Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more ➡
Standard view
Full view
of .
Add note
Save to My Library
Sync to mobile
Look up keyword or section
Like this
2Activity
×

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
aff rps

aff rps

Ratings:

4.5

(2)
|Views: 5,364|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See More
See less

10/16/2011

 
RPS Aff 1
7 Week Juniors – CPHS Lab
Index
1AC Action
Index ..............................................................................................................................................................................................1This Page is Blank .........................................................................................................................................................................6RPS 1AC Contention 1 ...............................................................................................................................................................7RPS 1AC Plan ............................................................................................................................................................................8RPS 1AC – Fossil Fuels Adv .........................................................................................................................................................9RPS 1AC – Fossil Fuels Adv .......................................................................................................................................................10RPS 1AC Fossil Fuels Adv .......................................................................................................................................................11RPS 1AC – Fossil Fuels Adv .......................................................................................................................................................12RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................13RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................14RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................15RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................16RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................17RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................18RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................19RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................20RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................21RPS 1AC Economy Adv ..........................................................................................................................................................22RPS 1AC Competitiveness Adv ...............................................................................................................................................23RPS 1AC Competitiveness Adv ...............................................................................................................................................24RPS 1AC Competitiveness Adv ...............................................................................................................................................25RPS 1AC Competitiveness Adv ...............................................................................................................................................26RPS 1AC Competitiveness Adv ...............................................................................................................................................27RPS 1AC Competitiveness Adv ...............................................................................................................................................28RPS 1AC China Adv ................................................................................................................................................................29RPS 1AC China Adv ................................................................................................................................................................30RPS 1AC China Adv ................................................................................................................................................................31RPS 1AC U.S.-E.U. Relations Adv ..........................................................................................................................................32RPS 1AC U.S.-E.U. Relations Adv ..........................................................................................................................................33RPS 1AC Solvency ...................................................................................................................................................................34RPS 1AC Solvency ...................................................................................................................................................................35RPS 1AC Solvency ...................................................................................................................................................................36RPS 1AC Solvency ...................................................................................................................................................................37RPS 1AC Solvency ...................................................................................................................................................................38RPS 1AC Solvency ...................................................................................................................................................................39Environment Ext – Coal Consumption Increasing ......................................................................................................................40Environment Ext RPS Reduces Coal Use ................................................................................................................................41Environment Ext – Renewables Conserve Water ........................................................................................................................42Environment Ext – Conventional Energies Pollute Water ..........................................................................................................43Environment Ext – Fossil Fuel Production Destorys Environment ............................................................................................44Environment Ext – Renewables Reduce Land Use .....................................................................................................................45Environment Ext Air Pollution 2AC .....................................................................................................................................46Environment Ext – Coal Casues Acid Rain .................................................................................................................................47Environment Ext – SO2 and NOx
Acid Rain ...........................................................................................................................48Environment Ext Acid Rain Impacts ........................................................................................................................................49Environment Ext – RPS Solves Acid Rain ..................................................................................................................................50Environment Ext Health Impact ...............................................................................................................................................51Environment Ext – Global Warming – 2AC ................................................................................................................................52Environment Ext – Global Warming Internals ............................................................................................................................53Environment Ext – Global Warming Internals ............................................................................................................................54Environment Ext – Global Warming Internals ............................................................................................................................55Environment Ext – Global Warming Solvency ...........................................................................................................................56Environment Ext – Renewables Reduce Pollution & Greenhouse .............................................................................................57Environment Ext – U.S. Environmental Leadership Solves Globally ........................................................................................58Economy Ext – RPS Reduces FF Transportation Costs ..............................................................................................................59Economy Ext – Biz Con Internal Link ........................................................................................................................................60
 
