Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
0Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Scotus Opinion on ACA

Scotus Opinion on ACA

Ratings: (0)|Views: 19 |Likes:
Published by Wnymedia Net
Supreme Court Upholds Health insurance Law
Supreme Court Upholds Health insurance Law

More info:

Published by: Wnymedia Net on Jun 28, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

04/23/2014

pdf

text

original

 
 
"
#$%&' ('&)&*)+
(,-(./0 -/012 34"" $5%%6789
:(-/; <=>?> &@ &9 A>69&7%>2 6 95%%6789 #=>6B)*@>+ C&%% 7> ?>%>69>B2 69 &97>&)D B*)> &) E*))>E@&*) C&@= @=&9 E69>2 6@ @=> @&F> @=> *'&)&*) &9 &998>BG-=> 95%%6789 E*)9@&@8@>9 )* '6?@ *A @=> *'&)&*) *A @=> ,*8?@ 78@ =69 7>>)'?>'6?>B 75 @=> 0>'*?@>? *A H>E&9&*)9 A*? @=> E*)I>)&>)E> *A @=> ?>6B>?G $>>
"#$%&' (%)%&*
 IG
 +&%,-$% .$/0&, 1 23/0&, 4-56
 344 JG $G K3"2 KKLG
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
$5%%6789
:M-N(:MO P/H/0M-N(: (P N:H/Q/:H/:- .J$N:/$$
/- MO
G
7
G $/./ONJ$2 $/,0/-M0R (P S/MO-S M:H SJ1M: $/0TN,/$2
/- MO
G
,/0-N(0M0N -( -S/ J:N-/H $-M-/$ ,(J0- (P MQQ/MO$ P(0 -S/ /O/T/:-S ,N0,JN- :*G ""UKVKG M?D8>B 16?E= 3W2 3L2 3X2 34"3YH>E&B>B Z8)> 3X2 34"3[ N) 34"42 ,*)D?>99 >)6E@>B @=> Q6@&>)@ Q?*@>E@&*) 6)B MAA*?B67%> ,6?> ME@ &) *?B>? @* &)E?>69> @=> )8F7>? *A MF>?&E6)9 E*I>?>B 75 =>6%@= &)98?6)E> 6)B B>E?>69> @=> E*9@ *A =>6%@= E6?>G ()> \>5 '?*I&9&*) &9@=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@>2 C=&E= ?>]8&?>9 F*9@ MF>?&E6)9 @* F6&)@6&)^F&)&F8F >99>)@&6%_ =>6%@= &)98?6)E> E*I>?6D>G 3W JG $G ,G `a444MGP*? &)B&I&B86%9 C=* 6?> )*@ >b>F'@2 6)B C=* B* )*@ ?>E>&I> =>6%@=&)98?6)E> @=?*8D= 6) >F'%*5>? *? D*I>?)F>)@ '?*D?6F2 @=> F>6)9 *A 96@&9A5&)D @=> ?>]8&?>F>)@ &9 @* '8?E=69> &)98?6)E> A?*F 6 '?&I6@> E*F'6)5G .>D&))&)D &) 34"c2 @=*9> C=* B* )*@ E*F'%5 C&@= @=> F6)B6@> F89@ F6\> 6 ^d9e=6?>B ?>9'*)9&7&%&@5 '65F>)@_ @* @=> P>Bf>?6% g*I>?)F>)@G `a444M#7+#"+G -=> ME@ '?*I&B>9 @=6@ @=&9 ^'>)6%@5_C&%% 7> '6&B @* @=> N)@>?)6% 0>I>)8> $>?I&E> C&@= 6) &)B&I&B86%h9 @6bf>92 6)B ^9=6%% 7> 699>99>B 6)B E*%%>E@>B &) @=> 96F> F6))>?_ 69 @6b '>)6%@&>9G ``a444M#E+2 #D+#"+G M)*@=>? \>5 '?*I&9&*) *A @=> ME@ &9 @=> 1>B&E6&B >b'6)9&*)G -=> E8??>)@ 1>B&E6&B '?*D?6F *AA>?9 A>B>?6% A8)B&)D @* $@6@>9 @* 699&9@ '?>D)6)@ C*F>)2 E=&%B?>)2 )>>B5 A6F&%&>92 @=> 7%&)B2 @=> >%B>?%52 6)B @=> B&967%>B &) *7@6&)&)D F>B&E6% E6?>G c3 JG $G ,G `"KVWB#6+G -=>  MAA*?B67%> ,6?> ME@ >b'6)B9 @=> 9E*'> *A @=> 1>B&E6&B '?*D?6F 6)B&)E?>69>9 @=> )8F7>? *A &)B&I&B86%9 @=> $@6@>9 F89@ E*I>?G P*? >bf YYYYYY [-*D>@=>? C&@= :*G ""UKVX2
 +&8),%/&#% -9 :&);%< )#' :3/)# (&,=7$>&* &% );5
IG
?;-,$') &% );56
 6)B :*G ""Uc442
?;-,$') &% );5
 IG
 +&8),%/&#% -9 :&);%< )#' :3/)# (&,7$>&* &% );56
 6%9* *) E>?@&*?6?& @* @=> 96F> E*8?@G
 
