Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more ➡
Standard view
Full view
of .
Add note
Save to My Library
Sync to mobile
Look up keyword or section
Like this
4Activity
×

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
CTL Aff - Scholars

CTL Aff - Scholars

Ratings:

5.0

(2)
|Views: 5,110|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See More
See less

12/29/2012

 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
1
Scholars Lab
Green Military Aff 
CTL Aff Index
CTL Aff Index.................................................................................................................................................................1***1AC***.....................................................................................................................................................................61AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Inh/Plan.................................................................................................................71AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Adv 1: Readiness (1/8)..........................................................................................81AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Scenario 1: China................................................................................................161AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Scenario 2: Iran (1/3)...........................................................................................171AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Scenario 3: Terrorism..........................................................................................211AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Advantage 2: Air Pollution (1/4).........................................................................221AC – CTL Good – AF Fuels Aff – Solvency (1/4).....................................................................................................26***Topicality***...........................................................................................................................................................30CTL Good – T – Alternative Energy – 2AC (1/2).........................................................................................................31CTL Good – T – Alternative Energy (1/6)....................................................................................................................33CTL Good – T – Alternative Energy – A2: AE = RE....................................................................................................39CTL Good – T – Alternative Energy – A2: 50-50 = Oil...............................................................................................40CTL Good – T – Incentives...........................................................................................................................................41CTL Good – T – Increase..............................................................................................................................................42***Inherency & UQ***................................................................................................................................................43CTL Good – Inherency – American Energy Production Act of 2008...........................................................................44CTL Good – A2: SQ Solves (1/3).................................................................................................................................45CTL Good – A2: SQ Solves (Fuel Use Down) – Fuel Use Up (1/2)............................................................................48CTL Good – Non-UQ – Incentives Now......................................................................................................................50CTL Good – Non-UQ – RE Up (1/2)............................................................................................................................51***Readiness Adv Links***.........................................................................................................................................53CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Links: Budget (1/4)......................................................................................................54CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Links: Natural Disasters...............................................................................................58CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Links: Fuel Simplification/Tactical Supplies ..............................................................59CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Links: Oil Dependence (Supply Shx UQ)...................................................................60CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Links: Oil Dependence (1/7)........................................................................................61CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Links: Oil Dependence (Terror)...................................................................................68***Readiness Adv Internals***....................................................................................................................................69CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Air Power Key (1/4).....................................................................................................70CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Air Power Key – Terrorism..........................................................................................74CTL Good – Readiness Adv – A2: Air Power =/= Key – Jet Fuel K to All..................................................................75CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Fuel Key.......................................................................................................................76CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Costs Key (1/2)............................................................................................................78CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Weight Requirements Key...........................................................................................80CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Missiles Key.................................................................................................................81CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Missiles Up (1/2)..........................................................................................................82CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Allied Coop Key..........................................................................................................84CTL Good – Readiness Adv – Interventions Key (1/2)................................................................................................85***Readiness Adv Solvency***...................................................................................................................................87CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Missiles...................................................................................................88CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Maintenance............................................................................................89CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Budget.....................................................................................................90CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Oil Demand (AF) (1/2)...........................................................................91CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Oil Demand (General) (1/6)....................................................................93CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Oil Control..............................................................................................99CTL Good – Readiness Adv – CTL Solves: Oil Shocks.............................................................................................100***Readiness Adv A2: Take-outs***.........................................................................................................................101CTL Good – Readiness Adv – A2: CTL Drawbacks..................................................................................................102CTL Good – Readiness Adv – A2: Retrofitting/Interoperability (1/3).......................................................................103CTL Good – Readiness Adv – A2: Interoperability – No Link..................................................................................106CTL Good – Readiness Adv – A2: Interoperability – NUQ.......................................................................................107CTL Good – Readiness Adv – A2: Aircraft Carriers DA – No Link: JP-5/JP-8 Fuels...............................................108***Iran Adv***...........................................................................................................................................................109
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
2
Scholars Lab
Green Military Aff 
CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Coming [1/5]............................................................................................................110CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Coming – Israel [1/2]...............................................................................................116CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Coming – Israel – Draws In U.S. ............................................................................118CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Coming – CIA/Covert Ops [1/3].............................................................................119CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – Prolif...........................................................................................................122CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – Miscalc NW................................................................................................123CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – Terrorism ....................................................................................................124CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: Too Many Places..................................................................................125CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: “Don’t know where they are”..............................................................126CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: = Fundamentalism................................................................................127CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: = Radiation...........................................................................................128CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: U.S.-EU Relations................................................................................129CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: Deterrence Solves................................................................................130CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: UN Solves [1/2]...................................................................................131CTL Good – Iran Adv – Strikes Good – A2: Sanctions Solve [1/3]...........................................................................133CTL Good – Iran Adv – Air Power Key.....................................................................................................................136***China Adv***.......................................................................................................................................................137CTL Good – China Adv – China is a Threat (1/3)......................................................................................................138CTL Good – China Adv – China is a Threat – AF......................................................................................................141CTL Good – China Adv – China War Inevit (1/3)......................................................................................................142CTL Good – China Adv – China War Inevit –Taiwan................................................................................................145CTL Good – China Adv – China War Inevit –Taiwan – US Intervention..................................................................146CTL Good – China Adv – A2: Deterrence Checks.....................................................................................................147CTL Good – China Adv – Air Force Key – General...................................................................................................148CTL Good – China Adv – Air Force Key – Taiwan [1/2]...........................................................................................149***Iraq Adv***...........................................................................................................................................................151CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Pullout Coming (1/2)...........................................................................................................152CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: Spillover.................................................................................................................154CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: NW (1/2).................................................................................................................155CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: Civil War (1/2)........................................................................................................157CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: Democracy..............................................................................................................159CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: Democracy – NW...................................................................................................160CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: Democracy – Terrorism..........................................................................................161CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Impact: Democracy – War etc. ...........................................................................................162CTL Good – Iraq Adv – Air Force key [1/3]...............................................................................................................163***Air Pollution Adv***............................................................................................................................................166CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Solves General (1/2)..............................................................................................167CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Solves Airlines.......................................................................................................169CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – US Key to World...................................................................................................170CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Famine (1/3)..........................................................................................................171CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Famine – O/W War................................................................................................174CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Marine Species......................................................................................................175CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Species...................................................................................................................176CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Ozone Layer..........................................................................................................177CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Ozone Layer – Survival.........................................................................................178CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Endocrine Disruption............................................................................................179CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Lichen (1/2)...........................................................................................................180CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Lichen: Keystone...................................................................................................182CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – Health Harms.........................................................................................................183CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – A2: Low-Level......................................................................................................184CTL Good – Air Pollution Adv – A2: Inefficient........................................................................................................185***Solvency***..........................................................................................................................................................186CTL Good – Solvency – 25-Year Contracts Solve (1/8).............................................................................................187CTL Good – Solvency – DOD Interprets CTL as AE.................................................................................................195CTL Good – Solvency – DOD Wants CTL (1/5)........................................................................................................197CTL Good – Solvency – Repeal EISA Solves............................................................................................................202CTL Good – Solvency – Excise Tax Credits Solve....................................................................................................203
 
