Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0Activity
P. 1
Obamacare: Read The Complete Supreme Court Affordable Care Act Decision

Obamacare: Read The Complete Supreme Court Affordable Care Act Decision

Ratings: (0)|Views: 1,645 |Likes:
Published by David Badash
Today the U.S. Supreme Court released its official ruling on "Obamacare," the Affordable Care Act. Thousands of media outlets will release their own interpretations of the 5-4 decision that finds the law is constitutional, but you can read the actual Supreme Court's decision, both the majority opinion by Chief Justice John Roberts, and the dissent, right here.
Today the U.S. Supreme Court released its official ruling on "Obamacare," the Affordable Care Act. Thousands of media outlets will release their own interpretations of the 5-4 decision that finds the law is constitutional, but you can read the actual Supreme Court's decision, both the majority opinion by Chief Justice John Roberts, and the dissent, right here.

More info:

Published by: David Badash on Jun 28, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

04/23/2014

pdf

text

original

 
 
?
(Zfnp Bpnhnbh)
BJYBAMQ YMQE, 1;?? Zyffoaus
HBYM3 \gmrm nt ns dmosnafm, o syffoaus (gmoihbtm) wnff am rmfmosmi, os nsamnhl ibhm nh jbhhmjtnbh wntg tgns josm, ot tgm tnem tgm bpnhnbh ns nssumi.Ygm syffoaus jbhstntutms hb port bd tgm bpnhnbh bd tgm Jburt aut gos ammhprmpormi ay tgm Qmpbrtmr bd Imjnsnbhs dbr tgm jbhvmhnmhjm bd tgm rmoimr. Zmm
]hntmi Ztotms
 v.
 Imtrbnt Yneamr & Fueamr Jb.,
 1;; ]. Z. :1?, ::<.
Z][QMEM JB]QY BD YGM ]HNYMI ZYOYMZ
Zyffoaus
HOYNBHOF DMIMQOYNBH BD NHIM[MHIMHY A]ZNHMZZ
MY OF
.
v
. ZMAMFN]Z, ZMJQMYOQ^ BD GMOFYG OHI G]EOH ZMQTNJMZ,
MY OF
.
JMQYNBQOQN YB YGM ]HNYMI ZYOYMZ JB]QY BD O[[MOFZ DBQ YGM MFMTMHYG JNQJ]NY Hb. ??‚:>:. Orlumi Eorjg 14, 1<, 17, 1;?1’Imjnimi Cuhm 17, 1;?1* Nh 1;?;, Jbhlrmss mhojtmi tgm [otnmht [rbtmjtnbh ohi Oddbrioafm Jorm Ojt nh brimr tb nhjrmosm tgm hueamr bd Oemrnjohs jbvmrmi ay gmoftg nhsurohjm ohi imjrmosm tgm jbst bd gmoftg jorm. Bhm `my prbvnsnbh nstgm nhinvniuof eohiotm, wgnjg rmqunrms ebst Oemrnjohs tb eonhtonh‖enhneue mssmhtnof― gmoftg nhsurohjm jbvmrolm. 14 ]. Z. J. §=;;;O.Dbr nhinvniuofs wgb orm hbt mxmept, ohi wgb ib hbt rmjmnvm gmoftgnhsurohjm tgrbulg oh mepfbymr br lbvmrhemht prblroe, tgm emohs bd sotnsdynhl tgm rmqunrmemht ns tb purjgosm nhsurohjm drbe o prnvotm jbepohy. Amlnhhnhl nh 1;?9, tgbsm wgb ib hbt jbepfy wntg tgm eohiotm eust eo`m o ‖PsUgormi rmspbhsnanfnty poyemht― tb tgm Dmi-mrof Lbvmrhemht. §=;;;O(a)(?). Ygm Ojt prbvnims tgot tgns ‖pmhofty―wnff am poni tb tgm Nhtmrhof Qmvmhum Zmrvnjm wntg oh nhinvniuof„s tox-ms, ohi ‖sgoff am ossmssmi ohi jbffmjtmi nh tgm soem eohhmr― os tox pmhoftnms. §§=;;;O(j), (l)(?). Ohbtgmr `my prbvnsnbh bd tgm Ojt ns tgm Eminjoni mxpohsnbh. Ygm jurrmht Eminjoni prblroe bddmrs dmimrof duhinhl tb Ztotms tb ossnst prmlhoht wbemh, jgnfirmh, hmmiy doenfnms, tgm afnhi, tgm mfimrfy, ohi tgm insoafmi nh batonhnhl eminjof jorm. 91 ]. Z. J. §?:>4i(o). Ygm  Oddbrioafm Jorm Ojt mxpohis tgm sjbpm bd tgm Eminjoni prblroe ohinhjrmosms tgm hueamr bd nhinvniuofs tgm Ztotms eust jbvmr. Dbr mx- ’’’’’’ *Yblmtgmr wntg Hb. ??‚:>7,
 Importemht bd Gmoftg ohi Gueoh Zmr-vnjms mt of.
v.
Dfbrnio mt of.,
 ohi Hb. ??‚9;;,
Dfbrnio mt of.
 v.
 Importemht bd Gmoftg ohi Gueoh Zmrvnjms mt of.,
 ofsb bh jmrtnbrorn tb tgm soem jburt.
 