 
3 :M-N(:MO P/H/0M-N(: (P N:H/Q/:H/:- .J$N:/$$
75
$/./ONJ$
 
$5%%6789
 
6F'%>2 @=> ME@ ?>]8&?>9 9@6@> '?*D?6F9 @* '?*I&B> 1>B&E6&B E*I>?6D> 75 34"c @* 6B8%@9 C&@= &)E*F>9 8' @* "KK '>?E>)@ *A @=> A>B>?6% '*If>?@5 %>I>%2 C=>?>69 F6)5 $@6@>9 )*C E*I>? 6B8%@9 C&@= E=&%B?>) *)%5&A @=>&? &)E*F> &9 E*)9&B>?67%5 %*C>?2 6)B B* )*@ E*I>? E=&%B%>99 6B8%@9 6@ 6%%G `"KVW6#6+#"4+#M+#&+#TNNN+G -=> ME@ &)E?>69>9 A>B>?6% A8)B&)D @*E*I>? @=> $@6@>9h E*9@9 &) >b'6)B&)D 1>B&E6&B E*I>?6D>G `"KVWB#5+#"+G.8@ &A 6 $@6@> B*>9 )*@ E*F'%5 C&@= @=> ME@h9 )>C E*I>?6D> ?>]8&?>fF>)@92 &@ F65 %*9> )*@ *)%5 @=> A>B>?6% A8)B&)D A*? @=*9> ?>]8&?>fF>)@92 78@ 6%% *A &@9 A>B>?6% 1>B&E6&B A8)B9G `"KVWEG -C>)@5f9&b $@6@>92 9>I>?6% &)B&I&B86%92 6)B @=> :6@&*)6% P>B>?6f@&*) *A N)B>'>)B>)@ .89&)>99 7?*8D=@ 98&@ &) P>B>?6% H&9@?&E@ ,*8?@2E=6%%>)D&)D @=> E*)9@&@8@&*)6%&@5 *A @=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@> 6)B @=>1>B&E6&B >b'6)9&*)G -=> ,*8?@ *A M''>6%9 A*? @=> /%>I>)@= ,&?E8&@ 8'=>%B @=> 1>B&E6&B >b'6)9&*) 69 6 I6%&B >b>?E&9> *A ,*)D?>99h9 9'>)B&)D '*C>?2 78@ E*)E%8B>B @=6@ ,*)D?>99 %6E\>B 68@=*?&@5 @* >)f6E@ @=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@>G P&)B&)D @=> F6)B6@> 9>I>?67%> A?*F @=> ME@h9 *@=>? '?*I&9&*)92 @=> /%>I>)@= ,&?E8&@ %>A@ @=> ?>9@ *A @=> ME@ &)f@6E@G
:&;'@
 -=> i8BDF>)@ &9 6AA&?F>B &) '6?@ 6)B ?>I>?9>B &) '6?@G WcX PG KB "3Ka2 6AA&?F>B &) '6?@ 6)B ?>I>?9>B &) '6?@G "G ,
SN/P
Z
J$-N,/
0
(./0-$
B>%&I>?>B @=> *'&)&*) *A @=> ,*8?@ C&@= ?>9'>E@ @* Q6?@ NN2 E*)E%8B&)D @=6@ @=> M)@&fN)i8)E@&*) ME@ B*>9 )*@76? @=&9 98&@G -=> M)@&fN)i8)E@&*) ME@ '?*I&B>9 @=6@ ^)* 98&@ A*? @=> '8?'*9> *A ?>9@?6&)&)D @=> 699>99F>)@ *? E*%%>E@&*) *A 6)5 @6b 9=6%% 7> F6&)f@6&)>B &) 6)5 E*8?@ 75 6)5 '>?9*)2_ 3W JG $G ,G `Lc3"#6+2 9* @=6@ @=*9>987i>E@ @* 6 @6b F89@ A&?9@ '65 &@ 6)B @=>) 98> A*? 6 ?>A8)BG -=> '?>f9>)@ E=6%%>)D> 9>>\9 @* ?>9@?6&) @=> E*%%>E@&*) *A @=> 9=6?>B ?>9'*)9&f7&%&@5 '65F>)@ A?*F @=*9> C=* B* )*@ E*F'%5 C&@= @=> &)B&I&B86%F6)B6@>G .8@ ,*)D?>99 B&B )*@ &)@>)B @=> '65F>)@ @* 7> @?>6@>B 696 ^@6b_ A*? '8?'*9>9 *A @=> M)@&fN)i8)E@&*) ME@G -=> MAA*?B67%> ,6?>  ME@ B>9E?&7>9 @=> '65F>)@ 69 6 ^'>)6%@52_ )*@ 6 ^@6bG_ -=6@ %67>% E6))*@ E*)@?*% C=>@=>? @=> '65F>)@ &9 6 @6b A*? '8?'*9>9 *A @=> ,*)f9@&@8@&*)2 78@ &@ B*>9 B>@>?F&)> @=> 6''%&E6@&*) *A @=> M)@&fN)i8)E@&*)  ME@G -=> M)@&fN)i8)E@&*) ME@ @=>?>A*?> B*>9 )*@ 76? @=&9 98&@G Q'G ""U "aG 3G ,
SN/P
 Z
J$-N,/
0
(./0-$
 E*)E%8B>B &) Q6?@ NNNUM @=6@ @=> &)B&fI&B86% F6)B6@> &9 )*@ 6 I6%&B >b>?E&9> *A ,*)D?>99h9 '*C>? 8)B>? @=> ,*FF>?E> ,%689> 6)B @=> :>E>996?5 6)B Q?*'>? ,%689>G Q'G "WUK4G#6+ -=> ,*)9@&@8@&*) D?6)@9 ,*)D?>99 @=> '*C>? @* ^
,&A3;)%&
,*FF>?E>G_ M?@G N2 `X2 E%G K #>F'=69&9 6BB>B+G -=> '*C>? @*
,&A3;)%&
E*FF>?E> '?>98''*9>9 @=> >b&9@>)E> *A E*FF>?E&6% 6E@&I&@5 @* 7> ?>Df8%6@>BG -=&9 ,*8?@h9 '?>E>B>)@ ?>A%>E@9 @=&9 8)B>?9@6)B&)D; M9 >bf'6)9&I> 69 @=&9 ,*8?@h9 E69>9 E*)9@?8&)D @=> 9E*'> *A @=> E*FF>?E>
 
