Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more ➡
Standard view
Full view
of .
Add note
Save to My Library
Sync to mobile
Look up keyword or section
Like this
4Activity
×

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Aff & Neg Nukes

Aff & Neg Nukes

Ratings: (0)|Views: 4,824|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See More
See less

05/24/2012

 
Michigan 7 weeks1 Nuclear power good / bad disads
NUCLEAR POWER GOOD / BAD
You need this file – it has a nuclear power good disad and a nuclear power bad disad in it. But, to eliminate duplication, itis also necessary to use a lot of these cards as a case neg to the nuclear power aff or as impacts for the nuclear power aff.
NUCLEAR POWER BAD DISAD
nuclear power good / bad............................................................................................................................................................1nuclear power bad 1nc.............................................................................................................................................................6uniqueness global nuclear power decreasing...........................................................................................................................7Uniqueness global nuclear power decreasing .........................................................................................................................8uniqueness u.s. nuclear power decreasing...............................................................................................................................9uniqueness u.s. nuclear power decreasing.............................................................................................................................10at: nonunique – nuclear power now..........................................................................................................................................11nuclear power isn’t cost competitive........................................................................................................................................12link carbon regulations..........................................................................................................................................................13link carbon regulations..........................................................................................................................................................14link carbon regulations..........................................................................................................................................................15link carbon regulations..........................................................................................................................................................16link – cap and trade...................................................................................................................................................................17link carbon tax.......................................................................................................................................................................18link carbon tax.......................................................................................................................................................................19link – coal regulations...............................................................................................................................................................20at: no link – will shift to renewables or energy efficiency.......................................................................................................21nuclear power bad – extinction.................................................................................................................................................22nuclear power bad – meltdowns shell.......................................................................................................................................23nuclear power bad – meltdowns shell.......................................................................................................................................24meltdown risk high - earthquakes.............................................................................................................................................25meltdown risk high - warmng...................................................................................................................................................26at: nuclear power is safe safety regulations...........................................................................................................................27at: nuclear power is safe safety regulations...........................................................................................................................28xt safety standards aren’t enforced........................................................................................................................................29at: technical safeguards prevent meltdowns.............................................................................................................................30at: new reactor designs solve accidents....................................................................................................................................31AT: Generation IV reactors solve safety...................................................................................................................................32at: generation iv reactors solve safety.......................................................................................................................................33at: pebble bed reactors solve safety..........................................................................................................................................34at: empirically – there’s never been an accident.......................................................................................................................35aging reactors make accidents possible....................................................................................................................................36at: nonunique – nuclear power now..........................................................................................................................................37risk of terrorist attack high........................................................................................................................................................38risk of terrorist attack high........................................................................................................................................................39airplane attacks risk meltdowns................................................................................................................................................40airplane attacks risk meltdowns................................................................................................................................................41at: technology protects against terrorist attacks........................................................................................................................42at: security upgrades prevent terrorism....................................................................................................................................43at: security upgrades prevent terrorism....................................................................................................................................44meltdowns impact massive death..........................................................................................................................................45meltdowns impact economy..................................................................................................................................................46xt – meltdowns kill the economy..............................................................................................................................................47meltdowns bad turn electricity advantages............................................................................................................................48meltdowns bad - environment .................................................................................................................................................49meltdown impact - destroys nuclear power..............................................................................................................................502nc proliferation / terrorism impact shell..............................................................................................................................51nuclear power bad – proliferation.............................................................................................................................................52nuclear power bad – proliferation.............................................................................................................................................53at: nuclear power decreases co2...............................................................................................................................................54xt 1 can’t solve warming fast enough....................................................................................................................................55
 
