NU 2008-2009Jeremy SelesnerRPS AFF and NEG
_________________ ............................................................................................................................................3***1AC ...........................................................................................................................................................3RPS 1AC – Inherency ......................................................................................................................................4RPS 1AC – Plan Text .......................................................................................................................................6RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ..................................................................................................7RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ..................................................................................................9RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................11RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................12RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................14RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................15RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................17RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................20RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................21RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................22RPS 1AC – Renewable Transition Advantage ................................................................................................23RPS 1AC – Solvency .....................................................................................................................................24RPS 1AC – Solvency .....................................................................................................................................25RPS 1AC – Solvency .....................................................................................................................................26RPS 1AC – Solvency .....................................................................................................................................27 ____________________ .....................................................................................................................................28***Topicality .................................................................................................................................................28 Topicality – Incentives ..................................................................................................................................29 Topicality – Incentives ..................................................................................................................................31 _________________ ..........................................................................................................................................32***Inherency ................................................................................................................................................32RPS Won’t Pass Now .....................................................................................................................................33 They Say “Markets Solve Now” ....................................................................................................................34 They Say “States Solve Now” ......................................................................................................................35 _________________________ .............................................................................................................................36***Global Warming Advantage .....................................................................................................................36Extinction Impact .........................................................................................................................................37CO2 Causes Warming ................................................................................................................................... 38Resource Wars Impact .................................................................................................................................39Biodiversity Impact ......................................................................................................................................40 _____________________ ...................................................................................................................................41***Economy Advantage ...............................................................................................................................41Oil Dependence Collapses US economy .......................................................................................................42 ____________________ .....................................................................................................................................44***Terrorism Addon ......................................................................................................................................44 Terrorism Addon 2AC ....................................................................................................................................45 __________________ ........................................................................................................................................46***Hegemony Addon ....................................................................................................................................46Environmental Leadership Addon 2AC .........................................................................................................47Soft Power Key to Hegemony .......................................................................................................................49 __________________ ........................................................................................................................................51***Iran Addon ...............................................................................................................................................51Iran Addon 2AC ............................................................................................................................................52Hegemony Module .......................................................................................................................................53 _____________________ ...................................................................................................................................54***Democracy Addon ...................................................................................................................................54Democracy Addon 2AC ................................................................................................................................55Middle East Democracy Good – Nuclear War ................................................................................................56Middle East Democracy Good – Nuclear War ................................................................................................58Middle East Democracy Good – Terrorism ....................................................................................................59 They Say “Transition Wars” ..........................................................................................................................61 ___________________ .......................................................................................................................................621
NU 2008-2009Jeremy SelesnerRPS AFF and NEG
***Solvency ..................................................................................................................................................62Solvency – Increase Renewables ..................................................................................................................63Solvency – Increase Renewables ..................................................................................................................65Solvency – Decrease Fossil Fuels .................................................................................................................66Solvency – Decrease Emissions ...................................................................................................................67Solvency – International Modeling ................................................................................................................ 68 They Say “Transmission Lines” ....................................................................................................................69 They Say “No Enforcement” ........................................................................................................................70 They Say “Empirically Failed” ......................................................................................................................71 They Say “Some Areas can’t support Renewables” .....................................................................................72 __________________ ........................................................................................................................................73***Answers to Disads ...................................................................................................................................73Energy Price Responses ...............................................................................................................................74Energy Price Responses ...............................................................................................................................76Business Confidence Responses ..................................................................................................................77 ______________________ ..................................................................................................................................78***Counterplan Responses ...........................................................................................................................78State Counterplan Responses ......................................................................................................................79State Counterplan Responses ......................................................................................................................80Efficiency Counterplan Responses ...............................................................................................................81CEPS Counterplan Responses ......................................................................................................................82Free Market Counterplan Responses ............................................................................................................83R&D Counterplan Responses .......................................................................................................................84*****NEGATIVE***** .....................................................................................................................................85 ____________________ .....................................................................................................................................85***Topicality .................................................................................................................................................85Incentives Topicality – 1NC Shell..................................................................................................................86Ext – RPS isn’t an Incentive ..........................................................................................................................88 __________________ ........................................................................................................................................89***Energy Price DA .......................................................................................................................................89Energy Price DA – 1NC Shell.........................................................................................................................90Energy Price DA – 1NC Shell.........................................................................................................................92Ext – Federal RPS Increases Energy Prices ...................................................................................................94Ext – High Prices Cause Industry Flight ........................................................................................................96 Turns Case – Economy .................................................................................................................................97 ____________________ .....................................................................................................................................98***States ......................................................................................................................................................98Inherency Turn – 1NC Shell........................................................................................................................... 99Ext – States Solving in Status Quo .............................................................................................................100Ext – National RPS Tradesoff ......................................................................................................................101Counterplan – 1NC Shell............................................................................................................................102Ext – Solvency ............................................................................................................................................103 They Say “Perm” ........................................................................................................................................105Federalism Links ........................................................................................................................................106 ___________________ .....................................................................................................................................107***Case Frontlines ......................................................................................................................................107Solvency Frontline ......................................................................................................................................108Solvency Frontline ......................................................................................................................................110Solvency Frontline ......................................................................................................................................111Ext – Wind Power .......................................................................................................................................113Ext – Trade Off ...........................................................................................................................................114Extend – Transmission Lines ......................................................................................................................115Economy Frontline .....................................................................................................................................116Economy Frontline .....................................................................................................................................118Global Warming Frontline ...........................................................................................................................119Foreign Oil Dependence Frontline ..............................................................................................................1202
NU 2008-2009Jeremy SelesnerRPS AFF and NEG
_________________ ***1AC
3
Search History:
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
p.
More From This User
Notes
Load more
