Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword or section
Like this
2Activity

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
SPS Affirmative[1]

SPS Affirmative[1]

Ratings: (0)|Views: 249 |Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

05/09/2014

 
K-State DebatePurple Lab
Solar Power Satellites Affirmative
Wildcat Debate Workshop 2008
Solar Power Satellites Affirmative
Solar Power Satellites Affirmative...................................................................................................................................................................................1First, the Inherency..........................................................................................................................................................................................................4 Next, is solvency.............................................................................................................................................................................................................6Advantage One Resource Wars.....................................................................................................................................................................................8Advantage Two – Hegemony.........................................................................................................................................................................................11Advantage Three – Hurricanes......................................................................................................................................................................................14Inherency – Investment Needed.....................................................................................................................................................................................16Inherency – BureaucraticProblems................................................................................................................................................................................16Inherency - SPS.............................................................................................................................................................................................................17Inherency.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................17Inherency.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................17Inherency – Incentives Needed......................................................................................................................................................................................18Feasibility – Cost Effective but needs funding...............................................................................................................................................................19Feasibility - Price...........................................................................................................................................................................................................19Feasibility - Affordable..................................................................................................................................................................................................20Feasibility – Cheaper Launch Mechanisms...................................................................................................................................................................20Feasibility - Technology................................................................................................................................................................................................21Feasibility – Can Use New Communication Satellites...................................................................................................................................................22Feasibility - Technology................................................................................................................................................................................................23Feasibility - Technology................................................................................................................................................................................................24Feasibility – Technology................................................................................................................................................................................................24Feasibility - Technology................................................................................................................................................................................................25Feasibility - A2 Requires Large Ground Based..............................................................................................................................................................25Solvency - Tax incentives..............................................................................................................................................................................................26Solvency – F.F. & Nuclear.............................................................................................................................................................................................26Solvency – Energy 4 da whole world............................................................................................................................................................................27Solvency – SPS funded by USFG..................................................................................................................................................................................27Solvency –Government should do it..............................................................................................................................................................................27Solvency – Already Have the Tech / Money..................................................................................................................................................................28Solvency – Now Key Time............................................................................................................................................................................................28Solvency - SPS best renewable energy..........................................................................................................................................................................29Solvency – Improved Recently......................................................................................................................................................................................29Solvency - USFG Should fund......................................................................................................................................................................................29Solvency - NASA..........................................................................................................................................................................................................30Solvency - Solar Satellites are Very Efficient................................................................................................................................................................30Solvency - US don’t need No help.................................................................................................................................................................................30Solvency - NRC.............................................................................................................................................................................................................31Solvency – Moon Based Solar Power............................................................................................................................................................................31Solvency – Laser Beams................................................................................................................................................................................................32Solvency - Efficient.......................................................................................................................................................................................................32Advantage - Resource Wars - Quick Timeframe............................................................................................................................................................33Advantage - Resource Wars - Markets Don’t Solve.......................................................................................................................................................33Advantage – Resource Wars - Solvency........................................................................................................................................................................34Advantage - Resource Wars - Solvency.........................................................................................................................................................................34Advantage – Resource Wars - Solvency........................................................................................................................................................................35Alternative – Resource Wars - Solvency........................................................................................................................................................................35Advantage - Resource Wars - Solvency.........................................................................................................................................................................35Advantage - Resource Wars - Solvency.........................................................................................................................................................................36Advantage – Resource Wars - Solvency........................................................................................................................................................................36Advantage – Resource Wars - Solvency........................................................................................................................................................................37Advantage - Resource Wars - Solvency.........................................................................................................................................................................37Advantage - Resource Wars - Solvency.........................................................................................................................................................................38Advantage - Economy - Solvency.................................................................................................................................................................................39Advantage – Economy - Solvency.................................................................................................................................................................................39Advantage - Hegemony - Uniqueness...........................................................................................................................................................................40Advantage - Hegemony - UK Getting SPS....................................................................................................................................................................40Advantage – Hegemony – Japan Getting SPS...............................................................................................................................................................40
Page | 1
 