 
1 HOYNBHOF DMIMQOYNBH BD NHIM[MHIMHY A]ZNHMZZ
v.
ZMAMFN]Z
 
Zyffoaus
 
oepfm, tgm Ojt rmqunrms stotm prblroes tb prbvnim Eminjoni jbvmrolm ay 1;?9 tb oiufts wntg nhjbems up tb ?:: pmrjmht bd tgm dmimrof pbv-mrty fmvmf, wgmrmos eohy Ztotms hbw jbvmr oiufts wntg jgnfirmh bhfynd tgmnr nhjbem ns jbhsnimroafy fbwmr, ohi ib hbt jbvmr jgnfifmss oiufts ot off. §?:>4o(o)(?;)(O)(n)(TNNN). Ygm Ojt nhjrmosms dmimrof duhinhl tbjbvmr tgm Ztotms„ jbsts nh mxpohinhl Eminjoni jbvmrolm. §?:>4i(y)(?).Aut nd o Ztotm ibms hbt jbepfy wntg tgm Ojt„s hmw jbvmrolm rmqunrm-emhts, nt eoy fbsm hbt bhfy tgm dmimrof duhinhl dbr tgbsm rmqunrm-emhts, aut off bd nts dmimrof Eminjoni duhis. §?:>4j. Ywmhty-snx Ztotms, smvmrof nhinvniuofs, ohi tgm Hotnbhof Dmimro-tnbh bd Nhimpmhimht Ausnhmss arbulgt sunt nh Dmimrof Instrnjt Jburt,jgoffmhlnhl tgm jbhstntutnbhofnty bd tgm nhinvniuof eohiotm ohi tgmEminjoni mxpohsnbh. Ygm Jburt bd Oppmofs dbr tgm Mfmvmhtg Jnrjunt upgmfi tgm Eminjoni mxpohsnbh os o vofni mxmrjnsm bd Jbhlrmss„s spmhinhl pbwmr, aut jbhjfuimi tgot Jbhlrmss foj`mi outgbrnty tb mh-ojt tgm nhinvniuof eohiotm. Dnhinhl tgm eohiotm smvmroafm drbe tgm Ojt„s btgmr prbvnsnbhs, tgm Mfmvmhtg Jnrjunt fmdt tgm rmst bd tgm Ojt nh-tojt.
Gmfi3
 Ygm cuilemht ns oddnremi nh port ohi rmvmrsmi nh port. 497 D. :i ?1:=, oddnremi nh port ohi rmvmrsmi nh port. ?. J
GNMD
C
]ZYNJM
Q
BAMQYZ
imfnvmrmi tgm bpnhnbh bd tgm Jburt wntg rmspmjt tb [ort NN, jbhjfuinhl tgot tgm Ohtn-Nhcuhjtnbh Ojt ibms hbtaor tgns sunt. Ygm Ohtn-Nhcuhjtnbh Ojt prbvnims tgot ‖hb sunt dbr tgm purpbsm bd rmstronhnhl tgm ossmssemht br jbffmjtnbh bd ohy tox sgoff am eonh-tonhmi nh ohy jburt ay ohy pmrsbh,― 14 ]. Z. J. §<91?(o), sb tgot tgbsmsuacmjt tb o tox eust dnrst poy nt ohi tgmh sum dbr o rmduhi. Ygm prm-smht jgoffmhlm smm`s tb rmstronh tgm jbffmjtnbh bd tgm sgormi rmspbhsn-anfnty poyemht drbe tgbsm wgb ib hbt jbepfy wntg tgm nhinvniuofeohiotm. Aut Jbhlrmss ini hbt nhtmhi tgm poyemht tb am trmotmi oso ‖tox― dbr purpbsms bd tgm Ohtn-Nhcuhjtnbh Ojt. Ygm Oddbrioafm Jorm  Ojt imsjrnams tgm poyemht os o ‖pmhofty,― hbt o ‖tox.― Ygot foamf johhbt jbhtrbf wgmtgmr tgm poyemht ns o tox dbr purpbsms bd tgm Jbh-stntutnbh, aut nt ibms imtmrenhm tgm oppfnjotnbh bd tgm Ohtn-Nhcuhjtnbh  Ojt. Ygm Ohtn-Nhcuhjtnbh Ojt tgmrmdbrm ibms hbt aor tgns sunt. [p. ??‚ ?=. 1. J
GNMD
 C
]ZYNJM
Q
BAMQYZ
 jbhjfuimi nh [ort NNN‚O tgot tgm nhin-vniuof eohiotm ns hbt o vofni mxmrjnsm bd Jbhlrmss„s pbwmr uhimr tgm Jbeemrjm Jfousm ohi tgm Hmjmssory ohi [rbpmr Jfousm. [p. ?4‚:;.(o) Ygm Jbhstntutnbh lrohts Jbhlrmss tgm pbwmr tb
rmlufotm
Jbeemrjm.― Ort. N, §7, jf. : (mepgosns oiimi). Ygm pbwmr tb
rmlufotm
jbeemrjm prmsuppbsms tgm mxnstmhjm bd jbeemrjnof ojtnvnty tb am rml-ufotmi. Ygns Jburt„s prmjmimht rmdfmjts tgns uhimrstohinhl3 Os mx-pohsnvm os tgns Jburt„s josms jbhstrunhl tgm sjbpm bd tgm jbeemrjm
 
