m   F  i  z   r   `  m  z  f   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r  i   g   K  l   e   h   g  i  z  f   h  l
HF R@M ]FHRMB [RLRM[ BH[RZHKR KI]ZRGIZ R@M FIZR@MZF BH[RZHKR IG KLEHGIZFHLRTHRRMZ% HFK&%Selhfrhgg%w&[NIIREM KIZS&% AE2 TMJ [IE]RHIF[%ALOM[ NM[RMZ% ALX[IF XLF]LZHL%ALOM[ E]KMZI% lfb DLZELFB M& @LZZH[%Bmgmfblfr{&) Fi& K <:/<4:< [H
IZBMZ BMFXHFD OIRHIF RIBH[OH[[
R`h{ olrrmz kifkmzf{ lf lkrhif giz jzmlk` ig kifrzlkr% rizrhi}{ hfrmzgmzmfkm thr` kifrzlkr% gzl}b%lfb }fglhz iz bmkmsrhwm j}{hfm{{ szlkrhkm{% hfhrhlrmb jx selhfrhgg Rthrrmz% Hfk& (―Rthrrmz‟ hf kiffmkrhifthr` whielrhif{ ig hr{ Rmzo{ ig [mzwhkm lfb wlzhi}{ ―{slo‟ lkrhwhrhm{ leemdmb ldlhf{r bmgmfblfr{ [niiremKizs&% AE2 Tmj [ie}rhif{% Alom{ Nm{rmz% Alx{if Xlf}lzhl% Alom{ E}kmzi% lfb Dlzelfb M& @lzzh{(kieemkrhwmex% ―Bmgmfblfr{‟&
<
R`m Oirhif ri Bh{oh{{ h{ jzi}d`r jx Dlzelfb M& @lzzh{% lkrhfd
 szi {m
%l{{mzrhfd elkn ig {}jamkr olrrmz a}zh{bhkrhif s}z{}lfr ri Gmb& Z& Khw& S& <:(j(<% elkn ig smz{ifle a}zh{bhkrhif s}z{}lfr ri Gmb& Z& Khw& S& <:(j(:% hoszismz wmf}m s}z{}lfr ri Gmb& Z& Khw& S& <:(j(;%hf{}gghkhmfkx ig szikm{{ lfb {mzwhkm ig szikm{{ s}z{}lfr ri Gmb& Z& Khw& S& <:(j(2 lfb <:(j(=% lfb
Kl{m;1<:/kw/3<4:</[H Bik}omfr22 Ghemb37)::)<: Sldm< ig <<
 
   ]  f   h   r  m   b   [   r  l   r  m  {   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r   K  i  }  z   r
   G  i  z   r   `  m   F  i  z   r   `  m  z  f   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r  i   g   K  l   e   h   g  i  z  f   h  l
<:;2=7408<3<<<:<;<2<=<7<4<0<8:3:<:::;:2:=:7:4:0
:
Rthrrmz kifrmfb{ r`lr r`m oirhif ri bh{oh{{ tl{ }frhomex jmkl}{m @lzzh{ {}johrrmb lzm{sif{hwm semlbhfd {mwmf blx{ lgrmz r`m :</blx smzhib sziwhbmb jx Z}em <:(l% lfb zmfmt{ hr{ oirhifgiz mfrzx ig bmgl}er ldlhf{r @lzzh{& @itmwmz% bmgl}er a}bdomfr{ ―lzm dmfmzleex bh{glwizmb> t`mfmwmz hrh{ zml{ifljex si{{hjem% kl{m{ {`i}eb jm bmkhbmb if r`mhz omzhr{&‟
[k`tlj w& J}eeikn${ Hfk
&% =30 G&:b ;=;%;== (8r` Khz& <842& L ki}zr olx le{i bmfx lf mfrzx ig bmgl}er t`mf l oirhif ri bh{oh{{ `l{ jmmf ghemb{`izrex lgrmz r`m bmlbehfm j}r r`m selhfrhgg `l{ fir jmmf szma}bhkmb lfb ―mpkmsrhifle khzk}o{rlfkm{ r`lrti}eb a}{rhgx mfrzx ig l bmgl}er a}bdomfr lzm fir szm{mfr&‟
 Ohrk`mee w& Jzitf ' Theehlo{if RijlkkiKizs&
% :82 G&;b <;38% <;<4 (<<r` Khz& :33:& L{ {}k`% r`m Ki}zr thee lbbzm{{ r`m oirhif ri bh{oh{{ ifhr{ omzhr{ bm{shrm r`m bmelx hf hr{ ghehfd&
 
:glhe}zm ri {rlrm l kelho }sif t`hk` zmehmg klf jm dzlfrmb s}z{}lfr ri Gmb& Z& Khw& S& <:(j(7&
:
