Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
4Activity
P. 1
Detecting and Tracking Political Abuse in Social Media

Detecting and Tracking Political Abuse in Social Media

Ratings: (0)|Views: 155|Likes:
Published by Fabrice Epelboin

More info:

Published by: Fabrice Epelboin on Jul 05, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/08/2013

pdf

text

original

 
Ihyhkydg` lgi Yslkodg` ^aedydkle Lcx{h dg [akdle Bhidl
F' Slyodhpdkv% B' I' Kagazhs% B' Bhd{{% C' @agk½lezh{% L' Jelbbdgd% J' Bhgkvhs
Khgyhs jas Kab~eh} Ghypaso{ lgi [t{yhb{ Sh{hlskm[kmaae aj Dgjasblydk{ lgi Kab~xydg`Dgidlgl Xgdzhs{dyt% Ceaabdg`yag% DG% X[L
Lc{yslky
Ph {yxit
l{ysayxsj 
~aedydkle klb~ld`g{ ag bdksacea``dg`~elyjasb{6 ~aedydkleet"baydzlyhi dgidzdixle{ lgi as`lgdvl"ydag{ ymly x{h bxeyd~eh khgysleet"kagysaeehi lkkaxgy{ ya kshlyhymh l~~hlslgkh aj pdih{~shli {x~~asy jas l klgidilyh as a~dg"dag' Ph ih{ksdch l blkmdgh ehlsgdg` jslbhpaso ymly kab"cdgh{ ya~aea`dkle% kagyhgy"cl{hi lgi ksapi{axskhi jhlyxsh{aj dgjasblydag idjjx{dag ghypaso{ ag Ypdyyhs ya ihyhky ymhhlset{yl`h{ajzdsle{~shlidg`aj~aedydklebd{dgjasblydag'Ph~sh{hgy ~sabd{dg` ~shedbdglst sh{xey{ pdym chyyhs ymlg 4:(lkkxslkt dg ymh ihyhkydag aj l{ysayxsj kagyhgy dg ymh sxg"x~ yaymh 3><> X'[' bdiyhsb hehkydag{'
< Dgysaixkydag
[akdle ghypasodg` lgi bdksacea``dg` {hszdkh{ shlkm mxg"ishi{ aj bdeedag{ aj x{hs{ lgi mlzh chkabh jhsydeh `saxgijas l zlsdhyt aj sh{hlskm hjjasy{' Ymht ajjhs l xgd|xh a~"~asyxgdyt ya {yxit ~lyyhsg{ aj {akdle dgyhslkydag lbag` jlsels`hs ~a~xelydag{ ymlg hzhs chjash' Dg ~lsydkxels% Ypdyyhs ml{shkhgyet `hghslyhi bxkm lyyhgydag dg ymh sh{hlskm kabbx"gdyt ixh ya dy{ ~hkxedls jhlyxsh{% a~hg ~aedkt ag ilyl {mls"dg`% lgi hgasbax{ ~a~xelsdyt' Ymh ~a~xelsdyt aj Ypdyyhs%lgi aj {akdle bhidl dg `hghsle% d{ jxsymhs hgmlgkhi ct ymhjlky ymly yslidydagle bhidl ~lt kea{h lyyhgydag ya ymh hcclgi ffiap aj ymh kabbxgdklydag ymly ymht {x~~asy' Pdym ymd{{ksxydgt kabh{ ymh ~ayhgydle jas ymh ma{yhi id{kx{{dag{ yashlkm l jls els`hs lxidhgkh ymlg {db~et ymh asd`dgle {akdlebhidl x{hs{' Leag` pdym ymh shkhgy `sapym aj {akdle bhidl~a~xelsdyt% ph lsh pdygh{{dg` lg dgkshl{hi x{l`h aj ymh{h~elyjasb{ ya id{kx{{ d{{xh{ aj ~xcedk dgyhsh{y% l{ ymht ajjhsxg~shkhihgyhi a~~asyxgdydh{ jas dgkshl{hi ~lsydkd~lydag lgidgjasblydag lplshgh{{ lbag` ymh Dgyhsghy"kagghkyhi ~xc"edk -Lilbdk lgi @elgkh 3>>8$' Pmdeh {abh aj ymh id{kx{"{dag{ ylodg` ~elkh ag {akdle bhidl blt {hhb clgle lgi {x"~hs﬌kdle% ymh lyyhgydag d{ gay pdymaxy bhsdy' [akdle bhidl aj"yhghgfat{xc{ylgydlex{hscl{h{pdym~lsydkd~lgy{islpgjsabidzhs{h `ha`sl~mdk% {akdle% lgi ~aedydkle clko`saxgi{ -Flzlhy le' 3>>0$' Bashazhs% ymh x{hs"l{"dgjasblydag"~saixkhsbaihe ~sazdih{ sh{hlskmhs{ lgi ghp{ as`lgdvlydag{ ledohpdym l bhlg{ aj dg{ysxbhgydg` lgi ac{hszdg` l sh~sh{hg"ylydzh {lb~eh aj ymh ~a~xelydag dg shle ydbh' Dgihhi% dy ml{
Ka~tsd`myk
3><<% L{{akdlydag jas ymh Lizlgkhbhgy aj Lsyd﬌kdleDgyheed`hgkh -ppp'llld'as`$' Lee sd`my{ sh{hszhi'
chhg shkhgyet ihbag{yslyhi ymly x{hjxe dgjasblydag klg chbdghi jsab Ypdyyhs ilyl {yshlb{-L{xs lgi Mxchsblg 3><>?Yxbl{flg hy le' 3><>? Caeehg% Bla% lgi Vhg` 3><<$'Pdym ymd{ dgkshl{dg` ~a~xelsdyt% maphzhs% kabh{ l ilso {dih ’ l{ {akdle bhidl `sap{ dg ~sabdghgkh% dy d{ glyxsleymly ~ha~eh ﬌gi plt{ ya lcx{h dy' L{ l sh{xey% ph ac{hszhzlsdax{ yt~h{ aj deeh`dydblyh x{h? {~lb d{ l kabbag h}lb"~eh -@sdhs hy le' 3><>? Plg` 3><>$' Mhsh ph jakx{ ag l ~ls"ydkxels {akdle bhidl ~elyjasb% Ypdyyhs% lgi ag agh ~lsydkxelsyt~h aj lcx{h% glbhet
~aedydkle l{ysayxsj 
’ ~aedydkle klb"~ld`g{ id{`xd{hi l{ {~agylghax{ ―`sl{{saay{‒ chmlzdas ymlylsh dg shledyt klssdhi axy ct l {dg`eh ~hs{ag as as`lgdvlydag'Ymd{ d{ shelyhi ya {~lb cxy pdym l bash {~hkd﬌k iabldg kag"yh}y% lgi ~ayhgydleet els`hs kag{h|xhgkh{'Agedgh {akdle bhidl yaae{ ~elt l ksxkdle saeh dg ymh {xk"kh{{h{ lgi jldexsh{ aj gxbhsax{ ~aedydkle klb~ld`g{ lgiklx{h{' H}lb~eh{ slg`h jsab ymh `sl{{saay{ as`lgdvdg`~aphs aj Clslko Aclbl—{ 3>>= ~sh{dihgydle klb~ld`g% yaMaplsi Ihlg—{ jldehi 3>>9 ~sh{dihgydle cdi lgi ymh ﬌s{y"hzhs Yhl ^lsyt sleet -Sl{bx{{hg lgi [kmahg 3><>? Pdh{hlgi @sagchko 3>>8$'Ymh {lbh {ysxkyxsle lgi {t{yhbdk ~sa~hsydh{ ymly hglceh{akdle bhidl {xkm l{ Ypdyyhs ya caa{y `sl{{saay{ ~aedydkleas`lgdvlydag klg le{a ch ehzhsl`hi% hzhg dglizhsyhgyet% ya{~shli eh{{ kag{ysxkydzh dgjasblydag' Jas h}lb~eh% ixsdg`ymh~aedydkleklb~ld`gjasymh3><>bdiyhsbhehkydag%{hzhsleblfas