RPS Aff 2
7 Week Juniors – CPHS Lab
Economy Ext – Biz Con Internal Link ........................................................................................................................................61 Natural Gas Ext – Steel Industry Addon – 2AC ..........................................................................................................................62 Natural Gas Ext Prices Increasing ............................................................................................................................................63 Natural Gas Ext Prices Increasing ............................................................................................................................................64 Natural Gas Ext – High Prices Destroy the Chemical Industry ..................................................................................................65 Natural Gas Ext – High Prices Destroy the Chemical Industry ..................................................................................................66 Natural Gas Ext – Fertilizer Food Impacts ..................................................................................................................................67 Natural Gas Ext – Fertilizer Pakistan Impact ..............................................................................................................................68 Natural Gas Ext – Renewables Reduce LNG Imports ................................................................................................................69 Natural Gas Ext – RPS Reduces Gas Demand & Prices .............................................................................................................70 Natural Gas Ext – RPS Reduces Gas Demand & Prices .............................................................................................................71 Natural Gas Ext – RPS Solves Price Spikes / AE Helps Chemical Industry ..............................................................................72 Natural Gas Ext – Alternative Energy Helps Chemical Industry ................................................................................................73Blackouts Ext – Investment in Transmission Needed .................................................................................................................74Blackouts Ext – Utilities Intentionally Promote Congestion ......................................................................................................75Blackouts Ext Blackouts Coming Now ....................................................................................................................................76Blackouts Ext Blackouts Coming Now ....................................................................................................................................77Blackouts Ext – A2: Blackouts Don’t Happen ............................................................................................................................78Blackouts Ext – A2: 2005 Energy Act Fixed Problem ................................................................................................................79Blackouts Ext – Minor Failures Snowball ...................................................................................................................................80Blackouts Ext Impacts ..............................................................................................................................................................81Blackouts Ext Impacts ..............................................................................................................................................................82Blackouts Ext Impacts ..............................................................................................................................................................83Blackouts Ext Renewables Solves ............................................................................................................................................84Blackouts Ext RPS Solves ........................................................................................................................................................85Blackouts Ext RPS Solves ........................................................................................................................................................86Blackouts Ext RPS Solves ........................................................................................................................................................87Grid Security Ext – Grid Vulnerable Now ..................................................................................................................................88Grid Security Ext – Grid Vulnerable Now ..................................................................................................................................89Grid Security Ext Impacts ........................................................................................................................................................90Grid Security Ext Impacts ........................................................................................................................................................91Grid Security Ext – Renewable Solves / Key to Distributed Generation ....................................................................................92Grid Security Ext – Renewable Solves / Key to Distributed Generation ....................................................................................93Grid Security Ext – Renewable Solves / Key to Distributed Generation ....................................................................................94Grid Security Ext – A2: Wind Turbines Will be Attacked ...........................................................................................................95Unemployment Ext Economy Internals ...................................................................................................................................96Unemployment Ext RPS = Jobs ...............................................................................................................................................97Unemployment Ext RPS = Jobs ...............................................................................................................................................98Unemployment Ext – RPS Increases Manufacturing ..................................................................................................................99Unemployment Ext – RPS = Jobs in Midwest / Rural Areas ....................................................................................................100Competitiveness Ext – RPS Will Boost Competitiveness .........................................................................................................101Competitiveness Ext – RPS = Export Capabilities ....................................................................................................................102Competitiveness Ext – Increased Renewables Key to Exports Markets ...................................................................................103Competitiveness Ext – Solar Key to Tech Leadership ..............................................................................................................104Competitiveness Ext – RPS Key to Create Demand For RE ....................................................................................................105Competitiveness Ext – Renewable Market Key to Tech Leadership ........................................................................................106Competitiveness Ext – Renewable Market Key to Tech Leadership ........................................................................................107Competitiveness Ext – Competitiveness Key to Heg / Heg Impact ..........................................................................................108Competitiveness Ext – RE has Huge Market Potential .............................................................................................................109Competitiveness Ext – U.S. Falling Behind / Small Threshold for Adv ...................................................................................110Competitiveness Ext – A2: Renewables Manufactured Abroad ................................................................................................111China Ext – Climate Impact / U.S. Solvency [1/2] ...................................................................................................................112China Ext – Climate Impact / U.S. Solvency [2/2] ...................................................................................................................113China Ext – Energy Consumption / Pollution Increasing ..........................................................................................................114China Ext China Not Solving Now ........................................................................................................................................115China Ext – Death Impacts .......................................................................................................................................................116China Ext Agriculture Impact .................................................................................................................................................117China Ext Economy Impact ....................................................................................................................................................118China Ext Economy Impact ....................................................................................................................................................119China Ext Pollution Impacts ...................................................................................................................................................120
 
