Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
3Activity

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
aff navy

aff navy

Ratings: (0)|Views: 140|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

07/20/2012

 
NHSI 2008SeniorsNuclear Navy Aff1
Nuclear Navy Index
Nuclear Navy Aff-Wey, Crowe, Jeremiah
 Nuclear Navy Index ...............................................................................................................................................................................11AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................31AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................41AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................51AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................61AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................71AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................81AC ........................................................................................................................................................................................................91AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................101AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................111AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................121AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................131AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................141AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................151AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................161AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................171AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................181AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................191AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................201AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................211AC ......................................................................................................................................................................................................22Inherency: Oil Spikes ...........................................................................................................................................................................23Inherency: Oil Spikes ...........................................................................................................................................................................24Inherency: Oil Shocks .........................................................................................................................................................................25Inherency: No Nuclear Power ..............................................................................................................................................................26Inherency: Navy=no investment ..........................................................................................................................................................272AC Impact-Ext...................................................................................................................................................................................282AC Impact--ext. ..................................................................................................................................................................................292AC Add-On: Rail Guns .....................................................................................................................................................................302AC Add-on: Rail Guns .......................................................................................................................................................................312AC Add-on: Blackouts .......................................................................................................................................................................322AC Add-On: Blackout ........................................................................................................................................................................332AC Add-on: Pollution .......................................................................................................................................................................34Hegemony Impacts ...............................................................................................................................................................................36Hegemony: Global War ........................................................................................................................................................................37Hegemony Good ..................................................................................................................................................................................38Hegemony Good .................................................................................................................................................................................39Hegemony Good ..................................................................................................................................................................................40Dependency kills readiness ..................................................................................................................................................................41Dependency kills readiness ..................................................................................................................................................................42Dependency Kills readiness .................................................................................................................................................................43Dependency kills readiness ..................................................................................................................................................................44Dependency Solvency ..........................................................................................................................................................................45Impact: Sea power ................................................................................................................................................................................46Impact: Sea Power ................................................................................................................................................................................47Impact: Global Stability/Power War ....................................................................................................................................................481AC Module: China .............................................................................................................................................................................491AC Module: China .............................................................................................................................................................................501AC Module: china ..............................................................................................................................................................................51
Northwestern University Debate SocietyNational Debate Tournament Champions2005 – 2003 – 2002 – 1999 – 1998 – 1995 – 1994 – 1980 – 1978 – 1973 – 1966 – 1959 – 1958
1
 