 
K ,&@> 69; aWL JG $G jjjj #34"3+ $5%%6789 '*C>? =6I> 7>>)2 @=>5 8)&A*?F%5 B>9E?&7> @=> '*C>? 69 ?>6E=&)D ^6Ef@&I&@5G_
B5A56 "#$%&' (%)%&*
 IG
2-8&C
2 a"c JG $G acV2 aW4G -=> &)B&I&Bf86% F6)B6@>2 =*C>I>?2 B*>9 )*@ ?>D8%6@> >b&9@&)D E*FF>?E&6% 6E@&I&f@5G N@ &)9@>6B E*F'>%9 &)B&I&B86%9 @*
0&>-/&
 6E@&I> &) E*FF>?E> 75'8?E=69&)D 6 '?*B8E@2 *) @=> D?*8)B @=6@ @=>&? A6&%8?> @* B* 9* 6AA>E@9&)@>?9@6@> E*FF>?E>G ,*)9@?8&)D @=> ,*FF>?E> ,%689> @* '>?F&@ ,*)D?>99 @* ?>D8%6@> &)B&I&B86%9 '?>E&9>%5
0&>)3*&
@=>5 6?> B*&)D )*@=&)D C*8%B *'>) 6 )>C 6)B '*@>)@&6%%5 I69@ B*F6&) @* E*)D?>99&*)6% 68@=*?&@5G ,*)fD?>99 6%?>6B5 '*99>99>9 >b'6)9&I> '*C>? @* ?>D8%6@> C=6@ '>*'%> B*G J'=*%B&)D @=> MAA*?B67%> ,6?> ME@ 8)B>? @=> ,*FF>?E> ,%689>C*8%B D&I> ,*)D?>99 @=> 96F> %&E>)9> @* ?>D8%6@> C=6@ '>*'%> B* )*@B*G -=> P?6F>?9 \)>C @=> B&AA>?>)E> 7>@C>>) B*&)D 9*F>@=&)D 6)B B*&)D )*@=&)DG -=>5 D6I> ,*)D?>99 @=> '*C>? @*
,&A3;)%&
 E*FF>?E>2 )*@ @*
>-/8&;
 &@G ND)*?&)D @=6@ B&9@&)E@&*) C*8%B 8)B>?F&)> @=> '?&)fE&'%> @=6@ @=> P>B>?6% g*I>?)F>)@ &9 6 D*I>?)F>)@ *A %&F&@>B 6)B>)8F>?6@>B '*C>?9G -=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@> @=89 E6))*@ 7> 989f@6&)>B 8)B>? ,*)D?>99h9 '*C>? @* ^?>D8%6@> ,*FF>?E>G_ Q'G "WU3LG#7+ :*? E6) @=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@> 7> 989@6&)>B 8)B>? @=> :>Ef>996?5 6)B Q?*'>? ,%689> 69 6) &)@>D?6% '6?@ *A @=> MAA*?B67%> ,6?> ME@h9 *@=>? ?>A*?F9G /6E= *A @=&9 ,*8?@h9 '?&*? E69>9 8'=*%B&)D %6C98)B>? @=6@ ,%689> &)I*%I>B >b>?E&9>9 *A 68@=*?&@5 B>?&I6@&I> *A2 6)B&) 9>?I&E> @*2 6 D?6)@>B '*C>?G
