Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
See Premium Plans
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
1Scholars Warming
Warming Master File
Index.................................................................................................................................................................1Warming Master File........................................................................................................................................1Warming Advantage – 1AC (1/5).....................................................................................................................4Warming Advantage – 1AC (2/5).....................................................................................................................6Warming Advantage – 1AC (3/5).....................................................................................................................7Warming Advantage – 1AC (4/5).....................................................................................................................8Warming Advantage – 1AC (5/5)...................................................................................................................10***Advantages***..........................................................................................................................................111AC Crazy Weather ADV...............................................................................................................................121AC Sea Level ADV – (1/2)...........................................................................................................................131AC Environment ADV.................................................................................................................................151AC Starvation ADV......................................................................................................................................161AC Disease ADV..........................................................................................................................................171AC Water ADV.............................................................................................................................................181AC Refugees ADV.......................................................................................................................................191AC Plankton ADV........................................................................................................................................201AC Coral ADV.............................................................................................................................................21***Warming Bad Science***.........................................................................................................................22Warming Real Frontline – (1/2)......................................................................................................................23Warming Real Ext. – (1/2)..............................................................................................................................25Warming is Anthropogenic Frontline – (1/3)..................................................................................................27Warming is Anthropogenic Ext – (1/2)...........................................................................................................30Emissions Increasing......................................................................................................................................32***A2: No Solve – Alt Caus/Time/US Key***.............................................................................................33A2: Deforestation – Turn: Warming is the Cause...........................................................................................34A2: Deforestation (1/4)...................................................................................................................................35A2: Contrails...................................................................................................................................................39A2: Cows........................................................................................................................................................40A2: Sun (1/2)..................................................................................................................................................41A2: Plants........................................................................................................................................................43A2: Arthropods...............................................................................................................................................44A2: “Solar Variations”....................................................................................................................................45A2: China........................................................................................................................................................46A2: Other Countries Key (1/6).......................................................................................................................47Energy Key (1/2)............................................................................................................................................53Warming Not Inevitable..................................................................................................................................55A2: Pipeline (1/3)...........................................................................................................................................56A2: Wavelength Saturation (1/2)....................................................................................................................59***Warming Bad: Indict/Prodict***..............................................................................................................61IPCC Good Frontline (1/2).............................................................................................................................62 Neg Authors Bad – Laundry List....................................................................................................................64A2: “Singer”...................................................................................................................................................65A2: “Balling”..................................................................................................................................................66A2: “Seitz”......................................................................................................................................................67A2: “Lindzen”.................................................................................................................................................68***Warming Bad – Feedbacks***.................................................................................................................69Positive Feedbacks – Carbon Cycle (1/2).......................................................................................................70Positive Feedbacks - Methane........................................................................................................................72Positive Feedbacks – Soil Carbon..................................................................................................................73Positive Feedbacks – Soil Carbon..................................................................................................................74Positive Feedbacks – Water Vapor/Ocean Uptake..........................................................................................75Positive Feedbacks – More Likely.................................................................................................................76Positive Feedbacks – o/w Negative Feedbacks..............................................................................................77
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
2Scholars Warming
Positive Feedbacks – Unstoppable Warming..................................................................................................78A2: “Clouds = negative feedback”.................................................................................................................79***Warming Bad – A2: Adaptation***..........................................................................................................80Adaptation Insufficient...................................................................................................................................81***Warming Bad – Impacts***.....................................................................................................................82Warming Impacts – War (1/3).........................................................................................................................83Warming Impacts – War – South Asia (1/4)...................................................................................................86Warming Impacts – Econ/Leadership.............................................................................................................90Warming Impacts – Crazy Weather (1/6).......................................................................................................91Warming Impacts – Crazy Weather – Econ....................................................................................................97Warming Impacts – Crazy Weather – Disease ...............................................................................................98Warming Impacts – Crazy Weather – Coral Reefs.........................................................................................99Warming Impacts – Natural Disasters..........................................................................................................100Warming Impacts – Natural Disasters – Economy (Quakes).......................................................................101Warming Impacts – Natural Disasters – Disease (Tsunamis).......................................................................102Warming Impacts – Water Shortages (1/3)...................................................................................................103Warming Impacts – Water Shortages – Prolif...............................................................................................107Warming Impacts – Water Shortages – Bio-d...............................................................................................108Warming Impacts – Biodiversity (1/3).........................................................................................................109Warming Impacts – Plankton – A2: Pollutants Turn....................................................................................112Warming Impacts – Plankton – A2: Resilience............................................................................................113Warming Impacts – Plankton – A2: Marine Mammals Turn........................................................................114Warming Impacts – Coral Reefs...................................................................................................................115Warming Impacts – Coral Reefs – Survival Impact.....................................................................................116Warming Impacts – Coral – A2: Calcification Turn.....................................................................................117Warming Impacts – Floods...........................................................................................................................118Warming Impacts – Econ .............................................................................................................................119Warming Impacts – Disease ........................................................................................................................120Warming Impacts – Refugees (1/5)..............................................................................................................121Warming Impacts – Refugees – War Impact................................................................................................127Warming Impacts – Fires (1/2).....................................................................................................................128Warming Impacts – Fires – Nuclear Winter.................................................................................................130Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise (1/7).....................................................................................................131Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise (7/7)....................................................................................................137Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise Impacts – Econ/BioD..........................................................................138Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise Impacts – Econ....................................................................................139Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise Impacts – BioD....................................................................................140Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise Impacts – Wetlands (1/2).....................................................................141Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise Impacts – Hazardous Wastes...............................................................143***Warming Good Science***....................................................................................................................144Warming not real 1NC (1/3).........................................................................................................................145Warming not real ext. (1/2)...........................................................................................................................148***Warming Good – Negative Feedbacks***.............................................................................................150 Negative Feedbacks 1NC.............................................................................................................................151 Negative Feedbacks – Ag Areas...................................................................................................................152 Negative Feedbacks – Clouds.......................................................................................................................153 Negative Feedbacks – Drying Troposphere..................................................................................................154Positive Feedback ≠ ↑ warming....................................................................................................................155A2: “Pos feedback = runaway warming”.....................................................................................................156A2: “Soil carbon positive feedbacks”...........................................................................................................157***Warming Good – Indict/Prodict***........................................................................................................158AT: Warming Bad – Authors Biased (1/2)....................................................................................................159AT: Warming Bad – Authors Biased (2/2)....................................................................................................160IPCC bad frontline (1/3)...............................................................................................................................161A2: “Scientific Consensus” (1/2)..................................................................................................................164A2: “Scientific Consensus- Oreskes”...........................................................................................................166
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
3Scholars Warming
Peer Reviewing Bad ....................................................................................................................................167Singer Good..................................................................................................................................................168Lindzen Good...............................................................................................................................................169***Warming Good – No Solvency***.........................................................................................................170 No Solve – Alt Cause – Deforestation (1/3).................................................................................................171 No Solve – Alt Cause – Contrails (1/2)........................................................................................................174 No Solve – Alt Cause – Several Gasses........................................................................................................176 No Solve – Alt Cause – Cows.......................................................................................................................177 No Solve – Alt Cause – Sun (1/2).................................................................................................................178 No Solve – Alt Cause – Plants (1/2).............................................................................................................180 No Solve – Alt Cause – Arthropods (1/2).....................................................................................................182 No Solve – China (1/2).................................................................................................................................184 No Solve – India...........................................................................................................................................186 No Solve – Developing Nations...................................................................................................................187 No Solvency – Larger CO2 Decrease Needed ............................................................................................188 No Solve – 1990 Levels Fail........................................................................................................................189 No Solve – Price Caps Bad...........................................................................................................................190 No Solve – Aviation......................................................................................................................................191 No Solve – Pipeline......................................................................................................................................192 No Solve – Wavelength Saturation ..............................................................................................................193 No Solve – Wavelength Saturation ..............................................................................................................194***Warming Good – A2: Aff Impacts***....................................................................................................195AT: Warming Impacts – A2: War (1/2).........................................................................................................196AT: Warming Impacts – A2: War (2/2).........................................................................................................197AT: Warming Impacts – Forests (1/2)...........................................................................................................198AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Disease............................................................................................................200AT: Warming Impacts – Water Shortages.....................................................................................................201AT: Warming Impacts – Natural Disasters...................................................................................................202AT: Warming Impacts – Crazy Weather (1/3)...............................................................................................203AT: Warming Impacts – Fires.......................................................................................................................206AT: Warming Impacts – Sea Level Rise (1/10)............................................................................................207AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Refugees (1/2).................................................................................................219AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Refugees (2/2).................................................................................................220AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Refugees – Security K (1/2)...........................................................................221AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Biod (1/3)........................................................................................................223AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Biod – Turn: Wetlands (1/2)...........................................................................226AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Plankton – Turn: Pollution Good....................................................................228AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Plankton – Turn: Marine Mammals (1/2).......................................................229AT: Warming Impacts – A2: Plankton – No Impact.....................................................................................231A2: Warming Impacts – A2: Coral – Turn: Calcification.............................................................................232
Search
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.
    • Notes
    Load more