NHSI 2008SeniorsNuclear Navy Aff2
1AC Module: China .............................................................................................................................................................................521AC Module: China .............................................................................................................................................................................531AC Module: China .............................................................................................................................................................................54China will surpass U.S. Navy before 2015 ..........................................................................................................................................551AC Module: Humanitarian Operations ..............................................................................................................................................561AC Module: Humanitarian Operations ..............................................................................................................................................571AC Module: Humanitarian Operations ..............................................................................................................................................58Soft Power i/l ........................................................................................................................................................................................59Soft power Impacts ..............................................................................................................................................................................60Soft Power Impact ................................................................................................................................................................................61Soft Power Impact ................................................................................................................................................................................62Adv: Arctic ...........................................................................................................................................................................................63Icebreakers Russia winning, U.S. needs ...........................................................................................................................................64Russians Taking Arctic .........................................................................................................................................................................65Russia/US Competition in Arctic .........................................................................................................................................................66Russian Navy-modernization ...............................................................................................................................................................67Russian Oil Dominance Bad ................................................................................................................................................................68Arctic Cold War Now ...........................................................................................................................................................................69Russia Module - Russians Taking Arctic .............................................................................................................................................70A2: Law of the Sea Treaty checks ........................................................................................................................................................711AC Module Shipping Industry ..........................................................................................................................................................721AC Module: Shipping Industry .........................................................................................................................................................731AC Module: Shipping Industry ..........................................................................................................................................................751AC Module: Shipping Industry ..........................................................................................................................................................761AC Module: Shipping Industry ..........................................................................................................................................................77 Navy Key to Shipbuilding ....................................................................................................................................................................78Shipbuilding Will Go International ......................................................................................................................................................79 Navy key to Shipbuilding .....................................................................................................................................................................80Shipbuilding Will Collapse ..................................................................................................................................................................81Shipbuilding Key to Global Stability ...................................................................................................................................................82 Navy Key to Shipbuilding ....................................................................................................................................................................83 Navy Investment Solves Shipbuilding .................................................................................................................................................84Investment Solves Shipbuilding ...........................................................................................................................................................85International Trade Impact ...................................................................................................................................................................86International Trade Impact ...................................................................................................................................................................87U.S. Competition ..................................................................................................................................................................................88Solvency: Navy Investment .................................................................................................................................................................89Solvency: Congressional Funding ........................................................................................................................................................90Solvency: Procument ...........................................................................................................................................................................91Solvency: Procumbent .........................................................................................................................................................................92Stable Industry=Nuclear Navy .............................................................................................................................................................93SOLVENCY Advanced Procurement ...............................................................................................................................................94 Naval Budget Cuts Inevitable/No New Funding=Cuts ........................................................................................................................95 No Funding ...........................................................................................................................................................................................96Dependency Solvency ..........................................................................................................................................................................97Solvency: Nuclear Navy solves dependence ........................................................................................................................................98Solvency: Leadership ...........................................................................................................................................................................99A2: Economy/speding ........................................................................................................................................................................100A2: economy/spending .......................................................................................................................................................................101A2: all there turns ...............................................................................................................................................................................101A2: Troops or draft CP .......................................................................................................................................................................102A2: Oil DA .........................................................................................................................................................................................104A2: Oil Da ..........................................................................................................................................................................................105
Northwestern University Debate SocietyNational Debate Tournament Champions2005 – 2003 – 2002 – 1999 – 1998 – 1995 – 1994 – 1980 – 1978 – 1973 – 1966 – 1959 – 1958
2
 
NHSI 2008SeniorsNuclear Navy Aff3
A2: Oil DA .........................................................................................................................................................................................106A2: Cap and Trade .............................................................................................................................................................................107Politics Links: Plan=Bipartisan ..........................................................................................................................................................108Politics-Plan unpopular ......................................................................................................................................................................109Politics-Plan popular ..........................................................................................................................................................................110Military Spending unpopular ..............................................................................................................................................................111McCain Supports Plan ........................................................................................................................................................................112Obama Supports maritime power projection .....................................................................................................................................113Obama Supports Nuclear Power ........................................................................................................................................................114A2: T-renewable energy and substantial ............................................................................................................................................115T-Alternative Energy ..........................................................................................................................................................................116T-Alternative Energy ..........................................................................................................................................................................117T - Not Alternate .................................................................................................................................................................................118Arctic Dominance Not Key ................................................................................................................................................................119Arctic Dominance Not Key ................................................................................................................................................................120Russia Won’t Attack ...........................................................................................................................................................................121 Nuclear Navy is costly .......................................................................................................................................................................122Japan Da .............................................................................................................................................................................................123
1AC
Observation 1: InherencyDespite its benefits the Navy is not serious about investing in Nuclear Powered fleet
Fein, 1/18/2008 (Geof, “Navy Needs Nuclear-Powered Surface Ships Given Future Needs, Lawmaker Assert” Lexis Nexis, accessed 7/15/08-e.wey)It makes no sense for the Navy to continue building conventionally powered surface ships given future power demands and the potential for an oil producing nation to impact America's fuel imports, according to Rep. Gene Taylor (D-Miss.) Taylor, chairmanof the House Armed Service Committee Seapower and Expeditionary Forces subcommittee, made his remarks at last week'sSurface Navy Association (SNA) symposium, and several days before the Navy delivered its report on alternative propulsion for 
Northwestern University Debate SocietyNational Debate Tournament Champions2005 – 2003 – 2002 – 1999 – 1998 – 1995 – 1994 – 1980 – 1978 – 1973 – 1966 – 1959 – 1958
3

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
azay101 liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->