K-State DebatePurple Lab
Solar Power Satellites Affirmative
Wildcat Debate Workshop 2008
Advantage – Hegemony - India and China Racing........................................................................................................................................................41Advantage – Hegemony - China Leads Space Race......................................................................................................................................................41Advantage – Hegemony – China Getting SPS...............................................................................................................................................................42Advantage – Hegemony – China Leads Space Race......................................................................................................................................................42Advantage – Hegemony – China Leads Space Race......................................................................................................................................................43Advantage - Hegemony – Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................43Advantage - Hegemony - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................44Advantage – Hegemony - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................44Advantage – Hegemony – Tech Key.............................................................................................................................................................................44Advantage – Hegemony – AT Counterbalancing...........................................................................................................................................................45Advantage – Hegemony – AT Counterbalancing...........................................................................................................................................................45Advantage – Hegemony - Solves Terrorism..................................................................................................................................................................45Advantage – Hegemony – Indo Pak / Taiwan War Impact.............................................................................................................................................46Advantage – Hegemony – Indo Pak Escalation.............................................................................................................................................................46Advantage – Hegemony – Taiwan Strait Impact............................................................................................................................................................46Advantage - Hegemony – China Nuke War Impact.......................................................................................................................................................47Advantage – Hegemony - Impact..................................................................................................................................................................................48Advantage - Hegemony - Impact...................................................................................................................................................................................49Advantage – Space Exploration - Uniqueness...............................................................................................................................................................50Advantage - Hegemony – AT Space Treaties.................................................................................................................................................................50Advantage – Space Exploration - Solvency...................................................................................................................................................................51Advantage - Space Exploration - Solvency....................................................................................................................................................................51Advantage - Space Exploration - Solvency....................................................................................................................................................................51Advantage – Space Exploration - Solvency...................................................................................................................................................................52Advantage – Space Exploration - Solvency...................................................................................................................................................................52Advantage - Space Exploration - Solvency....................................................................................................................................................................53Advantage – Space Exploration - Solvency...................................................................................................................................................................53Advantage - Space Exploration - Solvency....................................................................................................................................................................54Advantage – Space Exploration – Space Sails...............................................................................................................................................................54Advantage - Space Exploration - AT No Tech...............................................................................................................................................................54Advantage - Space Exploration - Impact.......................................................................................................................................................................55Advantages - Space Exploration - Impact......................................................................................................................................................................55Advantage – Space Exploration - Impact.......................................................................................................................................................................56Advantage - Asteroid - Solvency...................................................................................................................................................................................57Advantage – Global Warming - Solvency......................................................................................................................................................................58Advantage - Global Warming - Solvency......................................................................................................................................................................58Advantage - Global Warming - Impact..........................................................................................................................................................................59Advantage - Food Prices - Solvency..............................................................................................................................................................................60Advantage – Terrorism - Solvency................................................................................................................................................................................61Advantage – Hurricanes – Uniqueness..........................................................................................................................................................................62Advantage - Hurricanes - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................62Advantage - Hurricanes - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................63Advantage - Hurricanes - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................63Advantage - Hurricanes - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................64Advantage - Hurricanes - Solvency...............................................................................................................................................................................64Advantage - Hurricanes - Impact...................................................................................................................................................................................65Advantage – Space Weapons Good - Solvency..............................................................................................................................................................66Space Weapons – No Link.............................................................................................................................................................................................67Advantage - Robots - Solvency.....................................................................................................................................................................................68AT States CP - USFG Key.............................................................................................................................................................................................69AT States CP - USFG Key.............................................................................................................................................................................................69AT International CP - US Leadership Key.....................................................................................................................................................................70AT – Terrorism Against SPS..........................................................................................................................................................................................71A2-Your satellites will get hit by enemy forces.............................................................................................................................................................72AT Politics - Public Supports SPS.................................................................................................................................................................................73AT Politics - Bi-Partisan Support for SPS......................................................................................................................................................................73AT Biomass CP.............................................................................................................................................................................................................74 Neg - Too expensive......................................................................................................................................................................................................75 Neg – Laser power bad..................................................................................................................................................................................................76 Neg – Space Lasers are not safe....................................................................................................................................................................................77 Neg - SSP too expensive and dangerous........................................................................................................................................................................78 Neg - UN CP.................................................................................................................................................................................................................79
Page | 2
 
K-State DebatePurple Lab
Solar Power Satellites Affirmative
Wildcat Debate Workshop 2008
 Neg – Private Actor CP.................................................................................................................................................................................................80 Neg - Feasibility............................................................................................................................................................................................................82 Neg – AT Space Exploration Advantage........................................................................................................................................................................83 Neg – Space Exploration Advantage.............................................................................................................................................................................83 Neg – Hegemony Advantage.........................................................................................................................................................................................83 Neg – Hegemony Advantage.........................................................................................................................................................................................84 Neg –Inefficient Energy................................................................................................................................................................................................85SPS Neg- Not feasible...................................................................................................................................................................................................86Earth Based Solar Power Aff Parts................................................................................................................................................................................87Inherency – Solar Power................................................................................................................................................................................................87Inherency - US Solar Plans on Hold..............................................................................................................................................................................87Inherency – Solar Power................................................................................................................................................................................................87Solvency – Regular Solar Power...................................................................................................................................................................................88A2- Solar Power needs sun all the time.........................................................................................................................................................................89Generic Solar – Requires USFG....................................................................................................................................................................................90Solar Incentives = Leadership........................................................................................................................................................................................91Solvency – Solar Thermal.............................................................................................................................................................................................92Solar Thermal – Dependency Solvency.........................................................................................................................................................................93Solar Thermal Effective at night....................................................................................................................................................................................94Solar energy prices decreasing.......................................................................................................................................................................................95Solar power good for military........................................................................................................................................................................................96Solvency - CSP..............................................................................................................................................................................................................97Solar Power - Feasibility...............................................................................................................................................................................................98Solvency – Solar Thermal.............................................................................................................................................................................................99Solvency – Solar Power...............................................................................................................................................................................................100Solar Power – Cost Effective.......................................................................................................................................................................................100CSP – Fast Timeframe.................................................................................................................................................................................................101Solar Power Solvency – Global Warming....................................................................................................................................................................102A2: Generic Solar Energy bad Environment................................................................................................................................................................103Solar Power increasing internationally........................................................................................................................................................................104
Page | 3

Activity (2)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->