ghp{ as`lgdvlydag{ ~dkohi x~ ag ymh bh{{l`dg` jslbhaj l zdsle yphhy shelydg` ya ymh leeaklydag aj {ydbxex{ jxgi{%{xkkdgkyet ih{ksdcdg` l {yxit aj ihkd{dag blodg` dg isx`"liidkyhi blkl|xh{ l{ ―[ydbxex{ ) jas kaoh bagoht{‒ -YmhJa} Glydag 3><>$'Pmdeh ymh ―kaoh bagoht{‒ bhbh ihzhea~hi as`lgdkleetjsab ymh lyyhgydag itglbdk{ aj ymax{lgi{ aj x{hs{% dy deex{"yslyh{ ymh ~aphsjxe lgi ~ayhgydleet ihysdbhgyle saeh ymly {a"kdle bhidl klg ~elt dg {ml~dg` ~xcedk id{kaxs{h' L{ ph pdeeihbag{yslyh% l baydzlyhi lyylkohs klg hl{det askmh{yslyh lid{ysdcxyhi hjjasy ya bdbdk as dgdydlyh ymd{ odgi aj as`lgdk{~shlidg` chmlzdas% lgi pdym ymh sd`my kmadkh aj dgffilbbl"yast pasidg`% dgffixhgkh l ~xcedk phee chtagi ymh kag﬌gh{ aj md{ as mhs apg {akdle ghypaso'Xgedoh yslidydagle ghp{ {axskh{% {akdle bhidl ~sazdih edy"yeh dg ymh plt aj dgidzdixle lkkaxgylcdedyt as jlky"kmhkodg`bhkmlgd{b{' Klykmdgh{{ lgi sh~hlylcdedyt% slymhs ymlg ysxym"jxegh{{% klg jxgkydag l{ ymh ~sdblst isdzhs{ aj dgjasblydag
 
idjjx{dag' Pmdeh ffilbh pls{ lgi mt~hscaeh lsh mlsiet ghp~mhgabhgl agedgh% Ypdyyhs—{ <9>"kmlslkyhs {axgi ctyh{ lshshlit"blih mhliedgh jaiihs jas ymh 39"maxs ghp{ ktkeh'Dg ymh shbldgihs aj ymd{ ~l~hs ph ih{ksdch l {t{yhb ya lg"letvh ymh idjjx{dag aj dgjasblydag dg {akdle bhidl% lgi% dg~lsydkxels% ya lxyablydkleet dihgydjt lgi yslko askmh{yslyhi%ihkh~ydzh hjjasy{ ya bdbdk ymh as`lgdk {~shli aj dgjasblydagymsax`m ymh Ypdyyhs ghypaso' Ymh bldg kagysdcxydag{ aj ymd{~l~hs lsh zhst hgkaxsl`dg` ~shedbdglst sh{xey{ ag ymh ihyhk"ydag aj {x{~dkdax{ bhbh{ zdl {x~hszd{hi ehlsgdg` -4:( lk"kxslkt$ cl{hi ag jhlyxsh{ h}yslkyhi jsab ymh ya~aea`t aj ymhidjjx{dag ghypaso{% {hgydbhgy lglet{d{% lgi ksapi{axskhilggaylydag{' Chklx{h pmly id{ydg`xd{mh{ l{yayxsj jsab ysxh~aedydkle idlea`xh dgkexih{ ymh plt ymht lsh {~shli% axs l~"~salkm h}~edkdyet yloh{ dgya lkkaxgy ymh idjjx{dag ~lyyhsg{ aj bh{{l`h{ lksa{{ ymh {akdle ghypaso'
3 Clko`saxgi lgi Shelyhi Paso
3'< Dgjasblydag Idjjx{dag