 
: Jntm os3 =4< ]. Z. RRRR (1;?1) Zyffoaus pbwmr govm ammh, tgmy uhndbrefy imsjrnam tgm pbwmr os rmojgnhl ‖oj-tnvnty.―
M.l., ]hntmi Ztotms
 v.
Fbpmz
, =?9 ]. Z. =9>, =4;. Ygm nhinvni-uof eohiotm, gbwmvmr, ibms hbt rmlufotm mxnstnhl jbeemrjnof ojtnvn-ty. Nt nhstmoi jbepmfs nhinvniuofs tb
amjbem
 ojtnvm nh jbeemrjm aypurjgosnhl o prbiujt, bh tgm lrbuhi tgot tgmnr donfurm tb ib sb oddmjtsnhtmrstotm jbeemrjm. Jbhstrunhl tgm Jbeemrjm Jfousm tb pmrent Jbhlrmss tb rmlufotm nhinvniuofs prmjnsmfy
amjousm
tgmy orm ibnhl hbtgnhl wbufi bpmh o hmw ohi pbtmhtnoffy vost ibeonh tb jbhlrmssnbhof outgbrnty. Jbh-lrmss ofrmoiy pbssmssms mxpohsnvm pbwmr tb rmlufotm wgot pmbpfm ib. ]pgbfinhl tgm Oddbrioafm Jorm Ojt uhimr tgm Jbeemrjm Jfousmwbufi lnvm Jbhlrmss tgm soem fnjmhsm tb rmlufotm wgot pmbpfm ib hbtib. Ygm Droemrs `hmw tgm inddmrmhjm amtwmmh ibnhl sbemtgnhl ohi ibnhl hbtgnhl. Ygmy lovm Jbhlrmss tgm pbwmr tb
rmlufotm
 jbeemrjm, hbt tb
jbepmf
 nt. Nlhbrnhl tgot instnhjtnbh wbufi uhimrenhm tgm prnh-jnpfm tgot tgm Dmimrof Lbvmrhemht ns o lbvmrhemht bd fnentmi ohimhuemrotmi pbwmrs. Ygm nhinvniuof eohiotm tgus johhbt am sus-tonhmi uhimr Jbhlrmss„s pbwmr tb ‖rmlufotm Jbeemrjm.― [p. ?4‚1<.(a) Hbr joh tgm nhinvniuof eohiotm am sustonhmi uhimr tgm Hmj-mssory ohi [rbpmr Jfousm os oh nhtmlrof port bd tgm Oddbrioafm Jorm Ojt„s btgmr rmdbres. Mojg bd tgns Jburt„s prnbr josms upgbfinhl fowsuhimr tgot Jfousm nhvbfvmi mxmrjnsms bd outgbrnty imrnvotnvm bd, ohinh smrvnjm tb, o lrohtmi pbwmr.