RPS Aff 3
7 Week Juniors – CPHS Lab
China Ext – Warming / Biodiversity Impacts ............................................................................................................................121China Ext U.S. Export Solvency ............................................................................................................................................122China Ext U.S. Export Solvency ............................................................................................................................................123China Ext – Energy Cooperation Key to Relations ...................................................................................................................124China Ext – Energy Cooperation Key to Relations ...................................................................................................................125Terrorism Ext – Cooperation ....................................................................................................................................................126Terrorism Ext Impacts ............................................................................................................................................................127Hegemony – Energy Policy Key to Global Leadership ............................................................................................................128Hegemony – Renewables / Market Key to Leadership .............................................................................................................129Hegemony – Concessions on Climate Key to Coop & Heg ......................................................................................................130Hegemony – Concessions on Climate Key to Coop & Heg ......................................................................................................131 No Renewables Now .................................................................................................................................................................132 No Renewables Now .................................................................................................................................................................133State RPSs Undermines Renewables .........................................................................................................................................134A2: States Solving Now ............................................................................................................................................................135A2: States Solving Now ............................................................................................................................................................136Federal RPS Good Laundry List ............................................................................................................................................137Federal RPS key to Expand Renewables ...................................................................................................................................138Federal RPS key to Expand Renewables ...................................................................................................................................139Federal RPS key to Expand Renewables ...................................................................................................................................140Renewables Good Laundry List .............................................................................................................................................141Renewables Good Laundry List .............................................................................................................................................142Federal RPS Good – National REC Market ..............................................................................................................................143Federal RPS Good – National REC Market ..............................................................................................................................144RECs = Transition to Renewables .............................................................................................................................................145RECs = Transition to Renewables .............................................................................................................................................146A2: RPS Bad Arguments *** ....................................................................................................................................................147A2: RPS Bad Arguments *** ....................................................................................................................................................148A2: Renewables are Intermittent / Unreliable .........................................................................................................................149A2: Renewables are Intermittent / Unreliable .........................................................................................................................150A2: Renewables are Intermittent / Unreliable .........................................................................................................................151A2: RPS Only Increases Wind Power .......................................................................................................................................152A2: No Interconnection / A2: RPS Causes Electricity Restructuring .......................................................................................153A2: Long Timeframe for Renewables .......................................................................................................................................154A2: Meet Targets .......................................................................................................................................................................155A2: RPS Hurts Certain States / Regions ...................................................................................................................................156A2: RPS Hurts Certain States / Regions ...................................................................................................................................157A2: Southeastern Region Can’t Meet RPS ................................................................................................................................158A2: No Enforcement ..................................................................................................................................................................159A2: No Enforcement / Coordination with State RECs ..............................................................................................................160A2: No Materials for Renewables .............................................................................................................................................161Wind Solves Pollution / CO2 ....................................................................................................................................................162Wind Solves Pollution / CO2 ....................................................................................................................................................163Wind Helps Environment ..........................................................................................................................................................164Wind Key to Competitiveness ...................................................................................................................................................165Wind Increases Jobs ..................................................................................................................................................................166Wind Solves Rural Economy ....................................................................................................................................................167Wind Increases Tourism ...........................................................................................................................................................168Wind Can Meet All Energy Needs ............................................................................................................................................169Wind Has Larget Potential in Electiricty Market ......................................................................................................................170Wind Solves Natural Gas Price Shocks .....................................................................................................................................171Wind Solves Terrorist Attacks ...................................................................................................................................................172Wind is Key to Transition to Hydrogen ....................................................................................................................................173Wind is Key to Transition to Hydrogen ....................................................................................................................................174Wind is Key to Transition to Hydrogen ....................................................................................................................................175A2: Wind Kills Birds .................................................................................................................................................................176A2: Wind Kills Bats ...................................................................................................................................................................177A2: Wind Kills Animals ...........................................................................................................................................................178A2: Wind Hurts Soil / Environment / Causes Emissions ..........................................................................................................179A2: Wind Disrupts Radar ..........................................................................................................................................................180

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->