Ymh {yxit aj a~dgdag itglbdk{ lgi dgjasblydag idjjx{dagdg {akdle ghypaso{ ml{ l eag` yslidydag dg ymh {akdle% ~mt{d"kle% lgi kab~xylydagle {kdhgkh{ -Kl{yheelga% Jasyxglya% lgiEashya 3>>4? Clssly% Clsymhehbt% lgi Zh{~d`glgd 3>>=?Eh{oazhk% Lilbdk% lgi Mxchsblg 3>>:? Eh{oazhk% Clko"{ysab% lgi Oehdgchs` 3>>4$' Ypdyyhs ml{ shkhgyet chhg kag"{dihshi l{ kl{h {yxit jas dgjasblydag idjjx{dag' Jas h}lb~eh%@lexcl hy le' -3><>$ yloh dgya lkkaxgy x{hs chmlzdas% x{hs"x{hs dgffixhgkh% lgi sh{axskh zdsxehgkh ya ~shidky ymh {~shliaj XSE{ ymsax`m ymh {akdle ghypaso' Pmdeh x{xleet shjhsshiya l{ ”zdsle%— ymh plt dg pmdkm dgjasblydag as sxbas{ idjjx{hdg l ghypaso ml{ db~asylgy idjjhshgkh{ pdym sh{~hky ya dg"jhkydax{ id{hl{h{ -Bassd{ 3>>>$' Sxbas{ `slixleet lk|xdshbash kshidcdedyt l{ bash lgi bash ghypaso ghd`mcas{ lk"|xdsh ymhb' Ljyhs {abh ydbh% l ymsh{maei d{ ksa{{hi lgi ymhsxbas d{ chedhzhi ya ch ysxh pdymdg l kabbxgdyt'L {hsdax{ ac{ylkeh dg ymh baihedg` aj dgjasblydag ~sa~"l`lydag dg ymh shle pasei l{ phee l{ dg ymh cea`a{~mhshd{ ymh jlky ymly ymh {ysxkyxsh aj ymh xgihsetdg` {akdle ghy"paso d{ ajyhg xgogapg' Pmhg h}~edkdy dgjasblydag ag ymh{akdle ghypaso d{ lzldelceh -h'`' ymh Ypdyyhs—{ jaeeaphs sh"elydag{$ ymh {yshg`ym aj ymh {akdle edgo{ lsh mlsiet ogapglgi ymhds db~asylgkh klggay ch ihhbhi xgdjasb lksa{{ymh ghypaso -Mxchsblg% Sabhsa% lgi Px 3>>=$' Mhxsd{"ydk bhymai{ lsh chdg` ihzhea~hi ya jlkh ymd{ d{{xh' @abhv"Saisd`xhv% Eh{oazhk% lgi Oslx{h -3><>$ ~sa~a{h lg le`a"sdymb ymly klg hj﬌kdhgyet l~~sa}dblyh edgol`h dgjasblydagcl{hi ag ymh ydbh{ ly pmdkm {~hkd﬌k XSE{ l~~hls dg l ghy"paso aj ghp{ {dyh{' Jas ymh ~xs~a{h{ aj axs {yxit {xkm ~sac"ehb klg ch% ly ehl{y ~lsydleet% d`gashi' Ypdyyhs ~sazdih{ lgh}~edkdy plt ya jaeeap ymh idjjx{dag aj dgjasblydag zdl ymhyslkodg`aj 
shyphhy{'
Ymd{bhylilylyhee{x{pmdkmedgo{dgymh{akdle ghypaso mlzh lkyxleet ~elthi l saeh dg ymh idjjx{dag aj dgjasblydag' Shyphhy{ mlzh leshlit chhg kag{dihshi% h'`'% yamd`med`my ymh kagzhs{lydagle l{~hky{ aj agedgh {akdle dgyhs"lkydag -Maghtkxyy lgi Mhssdg` 3>>=$' lgi chklx{h dy d{ gay~xced{mhi as lkkh{{dceh thy Ymh shedlcdedyt aj shyphhyhi dg"jasblydag ml{ le{a chhg dgzh{yd`lyhi' Bhgiavl% ^acehyh% lgiKl{ydeea -3><>$ jaxgi ymly jle{h dgjasblydag d{ bash edohetya ch |xh{ydaghi ct x{hs{ ymlg shedlceh lkkaxgy{ aj lg hzhgy'Ymhds paso d{ id{ydgky jsab axs apg dg ymly dy iah{ gay dgzh{"yd`lyh ymh itglbdk{ aj bd{dgjasblydag ~sa~l`lydag'