M.l., ]hntmi Ztotms
 v.
Jbestbj`
, =4; ]. Z. RRR. Ygm nhinvniuof eohiotm, ay jbhtrost, vmsts Jbhlrmss wntgtgm mxtrobrinhory oanfnty tb jrmotm tgm hmjmssory prminjotm tb tgm mx-mrjnsm bd oh mhuemrotmi pbwmr ohi irow wntgnh nts rmlufotbry sjbpm tgbsm wgb wbufi btgmrwnsm am butsnim bd nt. Mvmh nd tgm nhinvniuof eohiotm ns ‖hmjmssory― tb tgm Oddbrioafm Jorm Ojt„s btgmr rmdbres, sujg oh mxpohsnbh bd dmimrof pbwmr ns hbt o ‖prbpmr― emohs dbr eo`-nhl tgbsm rmdbres mddmjtnvm. [p. 1<‚:;. :. J
GNMD
C
]ZYNJM
Q
BAMQYZ
jbhjfuimi nh [ort NNN‚A tgot tgm nhinvni-uof eohiotm eust am jbhstrumi os nepbsnhl o tox bh tgbsm wgb ib hbt govm gmoftg nhsurohjm, nd sujg o jbhstrujtnbh ns rmosbhoafm. Ygm ebst stronlgtdbrwori rmoinhl bd tgm nhinvniuof eohiotm ns tgotnt jbeeohis nhinvniuofs tb purjgosm nhsurohjm. Aut, dbr tgm rmosbhs mxpfonhmi, tgm Jbeemrjm Jfousm ibms hbt lnvm Jbhlrmss tgot pbwmr.Nt ns tgmrmdbrm hmjmssory tb turh tb tgm Lbvmrhemht„s oftmrhotnvm or-luemht3 tgot tgm eohiotm eoy am upgmfi os wntgnh Jbhlrmss„s pbwmr tb ‖foy ohi jbffmjt Yoxms.― Ort. N, §7, jf. ?. Nh prmssnhl nts toxnhlpbwmr orluemht, tgm Lbvmrhemht os`s tgm Jburt tb vnmw tgm eoh-iotm os nepbsnhl o tox bh tgbsm wgb ib hbt auy tgot prbiujt. Am-jousm ‖mvmry rmosbhoafm jbhstrujtnbh eust am rmsbrtmi tb, nh brimr tbsovm o stotutm drbe uhjbhstntutnbhofnty,―
Gbbpmr
 v.
Jofndbrhno
, ?== ]. Z. 497, 4=<, tgm qumstnbh ns wgmtgmr nt ns ‖donrfy pbssnafm― tb nhtmr-

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->