Gonzaga Debate Institute 2008
3
Scholars Lab
Green Military Aff 
CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Marketability (1/4).......................................................................................................204CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Marketability – Technical Problems (1/2)....................................................................208CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Marketability – CTL = Profits......................................................................................210CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Empirically Fails..........................................................................................................211CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Regulation Prevents.....................................................................................................212CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Backstopping................................................................................................................213CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Peak Coal (1/2).............................................................................................................214CTL Good – Solvency – A2: Long-Term....................................................................................................................216CTL Good – Solvency – CTL = Gasification.............................................................................................................217CTL Good – Solvency – Spillover – Commercialization (1/4)..................................................................................218CTL Good – Solvency – Spillover – Airlines (1/3)....................................................................................................222CTL Good – Solvency – AF Key (1/3).......................................................................................................................225***A2: Warming DA***............................................................................................................................................228CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – NUQ: CO2 Up.......................................................................................................231CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – NUQ: Methane Up.................................................................................................232CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – No Threshold.........................................................................................................233CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Blends Solve..........................................................................................................234CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – No Link: Storage Solves (1/2)...............................................................................235CTL Good – A2: Warming Da – Carbon Storage – A2: Feasibility (1/2)...................................................................237CTL Good – A2: Warming Da – Carbon Storage – A2: Costs....................................................................................239CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – No Link: Oil Recovery..........................................................................................240CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: NOx (1/2).....................................................................................................241CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: Airlines.........................................................................................................243CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: Plan Solves Bad Coal (1/2)..........................................................................245CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: CTL Solves Lifecycle CO2 (1/2).................................................................247CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: Ethanol Fermentation...................................................................................249CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: Hybrids.........................................................................................................250CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: Efficiency.....................................................................................................251CTL Good – A2: Warming DA – Turn: RE Shift (1/4)...............................................................................................252***A2: Other Enviro DA’s***....................................................................................................................................256CTL Good – A2: Water DA – No Link: Heat Recovery.............................................................................................257CTL Good – A2: Water DA – Turn: SQ Worse...........................................................................................................258CTL Good – A2: Water DA – Recycling....................................................................................................................259CTL Good – A2: Water Pollution................................................................................................................................260CTL Good – A2: Slag DA (1/2)..................................................................................................................................261CTL Good – A2: Radon DA (1/2)...............................................................................................................................263CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – 2AC...........................................................................................................................265CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – NUQ – Coal Up (1/4)...............................................................................................266CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – Turn: CTL = Efficiency............................................................................................270CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – No Impact.................................................................................................................271CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – A2: Waste..................................................................................................................272CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – A2: Dust and noise pollution....................................................................................273CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – Mine reclamation solves...........................................................................................274CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – A2: Emissions...........................................................................................................275CTL Good – A2: Mining DA – A2: Electricity ..........................................................................................................276CTL Good – A2: Toxics DA – Generic.......................................................................................................................277CTL Good – A2: Toxics DA – Turn: Biomass Slag....................................................................................................278CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Laundry List...............................................................................................................279CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Mercury (1/2).............................................................................................................280CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Trace/Particulate Emissions (1/2)..............................................................................282CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – NOx............................................................................................................................284CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Lead...........................................................................................................................285CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Chlorine.....................................................................................................................286CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Flourine .....................................................................................................................287CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Sulfur (1/2).................................................................................................................288CTL Good – A2: Toxins DA – Cyanide......................................................................................................................290***A2: Econ DA’s***................................................................................................................................................291

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->