3'3 Bdgdg` Bdksacea` Ilyl
[hzhsle {yxidh{ mlzh ihbag{yslyhi ymly dgjasblydag {mlshiag Ypdyyhs ml{ {abh dgysdg{dk zlexh% jlkdedylydg`% h'`'% ~shidk"ydag{ aj ca} aj﬌kh {xkkh{{ -L{xs lgi Mxchsblg 3><>$ lgiymh sh{xey{ aj ~aedydkle hehkydag{ -Yxbl{flg hy le' 3><>$' Kag"yhgyml{chhgjxsymhslgletvhiya{yxitkag{xbhsshlkydag{ya{~hkd﬌k cslgi{ -Flg{hg hy le' 3>>4$% ymh x{h aj yl`{ ya leyhskagyhgy -Mxlg`% Ymasgyag% lgi Hjymdbdlid{ 3><>$% dy{ shel"ydag ya mhliedgh ghp{ -Oplo hy le' 3><>$% lgi ymh jlkyas{ ymlydgffixhgkh ymh ~saclcdedyt aj l bhbh ya ch shyphhyhi -[xm hyle' 3><>$' Sabhsa hy le' -3><>$ mlzh jakx{hi ag map ~l{{dzhlgi lkydzh x{hs{ dgffixhgkh ymh {~shlidg` ~lym{'Shkhgy paso ml{ ehzhsl`hi ymh kaeehkydzh chmlzdas aj Ypdyyhs x{hs{ ya `ldg dg{d`my dgya l gxbchs aj idzhs{h ~mh"gabhgl' Lglet{d{ aj yphhy kagyhgy ml{ {mapg ymly {abhkasshelydag h}d{y{ chyphhg ymh `eacle baai aj dy{ x{hs{ lgidb~asylgy paseipdih hzhgy{% dgkexidg` {yako blsohy ffixk"yxlydag{ -Caeehg% Bla% lgi ^h~h 3><>? Caeehg% Bla% lgiVhg` 3><<$' [dbdels yhkmgd|xh{ mlzh chhg l~~edhi ya dg"jhs shelydag{md~{ chyphhg bhidl hzhgy{ {xkm l{ ~sh{dihg"ydle ihclyh{ lgi ljjhkydzh sh{~ag{h{ lbag` {akdle bhidlx{hs{ -Idloa~axea{ lgi [mlbbl 3><>$' [lgolslglsltlglghy le' -3>>4$ ihzhea~hi lg lxyablyhi cshlodg` ghp{ ih"yhkydag {t{yhb cl{hi ag ymh edgodg` chmlzdas aj Ypdyyhsx{hs{% pmdeh Mhhs lgi cati -3>>8$ ih{ksdch l {t{yhb jaszd{xledvdg` lgi h}~easdg` ymh shelydag{md~{ chyphhg x{hs{dg els`h"{kleh {akdle bhidl {t{yhb{' Isdzhg ct ~slkydklekagkhsg{% aymhs{ mlzh {xkkh{{jxeet l~~sa}dblyhi ymh h~d"khgyhs aj hlsym|xloh{ dg Fl~lg ct yshlydg` Ypdyyhs x{hs{l{ l `ha`sl~mdkleet"id{ysdcxyhi {hg{as ghypaso -[lolod%Aolvlod% lgi Bly{xa 3><>$'
3'; ^aedydkle L{ysayxsj lgi Ysxymdgh{{
Dg ymh shbldgihs aj ymd{ ~l~hs ph ih{ksdch ymh lglet{d{ aj ilyl acyldghi ct l {t{yhb ih{d`ghi ya ihyhky l{ysayxs﬌g`klb~ld`g{ ag Ypdyyhs -Slyodhpdkv hy le' 3><<$' Lg deex{"yslydzh h}lb~eh aj {xkm klb~ld`g ml{ chhg shkhgyet iakx"bhgyhi ct Bx{yljlslf lgi Bhyl}l{ -3><>$' Ymht ih{ksdchil kagkhsyhi% ihkhdyjxe lyyhb~y ya klx{h l {~hkd﬌k XSE yasd{h ya ~sabdghgkh ag Ypdyyhs ymsax`m ymh x{h aj l ghypaso aj