Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Kln 2ac Blocks

Kln 2ac Blocks

Ratings:

4.0

(1)
|Views: 160|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Jan 08, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/23/2012

 
KLNPage 1of 72
(Kay, Lietz, Naboulsi)
SDI 2008Hydrogen 2ac
2AC ANSWERS HYDROGEN AFF—INDEX
NOTE: OUR APOLOGIES—WITHOUT AN ELECTRONIC COPY OF THE ORIGINAL AFFFILE—EVIDENCE FROM THAT FILE IS ONLY REFERENCED IN THESE ARGUMENTS— YOU WILL NEED TO GO BACK TO THE ORIGINAL AFF FILE TO PULL THE CARDSAT:TOPICALITYAT:ELECTIONS
SUBSTANTIALLY
2
INDIA DEAL
43-45
INCREASE
3
IRAN
46
ALTERNATIVE ENERGY
4
GAG RULE
47-48
ASPEC
5
LINKS
49
OSPEC
6
AT:KRITIK AT:INHERENCY
ENVIR MANAGEMENT
50-52
HYDRO CARS NOW
7-8
THEORYAT:HARMS
CONDITIONALITY BAD
53
G WARMING D/N EXIST
9
CONDITIONALITY GOOD
54
G W NATURALLY CAUSED
10
DISPOSITIONALITY GOOD
55
 NOT AT PEAK OIL
11
DISPOSITIONALITY BAD
56
HEG/SOFT POWER 
12
PICs BAD
57
AT:SOLVENCY
PICs GOOD
58
HYDROGEN SAFE
13-14
FLOATING PICs GOOD
59
STORAGE
15
FLOATING PICs BAD
60
LEAKS
16
POLICY FRAMEWORK GOOD
61
ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY
17-18
POLICY FRAMEWORK BAD
62
TECHNOLOGICAL FEASIBILITY
19-20
INSTRINSIC GOOD
63
FOSSIL FUEL USE
21-22
INSTRINSIC BAD
64
AT:FEDERAL BESTOOPS OUT OF ORDE
FEDERALISM
23-24
AT: MINE US OIL
65
FED TAX INCENTIVES BEST
25-27
AT: PLAN NOT MODELED
66-69
TAX CREDIT CAP
28
TAX CREDITS WON’T WORK 
29-30
STATES COUNTERPLAN
31-32
AT:OTHER FORMS OF ENERGY
RENEW W/N WK FOR HYDRO
33
ETHANOL
34
METHANOL
35
 NATURAL GAS
36
CLEAN COAL
37
 NUCLEAR POWER 
38
SOLAR POWER 
39
WIND POWER 
40
HYDROELECTRIC
41-42
 
KLNPage 2of 72
(Kay, Lietz, Naboulsi)
SDI 2008Hydrogen 2ac
TOPICALITYAT: T Substantial1. We meet- We meet the interpretation because we not only increase 30%, we increaseincentives 100% because incentives haven’t been implemented before.2. The negative definition is a quote from the Institute of International Education inwhich they are talking about increases in applicants of international students. The negclaims they use a contextual definition from a real world scenario, but the scenario hasnothing to do with alternative energy. This hurts topic specific education because we areno longer debating standards for alternative energy definitions we are debating aboutdefinitions about international students admissions policies.3. Counterdefine- Substantial is a considerable amount, quanity, size, etc.www.dictionary.reference.com20081.We meet our definition because we increase a considerable amount.2.Reasons to prefer-A.Dictionary definitions bestOur definition is from a dictionary which is a reliable source because a team of educated people choose the definition. Also everyone has access to a dictionary, not everyone hasaccess to lexisnexis or Blacks Law Dictionary. Our def creates a fair playing field for everyone.B.Bright lineour definition gives a clear bright line between what is topical and what isn’t because if you don’t increase a considerable amount than you aren’t topical.3.VotersA.Clash- Since we are able to debate this plan it is topical, therefore youshould not grant your ballot to the neg based on a topicality argument.B.Lit checks abuse- we wouldn’t have so much information about this plan if it wasn’t topical.
 
KLNPage 3of 72
(Kay, Lietz, Naboulsi)
SDI 2008Hydrogen 2ac
AT: T increase1. We meet: we increase hydrogen incentives by 100%. They don’t exist prior to planand we implement the program thus a 100% increase2. Counter def. : Increase means to make greater or larger <<American Heritage Dictionary ‘04>>3. We meet counter-def. : We implement the incentives where there currently are none.4. We don’t violate: our plan requires new legislation to be passed5. Counter standards:A) Predictability: common sense tells us that increase means greater or larger B) Limits: the neg over limits the cases the aff can run by not allowing us toextend current policy. We limit fairly so the aff must make greater the incentive to claimsolvency.C) Ground: both sides have fair ground. Neg can still run arguments based onmore hydrogen and more hydrogen incentives6. No Voters:A) Lit check, Clash check : the neg. has literature on our case, so therefore we were predictableB)Don’t vote on potential abuse, it’s like voting on the DA they never ran.

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Andy Gu liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->