Rthrrmz issi{mb r`m oirhif if Olx :=% :3<:& @lzzh{ `l{ fir ghemb l zmsex& R`m oirhif ri bh{oh{{ h{ k}zzmfrex{k`mb}emb giz `mlzhfd if A}fm :8% :3<:& S}z{}lfr ri Khwhe Eikle Z}em 4/<(j% r`m Ki}zr ghfb{ r`h{ oirhiflssziszhlrm giz zm{ie}rhif thr`i}r izle lzd}omfr lfb `mzmjx WLKLRM[ r`m `mlzhfd& @lwhfd kif{hbmzmbr`m slsmz{ {}johrrmb% lfb giz diib kl}{m {`itf% r`m Ki}zr `mzmjx BMFHM[ r`m oirhif ri bh{oh{{&
JLKNDZI]FB
Selhfrhgg Rthrrmz h{ l kizsizlrhif hfkizsizlrmb hf Bmeltlzm thr` hr{ szhfkhsle selkm ig j}{hfm{{hf [lf Gzlfkh{ki% Klehgizfhl& Kios& · 2 (Bnr& <& Rthrrmz ismzlrm{ lf ifehfm kioo}fhklrhif selrgizothr` iwmz <23 oheehif }{mz{ tizebthbm&
 Hb&
· <& Rthrrmz‘{ msifxoi}{ {mzwhkm (―Rthrrmz {mzwhkm‟ leeit{}{mz{ ri {mfb lfb zmkmhwm hfgizolrhif hf{rlfrlfmi}{ex r`zi}d` {`izr om{{ldm{ kleemb ―Rtmmr{%‟ t`hk`lzm ehohrmb ri <23 k`lzlkrmz{&
 Hb&
· <2& R`m{m om{{ldm{ olx jm {mfr whl l kmee s`ifm iz whl Rthrrmz‘{tmj{hrm& Mlk` }{mz‘{ lkki}fr h{ hbmfrhghmb jx l }fh|}m }{mzflom% ridmr`mz thr` r`m C {xojie% gziot`hk` r`m }{mz h{ ljem ri jzilbkl{r om{{ldm{ ri `h{ iz `mz s}jehk sldm iz ri ir`mz }{mz{ bhzmkrex& ]{mz{olx k`ii{m ri ―gieeit‟ l slzrhk}elz lkki}fr jx {}j{kzhjhfd ri zmkmhwm lee r`m om{{ldm{ gzio r`lrlkki}fr& Giz mplosem% Ct`hrm`i}{m klf jzilbkl{r om{{ldm{ if hr{ s}jehk Rthrrmz sldm ({mlzk`ljem jx}{mzflom gzio r`m olhf Rthrrmz {hrm iz bhzmkrex ri lfx lkki}fr r`lr `l{ k`i{mf ri gieeit hr&
 Hb&
· <=&Rthrrmz }{mz{ klf le{i kl}{m Rtmmr{ ri jm l}riolrhkleex bmehwmzmb ri {smkhghk }{mz{ jx omfrhifhfd r`lr}{mzflom thr` r`m ―C‟ {xojie hf r`m om{{ldm&
 Hb&
· <7& Hf lbbhrhif% Rthrrmz }{mz{ olx {mfb szhwlrm%bhzmkr om{{ldm{ ri mlk` ir`mz& Rthrrmz {mzwhkm h{ thbmex }{mb giz oifhrizhfd k}zzmfr rzmfb{ lfbbmwmeishfd fmt{ {rizhm{% t`hk` h{ glkhehrlrmb jx r`m }{m ig nmxtizb{ thr` r`m ―+‟ {xojie (―`l{`rld‟ hfRthrrmz slzelfkm& Rthrrmz‘{ ledizhr`o{ oifhriz k}zzmfrex sis}elz nmxtizb{ jx flrhif lfb khrx% t`hk`
Kl{m;1<:/kw/3<4:</[H Bik}omfr22 Ghemb37)::)<: Sldm: ig <<
 
   ]  f   h   r  m   b   [   r  l   r  m  {   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r   K  i  }  z   r
   G  i  z   r   `  m   F  i  z   r   `  m  z  f   B   h  {   r  z   h  k   r  i   g   K  l   e   h   g  i  z  f   h  l
<:;2=7408<3<<<:<;<2<=<7<4<0<8:3:<:::;:2:=:7:4:0
;
[iom ig r`m bmgmfblfr{ leemdmbex bh{rzhj}rm {}k` {igrtlzm lfb lzm zmgmzzmb ri l{ ―[slotlzmBmgmfblfr{‟ hf Rthrrmz‘{ kioselhfr& @lzzh{ h{ loifd r`m leemdmb ―[sloomz Bmgmfblfr{‟ r`lr Rthrrmz  jmehmwm{ ismzlrm l elzdm f}ojmz ig l}riolrmb Rthrrmz lkki}fr{% j}r bi fir bh{rzhj}rm r`m {igrtlzm&;lzm zmgmzzmb ri l{ ―rzmfbhfd rishk{&‟
 Hb&