gdgh jloh x{hs lkkaxgy{' Ymh{h lkkaxgy{ ~saixkhi 434yphhy{ azhs ymh kaxs{h aj <;= bdgxyh{% lee aj pmdkm dgkexihil edgo ya l phc{dyh {bhlsdg` agh aj ymh klgidilyh{ dg ymh3>>4 Bl{{lkmx{hyy{ {~hkdle hehkydag' Ymh yphhy{ dgfhkydg`ymd{ bhbh bhgydaghi x{hs{ pma mli ~shzdax{et h}~sh{{hidgyhsh{y dg ymh hehkydag' Ymh dgdydlyas{ {ax`my gay fx{y ya h}"~a{h l ﬌gdyh lxidhgkh ya l {~hkd﬌k XSE% cxy ya ysd``hs lg dg"jasblydag kl{klih ymly paxei ehgi l {hg{h aj kshidcdedyt lgi`sl{{saay{ hgymx{dl{b ya l {~hkd﬌k ~aedydkle bh{{l`h' Pdymdgmaxs{% l {xc{ylgydle ~asydag aj ymh yls`hyhi x{hs{ shyphhyhiymh edgo% sh{xeydg` dg l sl~di {~shli ihyhkyhi ct @aa`eh—{shle"ydbh {hlskm hg`dgh' Ymd{ klx{hi ymh XSE dg |xh{ydagya ch ~sabayhi ya ymh ya~ aj ymh @aa`eh sh{xey{ ~l`h jas l|xhst ag ymh klgidilyh—{ glbh ’ l {a"kleehi
Ypdyyhs cabc'
Ymd{ kl{h {yxit ihbag{yslyh{ ymh hl{h pdym pmdkm l jakx{hi
 
Cacc~kab+ade{~dee
Hzhgy <
6 Cac yphhy{ pdym bhbh{ +ade{~dee lgi c~kab-Lglet{d{ blt dgjhs il{mhi hi`h{$Cacc~kab+ade{~dee
Hzhgy 3
6 Ledkh sh"yphhy{ Cac'{ bh{{l`hLedkh
HI@H
Phd`my[axskh% Yls`hy
HZHGY
Ydbh{ylb~
Jd`xsh <6 Baihe aj {yshlbdg` {akdle bhidl hzhgy{'hjjasy klg dgdydlyh ymh zdsle {~shli aj dgjasblydag ag Ypdyyhs%lgi ymh {hsdax{ kag{h|xhgkh{ aj {xkm lcx{h'Bl{{ kshlydag aj lkkaxgy{% db~hs{aglydag aj x{hs{% lgiymh ~a{ydg` aj ihkh~ydzh kagyhgy lsh chmlzdas{ ymly lsh edohetkabbag ya caym {~lb lgi ~aedydkle l{ysayxs﬌g`' Maphzhs%~aedydkle l{ysayxsj d{ gay h}lkyet ymh {lbh l{ {~lb' Pmdeh ymh~sdblst acfhkydzh aj l {~lbbhs d{ ajyhg ya ~hs{xlih x{hs{ya kedko l edgo% {abhagh dgyhsh{yhi dg ~sabaydg` lg l{ysayxsj bh{{l`h plgy{ ya h{ylced{m l jle{h {hg{h aj `sax~ kag{hg"{x{ lcaxy l ~lsydkxels dihl' Shelyhi ya ymd{ ~sakh{{ d{ ymh jlkyymly x{hs{ lsh bash edohet ya chedhzh l bh{{l`h ymly ymht ~hs"khdzh l{ kabdg` jsab {hzhsle dgih~hgihgy {axskh{% as jsablg lk|xldgylgkh -Fl`lydk hy le' 3>>0$' [~lb ihyhkydag {t{"yhb{ ajyhg jakx{ ag ymh kagyhgy aj l ~ayhgydle {~lb bh{"{l`h ’ jas dg{ylgkh% ya {hh dj ymh bh{{l`h kagyldg{ l khsyldgedgo as {hy aj yl`{' Dg ihyhkydg` ~aedydkle l{ysayxsj% ph jakx{ag
map
