Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
3Activity

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Fish Aff (ADI)

Fish Aff (ADI)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 544 |Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/21/2012

 
Arizona Debate Institute 2008
1
Russell’s Lab
Fish Aff 
Fish Aff 
Fish Aff............................................................................................................................................................................11AC (1/12)......................................................................................................................................................................41AC (2/12)......................................................................................................................................................................51AC (3/12)......................................................................................................................................................................61AC (4/12)......................................................................................................................................................................71AC (5/12)......................................................................................................................................................................81AC (6/12)......................................................................................................................................................................91AC (7/12)....................................................................................................................................................................101AC (8/12).....................................................................................................................................................................111AC (9/12)....................................................................................................................................................................121AC (10/12)..................................................................................................................................................................131AC (11/12)...................................................................................................................................................................141AC (12/12)..................................................................................................................................................................15Topicality – Subsidies Don’t Include Vessel Decommissioning...................................................................................17Topicality – Fisheries Includes Aquaculture.................................................................................................................18Topicality – Subsidies Exclude “Normal Benefits”......................................................................................................19Topicality – Subsidies are Confusing – Reasonability..................................................................................................20Topicality – Subsidies are Limited................................................................................................................................21Topicality – Subsidies – A2: FAO Definition...............................................................................................................22Subsidies Bad – Overfishing (1/9)................................................................................................................................23Overfishing – Up Now (1/3).........................................................................................................................................32Overfishing – A2: SQ Solves........................................................................................................................................35Overfishing – Solvency – A2: Post-Brink.....................................................................................................................36Overfishing – A2: Fisheries Resilient (1/2)..................................................................................................................37Overfishing – A2: Piracy T/O Solvency.......................................................................................................................39Overfishing – A2: Migration Solves.............................................................................................................................40Overfishing – A2: Species Extinction Long Timeframe...............................................................................................41Overfishing – A2: Fish High on Food Chain................................................................................................................42Overfishing – A2: Other Countries Key.......................................................................................................................43Overfishing – A2: Warming Key..................................................................................................................................44Overfishing – Ecosystem Collapse (1/4)......................................................................................................................45Overfishing – Ecosystem Collapse – Predators Key....................................................................................................49Overfishing – Ecosystem Collapse – Oceans Impact (1/4)...........................................................................................50Overfishing – Ecosystem Collapse – Extinction (1/4)..................................................................................................54Overfishing – Ecosystem Collapse – AT: Resilient: Tipping Point..............................................................................58Overfishing – Ecosystem Collapse – AT: Resilient: Deep-Water.................................................................................59Overfishing – Coral Reefs.............................................................................................................................................60Overfishing – Fish Wars................................................................................................................................................61Overfishing – Famine....................................................................................................................................................62Overfishing – Famine – MoB.......................................................................................................................................63Overfishing – Poverty (1/3)..........................................................................................................................................64Overfishing – Poverty – Impact....................................................................................................................................67Trawling Advantage – Subsidies Key...........................................................................................................................68Trawling Advantage – Destroys Deep Sea....................................................................................................................69Trawling Advantage – Sharks.......................................................................................................................................70Trawling Advantage – Marine Species (1/3).................................................................................................................71Trawling Advantage – Coral Reefs...............................................................................................................................74Trawling Advantage – Coral Reefs...............................................................................................................................75Bycatch – Subsidies Key...............................................................................................................................................76Bycatch – Impacts.........................................................................................................................................................77Bycatch – US Key.........................................................................................................................................................78Longlining Advantage – It’s Up....................................................................................................................................79Longlining Advantage – Subsidies Key........................................................................................................................80Longlining Advantage – Marine Ecosystems Impact...................................................................................................81Longlining Advantage – Sea Turtles Impact.................................................................................................................82
 