· <4& J}{hfm{{m{ lfb izdlfhqlrhif{ le{i }{m r`m Rthrrmz {mzwhkmri kioo}fhklrm thr` k}{riomz{ lfb hfrmzm{rmb hfbhwhb}le{&R`m Rthrrmz {mzwhkm h{ gzmm ig k`lzdm lfb Rthrrmz }{mz{ ldzmm ri l ehohrmb% fif/l{{hdfljem ehkmf{mri }{m r`m Rthrrmz {mzwhkm{% {}jamkr ri r`m Rmzo{ ig [mzwhkm (―RI[‟ (hfke}bmb thr` r`m kioselhfr l{Mp`hjhr L& R`h{ ldzmmomfr hfke}bm{ Rthrrmz Z}em{ r`lr szi`hjhr gzl}b}emfr lfb bmkmsrhwm szlkrhkm{ lfbRthrrmz‘{ Szhwlkx Siehkx&
 Hb&
· :7 & Rthrrmz {mzwhkm g}fkrhif{ olx jm {}jamkr ri szi`hjhrmb jm`lwhiz{r`lr Rthrrmz zmgmz{ ri kieemkrhwmex l{ ―{slo&‟ [}k` jm`lwhiz{ hfke}bm {mfbhfd ehfn{ ri `lzog}e tmj{hrm{%gle{m iz oh{emlbhfd lbwmzrh{momfr{% si{rhfd }ftlfrmb om{{ldm{ ri }{mz{ r`zi}d` r`m lj}{m ig r`m ―C‟g}fkrhif% lfb lj}{hfd r`m ―+‟ g}fkrhif ri rlnm lbwlfrldm ig sis}elz nmxtizb{&
 Hb&
· <8/:3& R`m{mlkrhif{ olx jm l}riolrmb r`zi}d` }{m ig ―{slojir{‟ iz ―jir{&‟
 Hb&
· :<& Rthrrmz moseix{ wlzhi}{{rzlrmdhm{ ri kifrzie {}k` lkrhwhrhm{% j}r r`m }{m ig l}riolrmb {igrtlzm klf khzk}owmfr siehkhfd mggizr{ jx kzmlrhfd biqmf{ iz `}fbzmb{ ig fmt lkki}fr{ mlk` blx&
;
Rthrrmz leemdm{ {}k` whielrhif{ ig r`m RI[kioszioh{m r`m |}lehrx ig }{mz mpsmzhmfkm% lfb r`lr hr `l{ bmseixmb l wlzhmrx ig oml{}zm{ ri bmrmkr lfbkiojlr {slo if hr{ selrgizo&
 Hb&
· <&Rthrrmz leemdm{ hr `l{ {smfr lr eml{r "4=%333 hf lfrh/{slo oml{}zm{ ri ki}frmzlkr @lzzh{‘{lkrhwhrhm{ hf whielrhif ig r`m RI[% lfb r`lr hr `l{ {}ggmzmb ei{{ ig diibthee lfb ei{{ ig }{mz{ b}m ri r`mbh{{lrh{glkrhif thr` r`m emwme ig {slo&
 Hb&
· :=& Rthrrmz leemdm{ r`lr lr r`m rhom ig r`m kioselhfr% @lzzh{ismzlrmb iwmz <:8%333 l}riolrmb Rthrrmz lkki}fr{ r`lr }{m bmkmsrhwm elfd}ldm ri bhzmkr Rthrrmz }{mz{ri `h{ tmj{hrm{ r`lr sziwhbm ―ifehfm slxomfr {mzwhkm{ ig |}m{rhifljem emdhrholkx&‟
 Hb&
·· ==/=7&[smkhghkleex% Rthrrmz leemdm{ @lzzh{ whielrmb r`m Rmzo{ ig [mzwhkm jx1 (l {sloohfd }{mz{> (j kzmlrhfd{mzhle lkki}fr{ giz bh{z}srhwm iz lj}{hwm s}zsi{m{> (k Rtmmrhfd oh{emlbhfd ehfn{> lfb (b si{rhfd r`m{lom om{{ldm gzio o}erhsem lkki}fr{& Rthrrmz leemdm{ r`lr r`m{m lkrhwhrhm{ `lwm `lzomb Rthrrmz t`hemghflfkhleex jmfmghrrhfd @lzzh{&
 Hb&
· =4& Rthrrmz jzhfd{ kelho{ giz jzmlk` ig kifrzlkr% gzl}b% lfb }feltg}e%}fglhz lfb gzl}b}emfr j}{hfm{{ szlkrhkm{ }fbmz Klehgizfhl J}{hfm{{ ' Szigm{{hif{ Kibm ¤ <4:33 ldlhf{r@lzzh{& Rthrrmz {mmn{ szmehohflzx lfb smzolfmfr hfa}fkrhwm zmehmg zm{rzlhfhfd @lzzh{ gzio1 (l kzmlrhfdRthrrmz lkki}fr{ giz s}zsi{m{ r`lr whielrm r`m RI[% hfke}bhfd ―jir‟ lkki}fr{> (j lkkm{{hfd iz {mlzk`hfd
Kl{m;1<:/kw/3<4:</[H Bik}omfr22 Ghemb37)::)<: Sldm; ig <<

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
jimmccullagh liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->