ymh bh{{l`h d{ ihedzhshi slymhs ymlg ag dy{ kagyhgy'Jxsymhs% blgt eh`dydblyh x{hs{ blt ch xgpdyydg`et kab~edkdydg ymh ~sa~l`lydag aj l{ysayxsj% mlzdg` chhg ymhb{hezh{ ih"khdzhi' [~lb ihyhkydag bhymai{ ymly jakx{ {aehet ag ~sa~hs"ydh{ aj x{hs lkkaxgy{% {xkm l{ ymh gxbchs aj XSE{ dg yphhy{jsab lg lkkaxgy as ymh dgyhszle chyphhg {xkkh{{dzh yphhy{%blt ymhshjash ch xg{xkkh{{jxe dg ﬌gidg` {xkm lcx{h'Ph lia~y ymh yhsb
ysxymt
ya id{ksdbdglyh jle{het"~sa~l`lyhidgjasblydagjsabas`lgdk`sl{{saay{bhbh{'Ymhyhsb pl{ kadghi ct kabhidlg [yh~mhg Kaechsy ya ih{ksdch{abhymdg` ymly l ~hs{ag chedhzh{ cl{hi ag hbaydag slymhsymlg jlky{' Ph klg ymhg ih﬌gh axs yl{o l{ ymh ihyhkydag aj ysxymt bhbh{ dg ymh Ypdyyhs {yshlb' Gay hzhst ysxymt bhbhpdee sh{xey dg l zdsle kl{klih edoh ymh agh iakxbhgyhi ctBx{yljlslf lgi Bhyl}l{% cxy ph pd{m ya yh{y ymh mt~aymh{d{ymly ymh dgdydle {yl`h{ h}mdcdy dihgyd﬌lceh {d`glyxsh{'
; Lgletydkle Jslbhpaso
Ph ihzhea~hi l xgd﬌hi jslbhpaso% pmdkm ph klee
Oely{km
%ymly lgletvh{ ymh chmlzdas aj x{hs{ lgi idjjx{dag aj dihl{ dgl csali zlsdhyt aj ilyl jhhi{' Ymd{ jslbhpaso d{ ih{d`ghiya ~sazdih ilyl dgyhsa~hslcdedyt jas ymh shle"ydbh lglet{d{ aj bl{{dzh {akdle bhidl ilyl {yshlb{ -bdeedag{ aj ~a{y{ ~hsilt$ jsab {dyh{ pdym idzhs{h {ysxkyxsh{ lgi dgyhsjlkh{' Yaymd{ hgi% ph baihe l `hghsdk {yshlb aj {akdle ghypasodg`ilyl l{ l {hsdh{ aj hzhgy{ ymly sh~sh{hgy dgyhslkydag{ chyphhg
lkyas{
lgi
bhbh{
% l{ {mapg dg Jd`' <' Hlkm hzhgy dgzaezh{{abh gxbchs aj lkyas{ -hgydydh{ ymly sh~sh{hgy x{hs{$% {abhgxbchs aj bhbh{ -hgydydh{ ymly sh~sh{hgy xgdy{ aj dgjasbl"ydag ly ymh ih{dshi ehzhe aj ihylde$% lgi dgyhslkydag{ lbag`ymhb' Jas h}lb~eh% l {dg`eh yphhy hzhgy bd`my dgzaezh ymshhas bash lkyas{6 ymh ~a{yhs% ymh x{hs {mh d{ shyphhydg`% lgiymh ~ha~eh {mh d{ liish{{dg`' Ymh ~a{y bd`my le{a dgzaezh l{hy aj bhbh{ kag{d{ydg` aj ”ml{myl`{— lgi XSE{ shjhshgkhidg ymh yphhy' Hlkm hzhgy klg ch ymax`my aj l{ kagysdcxydg` lxgdy aj phd`my ya hi`h{ dg l ghypaso {ysxkyxsh% pmhsh gaih{lsh l{{akdlyhi pdym hdymhs lkyas{ as bhbh{' Ymh ydbh{ylb~{l{{akdlyhi pdym ymh hzhgy{ leeap x{ ya ac{hszh ymh kmlg`dg`{ysxkyxsh aj ymd{ ghypaso azhs ydbh'
;'< Bhbh Yt~h{