Arizona Debate Institute 2008
2
Russell’s Lab
Fish Aff 
Longlining Advantage – Shark Impact.........................................................................................................................83Salmon Advantage – Subsidies Key (1/3).....................................................................................................................84Salmon Impacts – Species Loss (1/2)...........................................................................................................................87Salmon Impacts – Economy (1/2).................................................................................................................................89Tuna Advantage – US Key............................................................................................................................................91Turtles Advantage – Trawling Links.............................................................................................................................92Turtles Advantage – Longlining Links..........................................................................................................................93Turtles Advantage – Species Impacts............................................................................................................................94Turtles Advantage – Econ Impacts................................................................................................................................95Turtles Advantage – US Key.........................................................................................................................................96A2: Aquaculture Turn – NUQ – Aquaculture Up (1/2).................................................................................................97A2: Aquaculture Turn – Link Turn: Subsidies Key......................................................................................................99A2: Aquaculture Turn – No Impact: Ecosystems (1/3)...............................................................................................100A2: Aquaculture Turn – A2: US Key..........................................................................................................................103A2: Aquaculture Turn – Impact Turn – Econ..............................................................................................................104A2: Aquaculture Turn – Impact Turn – Food..............................................................................................................105A2: Aquaculture Turn – No Impact: Ecosystems........................................................................................................106A2: Food Prices – Prices Up (1/3)..............................................................................................................................107A2: Food Prices – Turn: Subsidies Increase Prices.....................................................................................................110A2: Econ DA – UQ – Fishing Industry Down............................................................................................................112A2: Econ DA – Link Turn: Fishing Industry (1/7)......................................................................................................113A2: Econ DA – A2: Access Payments Link................................................................................................................120A2: Econ DA – No I/L – Fisheries Not Key...............................................................................................................121A2: Econ DA – Florida Econ Down...........................................................................................................................122A2: Econ DA – A2: Fishing Key to FL Economy.......................................................................................................124A2: Econ DA – Florida Resilient................................................................................................................................125A2: Econ DA – A2: Florida Key to U.S./Global Econ...............................................................................................126A2: Vessel Decomissioning Good (1/3)......................................................................................................................127A2: Vessel Construction Subsidies Good....................................................................................................................130A2: Capacity Reduction Subsidies Good....................................................................................................................131A2: Conservation Subsidies Good..............................................................................................................................132A2: Buyback Subsidies Good.....................................................................................................................................133A2: Vessel Construction Subsidies Good....................................................................................................................134A2: R&D Subsidies Good (1/2)..................................................................................................................................135A2: Fuel Subsidies Good (1/3)....................................................................................................................................137A2: Fuel Subsidies Good – Econ................................................................................................................................140A2: Fuel Subsidies Good – A2: Coastal Fishing Bad – Deep Sea Fishing Key.........................................................141A2: Management CP – No Modeling..........................................................................................................................142A2: Management CP – Subsidies Key (1/2)...............................................................................................................143A2: Management CP – No Solvency (1/5)..................................................................................................................145A2: Marine Reserves CP – Perm Solvency.................................................................................................................150A2: Marine Reserves CP – No Solvency – Overfishing (1/4)....................................................................................151A2: Marine Reserves CP – No Solvency – Sharks ....................................................................................................155A2: Marine Reserves CP – No Solvency – Coral.......................................................................................................156A2: Marine Reserves CP – No Solvency – Land Based.............................................................................................157A2: Marine Reserves CP – Turn: Bycatch..................................................................................................................158A2: Marine Reserves CP – Turn: Species Shift..........................................................................................................160A2: Marine Reserves CP – Turn: Anthropocentrism (1/2)..........................................................................................161A2: ITQ CP – = Overfishing (1/2)..............................................................................................................................163A2: ITQ CP – Turn: Bycatch.......................................................................................................................................165A2: ITQ CP – A2: Solves Subsidies Harms................................................................................................................166A2: ITQ CP – A2: Industry Net Ben...........................................................................................................................167A2: ITQ CP – Turn: Small Fishers..............................................................................................................................168A2: ITQs – Subsidies Key..........................................................................................................................................169US Key (1/3)...............................................................................................................................................................170A2: WTO CP – No Solvency – Technical Issues (1/2)...............................................................................................173A2: WTO CP – No International Agreement..............................................................................................................175
 
Arizona Debate Institute 2008
3
Russell’s Lab
Fish Aff 
A2: WTO CP – No Solvency: DOHA.........................................................................................................................176A2: WTO CP Relations ............................................................................................................................................177A2: WTO CP – Japan/EU Relations...........................................................................................................................178A2: WTO CP – Japan Relations..................................................................................................................................179

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Kwok Chi Kin liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->