B5A56 "#$%&' (%)%&*
 IG
4-/*%->D
2 aW4 JG $G jjjG -=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@>2 75 E*)@?69@2 I>9@9 ,*)D?>99 C&@=@=> >b@?6*?B&)6?5 67&%&@5 @* E?>6@> @=> )>E>996?5 '?>B&E6@> @* @=> >bf>?E&9> *A 6) >)8F>?6@>B '*C>? 6)B B?6C C&@=&) &@9 ?>D8%6@*?5 9E*'> @=*9> C=* C*8%B *@=>?C&9> 7> *8@9&B> *A &@G /I>) &A @=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@> &9 ^)>E>996?5_ @* @=> MAA*?B67%> ,6?> ME@h9 *@=>? ?>A*?F92 98E= 6) >b'6)9&*) *A A>B>?6% '*C>? &9 )*@ 6 ^'?*'>?_ F>6)9 A*? F6\f&)D @=*9> ?>A*?F9 >AA>E@&I>G Q'G 3LUK4G KG ,
SN/P
Z
J$-N,/
0
(./0-$
E*)E%8B>B &) Q6?@ NNNU. @=6@ @=> &)B&I&Bf86% F6)B6@> F89@ 7> E*)9@?8>B 69 &F'*9&)D 6 @6b *) @=*9> C=* B* )*@ =6I> =>6%@= &)98?6)E>2 &A 98E= 6 E*)9@?8E@&*) &9 ?>69*)67%>G -=> F*9@ 9@?6&D=@A*?C6?B ?>6B&)D *A @=> &)B&I&B86% F6)B6@> &9 @=6@&@ E*FF6)B9 &)B&I&B86%9 @* '8?E=69> &)98?6)E>G .8@2 A*? @=> ?>69*)9 >b'%6&)>B2 @=> ,*FF>?E> ,%689> B*>9 )*@ D&I> ,*)D?>99 @=6@ '*C>?GN@ &9 @=>?>A*?> )>E>996?5 @* @8?) @* @=> g*I>?)F>)@h9 6%@>?)6@&I> 6?fD8F>)@; @=6@ @=> F6)B6@> F65 7> 8'=>%B 69 C&@=&) ,*)D?>99h9 '*C>? @* ^%65 6)B E*%%>E@ -6b>9G_ M?@G N2 `X2 E%G "G N) '?>99&)D &@9 @6b&)D'*C>? 6?D8F>)@2 @=> g*I>?)F>)@ 69\9 @=> ,*8?@ @* I&>C @=> F6)fB6@> 69 &F'*9&)D 6 @6b *) @=*9> C=* B* )*@ 785 @=6@ '?*B8E@G .>fE689> ^>I>?5 ?>69*)67%> E*)9@?8E@&*) F89@ 7> ?>9*?@>B @*2 &) *?B>? @*96I> 6 9@6@8@> A?*F 8)E*)9@&@8@&*)6%&@52_
:--8&,
 IG
4);$9-,#$)
2 "aa JG $G WcX2 WaL2 @=> ]8>9@&*) &9 C=>@=>? &@ &9 ^A6&?%5 '*99&7%>_ @* &)@>?f

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->