Ya {yxit ymh idjjx{dag aj dgjasblydag ag Ypdyyhs dy d{ ghkh{"{lst ya dihgydjt l {~hkd﬌k ya~dk l{ dy ~sa~l`lyh{ ymsax`m ymh{akdle {xc{yslyh' Pmdeh ymhsh h}d{y {a~md{ydklyhi {ylyd{ydkleyhkmgd|xh{jasbaihedg`ymhya~dk{xgihsetdg` caidh{ajyh}y%ymh {blee {dvh aj hlkm yphhy lgi ymh kagyh}yxle isdjy ~sh{hgydg {yshlbdg` ilyl kshlyh {d`gd﬌klgy kab~edklydag{ -Plg` hyle' 3>>;$' Jasyxglyhet% {hzhsle kagzhgydag{ {mlshi ct Ypdy"yhs x{hs{ leeap x{ ya {dih{yh~ ymh{h d{{xh{' Ph jakx{ ag ymhjaeeapdg` jhlyxsh{ ya dihgydjt idjjhshgy yt~h{ aj bhbh{6
Ml{myl`{
Ymh Ypdyyhs kabbxgdyt x{h{ yaohg{ ~sh﬌}hi ctl ml{mblso -+$ ya elche ymh ya~dkle kagyhgy aj yphhy{'[abh h}lb~eh{ aj ~a~xels yl`{ lsh
+`a~
%
+aclbl
% lgi
+ih{hg
% blsodg` id{kx{{dag lcaxy ymh Sh~xcedklg ~lsyt%^sh{dihgy Aclbl% lgi ymh Ihelplsh slkh jas X'[' [hglyh%sh{~hkydzhet' Ymh{h lsh ajyhg kleehi
ml{myl`{
'
Bhgydag{
L Ypdyyhs x{hs klg dgkexih lgaymhs x{hs—{ {kshhgglbh dg l ~a{y% ~sh~hgihi ct ymh
N
{tbcae' Ymh{h
bhg"ydag{
klg ch x{hi ya ihgayh ymly l ~lsydkxels Ypdyyhs x{hsd{ chdg` id{kx{{hi'
XSE{
Ph h}yslky XSE{ jsab yphhy{ ct blykmdg` {ysdg`{ aj zlediXSEkmlslkyhs{ymlych`dgpdym ”
myy~6!!
'Maght"kxyy lgi Mhssdg` -3>>=$ {x``h{y ymly XSE{ lsh l{{akdlyhipdym ymh yslg{bd{{dag aj dgjasblydag ag Ypdyyhs'
^msl{h{
Jdgleet% ph kag{dihs ymh hgydsh yh}y aj ymh yphhy dy"{hej ya ch l bhbh% agkh lee Ypdyyhs bhylilyl% ~xgkyxlydag%lgi XSE{ mlzh chhg shbazhi'Shetdg` ag ymh{h kagzhgydag{ ph lsh lceh ya jakx{ ag ymhplt{ dg pmdkm l els`h gxbchs aj bhbh{ ~sa~l`lyh ymsax`mymh Ypdyyhs {akdle ghypaso' Gayh ymly l yphhy blt ch dg"kexihi dg {hzhsle aj ymh{h klyh`asdh{' L yphhy kagyldgdg` -jasdg{ylgkh$ ypa ml{myl`{ lgi l XSE paxei kaxgy l{ l bhbchsaj hlkm aj ymh ymshh sh{xeydg` bhbh{'
;'3 Ghypaso Hi`h{
Ya sh~sh{hgy ymh ffiap aj dgjasblydag ymsax`m ymh Ypdyyhskabbxgdyt% ph kag{ysxky l idshkyhi `sl~m dg pmdkm gaih{lsh dgidzdixle x{hs lkkaxgy{' Lg h}lb~eh idjjx{dag ghypaso dgzaezdg` ymshh x{hs{ d{ {mapg dg Jd`' 3' Lg hi`h d{ islpgjsab gaih
L
ya
C
pmhg hdymhs
C
d{ ac{hszhi ya shyphhy lbh{{l`h jsab
L
% as
L
bhgydag{
C
dg l yphhy' Ymh phd`myaj lg hi`h d{ dgkshbhgyhi hlkm ydbh ph ac{hszh lg hzhgykagghkydg` ypa x{hs{' Dg ymd{ plt% hdymhs yt~h aj hi`h klg chxgihs{yaai ya sh~sh{hgy l ffiap aj dgjasblydag jsab
L
ya
C
'

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->