Michigan 7 weeks2 Nuclear power good / bad disadsxt 1 can’t solve warming fast enough....................................................................................................................................56xt 2 - construction of nuclear power releases co2....................................................................................................................57xt 3 uranium mining difficulty increases co2 emissions.......................................................................................................58at: nuclear power good key to leadership..............................................................................................................................59at: nuclear power good key to leadership..............................................................................................................................60at: nuclear power good key to leadership..............................................................................................................................61xt 1 hypocrisy undermines leadership...................................................................................................................................62uniqueness - Reprocessing decreasing now..............................................................................................................................63links – u.s. nuclear leadership means it will push reprocessing...............................................................................................64reprocessing bad proliferation / terrorism.............................................................................................................................65reprocessing bad proliferation...............................................................................................................................................66reprocessing bad proliferation...............................................................................................................................................67 purex processing increases proliferation risks..........................................................................................................................68AT: Pyroprocessing Solves Prolif.............................................................................................................................................69AT: Innovation Solves Reprocessing Costs..............................................................................................................................70AT: Generation IV reactors solve prolif....................................................................................................................................71 breeder reactors fail..................................................................................................................................................................72at: gnep solves problems with reprocessing.............................................................................................................................73at: gnep solves waste................................................................................................................................................................74at: reprocessing solves waste siting issues...............................................................................................................................75Reprocessing Bad---Oceans.....................................................................................................................................................76reprocessing bad accidents....................................................................................................................................................77reprocessing isn’t cost competitive...........................................................................................................................................78u.s. nuclear leadership high now .............................................................................................................................................79u.s. nuclear leadership high now..............................................................................................................................................80nuclear leadership alternate causalities.....................................................................................................................................81 Nuclear power bad – waste ......................................................................................................................................................82Waste bad - radiation................................................................................................................................................................83Waste impact – water contamination........................................................................................................................................84 Nuclear waste bad risks proliferation....................................................................................................................................85nuclear power bad water contamination................................................................................................................................86nuclear power bad water contamination................................................................................................................................87ext - nuclear power bad – water................................................................................................................................................88at: nuclear power key to desalination.......................................................................................................................................89nuclear power bad food chain contamination........................................................................................................................90at: there won’t be a meltdown so no contamination.................................................................................................................91at: scientific studies prove radiation has no impact..................................................................................................................92nuclear power bad ozone.......................................................................................................................................................93xt – nuclear power destroys the ozone......................................................................................................................................94nuclear power bad native americans......................................................................................................................................95nuclear power bad native americans......................................................................................................................................96nuclear power bad - patriarchy.................................................................................................................................................97at: nuclear power solves energy dependence............................................................................................................................98at: nuclear power decreases oil demand...................................................................................................................................99indict nei evidence...............................................................................................................................................................100 No link Carbon pricing doesn’t trigger nuclear power........................................................................................................101nuclear power good - 1nc.......................................................................................................................................................102nuclear power good – 1nc.......................................................................................................................................................103uniqueness nuclear power investment increasing................................................................................................................104Uniqueness nuclear power investment increasing ..............................................................................................................105uniqueness nuclear power investment increasing................................................................................................................106uniqueness nuclear power investment increasing................................................................................................................107Uniqueness Nuke power winning over coal........................................................................................................................108at: lack of incentives blocks nuclear power............................................................................................................................109reactor technology increasing now.........................................................................................................................................110 Nuclear power increasing globally.........................................................................................................................................111nuclear power increasing globally..........................................................................................................................................112nuclear power increasing globally..........................................................................................................................................113
 
Michigan 7 weeks3 Nuclear power good / bad disadsnuclear power increasing – asia..............................................................................................................................................114at: public opposition to new construction...............................................................................................................................115at: construction costs too high................................................................................................................................................116at: environmental activists block nuclear power.....................................................................................................................117at: current loan guarantees don’t cover enough of the debt....................................................................................................118at: lack of loan guarantees block new construction................................................................................................................119at: lack of loan guarantees block construction........................................................................................................................120at: uranium shortages block nuclear power............................................................................................................................121at: regulatory uncertainty blocks expansion...........................................................................................................................122uniqueness renewables low.................................................................................................................................................123links decreasing electricity demand kills nuclear power.....................................................................................................124links renewable energy tradesoff with nuclear power.........................................................................................................125nuclear power links – rps........................................................................................................................................................126nuclear power links - rps........................................................................................................................................................127nuclear power tradesoff with renewables...............................................................................................................................128nuclear power tradesoff with renewables...............................................................................................................................129generation iv reactors tradeoff with renewable energy...........................................................................................................130at: renewables solve energy demand......................................................................................................................................131at: renewables solve energy demand......................................................................................................................................132at: renewables solve energy demand......................................................................................................................................133at: renewables solve energy demand......................................................................................................................................134at: renewable energy more sustainable / infinite energy........................................................................................................135nuclear power good terrorism impact addon.......................................................................................................................136Uniqueness no u.s. nuclear power leadership now..............................................................................................................137new construction key to nuclear leadership............................................................................................................................138new construction key to nuclear leadership............................................................................................................................139new construction key to nuclear leadership............................................................................................................................140substantial increase key to u.s. nuclear leadership.................................................................................................................141nuclear power leadership key to solve proliferation...............................................................................................................142nuclear power leadership key to solve proliferation...............................................................................................................143nuclear power leadership key to solve proliferation...............................................................................................................144expanding nuclear power key to competitiveness..................................................................................................................145nuclear power leadership key to nuclear safety......................................................................................................................146nuclear power leadership key to nuclear safety......................................................................................................................147u.s. nuclear power leadership key to gnep credibility............................................................................................................148nuclear power leadership solves reprocessing impacts.......................................................................................................149nuclear power key to soft power.............................................................................................................................................150AT: nuclear power increases the risk of prolif – tech transfer / reprocessing.........................................................................151at: increasing nuclear power is modeled increases prolif....................................................................................................152at: nuclear power causes reprocessing....................................................................................................................................153Reprocessing good solves proliferation and waste..............................................................................................................154reprocessing good solves proliferation................................................................................................................................155at: reprocessing risks diversion of fuel...................................................................................................................................156Reprocessing key to prolif leadership ...................................................................................................................................157Reprocessing key to prolif leadership....................................................................................................................................158reprocessing solves waste storage..........................................................................................................................................159reprocessing solves waste storage..........................................................................................................................................160reprocessing solves waste storage..........................................................................................................................................161at: reprocessing bad – terrorism..............................................................................................................................................162MOX doesn’t Solve Prolif......................................................................................................................................................163 Nuclear power solves warming .............................................................................................................................................164 Nuclear power solves warming .............................................................................................................................................165 Nuclear power solves warming .............................................................................................................................................166 Nuclear power solves warming .............................................................................................................................................167solvency - substantial increase in nuclear power key to solve warming................................................................................168AT: Lifecycle carbon costs prove nuclear power doesn’t decrease c02.................................................................................169coal reliance increasing..........................................................................................................................................................170Coal Bad Environment........................................................................................................................................................171

Activity (4)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
bhbatson liked this
100buzz liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->